Reeves braced for OBR forecasts to blow £20bn hole in tax and spending plans
Rachel Reeves is braced for revised forecasts by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) to blow a £20bn hole in her tax and spending plans before the autumn budget,Even without changing the totals the chancellor set out in her spending review on Wednesday, a weaker forecast from the the Treasury’s independent watchdog could force her to find significantly more money at the budget to meet her “non-negotiable” fiscal rules,Reeves has said repeatedly that flexing her fiscal rules – designed to provide certainty over UK public finances – is not an option even if the economic outlook deteriorates,At her spring statement, she left herself on course to meet those rules with less than £10bn of headroom to spare, on a total budget for day-to-day spending of more than £1,3tn.
Amid trepidation at the Treasury, the OBR has kicked off its annual summer review of the “supply side” of the economy – including productivity, which it has consistently overestimated.Sources with knowledge of the OBR’s thinking told the Guardian that the watchdog was “uncomfortable”, with the fact its current forecast for productivity growth was more positive than the consensus from other economic forecasters, and wanted to “rein it in”.Productivity is one of the key determinants of economic growth, and revising it down would have a significant knock on effect on the OBR’s forecasts for gross domestic product.The consultancy Oxford Economics estimates that moving the productivity forecast back in line with the average independent projection, would knock 1.4% off forecast GDP at the end of the OBR’s five-year forecast period.
That would force Reeves to increase taxes or cut spending by an eye-watering £20bn, to meet her fiscal rules and maintain her slim £10bn of headroom.That would be roughly equivalent to raising both the main and higher rates of income tax by 2p.A more cautious approach, taking the middle path between two alternative “scenarios” the OBR set out in its March economic and financial outlook, could still force the chancellor to make a £12bn correction.The OBR could send an early signal of its intention to revisit its productivity outlook as soon as 1 July, in its regular forecast evaluation report.Andy King, a former member of the OBR’s budget responsibility committee, now at the consultancy Flint Global, said: “The reason why anyone in the Treasury who cares about this will be worried, is that the OBR is currently more optimistic than everyone else.
“What can happen next? Either everyone else thinks, ‘We’re too pessimistic’; or the OBR thinks, ‘We are too far away from the pack, there’s been more bad news than good since March, we should revise down.’ I think that’s the expectation for many.”The Treasury is likely to point the OBR to policies it hopes will be positive for productivity growth in the long term, including infrastructure investment, though the scale of this was already known before the OBR’s last forecast in March.Alongside weaker productivity, slower net migration as a result of the government’s recent white paper could also prompt the OBR to be more pessimistic.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionJames Smith an economist at ING, said: “Further downgrades to trend productivity growth projections, as well as net migration, mean the chancellor is likely in the red, before even considering the mounting pressures on the public purse.
“The overall shortfall may amount to at least £20bn, and that means tax rises are highly likely.”Adrian Pabst, the deputy director of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, said the prospect of another significant forecast revision underlined the current instability of tax and spend policy.“We’re in this vicious circle where we’ve got these fiscal rules, then the OBR have to take a view, because that’s their remit, that’s their mandate; and then we’re constantly speculating about what is going to happen at the next fiscal event,” he said, adding: “It’s not a good place for fiscal policy to be.”In a recent speech, Reeves said: “Strong and transparent fiscal rules are an indispensable safeguard for working people – and that is why my rules are non-negotiable.”The Treasury declined to comment on the prospect of an OBR growth downgrade but underlined Reeves’s determination to stick to her fiscal rules.
The OBR declined to comment.
‘A giant parenting group’: how online comedians are making a living by laughing about the chaos of kids
Many Instagram-frequenting parents of small children will have seen George Lewis’s sketch about two toddlers discussing their feelings of abandonment and relief wrapped in a game of peekaboo.“It was a normal day, I was just playing with Dad. And then he put his hands in front of his face and he was just gone,” the British comedian and father says in the widely shared video. “He was behaving so erratically.”Life through a two-year-old’s lens – especially in relation to their sleep-deprived parents – is fertile ground for a growing group of online parent comedians whose content is clocking up millions of views
Adam Hills: ‘I knew I should have gone to the King’s birthday but I really wanted to go to rugby training’
Is it true that you turned down an invite to King Charles’s 70th birthday so you could go to rugby training?Yes, that’s 100% true. To be honest, I knew I should have gone to the birthday but I really wanted to go to rugby training. This is ridiculous, but I’d been to Buckingham Palace a couple of times before and I’m at a stage in my life where I thought: “Actually, I’d much rather go to rugby training.” I had started playing disability rugby league and I became quite addicted to it. Training was my favourite part, just hanging out with a bunch of mates playing footy
Andrew Lloyd Webber is ‘hot again’ –with help from new kids on musicals block
When Andrew Lloyd Webber walked on stage to collect the Tony award for best musical revival for Sunset Boulevard, it was the first time in 30 years he had been recognised by the American Theatre Wing.The Jamie Lloyd-directed revival was the star of the show at American theatre’s big night last Sunday with its three wins signifying a return to prominence for the veteran composer.But this wasn’t just about one hit show starring a former Pussycat Doll.Look around theatreland on either side of the Atlantic and Lord Lloyd-Webber’s fingerprints are everywhere: a successful revival of Starlight Express (in the unlikely environs of Wembley); a forthcoming outing for Jesus Christ Superstar; Jamie Lloyd is directing Evita (starring Rachel Zegler) in London, there is a new musical called The Illusionist in the works, and cryptic messages announcing the return of Phantom of the Opera have sprung up around New York.Arguably, we have reached peak Lloyd Webber five decades after his work was first performed on stage
How to Train Your Dragon to Neil Young: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
How to Train Your DragonOut now This live-action remake was shot by Bill Pope, the cinematographer behind films as diverse as Clueless, The Matrix and Spider-Man 3, with puppets used on set to give the actors something to work with before painting in the CGI. Starring Mason Thames, Gerard Butler and Nick Frost.Film on Film WeekendBFI Southbank, London, 14 & 15 JuneA whole weekend of films screening exclusively from actual physical prints? Sign us up. Physical film in a digital world is a use-it-or-lose-it kind of treasure, so to see the likes of Star Wars screened from prints, vote with your wallet and get down to the BFI.LollipopOut now Daisy-May Hudson based this portrait of a woman trying to regain custody of her kids on her own experiences of the social care system, with Posy Sterling giving a barnstorming performance as a woman who can’t get a bigger flat because she doesn’t have her children with her, and can’t get her kids back because her flat is too small
British Library to reinstate Oscar Wilde’s reader card 130 years after it was revoked
The British Library is to symbolically reinstate Oscar Wilde’s reader pass, 130 years after its trustees cancelled it following his conviction for gross indecency.A contemporary pass bearing the name of the Irish author and playwright will be officially presented to his grandson, Merlin Holland, at an event in October, it will be announced on Sunday.Rupert Everett, who wrote, directed and starred as Wilde in The Happy Prince – the acclaimed 2018 film about the writer’s tragic final years in exile – will play a part in the ceremony.Holland is an expert on Wilde whose publications include The Complete Letters of Oscar Wilde. Asked how his grandfather might have reacted to the pass being reinstated, he said: “He’d probably say ‘about time too’
The Guide #195: How Reddit made nerds of us all
It only ended a few years ago, but Westworld already feels a bit of a TV footnote. A pricey mid-2010s remake of a 70s Yul Brynner movie few people remembered, HBO’s robot cowboy drama lumbered on for four lukewarm seasons before getting cancelled – with few people really noticing.Still, when it premiered, Westworld was big news. Here was a show well-placed to do a Game of Thrones, only for sci-fi. Its high production values were married to an eye-catching cast (Evan Rachel Wood, Ed Harris, Thandiwe Newton, Jeffrey Wright) and it was run by the crack team of Lisa Joy and Jonathan Nolan, who promised they had a playbook for how the whole show would shake out
UK ‘woefully’ unprepared for Chinese and Russian undersea cable sabotage, says report
Labour needs to make its priorities clear to everyone | Letters
Keir Starmer in diplomatic push to head off Middle East crisis before G7 summit in Canada
Rachel Reeves accused of leaving devolved nations in red after NICs rise
Rachel Reeves defends Starmer’s delay in launching grooming gangs inquiry
China considers lifting sanctions on UK parliamentarians as relations warm