Ministers urged to close £2bn tax loophole in car finance scandal

A picture


Ministers are being urged to close a loophole that will allow UK banks and specialist lenders to avoid paying £2bn in tax on their payouts to motor finance scandal victims.Under the current law, any operation that is not a bank can deduct compensation payments from their profits before calculating their corporation tax, reducing their bill.UK banks have been blocked from claiming this relief since 2015, but it has now emerged that those due to pay redress as part of the pending £11bn car loan compensation scheme can exploit it because their motor finance arms are considered “non-bank entities”.The Guardian has learned this includes the operations of big high street names including Barclays and Santander UK, and Lloyds Banking Group, which is the UK’s biggest provider of car loans through its Black Horse division.Specialist lenders in the scandal, which include the lending arms of car manufacturers such as Honda and Ford, also fall outside this taxation rule.

The loophole means taxpayers will lose out on £2bn in corporation tax over the next two years, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) confirmed,The block on banks being able to remove compensation payouts – and any related expenses – before corporation tax bills were calculated was introduced in 2015 to ensure “past misconduct and management failure” did not impact state revenues,It meant that taxpayers did not lose out when banks paid out compensation for controversies such as the payment protection insurance (PPI) scandal,Bobby Dean, a Liberal Democrat MP on the Treasury committee, is now urging the government to intervene to ensure the rule applies to payouts for car loan mis-selling,“It’s not right that that the taxpayer is set to lose out on billions due to a loophole in compensation rules,” Dean said.

“The UK banned banks from deducting payouts from tax bills for good reason and it seems that those caught up in the motor finance scandal are going to dodge their responsibilities by operating through spin-off companies,“I hope the government will intervene and ensure that the spirit of the compensation payout rules are maintained,”OBR documents released alongside the autumn budget showed that corporation tax takings would be offset by a £2bn loss linked to the Financial Conduct Authority’s proposed motor finance compensation scheme over 2025-26 and 2026-27,The scheme, which is out for consultation, is meant to compensate borrowers who were overcharged as a result of unfair commission arrangements between lenders and car dealers,When asked for clarification, the OBR told the Guardian the forecasts were made on the basis that the compensation payouts by non-bank entities – in both banking and non-banking groups – were “expected to be deductible for corporation tax purposes”.

Dean said he is planning to write to ministers to raise the matter this week, days before the FCA’s consultation on the compensation scheme is due to close on Friday,Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionIf maintained, however, it will provide another relief for banks which narrowly escaped a tax raid in the budget last month amid heavy sector lobbying,Darren Smith, managing director of claims law firm Courmacs Legal, which is representing 1,5 million car finance victims said: “Following a budget that will lead to millions of people’s tax bills going up, it’s hard to understand why the Labour government is not closing this loophole, allowing big banks to profit from a £2bn tax break for their own historic misconduct,”Lenders have continued to rail against their expected £11bn car finance compensation bill and have pushed for government support, with Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, already having tried to influence the direction of the car finance scandal this year, trying to intervene in a supreme court hearing in January.

The Guardian later revealed that Reeves was considering overruling the supreme court’s decision with retrospective legislation, in order to help save lenders billions of pounds in the event that it ruled in favour of consumers.The court largely sided with lenders in the end, and Reeves did not step in.The Financing and Leasing Association (FLA) lobby group, which represents car lenders, has been pushing for the FCA’s compensation scheme terms to be narrowed, claiming the scheme’s terms are “so broad that they will compensate customers who suffered no loss – effectively ignoring the requirement for proportionality on the part of the regulator”.Commenting on the loophole, the FLA’s director of motor finance, Adrian Dally, said: “Focus the scheme on loss, therefore it’ll cost less than proposed.That will have less of an impact on profits and lenders will pay more corporation tax as a result.

”The Treasury did not directly comment on the tax relief.A spokesperson said: “It is vital that consumers have access to motor finance to enable them to spread the cost of a vehicle in a way that is manageable and affordable.“We want to see this issue resolved in an efficient and orderly way that provides certainty for consumers and firms.”
sportSee all
A picture

Lando Norris wins F1 world title in Abu Dhabi despite Verstappen’s GP win

In tears and almost rendered speechless by the sheer weight of emotion, what winning his debut Formula One world championship meant to Lando Norris was writ large across every inch of his face. What had begun as a childhood dream and at one point this season had ­seemingly slipped from his grasp was, finally, a reality he clearly found hard to take in, as he sealed it with third place at the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix.It would have taken truly a heart of stone not to have been moved by it all as he secured the title after what has been an enormously hard‑fought season across 24 gruelling races that went to the wire at the Yas Marina ­Circuit.Despite his title rivals ­finishing ahead of him in the race – Red Bull’s Max Verstappen winning and his McLaren teammate Oscar Piastri taking ­second – ­Norris did enough to close it out with a gutsy, nerveless drive that gave way to untrammelled emotion as his podium place was just enough to pip Verstappen to the title by two points.“I’m not crying,” Norris said through the sobbing inside his ­helmet before being embraced by his equally tearful mother, Cisca, as he then tried to embrace as many of his team as he could

A picture

Ben Stokes says England have been ‘letting the pressure get to us’ in Ashes

Ben Stokes has admitted that the way England have folded in key moments during the first two Ashes Tests has led him to question the character of his players, and said: “A dressing room that I am captain of isn’t a place for weak men.”After Australia won the second Test in Brisbane by the same eight-wicket margin with which they secured the first, Stokes suggested the telling difference was that the home side had been superior in the “moments in the game where the heat is on and the pressure is really, really cooking” whereas his players “have all been guilty at moments [of] letting the pressure, the occasion, the circumstances, get to us”.“Over and over again, Australia have managed to get through those periods and outdo us,” Stokes said. “I know it’s not a skill thing, because they’re all incredibly talented players. But if you can’t put it down to skill then you start to wonder, what is it? Do we need to start thinking about what mentality we’re taking into those pressure moments?“Because when we’re on top we’re great, but when the game is neck and neck we’re not coming out on top on enough occasions to be able to challenge Australia

A picture

Alex Yee runs second fastest British marathon time to trail only Mo Farah

Alex Yee, the Olympic triathlon champion, has become the second-fastest British marathon runner in history with a stunning run in Valencia. The 27-year-old finished seventh in a strong field in a time of 2hr 6min 38sec, quicker than any Briton in history apart from Mo Farah, who ran 2:05:11 in Chicago in 2018.It was a remarkable performance, especially given Yee took up the marathon only this year as a mini-sabbatical from triathlon after he won gold in Paris. As Yee crossed the line he roared to the skies before placing his hands to his head, in disbelief at the time he had just achieved.“Valencia marathon blew away any expectations I had of myself,” said Yee

A picture

Australia v England: Ashes second Test, day four – as it happened

Righto, that is all from us today. The lights are dimmed here at Brisbane’s Gabba and the pitch is being watered by the ground staff. Australia are one win away from being home and hosed themselves.We’ll be back to OBO the third game of the series in Adelaide starting on 16th December.All Ben Stokes wants for Christmas… is a Test match win in Australia

A picture

He’ll always have Brisbane: Michael Neser revels in sweet day of Ashes glory | Geoff Lemon

In the end, the only tension was whether Brisbane’s rain would descend before Australia could knock off the last 32 runs in the final session, and so whether going 2-0 up in the Ashes would be delayed until the fifth day. It turned out that England’s resistance through the light of the afternoon had only dished up some evening entertainment for home fans, with Travis Head able to put on a brief show in dispatching the pink ball over the fence before he headed back the same way.Although through the longest partnership of the series so far, 221 balls on the hottest day of the second Test, Ben Stokes and Will Jacks made Australia work in the field, something that was perhaps worth doing for the simple fact of proving that it can be done. With Mitchell Starc tiring after leading the line all series, the contest became a grind. What it reflected about Australia’s bowling makeup was instructive

A picture

England to seek better warmup preparations before 2029-30 Ashes series

The England and Wales Cricket Board is ready to offer Australia their pick of warmup facilities before the next Ashes series in 2027, in an attempt to secure similar treatment when England return in 2029-30 and avoid being forced into the kind of buildup that preceded this series and has become the focus of intense criticism.England’s preparations are under the microscope given their dismal start to this series, with the first Test lost inside two days and the second match lost in four, with Australia’s winning margin being eight wickets on each occasion.“If I was an England supporter and had paid the money to come here, I’d be asking the ECB for a refund,” Ian Botham said on Sunday. “Because this team, for me, is not prepared.”Though much of the travelling squad was in Perth, venue of the first Ashes Test, by 2 November, 19 days before the commencement of hostilities, and the remainder had arrived by 9 November, their only cricket that could even be loosely defined as competitive before the series got under way was a two-day game against the Lions, a collection of their own reserves and promising youngsters