‘I’d do it all again’: the UK factory worker who beat the car lenders in court
Marcus Johnson never expected he would be rushing to a car park during a family holiday in Somerset to discuss a ruling by the highest court in the UK.But the 35-year-old factory worker from Cwmbran in south Wales also had little idea that a loan he took out in 2017 to buy a second-hand Suzuki Swift would place him at the heart of a David v Goliath battle.His case would go on to expose egregious commission practices in the car finance market and lead to a compensation scheme that could cost some of the UK’s largest banks and specialist lenders up to £18bn.“I thought it would be like when you did those PPI claim forms: you were just going to get a few pounds in the bank in a month or two.That’s what I expected this to be,” Johnson said.
“I had no idea it would turn into what it has today.I had no idea the impact it would have.”What started as interest in a Facebook advert about potential misselling of car loans led to a three-and-a-half year legal battle escalating to the UK supreme court.On Friday, Johnson’s case was the sole one of three consumer complaints left standing, with supreme court judges concerned about his “unfair” treatment by car lenders.That was due in part to the size of the commission that the lender paid to the car dealer – a quarter of the Suzuki’s near-£6,500 price tag – as well as a failure to disclose that a single lender, in this case South Africa’s FirstRand, was given first dibs on the contract, rather than it being taken to a panel of lenders to secure the best deal.
Johnson admitted that he did not read all the documents that the Cardiff dealership gave him about the blue hatchback.But the supreme court questioned whether it was reasonable to expect “commercially unsophisticated” borrowers to read and understand the terms of the commission buried in reams of fine print.“It was a very rushed process where they gave me a big box full of paperwork and expected me then to comb through hundreds of pages,” Johnson recalls.“I felt like they were telling me what I needed to know.I had no idea that they were leaving things out.
”Once lawyers explained the terms of his loan, Johnson was floored.“As all the evidence and all the information was presented, I almost found it unbelievable.”His case, which has dragged through Britain’s legal system since November 2022, exposed the complex and symbiotic relationship between lenders, manufacturers and car dealers in the UK’s multi-billion pound motor finance industry.Between 80% and 90% of new cars in the UK are now bought using borrowed money, with lenders paying commission to dealers.Had the two other cases bundled with Johnson’s claim been upheld, the industry could have faced a massive compensation bill fit to rival the £50bn PPI scandal.
Johnson, speaking during a trip to Butlin’s in Minehead with his six-year-old daughter, said the entire saga had been stressful at times and pushed him out of his comfort zone.He even gets recognised on the street, thanks to doing TV interviews.“I’m not shy, but I kind of keep myself to myself, so it’s just a bit strange for me.”However, he feels it is a small price to pay to hold lenders to account.He said one car finance company contacted him in recent months to ask how it could be more transparent with buyers.
Johnson is hoping those changes last, and that the regulator’s new compensation scheme will give money back to consumers who were unknowingly overcharged.“Hopefully it opens up a way for people in my position to be able to get what they should back.I would definitely do it all again.”Even Andrew Wrench, 61, who lost his case in the same court ruling on Friday, said it was worth the battle.Judges rejected Wrench’s case, alongside another filed by Amy Hopcraft, a nurse, which argued that commissions paid to car dealers amounted to bribes, and that dealers should be acting in customers’ best financial interests.
While it proved a disappointing end to his 26-month court battle, Wrench said family and friends were proud of his work.“My nephew Billy said ‘Look, you’ve highlighted it.You’ve done the right thing.A lot of people respect you for that, and be proud of what you’ve achieved, because there are going to be some compensatory packages for consumers.’”While Wrench will not get a payout on that single claim, he acknowledged that there could have been sweeping repercussions had his case been upheld.
Car lenders have warned that a big compensation bill could push some firms into failure, while others would offer fewer, or more expensive loans, to claw back their losses,That could restrict options for people who relied on credit,Spooked by the warning, Rachel Reeves subsequently launched a failed attempt to intervene in the supreme court ruling, and warned judges to avoid handing a “windfall” to consumers,The chancellor later considered overruling the supreme court with retrospective legislation, in order to limit a potential £44bn bill,“I didn’t want anybody to lose jobs.
I don’t want the economy to be affected.And the Treasury is already in a mess anyway,” Wrench said.“I wasn’t in it for that, and I wasn’t in it for compensation at all.I was in, from the get-go, [to expose lenders] that were deceitful, dishonest and otherwise.”But Wrench’s work is not over.
He has one more car finance claim to pursue, and has two other unrelated cases – on mortgage terms and diesel emissions claims – making their way through the courts,In the meantime, he is keeping inspirational figures, such as the underdog lawyer and environmental campaigner Erin Brockovich, in mind,“She risked everything to take on the big boys,” This article was amended on 5 August 2025,An earlier version said that car dealers paid commission to lenders when it should have said that lenders paid commission to dealers.
BP begins costs review as quarterly profits of £1.77bn beat forecast
The oil and gas group BP is launching a fresh cost-cutting scheme, despite reporting better-than-expected profits, as it tries to do more for its shareholders to fend off pressure from activist investors.The fossil fuel company said it would begin a fresh review of its business when its new chair, Albert Manifold, joins the board in September.BP reported a rise in profits to $2.35bn (£1.77bn) between April and June, a drop of 15% on the same period a year earlier when the company benefited from higher oil and gas prices
Chinese carmakers led by BYD report big rises in UK sales in July
Chinese carmakers led by BYD reported big jumps in UK sales last month, despite a declining overall car market, including a 59% slump in sales from their electric vehicle rival Tesla.BYD sales quadrupled year on year to reach 3,200 in July, even as overall sales of all types of car declined by 5% to 140,000, according to data published on Tuesday by the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), a lobby group.The car industry has said it is struggling with a weak economy, which is holding back consumer spending.At the same time, carmakers are waiting for clarity on which models will be eligible for subsidies of up to £3,750 under a new grant scheme announced by the UK government last month. The government on Tuesday said that four Citroën models would be eligible for the grant
UK services sector has biggest fall in orders for nearly three years
The UK’s dominant service sector has reported its biggest drop in new orders in almost three years in July, adding to pressure on the Bank of England to cut interest rates on Thursday.Sounding the alarm over a loss of momentum amid a worsening global economic backdrop, the data provider S&P Global Market Intelligence said total new work in the sector, which accounts for about 80% of the economy, eased to the slowest pace since November 2022.The survey of 650 companies in the sector, which includes finance, IT, communications and property but excludes retail, is closely watched by the Bank and the government for early warning signs from the economy.Threadneedle Street is widely expected to cut borrowing costs at its next policy meeting on Thursday from the current level of 4.25% amid growing concerns about the strength of the economy
Domino’s Pizza profits dive as people cut back on takeaways in UK
Domino’s Pizza said the takeaway market had “become tougher” as it blamed weaker consumer confidence in the run-up to the autumn budget and rising wage costs for lower-than-expected sales and a slump in profits.After a drop of nearly 15% in half-year profits, the company now expected full-year underlying profits of between £130m and £140m, about £6m below analysts’ expectations.Domino’s said it was gaining market share but its franchise partners were being more cautious about opening new outlets because of higher employment costs. Employers’ national insurance payments and the legal minimum wage were both increased in April.The company opened 11 stores in the six months to the end of June, fewer than expected, and is now forecasting openings in the mid-20s for the full year
Neil Woodford and his investment firm fined almost £46m over fund failings
The former star stock picker Neil Woodford and his investment management company have been fined almost £46m by the UK’s financial regulator over the collapse of his popular equity fund.The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has given Woodford a penalty of £5.89m and banned him from holding senior manager roles and managing funds for retail investors and fined Woodford Investment Management (WIM) £40m.The penalties are for failures in their management of the flagship Woodford Equity Income Fund (WEIF), which closed in October 2019 after investors, including many ordinary retail customers, rushed to withdraw money in response to the poor performance of a number of company investments, including some hard-to-sell illiquid assets.The value of the fund fell from a high of more than £10
Guinness owner Diageo’s profits slump as it warns of $200m Trump tariff hit
The world’s biggest spirits company, Diageo, has revealed a slump in annual profits and expanded its cost-cutting plan as it searches for a new boss after the resignation of the chief executive, Debra Crew.The FTSE 100 company, which owns brands including Guinness, Johnnie Walker whisky, Gordon’s gin and Smirnoff vodka, reported a nearly 28% fall in operating profit in the 12 months to the end of June compared with a year earlier.The drinks maker also upped its target for cost savings from £500m to £625m. The interim CEO, Nik Jhangiani, said the savings were “not about job cuts”, adding that while some roles would go, the overall workforce could still increase.The figures come weeks after the surprise announcement that the group had begun the hunt for a successor to Crew, who it said had stepped down “by mutual agreement”, after a period of investor disquiet over its declining share price
Home cooking and minimally processed foods best for weight loss, study finds
Experts express concern for future of Health Survey for England
Call to crack down on ‘hooch’ and medicine in prisons after Dorset death
A Clockwork Orange estate fights ‘art washing’ redevelopment plans
‘Cat-sized’ rat found in Teesside town puts focus on pest control cuts
UK pornography taskforce to propose banning ‘barely legal’ content after Channel 4 documentary airs