Home cooking and minimally processed foods best for weight loss, study finds
People lose more weight if they cook minimally processed food from scratch than if they eat ultra-processed and ready-made foods, according to the first study to establish a clear link between ultra-processed foods (UPFs) and weight.Trial participants were given one of two diets with the same nutritional profile for eight weeks.One diet was made up of UPFs while the other comprised minimally processed foods.When the first group ate breakfast bars and ready-made lasagne, for example, the second ate oats soaked in milk and natural yoghurt and homemade spaghetti bolognese.At the end of the trial, participants on the second diet had lost twice as much weight as those on the first.
Prof Chris van Tulleken, an author of the study and of the book Ultra-Processed People, said: “The global food system at the moment drives diet-related poor health and obesity, particularly because of the wide availability of cheap, unhealthy food.“This study highlights the importance of ultra-processing in driving health outcomes in addition to the role of nutrients like fat, salt and sugar.It underlines the need to shift the policy focus away from individual responsibility and on to the environmental drivers of obesity, such as the influence of multinational food companies in shaping unhealthy food environments.”The study by University College London and UCL hospitals NHS trust was designed to address the lack of good-quality evidence on the health outcomes of UPFs.The findings suggest that choosing minimally processed foods and cooking from scratch as much as possible rather than buying ultra-processed packaged foods or ready meals may be more effective for losing weight.
Minimally processed means that a food has undergone limited alteration from its natural state, for example fruits, vegetables, whole grains, meat, fish and dairy products such as natural yoghurt.UPFs have been significantly altered and typically contain ingredients not commonly used in home cooking, such as artificial flavours, preservatives and emulsifiers.People who followed the UPF diet consumed 120 calories fewer than usual and lost 1% of their weight on average during the study.Those who followed the minimally processed diet consumed 290 calories fewer and lost 2% of their weight on average, including much more fat mass.Over a year, this could scale up to a 13% weight reduction for men and 9% for women, the researchers said.
Dr Samuel Dicken, the first author of the study, said that while previous research has linked UPFs with poor health outcomes, not all are “inherently unhealthy”,But, he explained, because UPFs have a softer texture and are more calorie-dense, they do make it easier to overeat,The study, published in Nature Medicine, split 55 adults with an average BMI of 32, indicating obesity, into two groups, who followed one diet for eight weeks, returned to their normal diet for four weeks, and then swapped to the other diet for another eight weeks,The diets were nutritionally matched in accordance with government advice on healthy eating from the Eatwell Guide,Participants had food containing more calories than they needed delivered to their homes and were told to eat as much or as little as they wanted, as they would normally.
Participants also completed questionnaires to assess food cravings, which found significant improvements in the number of cravings and ability to resist them on the minimally processed diet compared with the UPF one – despite the fact that weight loss is often associated with stronger cravings.The team recommended that policymakers use warning labels, marketing restrictions, progressive taxation and subsidies to increase awareness and make healthy diets affordable for all.Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionDr Adrian Brown, another author of the study, said: “The cost-of-living crisis has impacted people’s choices on food.Healthy food is up to two times more expensive than unhealthy food.”Rob Percival, the Soil Association’s head of food policy, said: “For decades, the UK government’s ‘healthy eating’ guidelines have neglected processing, assuming that whole foods and ultra-processed products might deliver the same health outcomes.
We now know that to be false,”A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said the government had commissioned research to understand more about the health impacts of UPFs and was “committed to tackling obesity and building a healthier Britain”,Meanwhile, the NHS should do more to help those who have come off a course of obesity drugs or just finished a weight loss programme, to ensure they do not regain the pounds they have lost,Such people should receive regular check-ups, advice and tailored action plans to help ensure they stay healthy, according to the National Institute for health and Clinical Excellence,Minimally processedBreakfast: Cinnamon and apple overnight oats Lunch: Mexican chicken with salad and flatbread Dinner: Home-cooked cottage pie with green beans and cornUltra processedBreakfast: Oat and fruit breakfast bar Lunch: Meal deal-style packaged chicken tikka wrap Dinner: Ready-made cottage pie with greens and corn
Share your question for the Green party leadership candidates
Voting is underway in the leadership contest for the Green party of England and Wales. Current party co-leader Adrian Ramsay has teamed up with MP Ellie Chowns, after Carla Denyer decided not to stand for re-election.The party membership will have to decide between the Ramsay and Chowns ticket or the Green party’s current deputy leader, Zack Polanski.Ramsay, who was elected as Green party MP for Waveney Valley in 2024, has been co-leader since 2021. He was previously the deputy leader of the Green party of England and Wales from 2008 to 2012
Truss accuses Badenoch of not telling truth about Tory failures
The Conservative leader, Kemi Badenoch, is not telling the truth about the “real failures of 14 years of Conservative government”, the former Conservative prime minister Liz Truss has said.Writing in the Telegraph, Truss said: “In a recent speech Kemi said: ‘From now on, we are going to be telling the British people the truth even when it is difficult to hear.’ If she’s not willing to tell the truth to her own supporters, the Conservative party is in serious trouble.”Truss’s comments came after Badenoch’s own Telegraph article in which she claimed the current Labour government was failing to heed the warnings of the disastrous mini-budget that defined Truss’s short-lived premiership.The former prime minister has been fighting a desperate battle to rewrite the narrative around her 45 days in office in 2022
Like Clement Attlee, Keir Starmer must rise to the occasion | Letters
Martin Kettle rightly says Aneurin Bevan is the one politician other than Clement Attlee whom Labour leaders regularly invoke (Critics say Starmer is no Attlee – and they’re right. Labour must look to the future, not the past, 31 July). Keir Starmer has drawn on Harold Wilson for inspiration, but more pertinent to Kettle’s argument is David Lammy claiming a role model in Ernest Bevin. Made minister of labour in 1940 and foreign secretary in 1945, Ernie Bevin dominated the decade. Bevin sought a continued US military presence in Europe but had no illusions about the “special relationship”
Journey times up, deaths down: Welsh 20mph speed limit still divisive two years on
A few weeks ago, two groups of protesters gathered on the steps of the Senedd in Cardiff Bay. One demonstration was against the war in Gaza; the other, against the Welsh government’s two-year-old default 20mph speed limit in urban areas.The change from 30mph was brought in by the Welsh Labour government across about 35% of the country’s roads in September 2023, at a cost of £34m. The reduced speed limit applied to any built-up area, defined as roads where lamp-posts were no more than about 180 metres apart.Last week a small study by GoSafe, which monitors road cameras, found the policy had added an average of two minutes to journey times of differing lengths, aggravating an already bitter culture war over legislation designed to save lives
UK to evacuate ill and injured children from Gaza to receive NHS care
The UK government will evacuate seriously ill and injured children from Gaza to the UK for NHS treatment under a scheme to be announced within weeks.Ministers will enable children in severe need to receive taxpayer-funded care. Three children were brought to the UK this year through a private scheme by the charity Project Pure Hope.A government spokesperson said: “We are taking forward plans to evacuate more children from Gaza who require urgent medical care, including bringing them to the UK for specialist treatment where that is the best option for their care.“We are working at pace to do so as quickly as possible, with further details to be set out in due course
Chris Bryant MP says he was abused at 16 by former head of National Youth Theatre
The MP Chris Bryant has said he was sexually abused as a teenager by the former head of the National Youth Theatre, Michael Croft.The Labour MP, who is an arts and telecoms minister, said he was 16 when he was abused by Croft, who was around 40 years his senior and died in 1986.In an interview with the Sunday Times before the publication of his memoir, Bryant said Croft invited him to dinner every evening while he was attending company rehearsals in London during the summer of 1978, and that they would go to his house afterwards.He recalled coming back from the toilet one evening at Croft’s house to find his host naked except for a silk robe. He said Croft then asked him for oral sex, which he felt he had no option but to go through with, leaving him feeling as if he was “a 16-year-old whore”
My cultural awakening: Minecraft taught me how to navigate life as a transgender person – one block at a time
From The Naked Gun to Wednesday: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Seth Meyers on the Epstein conspiracy: ‘This is a crisis of Trump’s making’
A men’s only club in Sydney has banned sockettes. Is it Victorian-era modesty or fashion policing below the ankle?
Justin Timberlake reveals Lyme disease diagnosis
Seth Meyers on Maga’s Epstein scandal: ‘They did this to themselves’