Lib Dems call for urgent regulation of YouTube ads after wave of scams

A picture


The Liberal Democrats are calling for urgent regulation of YouTube advertising after scams including deepfakes, impersonated public figures and fraudulent investment claims were found to be spreading on the platform with little oversight.The party said YouTube’s adverts remain largely unchecked by independent regulators, despite new data from Ofcom showing the platform has overtaken ITV in weekly UK viewership and continues to dominate children’s media consumption.Among the recent scams onYouTube was a series of ads using an AI-generated voice and likeness of the consumer champion Martin Lewis to promote a cryptocurrency scheme, despite Lewis having no involvement.The videos, which have drawn thousands of complaints on Reddit and X, mislead users into thinking they are receiving financial advice from a trusted source.Other viewers have reported false product claims, scam diet pills and fake competitions.

In one Reddit thread users reported being targeted with ads impersonating UK media figures or pretending to offer government-backed grants, with little clarity over how to report or block such content.YouTube adverts fall under the same Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) rules as TV, but unlike broadcasters, there is no pre-approval, real-time scrutiny or independent enforcement unless someone complains.The ASA has previously warned of a rise in “celebrity deepfake” and “impersonation” scams on online platforms, particularly for financial services.The lack of mandatory pre-approval or independent enforcement means that many of these adverts remain online for days before action is taken, if any is.Max Wilkinson, the Liberal Democrats’ spokesperson for culture, media and sport, said the system leaves the public exposed.

“We cannot allow a two-tier system where traditional broadcasters face robust scrutiny, while a digital giant like YouTube is allowed to mark its own homework,” he said.The party is calling for YouTube advertising to be brought into line with the system used for TV and radio, including tougher oversight, clearer accountability, and the power for Ofcom to levy fines on platforms that repeatedly allow harmful or misleading ads.It also wants revenues from those fines used to support victims of online scams.YouTube ads are served through Google Ads and are regulated under a voluntary framework created by the tech industry.This contrasts with the ASA’s co-regulatory model for broadcast advertising, where Ofcom retains backstop powers and many adverts must be pre-cleared before airing.

Privately, some Labour MPs acknowledge that online ad regulation is “behind the curve”, but there is little appetite for major change,Others have warned that new restrictions could make it harder to target voters aged under 35, many of whom are disengaged from traditional media,Last month the Guardian revealed that Ofcom is preparing to push for new legal powers to require platforms like YouTube to give greater prominence to public service content, amid concerns that trusted news, children’s programming and UK-produced shows are becoming “invisible” to younger viewers,The Lib Dems argue that the same logic should apply to advertising, especially given the rise in misleading financial content and impersonation scams,“YouTube is no longer a niche platform – it’s one of the main ways people of all ages consume news, entertainment and information,” said Wilkinson.

“The government needs to act now to ensure that consumers are properly protected.”A YouTube spokesperson said: “YouTube is not a broadcaster and it should not be regulated like one.“We have strict policies that govern the ads on our platform which we enforce rigorously.When we find ads that breach our policies we take immediate action, including removing the ads and suspending the account when necessary.”
politicsSee all
A picture

Keir Starmer plays down warnings that taxes will have to be raised in autumn

Keir Starmer has sought to play down warnings that the government will be forced to raise taxes this autumn and said some of the figures being circulated “are not ones I recognise”.The prime minister was responding to forecasts from the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR), which projected a shortfall of up to £51bn in the public finances, given a number of factors had knocked the chancellor’s plans to stay within Whitehall spending limits, including higher debt interest payments and U-turns on welfare spending cuts.NIESR said “moderate but sustained” tax rises would be needed in the autumn budget for Rachel Reeves to overcome the deficit of £41.2bn and then restore a near £10bn buffer in the current budget or be forced to use harsh cost-cutting measures in the autumn statement.Speaking during a visit to Milton Keynes, Starmer disagreed with the economists’ warnings

A picture

Rachel Reeves needs to put up taxes to cover £40bn deficit, thinktank says

Rachel Reeves will need to raise taxes to close a government spending gap that is on course to reach more than £40bn after a slowdown in economic growth and higher-than-expected inflation, according to a leading thinktank.In a blow to Labour’s hopes of balancing the books without breaking manifesto commitments ruling out personal tax rises, the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR) said a number of factors would knock off course the chancellor’s plans to stay within Whitehall spending limits.These factors included headwinds from Donald Trump’s tariff war, higher debt interest payments and U-turns on welfare spending cuts.NIESR said “moderate but sustained” tax rises would be needed in the autumn budget for Reeves to overcome a deficit of £41.2bn and then restore a near £10bn buffer in the current budget, forcing the Treasury to raise more than £51bn from taxes, secure extra borrowing or use severe cost-cutting measures to find extra savings

A picture

Labour thinktank offers sponsorship packages to meet and influence ‘key policymakers’

A Labour thinktank has been offering sponsorship packages where businesses can meet and influence MPs and ministers, according to a report.The Labour Infrastructure Forum (LIF) has been offering companies the chance to sponsor events at which they can meet “key policymakers” in private and “shape the discussion”, the Times said.An LIF prospectus lists a set of sponsorship packages on offer for companies, including a £7,850 deal for a “private breakfast/dinner roundtable with an influential Labour figure”.Other deals on offer include £11,750 for a “parliamentary panel event with key policymakers”, and between £21,500 and £30,000 for a “Westminster drinks reception”. The prices are not inclusive of VAT

A picture

Support for hardline anti-immigration policies linked to ignorance about migration figures, poll suggests – as it happened

YouGov has released detailed polling on attitudes to immigration that shows a clear link between having hardline anti-immigrant views and being ignorant about the level of illegal immigration into the UK.It is well known that many people massively over-estimate the extent to which irregular migration contributes to the overall net migration figures, which reached a record high of 900,000 in the year ending June 2023.The confusion is partly explained by the huge media and political attention given to people arriving illegal in the UK on small boats. But the annual small boat arrival figure has never been higher than the 46,000 total it reached in 2022 – although it is on course to pass that this year.The YouGov polling suggests that, while cutting migration numbers signifcantly but still allowing some migrants into the country is the policy with most support (very broadly, this is also what Labour and the Tories advocate), almost half of voters either strongly (26%) or somewhat (19%) support “admitting no more new migrants and requiring large numbers of migrants who came to the UK in recent years to leave”

A picture

Scottish ministers criticised for slow progress in exam passes for poorer students

Ministers in Scotland are facing intense criticism over a sluggish increase in exam passes by teenagers from deprived areas after repeated promises to greatly improve performance.Opposition parties and Scotland’s largest teaching union said progress in closing the attainment gap – the difference between exam passes for pupils from the wealthiest areas and those from the most deprived – was too slow and too patchy.In 2016, Nicola Sturgeon, then the first minister, published her government’s legislative programme with the promise that “substantially eliminating” the attainment gap by 2026 would be her government’s “defining mission”.This year’s exam results showed that the attainment gap had closed slightly year on year for pupils sitting National 5s, the Scottish equivalent to GCSEs, falling from 17.2 percentage points last year to 16

A picture

‘We’re the party of ambition’: Plaid Cymru sets out to topple Labour

It is fair to say that Rhun ap Iorwerth, the leader of Plaid Cymru, was on safe ground at the national Eisteddfod in Wrexham this week. More than once, festivalgoers interrupted his interview with the Guardian to shake his hand or take a selfie.Ap Iorwerth has just embarked on a nationwide “listening tour” during which he will visit every Welsh constituency, beginning in Wrexham, before the Senedd elections next May.On Tuesday, the Welsh nationalist party celebrates its 100th anniversary, and ap Iorwerth believes he is on the verge of delivering the best present the party could ever ask for: ending Labour’s long reign to win power in Wales for the first time.“Wales gave Keir Starmer his big majority but I don’t think [voters] expected this barrage of bad policy, passing on the cost of the failures of successive governments to the most vulnerable,” the 52-year-old said of the UK Labour government’s refusal to lift the two-child benefit cap and attempts to cut the winter fuel payment and disability benefits