Proportional representation is true rule by the people | Letters
Gaby Hinsliff (Nobody wants to defend Britain’s voting system any more – but here’s why I will, 26 February) writes that proportional representation (PR) “doesn’t guarantee that we could all just vote for what we want instead of endlessly against what we fear (ask the French)”.Yet France does not use PR, which is precisely why tactical blocking occurs there.Indeed, there is overwhelming cross-party support in France for moving towards PR.Under first past the post (FPTP), whoever wins the most votes takes the seat, even without a majority.That means a majority of voters in a constituency can end up unrepresented, as in Gorton and Denton, where six in 10 votes were not represented.
The debate becomes not who can best represent you, but who can most likely beat someone else.Much of the byelection became precisely this: Labour and Green supporters second-guessing the “anti-Reform” candidate rather than voting for what they actually wanted.Hinsliff warns that PR risks coalitions “dangerously prone either to making disproportionately powerful kingmakers of tiny fringe parties … or making junior partners renege on their promises”.Yet Britain has experienced both: the Liberal Democrats’ broken promises in 2010 and the 10 kingmaker DUP MPs in 2017.The difference is that PR begins from representation that reflects how people voted.
If we take Hinsliff’s metric of doing “a sterling job of keeping extremists out”, she herself notes Reform could theoretically win 48% of seats on just 27% of the vote under FPTP,Under PR, such vote shares do not translate into majorities,Ultimately voting systems should exist to reflect the will of the people,If they do not, is it rule of the people or rule by the system?Hugo HarveyYouth ambassador, Make Votes Matter Polly Toynbee articulately explains why our current election system is outdated and potentially dangerous (Want to stop Farage with your vote? At the moment you can’t – and Starmer must fix that, theguardian,com, 4 March).
But, while FPTP often produces lopsided, unrepresentative outcomes – 2024 being the most recent example – PR allows tiny parties undue influence.In Germany, the Free Democrats stayed in power for many years, regardless of election results, for this reason.Imagine Nigel Farage exploiting that situation.Despite all their current problems, maybe France’s two-round system can teach us something.If their last parliamentary election had been held under FPTP, the extreme right would have won a majority, on a minority of votes.
Instead, progressive parties cooperated so that, in the second round, voters mostly had a straight choice between democratic and far-right candidates.The outcome of the Gorton and Denton byelection suggests that such a system could work here, and stop extremists sneaking into power.Peter Loschi Oldham, Greater Manchester As a long-term campaigner for proportional representation, I feel strongly that we all have to understand that changing the voting system does not change people’s opinions.There will still be dishonest and disingenuous politicians who blame scapegoats rather than engaging with the complex issues that face the modern world.PR won’t make Reform go away – but what it does do is stop political parties gaming a system that is designed for two parties.
Multiple parties are good and healthy for democracy.Grownup politics is about listening to other points of view, working together and finding the best compromises available.PR won’t get rid of the bad actors but it will make it easier to keep them from dominating.Caroline HuntGwernogle, Carmarthenshire Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
T20 World Cup final, Six Nations, FA Cup and F1 returns – follow with us
Formula One’s new era gets under way at the season-opening Australian Grand Prix, where teams will leap into the unknown and grapple with sweeping technical changes under race conditions for the first time. F1 has simultaneously overhauled chassis and power unit regulations for the first time in decades, posing a challenge for drivers and engineers alike while raising concerns about the quality of racing. The new rules have raised hopes of a more open championship and the prospect of a disruptor team emerging. But pre-season testing in Bahrain hinted at a familiar top four, with Ferrari, Mercedes, Red Bull and McLaren all performing well. Joey Lynch buckles up for our qualifying blog, with Giles Richards reporting from Albert Park
Nine speeding tickets and counting: Myles Garrett and the illusion of invincibility | Lee Escobedo
The taste of cold beer lingered on my lips as I cut through the quiet night, 105mph toward cigarettes and hot wings. Halfway to my destination, Beyoncé’s Irreplaceable looping through the speakers, my tires hugged the winding turns around the lake that separated my neighborhood from the city. I was young and careless, high on anticipation. No seat belt. Eyes squinting through the haze of cigarette smoke
Stakes sky high for England as Italy eye Six Nations upset for the ages | Robert Kitson
Most England fans will remember the classic final scene in The Italian Job. The bus precariously balanced on the edge of a precipice, the golden loot slipping away. One false move and it’s curtains. Welcome to this weekend’s sequel with Steve Borthwick and his under-pressure England players replacing Michael Caine – “Hang on a minute, lads, I’ve got a great idea” – and the rest of the original film’s cast.Talk about the self-preservation society
Naoya Inoue to face Junto Nakatani in historic Tokyo Dome megafight
Japan’s Naoya Inoue said Friday that he will need to be at his destructive best when he faces unbeaten countryman Junto Nakatani in their highly anticipated showdown at Tokyo Dome in May.The two fighters met in Tokyo to formally confirm their 2 May clash, with Inoue set to defend his undisputed super bantamweight world championship against Nakatani, who is moving up in weight in pursuit of a fourth divisional title.Both fighters are unbeaten and the long-anticipated bout is expected to draw enormous interest in Japan and beyond.“May 2 will be a historic day for boxing,” said Inoue, who will be making the seventh defense of his undisputed crown.“But in terms of my boxing career, I have to think of it as just a point on the way,” added the 32-year-old, whose record stands at 32-0 with 27 knockouts
Scotland sense chance against France to end cycle of brilliance and despair | Michael Aylwin
The mischievous will have eyes on Rome on Saturday in case of a historic win but the game of the weekend is in Edinburgh. Second versus first, Scotland versus France, entertainers versus entertainers. The title on the line. We could even have a champion by the end of it.If France win with a bonus point, that is it
World Cup exit ‘a tough pill to swallow’ for England’s Jacob Bethell after maiden T20 ton
Jacob Bethell described England’s T20 World Cup semi-final defeat by India as “a tough pill to swallow” after his first century in the format failed to prevent his team’s elimination in Thursday’s record-obliterating Mumbai run-fest.The 22-year-old had never scored a senior hundred in any format and for any side when he first broke into the England team towards the end of 2024. But less than six months after banking his debut ton against South Africa in an ODI he became just the fourth Englishman to reach triple figures in all three international formats – just a week after Harry Brook’s spectacular innings against Pakistan made him the third.“I always had the self-belief to be able to do it,” Bethell said. “Me and Brooky were joking about who was going to be the first to get all three
Ian Arnot obituary
Iran war pushes oil price above $90 threatening rise in global inflation
The Guardian view on AI in war: the Iran conflict shows that the paradigm shift has already begun
Ben Affleck sells his AI postproduction startup to Netflix
Ireland v Wales: Six Nations rugby union – live
‘I believe I can do it’: George Russell favourite for F1 title as new era begins