Reform UK’s ugly response to slavery reparations claims | Letters
It is not necessary to agree with the slavery reparations movement in order to see through the crude and threadbare logic of Zia Yusuf’s tirade against it (Reform UK would stop visas for people from countries seeking slavery reparations, 7 April),Britain’s prominent role in ending the slave trade and subsequently slavery neither absolves its involvement in those enterprises nor erases their effects,Endless reiteration of it does, however, encourage a sentimental attachment to a single, insular version of history,Similarly, to claim that advocates for reparations are using history “as a weapon to drain our treasury” is a wilful misrepresentation, designed to jolt the indignant reflexes of Reform UK supporters too lazy to engage with extensive argument,But the ugly coup de grace in Yusuf’s diatribe is his willingness to demonise whole populations whose governments have the audacity to question historical narrative or to possess opinions built on principle – a crime so heinous that it deserves the denial of visas for entry to Britain.
Typically, however, Reform’s right brain rarely knows what its left hemisphere is up to.So, Nigel Farage’s coincidental statement that “I think if we start banning people from entering the country because we don’t like what they say, I worry where that ends up” (with reference to Kanye West) ought to see Yusuf beat an ignominious retreat.But, unfortunately, this is unlikely, as Reform is as hypocritical as it is dishonest.Paul McGilchristCromer, Norfolk I am confident that my ancestor William Wilberforce would find the Reform party’s claim that the UK made “huge sacrifices” to end the slave trade both ignorant and tone‑deaf.Should we be lamenting no longer being able to profit from the labour of men, women and children denied their freedom and often treated appallingly?Enslavers and plantation owners had to be compensated handsomely by the British government to get the 1833 act that abolished slavery in the British empire through parliament.
These did not compensate formerly enslaved people for their enslavement, or take steps to rehabilitate them.Many were forced to continue working for their former enslavers in similar working conditions.The question of reparations is a complex one.To deny visas to members of the nations seeking them, many of whom will be descendants of enslaved people, is nasty and small-minded.Applications should be considered on their merits, and many to whom visas are granted will benefit this country in all sorts of ways.
Sebastian WilberforceTai Tapu, New Zealand European countries involved in slavery and the US should pay reparations (Commonwealth leaders vow to keep seeking reparations after Reform UK plan to halt visas, 7 April).The profits from slavery created vast wealth for white UK and US “owners” of enslaved people.None of the perpetrators of that vile crime were held to account – and none of the proceeds were confiscated.On the contrary, the UK government compensated the perpetrators and profiteers.Forty six thousand UK owners of enslaved people were compensated for their “loss”.
The government took out a massive loan (not fully repaid until 2015) and gave each owner, on average, about £400,000 in today’s values.African enslaved people were given nothing by the UK or the US – except, in the case of US freed people, the famous broken promise of 40 acres and a mule.Chris Hughes Leicester Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Votes for populist parties in May elections will put NHS at risk, Streeting says
Voters in May’s local and devolved elections risk putting the NHS in jeopardy if they vote for populist parties, Wes Streeting has said, as he sought to make the health service a key battleground.“The founding principles of the NHS are at greater threat than at any time since the NHS was founded in 1948,” the health secretary said.He warned that there was “a particular jeopardy” for the NHS in Wales, where Labour faces electoral wipeout at the hands of Reform UK and Plaid Cymru, with the latter pitching itself to voters as the best “stop Reform” option.Streeting called Labour’s progressive rivals “rookies” and said he “refuse[d] to believe that many people in Wales would vote for Reform if they knew where Nigel Farage stood on the NHS”.Streeting argued that the NHS in Scotland was weaker after almost two decades of SNP governance, while in England Labour-run councils would work more efficiently with Labour in government
Tories would reinstate two-child benefit cap to fund defence, says Badenoch
The Conservatives would reinstate the two-child benefit cap and use the savings for a wide-ranging spending splurge on defence in what Kemi Badenoch said would be “the biggest peacetime programme of rearmament in our country’s history”.Speaking at a defence conference in London, the Tory leader criticised the government for Britain’s “lack of readiness” for war, which has been exposed by recent world events.Badenoch said the UK needed to “reassert” itself as a global power and committed the Tories to “the largest net increase in British troops under any government since the second world war” if they returned to power at the next general election.The pledge would involve recruiting 6,000 full-time soldiers and 14,000 reservists. The Tories say they could raise £20bn towards the venture by reinstating the two-child benefit cap and reallocating money earmarked for net zero projects
UK starts crackdown on EU citizens’ post-Brexit rights
UK ministers are to start removing post-Brexit residency rights from EU citizens who are no longer “continuously” living in the country.The initiative is legal under the 2020 Brexit withdrawal agreement, but the decision to use travel data to partly determine absences has raised concerns after the HMRC fiasco in which almost 20,000 parents were stripped of child benefits because of inaccurate Home Office border data.The Home Office said the crackdown was aimed at those who had received “pre-settled status” to remain in the UK before Brexit, a status that applied to anyone who had been in the UK for less than five years.Officials will start with those believed to have left the country more than five years ago and there will be safeguards including consideration of reasons for prolonged absences.The Home Office said the crackdown protected public services and was aimed at preventing unlawful immigration by abuse of the system
Reform UK local election candidate was twice disciplined by Tories over ‘racist comments’
A Reform UK candidate for next month’s council elections was twice disciplined by the Conservatives over alleged offensive or racist comments, while another shared conspiracy theories about Covid, it has emerged, as the full slate of candidates was confirmed.More than 5,000 council places in England are being contested on 7 May, along with several mayoralties, and elections for the Scottish and Welsh parliaments, in a significant test for all the major parties.Councils began publishing lists of confirmed candidates on Friday, after the closure of nominations at 4pm on Thursday. Reform says it is standing candidates in just over 95% of seats, around as many as Labour. Nigel Farage, Reform UK’s leader, has said the party’s vetting procedures have been beefed up
Starmer implies he didn’t tell Trump he was ‘fed up’ about his impact on rising UK energy bills – as it happened
Keir Starmer has recorded a short pooled TV interview in Qatar this morning. It did not really add much to what we have heard him say before but, for the record, here are the main lines.Starmer implied that he declined the opportunity to tell Donald Trump in person how “fed up” he is about the president’s impact on UK energy bills (see 9.01am) when they spoke last night. He said their focus in the call was on the need for a “practical plan” to open the strait of Hormuz
Not just about Gaza: the Muslim voters turning from Labour to the Greens
Campaigning in Newcastle before next month’s local elections shows the rise of the far right, the climate and cost of living are concerning voters as much as the Middle EastMohammed Suleman, a self-described “straight-talking Geordie”, doesn’t love politics. The taxi driver and businessman prefers to focus on community initiatives. But when the time came, he voted Labour as the lesser of two evils.Then came the war in Gaza.A month into the war, which a UN committee would later describe as a genocide, Suleman, and others at his local mosque, began a petition calling on their Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West Labour MP, Chi Onwurah, to vote for a ceasefire
Wigan edge out Wakefield in thriller to set up mouthwatering Saints semi-final
Fury only wants Joshua but after 10 years of wrangling will superfight ever happen?
Gout Gout leaves onlookers dumbfounded with record-breaking run drawn from the future | Jack Snape
Gout Gout smashes 20-second barrier to set new 200m national record
Rory McIlroy aims for ‘freer’ state of mind in final round of Masters after losing six-shot lead
Cameron Young reels in Rory McIlroy with pack on their tails for Masters finale