Is Farage right to claim that racism allegations are response to a dislike of his politics?

A picture


Nigel Farage has again denied allegations of racism as a schoolboy and repeated his claim that some had been concocted because people disliked his politics.During a press conference, he snapped at one reporter who asked about the issue, saying: “I think we’ve gone quite a long way towards answering all this, don’t you?”Farage, who prides himself on answering numerous questions at press conferences, took 10 this time, but did not include any from the Guardian.So what did he say – and is it true?The claim: Farage said the director Peter Ettedgui is the “one person that said I directly abused him”.He added: “One person says they were hurt, and if they feel they were hurt, then I’m genuinely sorry.But I never, ever, ever would have said or done anything like that directly to a human being.

Absolutely not.”Analysis: Ettedgui is actually one of several contemporaries from minority ethnic backgrounds to claim Farage abused them when they were at school.Ettedgui, a Jewish student, has said: “[Farage] would sidle up to me and growl, ‘Hitler was right’ or ‘gas them’, sometimes adding a long hiss to simulate the sound of the gas showers.”Cyrus Oshidar has said Farage repeatedly called him a “Paki”.Another former pupil told the Guardian he was also directly targeted by Farage.

“[Farage] walked up to a pupil, flanked by two similarly tall mates, and spoke to anyone looking ‘different’.That included me on three occasions; asking me where I was from, and pointing away, saying, ‘That’s the way back’ to wherever you replied you were from.”The claim: Farage suggested the allegation he abused Ettedgui had only come from Ettedgui himself.Analysis: This is wrong.Seven other contemporaries have come forward to say they saw Farage abusing Ettedgui with antisemitic language.

Stefan Benarroch said: “[Ettedgui] was such a gentle soul and Farage – Farage made his life a fucking nightmare … They could only identify us, because we had to go to this stupid Jewish service in the science labs school.I mean, none of us were remotely religious.They would hang out there.Farage would hang out with his minions.And then they would taunt us as we would leave.

”Rickard Berg said: “He definitely had a go at Peter and there were a couple of others he would also have a go at … He was nasty, there was no question,[The song] Gas ’em all, I heard him singing it to Ettedgui,I didn’t get it at the time, because Peter didn’t react,Back in the day, you thought it was for him to react,”Anthony Butler said: “I clearly recall him relentlessly hectoring and bullying Ettedgui with shouts of ‘stupid yid’ in the playground.

” Butler offered an apology to Ettedgui.Jean-Pierre Lihou said: “[Farage] used to say things like, you know, ‘Jude’, to Peter, which is the German for Jew, in the way it was said in the 1930s, a long ‘u’ in a menacing way, you know? It’s pretty awful.”Bob Jope, a former teacher, said: “I think he [Farage] said ‘Shut up you Jew’ to Peter Ettedgui.”Martin Rosell said: “[Farage] certainly made comments to the Jewish guy in that class, Peter Ettedgui … Comments like, under his breath, sort of ‘Jew’ … and comments about how they ‘missed you’, that sort of thing.”If you have something to share about this story, you can contact Henry using one of the following methods.

Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories.Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don’t already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Select ‘Secure Messaging’.

To send a message to Henry Dyer please choose the ‘UK Investigations’ team.Email (not secure)If you don’t need a high level of security or confidentiality you can email henry.dyer@theguardian.com.SecureDrop and other secure methodsIf you can safely use the tor network without being observed or monitored you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform.

Finally, our guide at theguardian.com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.The claim: Farage has suggested that some of the more than 20 people who have made claims about his behaviour in school did so for political reasons.“Look at what they say.None of them say, I directly attack them or abuse them,” Farage said.

“What they do say, they do say, very clearly, is they have different political views to me.”Analysis: The overwhelming majority of the contemporaries that the Guardian has spoken to are not active in party politics.Some disagree with him, and dislike Reform, but they say they came forward because of his denials about his past behaviour – and their expectation that he should show some contrition.One of those who spoke out, Martin Rosell, is the chair of the Liberal Democrats in Salisbury.Farage was told this by the Guardian prior to publication.

His account is supported by others,Farage has cited the example of Roger Gough, a former Conservative leader of Kent county council,But Gough was not among the individuals who claimed they had either been victims of, or witnesses to, racist and antisemitic behaviour by Farage,
societySee all
A picture

Shortfall in return on investment in health | Brief letters

Lord Hutton writes of the NHS health centres that have been built thanks to private finance (Letters, 23 November). In Didcot we’ve been waiting more than 10 years for the Great Western Park health centre. The return on investment required by the developer is greater than the NHS will reimburse. The local integrated care board fears that at that cost they’ll not get a GP practice to take on the health centre.Cllr Sarah JamesVale of White Horse district council Congratulations on the print-edition headline “Lights, Canberra, no action”, about England’s beaten cricketers not playing in the Australian capital (24 November)

A picture

‘I didn’t even know this type of attack existed’: more than 200 women allege drugging by senior French civil servant

When Sylvie Delezenne, a marketing expert from Lille, was job-hunting in 2015, she was delighted to be contacted on LinkedIn by a human resources manager at the French culture ministry, inviting her to Paris for an interview.“It was my dream to work at the culture ministry,” she said.But instead of finding a job, Delezenne, 45, is now one of more than 240 women at the centre of a criminal investigation into the alleged drugging of women without their knowledge in a place they never expected to be targeted: a job interview.An investigating judge is examining allegations that, over a nine-year period, dozens of women interviewed for jobs by a senior civil servant, Christian Nègre, were offered coffees or teas by him that had been mixed with a powerful and illegal diuretic, which he knew would make them need to urinate.Nègre often suggested continuing the interviews outside, on lengthy strolls far from toilets, the women say

A picture

Horrific death of Kardell Lomas sparks urgent calls for new independent oversight of police

Members of the federal government’s own expert advisory panel on sexual violence have called for “urgent” independent national oversight of police after new revelations about Queensland police failures before the killing of the First Nations woman Kardell Lomas.Guardian Australia’s Broken trust investigation revealed that Lomas, a 31-year-old Kamilaroi and Mununjali woman, had sought help from police and other agencies in the months before she was killed.Her family has applied for an inquest to examine, among other things, failures by police to help Lomas, protect her from her dangerous partner, or investigate evidence of domestic violence.A statement signed by 16 of the 20 members of the expert panel selected to advise the federal government about sexual violence law reform has called on the attorney general, Michelle Rowland, to take “urgent, decisive action” in relation to the case.They said the case highlighted issues they had raised throughout the Australian Law Reform Commission’s inquiry into justice responses to sexual violence but that the inquiry’s recommendations had not gone far enough

A picture

‘Outdated and ever less fit for purpose’: five takeaways from the carer’s allowance report

Of all the devastating passages in Liz Sayce’s 146-page criticism of the government’s failing carer’s allowance system, one above all leaps out. It describes how some felt so “overwhelmed”, ashamed and criminalised they considered killing themselves.One even investigated whether their fine would be cancelled if they died, only to find the government would still chase their family.The year-long independent review, sparked by a Guardian investigation, describes in brutal detail how those who have selflessly given up their lives to care for loved ones – saving the state an estimated £184bn a year – have been criminalised by a policy riddled with “systemic flaws” and a culture that assumed “negligence as a default”.The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has vowed to review a decade’s worth of carer’s allowance overpayments as a result

A picture

UK gambling firms make extra £1bn from punters amid calls for tax rises

The UK gambling sector made an extra £1bn from punters in the year to March, according to new data expected to buoy calls for the chancellor to raise betting taxes in Wednesday’s budget.Betting companies made £12.6bn from services excluding lotteries in the latest 12-month reporting period, the Gambling Commission revealed on Tuesday, a 9.3% rise on the £11.5bn the industry made during the previous year

A picture

CPS to train staff on ‘spectrum of abuse’ in violence against women and girls

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) will train its staff to recognise the “wide spectrum of abuse” in cases of violence against women, after new data found that domestic abuse was present in more than a third of rape cases, and in more than eight out of 10 cases of stalking and image-based abuse.Launching its five-year Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG) strategy, the body said its main aims were to increase casework quality and increase trust in the CPS.The CPS data found a significant overlap in crime types relating to violence against women and girls, with 93.5% of charges of “honour” crimes linked to domestic abuse, as well as 35.1% of rape charges, 82