John Swinney defends immigration as Scotland faces rise of Reform
Scotland needs immigration to bolster the size of its working-age population, the country’s first minister has said, mounting a forceful defence of diversity in the face of rising support for Reform ahead of next May’s Holyrood elections.John Swinney was speaking at the end of a year marked by a significant shift in Scottish public sentiment, with Nigel Farage’s party securing 26% of the vote in its first Holyrood byelection test.Farage now polls higher in popularity than Keir Starmer and Scotland has been forced to confront its prevailing self-image – heavily promoted by the Scottish National party government – as a welcoming country in the face of protests outside asylum hotels and flag raising across the country.“Of course I am concerned about it because I believe with every fibre of my body in the importance of inclusion within our society,” Swinney said.“During my lifetime Scotland has become a much more diverse country.
I’m very proud of that, and I want to make sure that remains our fundamental outlook,”As 750 of Reform UK’s Scottish supporters gather this weekend for an event with Farage, Swinney said he accepted that some “will be attracted by the absolutely core prejudicial message”,But he argued that far-right views of the type expressed at some asylum accommodation protests – which have taken place in East Kilbride, Falkirk, Perth, Aberdeen and most recently in Inverness, where the UK government is converting a barracks to house asylum seekers – represent “a very, very small minority in Scotland” and suggested there was “quite a lot of travelling support” for Reform,“What the far right do is to apportion the blame for those concerns to asylum seekers or migrants and I think that is the root of the poison that Farage and his cohorts are spreading within Scotland,” he said,Swinney also made a clear distinction, however, between those who hold far-right views and people with “legitimate points” about pressure on local services or community safety, which he noted were not unique to areas where migrants were housed.
Recent polling suggests immigration has become a voter priority for the first time in Scotland, and focus groups reference views previously more apparent in England and Wales that politicians fail to take such concerns seriously enough.Swinney said he was prepared to listen, but also wanted to engage in rational argument about the economic benefits of migration, particularly in the context of many people being “angry and frustrated” about living standards.He said he often spoke to businesses that were struggling to recruit staff.“We have a problem with the size of our working-age population, which I think needs to be addressed by migration,” he said.“It’s in all of our interests to have a welcoming economy that brings people in, can generate wealth and makes us all much wealthier as a consequence.
”He said he had of course spoken to voters with “strong views”.“My approach is not to dismiss people’s legitimate concerns, but I would engage with them and give them an alternative point of view,” he said.“My job as first minister is to do as much as I can to overcome those attitudes, to persuade them not to vote for Reform.“Let’s not think that the only pressure on public services is because of migration.We’ve been swimming against the tide of austerity since 2010, where public services have been consistently undermined through reductions in funding by the UK government.
”So people concerned about public services should blame the UK government rather than asylum seekers? Not the Scottish government? “We’ve taken decisions to break out the mould of austerity, like asking higher earners to pay more taxations so we can begin to invest in public services,,” he said,Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionScots of colour, including the former first minister Humza Yousaf, have previously cautioned against “Scottish exceptionalism”, particularly when the country avoided the far-right-led riots that swept England in the summer of 2024,Swinney denied complacency, pointing to a plethora of government programmes that promote community integration,“I don’t think at any stage were we immune from these sentiments,” he said.
He argued that the Brexit referendum, in which the majority of Scots voted to remain in the EU, proved that “at the beginning of all of this, very different attitudes prevailed in Scotland and the rest of the UK”.He also denied that a strategy of attacking Reform risked inadvertently boosting its vote, as some of his own MSPs suggested had happened in the Hamilton byelection, where the SNP lost the seat to Labour with Reform coming in a strong third from a standing start.“The visibility of their support is clear and if I don’t acknowledge that, you could quite easily say to me that I’ve missed something very significant in front of my eyes,” he said.Ahead of the SNP’s first Holyrood election campaign event, Swinney said he regrettably believed Reform would win seats in the Scottish parliament in May.Polling suggests the party will win a clutch of seats in the high teens through Holyrood’s proportional system.
The same polling has the SNP back in the lead after a disastrous general election result, with Labour pulled back to second place by the unpopularity of the UK government.Swinney would not be drawn on whether the SNP would work with Scottish Labour to lock Reform out of any kingmaker role, but offered the unsurprising “absolute guarantee” that he would not work with Reform and intended to win an outright majority.He said that after May there could well be a Plaid first minister in Wales, a Sinn Féin first minister in Northern Ireland and an SNP first minister in Scotland.“The UK government would have an altogether more challenging set of circumstances on its hands,” he said.
Sale blow 14-0 lead and slump to home defeat by Glasgow in Champions Cup opener
Losing is in danger of becoming a habit for Sale after a stellar Glasgow side headed back north with a bonus-point win in this Champions Cup opener.Alex Sanderson’s hosts, beaten here by Exeter a week ago and already off the pace in their Prem campaign, let slip an early 14-0 lead to a Warriors team packed with some of Scotland’s finest talent.Franco Smith’s men, inspired by the captain, Kyle Steyn, and centre pairing Stafford McDowall and Sione Tuipulotu, showed their mettle to beat Sale in this competition for the second season running.Several of Sale’s England internationals – George Ford, Tom Roebuck, Bevan Rodd, Luke Cowan-Dickie, Joe Carpenter and Asher Opoku-Fordjour – were unavailable. But defeats on their home turf on the outskirts of Salford have been a rarity in recent seasons under Sanderson; now they have suffered two inside a week
Norris’ date with F1 destiny arrives as he aims to keep Verstappen and Piastri at bay
He has a 12-point lead before Sunday’s Abu Dhabi GP but the British driver vows to ‘crack on’ if the title goes elsewhereThe atmosphere at a season-deciding finale in the Formula One world championship is like no other. The paddock positively hums with a febrile, pulsing excitement and sense of expectation that is impossible to ignore. Amid all of which the title favourite, Lando Norris, finds himself at the moment he has dedicated his life toward, destiny lying in his own hands.After a gruelling 23-race trek around the world, the conclusion of all the work, sacrifice and effort will be decided in just an hour and a half on Sunday afternoon in Abu Dhabi.Norris has been fascinating to observe across a season during which he opened on top, was then eclipsed by his McLaren teammate Oscar Piastri before mounting a comeback in the final third to retake the lead
Your Guardian sport weekend: F1 finale, the Ashes and Premier League
James Wallace and Rob Smyth will cover all the day-three action, over by over. The day-nighter at the Gabba has already thrown up more storylines than an entire season of Neighbours, and our team of writers – Ali Martin, Geoff Lemon and Simon Burnton – are in Brisbane for reports, news and analysis. Australian supporters are welcome to join the conversation, too.Emillia Hawkins and John Brewin take the controls for our essential weekly gateway to the day’s football action. There’ll be plenty of washup from Friday’s World Cup draw in Washington DC as well as team news, breaking stories and snippets from our reporters around the grounds
L’Eau Du Sud bids to create history in Tingle Creek for title leader Skelton
After his Crisp-like capitulation around the Elbow in the last two National Hunt trainers’ championships, Dan Skelton has set off at an even faster pace in this season’s title race and has already amassed more than £1.7m in prize money, nearly £1m ahead of second-placed Olly Murphy.The tally that is likely to matter most in April 2026, of course, will belong to Willie Mullins, who has shown that quality matters more than quantity by winning the last two titles with big hauls at the spring festivals, despite an overall aggregate winner-count of 300-66 in Skelton’s favour.But in that respect too there is encouragement for Skelton, who saddled 20 fewer winners in from May to the end of November than in the 2024-25 campaign, but upped his prize money total by nearly £450,000 year-on-year.It is a step up in terms of quality that may be further underscored at Sandown on Saturday when Skelton’s L’Eau Du Sud lines up for the Grade One Tingle Creek Chase against two top-class rivals in Mullins’s Il Etait Temps and Nicky Henderson’s popular and consistent Jonbon, the winner for the past two seasons
Saracens hatch plan to put dent in French dominance against Clermont
Judging by the Saracens side starting their Champions Cup campaign against Clermont Auvergne on Saturday, a show of strength is the aim. Owen Farrell, Elliot Daly, Tom Willis and Nick Isiekwe are some of the distinguished names who will line up in north London aiming to put a small, symbolic dent in the notion that French clubs are poised to dominate the competition again.Even without the rested England captain, Maro Itoje, and back-row Ben Earl – both recently returned from a successful autumn campaign – the quality of the lineup indicates the depth required for a deep tournament run.Noah Caluori, the 19-year-old who shot to prominence in October and was rewarded with an England call-up, makes his European debut: the presence of the 6ft 4in wing, allied to Farrell’s kicking prowess, will be causing some stress among Clermont’s coaching team.Saracens last lifted the trophy in 2019, when they beat Leinster in the final, and Caluori had yet to enter his teens
McLaren will use team orders in quest for F1 world drivers’ title in Abu Dhabi
Zak Brown has said McLaren will use team orders for Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri if required to ensure the team secure the Formula One drivers’ championship in the season finale at Abu Dhabi on Sunday.With Red Bull’s Max Verstappen trailing Norris by 12 points, the Dutchman still has a shot at taking the title from McLaren’s grasp. Piastri is a further four points back. Having spent all season allowing their drivers to race and attempting to be scrupulously fair to both, Brown announced at the Yas Marina circuit that if circumstances rendered it necessary, they would use orders.“Yes, of course
What is in the UK government’s child poverty strategy?
Mixed messages on prostate cancer testing proved deadly for my husband | Letter
We must warn travellers about the risk of methanol poisoning | Letters
Whales, beards, mules and VIPs: the secret world of high-rolling professional gambling
Tell us: have you lived in temporary accommodation in the UK with children?
Communities are our defence against hatred. Now, more than ever, we must invest in hope