Reeves braced for OBR forecasts to blow £20bn hole in tax and spending plans
Rachel Reeves is braced for revised forecasts by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) to blow a £20bn hole in her tax and spending plans before the autumn budget.Even without changing the totals the chancellor set out in her spending review on Wednesday, a weaker forecast from the the Treasury’s independent watchdog could force her to find significantly more money at the budget to meet her “non-negotiable” fiscal rules.Reeves has said repeatedly that flexing her fiscal rules – designed to provide certainty over UK public finances – is not an option even if the economic outlook deteriorates.At her spring statement, she left herself on course to meet those rules with less than £10bn of headroom to spare, on a total budget for day-to-day spending of more than £1.3tn.
Amid trepidation at the Treasury, the OBR has kicked off its annual summer review of the “supply side” of the economy – including productivity, which it has consistently overestimated.Sources with knowledge of the OBR’s thinking told the Guardian that the watchdog was “uncomfortable”, with the fact its current forecast for productivity growth was more positive than the consensus from other economic forecasters, and wanted to “rein it in”.Productivity is one of the key determinants of economic growth, and revising it down would have a significant knock on effect on the OBR’s forecasts for gross domestic product.The consultancy Oxford Economics estimates that moving the productivity forecast back in line with the average independent projection, would knock 1.4% off forecast GDP at the end of the OBR’s five-year forecast period.
That would force Reeves to increase taxes or cut spending by an eye-watering £20bn, to meet her fiscal rules and maintain her slim £10bn of headroom,That would be roughly equivalent to raising both the main and higher rates of income tax by 2p,A more cautious approach, taking the middle path between two alternative “scenarios” the OBR set out in its March economic and financial outlook, could still force the chancellor to make a £12bn correction,The OBR could send an early signal of its intention to revisit its productivity outlook as soon as 1 July, in its regular forecast evaluation report,Andy King, a former member of the OBR’s budget responsibility committee, now at the consultancy Flint Global, said: “The reason why anyone in the Treasury who cares about this will be worried, is that the OBR is currently more optimistic than everyone else.
“What can happen next? Either everyone else thinks, ‘We’re too pessimistic’; or the OBR thinks, ‘We are too far away from the pack, there’s been more bad news than good since March, we should revise down,’ I think that’s the expectation for many,”The Treasury is likely to point the OBR to policies it hopes will be positive for productivity growth in the long term, including infrastructure investment, though the scale of this was already known before the OBR’s last forecast in March,Alongside weaker productivity, slower net migration as a result of the government’s recent white paper could also prompt the OBR to be more pessimistic,Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionJames Smith an economist at ING, said: “Further downgrades to trend productivity growth projections, as well as net migration, mean the chancellor is likely in the red, before even considering the mounting pressures on the public purse.
“The overall shortfall may amount to at least £20bn, and that means tax rises are highly likely.”Adrian Pabst, the deputy director of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, said the prospect of another significant forecast revision underlined the current instability of tax and spend policy.“We’re in this vicious circle where we’ve got these fiscal rules, then the OBR have to take a view, because that’s their remit, that’s their mandate; and then we’re constantly speculating about what is going to happen at the next fiscal event,” he said, adding: “It’s not a good place for fiscal policy to be.”In a recent speech, Reeves said: “Strong and transparent fiscal rules are an indispensable safeguard for working people – and that is why my rules are non-negotiable.”The Treasury declined to comment on the prospect of an OBR growth downgrade but underlined Reeves’s determination to stick to her fiscal rules.
The OBR declined to comment.
AI could lead to more job cuts at BT, says chief executive
The chief executive of BT has said that advances in artificial intelligence could presage deeper jobs cuts at the FTSE 100 telecoms company, which has already outlined plans to shed up to 55,000 workers.Two years ago, the company said that between 40,000 and 55,000 jobs would be axed as it set out to become a “leaner” business by the end of the decade.However, in a weekend interview, its chief executive, Allison Kirkby, said the plan, which includes stripping out £3bn of costs, “did not reflect the full potential of AI”.“Depending on what we learn from AI … there may be an opportunity for BT to be even smaller by the end of the decade,” Kirkby said in an interview with the Financial Times.BT, which is the biggest broadband provider in the country, laid out plans in 2023 to cut the size of its workforce, including contractors, by 2030
Policymakers who think AI can help rescue flagging UK economy should take heed | Heather Stewart
From helping consultants diagnose cancer, to aiding teachers in drawing up lesson plans – and flooding social media with derivative slop – generative artificial intelligence is being adopted across the economy at breakneck speed.Yet a growing number of voices are starting to ask how much of an asset the technology can be to the UK’s sluggish economy. Not least because there is no escaping a persistent flaw: large language models (LLMs) remain prone to casually making things up.It’s a phenomenon known as “hallucination”. In a recent blogpost, the barrister Tahir Khan cited three cases in which lawyers had used large language models to formulate legal filings or arguments – only to find they slipped in fictitious supreme court cases, and made up regulations, or nonexistent laws
UK government rollout of Humphrey AI tool raises fears about reliance on big tech
The government’s artificial intelligence (AI) tool known as Humphrey is based on models from OpenAI, Anthropic and Google, it can be revealed, raising questions about Whitehall’s increasing reliance on big tech.Ministers have staked the future of civil service reform on rolling out AI across the public sector to improve efficiency, with all officials in England and Wales to receive training in the toolkit.However, it is understood the government does not have overarching commercial agreements with the big tech companies on AI and uses a pay-as-you-go model through its existing cloud contracts, allowing it to swap through tools as they improve and become competitive.Critics are concerned about the speed and scale of embedding AI from big tech into the heart of government, especially when there is huge public debate about the technology’s use of copyrighted material.Ministers have been locked in a battle with critics in the House of Lords over whether AI is unfairly being trained on creative material without credit of compensation
Hey AI! Can ChatGPT help you to manage your money?
Artificial intelligence seems to have touched every part of our lives. But can it help us manage our money? We put some common personal finance questions to the free version of ChatGPT, one of the most well-known AI chatbots, and asked for its help.Then we gave the answers to some – human – experts and asked them what they thought.We asked: I am 35 years old and want to ensure I have a comfortable retirement. I earn about £35,000 a year and have a workplace pension, in which I have saved £20,000
Bailey Smith hits the right note at Geelong but he is no showstopper | Jonathan Horn
Bailey Smith could easily have coasted along against Essendon on the weekend. He could have racked up a few dozen disposals for Geelong and saved his hamstrings for the far more onerous challenge of Brisbane this Friday. But that’s not how he’s wired. Everything is at full throttle. There is not a lot of craft or guile to how he plays
Tatjana Maria shocks Amanda Anisimova to win Queen’s Club women’s singles final – as it happened
Righto, that is us. Check back here and on sight for Tumaini Carayol’s match report which’ll be live shortly, but otherwise, thanks for your company – peace out.Maria tells BBC that her daughter liked the look of the trophy so she said “Let’s try to win it”.“Everything is possible if you believe in it,”she says, and that she’s trying to show that to the kids, who she knows are proud of her anyway. She was meant to be going to Nottingham tonight, but these things don’t happen often so they need to celebrate; doubtless her kids will want to “eat some crap with Nutella”
Disney and Universal sue AI image creator Midjourney, alleging copyright infringement
‘They went too far’: Musk says he regrets some of his posts about Trump
Meta to announce $15bn investment in bid to achieve computerised ‘superintelligence’
UK students and staff: tell us your experiences with AI at university
As big tech grows more involved in Gaza, Muslim workers are wrestling with a spiritual crisis
AI can ‘level up’ opportunities for dyslexic children, says UK tech secretary