Prominent PR firm accused of commissioning favourable changes to Wikipedia pages

A picture


A high-profile PR company founded by Keir Starmer’s communications chief has been accused of commissioning changes to Wikipedia pages to make them more favourable towards clients.Portland Communications, founded by Tim Allan, has been linked to the so-called black hat edits, sometimes referred to as “Wikilaundering”.Several changes were made to Wikipedia pages by a network of editors, allegedly controlled by a contractor working on Portland’s behalf.According to an investigation by the Bureau of Investigative Journalism (TBIJ), Portland outsourced Wikipedia editing relating to some of its high-profile clients, including the state of Qatar.TBIJ said it had evidence of alleged Wikipedia edits made on behalf of Portland between 2016 and 2024.

Between 2016 and 2021, many were made by Web3 Consulting, which is run by a consultant allegedly used by Portland to make edits.Portland was founded by Allan, a former adviser to Tony Blair, in 2001.There is no suggestion that Allan personally ordered any changes to be made or was aware of them.He sold most of his shares in the company in 2012 and left Portland in 2019.He was contacted for comment.

A spokesperson for Portland said: “Portland does not have a relationship with the firm mentioned and has a policy of strict adherence to the guidelines on all social media platforms.”A Portland employee said: “If anyone who worked here in the past did this, they were foolish.For sure nobody does it today.”TBIJ said some of the alleged edits were designed to improve Qatar’s image by burying references to critical reporting before the 2022 World Cup.The intermediary is alleged to have removed suggestions that a billion-dollar philanthropy project linked to another Portland client had failed to achieve its mission.

TBIJ found other subtle changes, such as relegating unwelcome information about clients under descriptions of their philanthropic work, or swapping out critical news references to articles with something more positive.Undisclosed paid advocacy on Wikipedia, also known as “black hat” editing, violates the terms of use set out by The Wikimedia Foundation, the non-profit body that supports the online encyclopedia.The practice of institutions, states and individuals finessing their Wikipedia pages to improve their image is frowned on by the PR industry.Guidelines on the use of “dark arts” in relation to Wikipedia, written by the Chartered Institute of Public Relations (CIPR), state: “Intentional deceit and anonymous or incognito activities are breaches of professional codes of conduct.” The CIPR is a voluntary members-based association to which Portland has not signed up.

The rise of AI chatbots and summaries have made Wikipedia pages even more influential, as they are often a source for the tools,Portland has a history of making Wikipedia edits,In 2012, it was found to have made alterations on behalf of the company that produces Stella Artois, removing references on Wikipedia to an unwanted nickname, “wife beater”,At the time, it said the changes had been made openly and within Wikipedia’s rules,However, former employees told TBIJ that Portland instead began to contract out edits of Wikipedia, with one telling its reporters: “No one said: ‘We should stop doing this’.

The question was how we could keep doing it without getting caught.”Several of its sources claimed Portland commissioned a web consultant, Radek Kotlarek, whose network of accounts made Wikipedia changes.TBIJ said seven Portland insiders said Kotlarek’s services were used.Kotlarek was contacted for comment, but did not respond.The TBIJ’s investigation claimed to have identified a network of 26 accounts making edits.

They were linked to Web3 Consulting, Kotlarek’s company.TBIJ said that while its sources were confidential, it had been able to corroborate their information using the public record of Wikipedia edits.All accounts in this network that were still active in 2024 were blocked by volunteer Wikipedia editors, who investigated their activity.Six former Portland employees involved in some of the Qatar work reportedly said that Wikipedia edits were a common request.They claimed that Portland hired subcontractors to target pages related to Qatar’s human rights record, particularly around World Cup stadium-building.

Some changes were performed by accounts outside the Web3 network.Companies other than Portland also worked on major accounts such as the Qatar government’s public relations.Allan has faced controversy since becoming Downing Street’s executive director of communications at the start of September, as part of Starmer’s attempt at a government-wide reset.He retains a financial stake in another PR firm, Strand Partners, but has said he will not to take dividends or become involved in running the company while in government.He also resigned as chair on his appointment to No 10.

He has also pushed for sweeping changes to political journalists’ access to Downing Street, including scrapping one of the two daily briefings with the prime minister’s official spokesperson.In an email last month, Allan said the changes were necessary because the media landscape had been “utterly transformed”, making existing arrangements “not fit for purpose”.The group that represents political journalists was not consulted on the plan.Journalists warned the move towards ad hoc press conferences could restrict access and scrutiny.
A picture

Not keen on feeble nolo wine? Try these instead

Are you a lover of oaky rioja, or maybe zingy Kiwi sauvignon blanc, and looking to find a non-alcoholic lookalike? To put it bluntly, I’m afraid you’re out of luck. Alcohol does much more than make you tipsy; it is the magic ingredient that gives so much of wine’s wondrous complexity, character and charm. Not only does it carry volatile compounds that make up wine’s endlessly fascinating combinations of scents and tastes, along with a sensation of warmth, it also creates that viscous body and texture – what’s rather grossly known in the trade as “mouthfeel” – of the liquid in your mouth, and the overall balance of all these factors in the wine.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link

A picture

Doing dry January? Use languishing bottles of wine to make the ultimate comfort food

Whether you’re abstaining or just cutting back, a glass of red, white or rosé can elevate everything from risottos and stews to pasta and puddings Sign up here for our weekly food newsletter, FeastHands up, who is dry Januarying? While it’s not something I do explicitly, I do like to cut back a bit at the beginning of the year. The marathon that is Christmas socialising can be fun but relentless, and I imagine there are many others in the same boat. When it comes to wine, at least, the problem with cutting back is what to do with the rest of the bottle. Sure, I’ll have a glass or two if I fancy it one evening, but it’s pretty much a wasted bottle if you don’t finish the rest within a few days. Fear not – I have a plethora of recipes that will ensure you never need to waste a drop – enjoy a glass or two, then use the rest in the dish of your choice

A picture

Mark Hix’s recipe for baked scallops with a herb crust

Sustainable fresh scallops are best treated simply, and this herby, garlicky breadcrumb topping ticks all the right boxesAs a kid growing up in West Bay, Dorset, I used to sit on the harbour wall and watch the small trawlers coming in with their catch. My friend Mark’s dad’s boat, along with all the others, would be stacked high with sacks of queenies that they’d dredged up only hours before, and Mark’s mum would pack us off to school with a tub each of queen scallop meat doused in Sarson’s vinegar and white pepper, to eat later as a playground snack. At the time, I thought nothing of it, but, looking back now, I realise quite what a luxurious schoolday treat this was.These days, however, our local scallop fishermen don’t fish for queenies much any more, because the time it takes to shuck and clean them is more or less the same as that for larger king scallops, so they’re no longer financially viable; also, instead of all those trawlers that Lyme Bay had in the past, it’s now mostly divers who fish more sustainably for king scallops, without demolishing the sea bed in the process. There are two main dive boats that fish out of Lyme Regis nowadays, operated by Jon Shuker and Ali Day, and they’ve pretty much cornered the local market

A picture

How to turn any root vegetables into latkes – recipe | Waste not

It’s not just potatoes that you can turn into these moreish fried cakes – just about any root veg will do the trickCrisp, savoury and satiating latkes are my idea of the perfect brunch and, rather than sticking to potatoes, I often make them with a mixture of root vegetables, using up whatever I have to hand – just 25-50g of any vegetable will make a latke – and adding some ground linseeds or flax, which gives breakfast some nutrition-boosting omega-3s. I usually have them with a poached egg for protein or apple compote and soya yoghurt.This is a great way to use up any tired root vegetables lurking in the crisper drawer, and a recipe I come back to again and again. Latkes are a traditional Jewish potato cake that work really well made with other root vegetables as well. If I have a few different coloured vegetables, I will grate and mix the vegetables separately to make multicoloured latkes, but it’s much simpler to mix them all together

A picture

Eleven quick and easy summer weekday dinners, from pasta to Maggi goreng – recipes

(Pictured above)Rukmini Iyer’s recipe contains a microwave method for cooking rice, but I’ve successfully made basmati in a rice cooker countless times – just pop the whole garlic clove in with the rice grains. After that, it’s only a matter of stir-frying the cashews, broccoli and tofu. If you need more convincing, Iyer says this recipe was “an absolute hit with my children”. My own children happily mainline tofu and rice, and can be persuaded to have broccoli if I tell them they’re actually eating mini Christmas trees, so I believe her.There are many ways to level up your instant noodles, and this recipe follows a familiar formula: add greens for health and a fried egg for protein

A picture

January tips if you’re cooking for one | Kitchen aide

I really struggle with cooking for one, so what can I make in January that’s interesting but easy and, most importantly, warming?Jane, via email “There’s an art to the perfect solo meal,” says Bonnie Chung, author of Miso: From Japanese Classics to Everyday Umami, “and that’s balancing decadence with ease.” For Chung, that means good-quality ingredients (“tinned anchovies, jarred beans”), a dish that can be cooked in one pan (“a night alone must be maximised with minimal washing-up”) and eaten with a single piece of cutlery, “preferably in front of the telly and out of a bowl nestling in your lap”. Happily, she says, all of those requirements are met by miso udon carbonara: “It has all the rich and creamy nirvana of a cheesy pasta, but with a delicious, mochi-like chew that is incredibly satisfying.” Not only that, but you can knock it up in less than 10 minutes. “Melt cheese, milk and miso in a pan to make the sauce base, then add frozen udon that have been soaked in hot water