‘It cannot provide nuance’: UK experts warn AI therapy chatbots are not safe
Having an issue with your romantic relationship? Need to talk through something? Mark Zuckerberg has a solution for that: a chatbot,Meta’s chief executive believes everyone should have a therapist and if they don’t – artificial intelligence can do that job,“I personally have the belief that everyone should probably have a therapist,” he said last week,“It’s like someone they can just talk to throughout the day, or not necessarily throughout the day, but about whatever issues they’re worried about and for people who don’t have a person who’s a therapist, I think everyone will have an AI,”The Guardian spoke to mental health clinicians who expressed concern about AI’s emerging role as a digital therapist.
Prof Dame Til Wykes, the head of mental health and psychological sciences at King’s College London, cites the example of an eating disorder chatbot that was pulled in 2023 after giving dangerous advice.“I think AI is not at the level where it can provide nuance and it might actually suggest courses of action that are totally inappropriate,” she said.Wykes also sees chatbots as being potential disruptors to established relationships.“One of the reasons you have friends is that you share personal things with each other and you talk them through,” she says.“It’s part of an alliance, a connection.
And if you use AI for those sorts of purposes, will it not interfere with that relationship?”For many AI users, Zuckerberg is merely marking an increasingly popular use of this powerful technology.There are mental health chatbots such as Noah and Wysa, while the Guardian has spoken to users of AI-powered “grieftech” – or chatbots that revive the dead.There is also their casual use as virtual friends or partners, with bots such as character.ai and Replika offering personas to interact with.ChatGPT’s owner, OpenAI, admitted last week that a version of its groundbreaking chatbot was responding to users in a tone that was “overly flattering” and withdrew it.
“Seriously, good for you for standing up for yourself and taking control of your own life,” it reportedly responded to a user, who claimed they had stopped taking their medication and had left their family because they were “responsible for the radio signals coming in through the walls”.In an interview with the Stratechery newsletter, Zuckerberg, whose company owns Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, added that AI would not squeeze people out of your friendship circle but add to it.“That’s not going to replace the friends you have, but it will probably be additive in some way for a lot of people’s lives,” he said.Outlining uses for Meta’s AI chatbot – available across its platforms – he said: “One of the uses for Meta AI is basically: ‘I want to talk through an issue’; ‘I need to have a hard conversation with someone’; ‘I’m having an issue with my girlfriend’; ‘I need to have a hard conversation with my boss at work’; ‘help me roleplay this’; or ‘help me figure out how I want to approach this’.”In a separate interview last week, Zuckerberg said “the average American has three friends, but has demand for 15” and AI could plug that gap.
Dr Jaime Craig, who is about to take over as chair of the UK’s Association of Clinical Psychologists, says it is “crucial” that mental health specialists engage with AI in their field and “ensure that it is informed by best practice”.He flags Wysa as an example of an AI tool that “users value and find more engaging”.But, he adds, more needs to be done on safety.“Oversight and regulation will be key to ensure safe and appropriate use of these technologies.Worryingly we have not yet addressed this to date in the UK,” Craig says.
Last week it was reported that Meta’s AI Studio, which allows users to create chatbots with specific personas, was hosting bots claming to be therapists – with fake credentials.A journalist at 404 Media, a tech news site, said Instagram had been putting those bots in her feed.Meta said its AIs carry a disclaimer that “indicates the responses are generated by AI to help people understand their limitations”.
Art Fund to launch £5m project for UK museums to share their collections
A £5m project in which 20 museums will share their collections and expertise with each other could revolutionise the touring model in the UK.Going Places has been developed by Art Fund, the charity that secures art for public collections while providing financial support for museums, and will involve local people when the nationwide project launches in May 2026.Billed as “the UK’s largest ever collaborative touring project”, several institutions will work together on themed exhibitions while pooling resources and sharing expertise.Museums that wanted to take part met up and underwent a “matchmaking” process where they identified themes that interested them before splitting into groups.Museums Worcestershire, OnFife and Penlee House Gallery and Museum in Penzance will collaborate on exhibitions focusing on the female artists in their collections
Jon Stewart on Trump ignoring the constitution: ‘It’s not optional’
Late-night hosts recapped Donald Trump’s refusal to commit to defending the constitution and blaming Joe Biden for his hits on the economy.From his Monday night perch on The Daily Show, Jon Stewart attempted to bring a new, level-headed approach to handling the daily torrent of Trump administration news. “I’m trying very hard in this new Trump ‘flood the zone’ media ecosystem strategy to not get too high or low. To not take the bait,” he said.But as evidenced by Trump’s latest interview with Meet the Press, “to get to substantive policy questions, you have to face down the fire hose of his nonsense and bullshit that moves you off track”, Stewart noted
No Way Out: the 1987 thriller that prophesied a deeply corrupt US government
In 1987, right before he became the biggest movie star in the world with a five-year hot streak that included Field of Dreams, Dances with Wolves and The Bodyguard, Kevin Costner headlined two films that offered very different visions of America. The Untouchables assembles a group of plucky misfits to dole out frontier justice against those who would seek to extort the American dream – it’s brash, gung ho and morally transparent. A guaranteed classic.Far more interesting, though, is No Way Out, Roger Donaldson’s 1987 political potboiler that’s equal parts pulpy spectacle and damning critique of the US project. Functioning as a bridge between the conspiracy flicks of the 70s and the erotic thrillers of the 90s, the film starts with a sex scene in the back of a limo (complete with a perfectly timed cutaway to the Washington Monument) and ends with an unforgettable flourish
Kula Shaker on making Govinda: ‘Crowds would sing the lyrics as, “Go cash your giro giro”’
‘It was great to get a song that’s entirely in Sanskrit on Radio 1. It has a power that’s beyond us. We’re just the vessels’It’s not our song; it’s as old as the hills. The first time I heard it was in a Krishna temple as a kid. George Harrison was the first person I know of who recorded it – it’s the last track on 1971’s The Radha Krsna Temple album
From Anita Dump to Paula Roid: how a Facebook group about drag names became my favourite place online
I remember exactly where I was when I found it. At uni. In a cavernous lecture hall. Slouched in a vaguely uncomfortable seat. Ping
My cultural awakening: Groundhog Day made me quit my job, move house and leave my girlfriend
When I saw Bill Murray’s classic comedy I realised that I was trapped in my own unfulfilling time loopI didn’t know anything about the plot of Groundhog Day before I decided to watch it 10 years ago. I remember collapsing on to the sofa after work – completely exhausted – and putting it on. My girlfriend was already asleep in the next room. Her drinking had been getting steadily worse that year, but I think we were both in denial about it. Most evenings I’d spend alone, so I’d put a movie on in the background for company
UK woman who took pills during lockdown cleared of illegal abortion
At least 216 children died in first high severity US flu season in seven years, CDC says
‘Utterly traumatised’: anger at ordeal of UK woman accused of illegal abortion
Gangs hold such influence over jails ‘it keeps me awake at night’, says Timpson
‘It makes no sense’: Macmillan hiring for senior roles after axing 26% of staff
Cringe! How millennials became uncool