Anthropic did not breach copyright when training AI on books without permission, court rules
A US judge has ruled that a tech company’s use of books to train its artificial intelligence system – without permission of the authors – did not breach copyright law,A federal judge in San Francisco said Anthropic made “fair use” of books by the writers Andrea Bartz, Charles Graeber and Kirk Wallace Johnson to train its Claude large language model (LLM),Judge William Alsup compared the Anthropic model’s use of books to a “reader aspiring to be a writer” who uses works “not to race ahead and replicate or supplant them” but to “turn a hard corner and create something different”,Alsup added, however, that Anthropic’s copying and storage of more than 7m pirated books in a central library infringed the authors’ copyrights and was not fair use – although the company later bought “millions” of print books as well,The judge has ordered a trial in December to determine how much Anthropic owes for the infringement.
“That Anthropic later bought a copy of a book it earlier stole off the internet will not absolve it of liability for the theft but it may affect the extent of statutory damages,” Alsup wrote,US copyright law says that wilful copyright infringement can result in damages of up to $150,000 (£110,000) a work,The copyright issue has pitted AI firms against publishers and the creative industries because generative AI models – the term for technology that underpins powerful tools such as the ChatGPT chatbot – have to be trained on a vast amount of publicly available data in order to generate their responses,Much of that data has included copyright-protected works,An Anthropic spokesperson said the company was pleased the court recognised its AI training was transformative and “consistent with copyright’s purpose in enabling creativity and fostering scientific progress”.
John Strand, a copyright lawyer at the US law firm Wolf Greenfield, said the decision from a “well-respected” judge was “very significant”,He added: “There are dozens of other cases involving similar questions of copyright infringement and fair use pending throughout the US, and Judge Alsup’s decision here will be something those other courts must consider in their own case,”Due to the number of other AI copyright cases working their way through the legal system, Strand said: “The expectation is that at some point the primary question of whether training LLMs on copyrighted materials is fair use likely will be addressed by the US supreme court,”The writers filed the proposed class action against Anthropic last year, arguing the company, which is backed by Amazon and Alphabet, used pirated versions of their books without permission or compensation to teach Claude to respond to human prompts,The proposed class action is one of several lawsuits brought by authors, news outlets and other copyright owners against companies including OpenAI, Microsoft and Meta Platforms over their AI training.
The doctrine of fair use allows the use of copyrighted works without the copyright owner’s permission in some circumstances.Fair use is a key legal defence for the tech companies, and Alsup’s decision is the first to address it in the context of generative AI.Sign up to TechScapeA weekly dive in to how technology is shaping our livesafter newsletter promotionAI companies argue their systems make fair use of copyrighted material to create new, transformative content, and that being forced to pay copyright holders for their work could hamstring the nascent industry.Anthropic told the court that it made fair use of the books and that US copyright law “not only allows, but encourages” its AI training because it promotes human creativity.The company said its system copied the books to “study plaintiffs’ writing, extract uncopyrightable information from it, and use what it learned to create revolutionary technology”.
Giles Parsons, a partner at the UK law firm Browne Jacobson, said the ruling would have no impact in the UK, where the fair use argument held less sway.Under current UK copyright law, which the government is seeking to change, copyright-protected work can be used without permission for scientific or academic research.He said: “The UK has a much narrower fair use defence which is very unlikely to apply in these circumstances.”Copyright owners in the US and UK say AI companies are unlawfully copying their work to generate competing content that threatens their livelihoods.A UK government proposal to change copyright law in the UK by allowing use of copyright-protected work without permission – unless the work’s owner signals they want to opt out of the process – has been met with vociferous opposition from the creative industries.
Alsup said Anthropic violated the authors’ rights by saving pirated copies of their books as part of a “central library of all the books in the world” that would not necessarily be used for AI training.Anthropic and other prominent AI companies including OpenAI and Facebook owner Meta have been accused of downloading pirated digital copies of millions of books to train their systems.
Thames Water court case shows there are alternatives to massive infrastructure
Britain is running out of water, we are told. Soon there will be curfews, banning people from turning on their taps, as happens in Italy. Standpipes will sprout on the side of parched roads where trees once stood.Rivers will run dry and rural communities will begin digging wells in response to a water apocalypse destined to arrive courtesy of the ravaging effect of climate change.The water companies argue that major investment is needed to cope with the changing weather patterns, with those funds primarily channelled into building massive new infrastructure
‘He left us with nothing’: the British investors swindled by a German property firm
“He took everything, left us with absolutely nothing,” says David Middleton, one of thousands of British and Irish investors who racked up huge losses from the collapse of a German property ponzi scheme.The 72-year-old pensioner from Northern Ireland is referring to Charles Smethurst, the German-British businessman who set up Dolphin Capital in 2008, later renamed Dolphin Trust, then German Property Group (GPG), with 200 affiliated companies. In July 2020, the business filed for insolvency, owing more than €1bn to up to 25,000 investors around the world.Smethurst was convicted this month of “serious fraud” and sentenced to six years and 11 months in prison by a regional court in Hildesheim, in northern Germany. As part of a plea bargain, he admitted to four of 27 counts of commercial fraud, filed against him by the Hanover public prosecutor’s office last October, for total damages of €56m
Online hacks to offline heists: crypto leaders on edge amid increasing attacks
Industry figures are seeing beyond the ‘illusion of invisibility’ after series of investor kidnappingsCryptocurrency traders such as Mohammed Arsalan are prepared to watch their online assets expand and explode if they miss the right moment, making or breaking their fortunes in just minutes. All in a day’s work on the internet. Offline, though, they have found themselves less equipped for the consequences of affluence. A string of kidnappings has plagued the industry over the past year and left traders across the globe paranoid, fearful and keen to invest in physical security measures.Arsalan grew up working class in Karachi, Pakistan
Jeff in Venice: seven takeaways from the Bezos-Sánchez wedding
Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and journalist Lauren Sánchez held their wedding ceremony in Venice’s Grand canal on Friday, the centrepiece of a three-day gala that drew dozens of stars but also protests by local activists. Here are seven takeaways.The couple kicked off celebrations with a foam party on their $500m (£364m) super yacht moored near the Croatian island of Unije. Coinciding with Sánchez’s son Evan Whitesell’s 19th birthday, paparazzi photos showed the couple wearing swimwear and sunhats covered in frothy suds as they partied alongside Whitesell and his friends. Foam parties can cause conjunctivitis, so the decision to hold one just days before their nuptials was somewhat surprising but maybe billionaire foam hits different
Novak Djokovic confident Wimbledon is his ‘best chance’ of extending slam record
Novak Djokovic believes that this year’s Wimbledon likely represents his best chance of winning a record-extending 25th grand slam title as he tries to disrupt the dominance established by Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz at the biggest tournaments in the world.“I would probably agree that Wimbledon could be the best chance because of the results I had, because of how I feel, how I play at Wimbledon, just getting that extra push mentally and motivation to perform the best tennis at the highest level,” said Djokovic.The seven-time champion at SW19 returns to the All England Club in an intriguing position. After defeating Alcaraz, the world No 2, en route to the Australian Open semi-finals in January, Djokovic reached the French Open semi-finals with a stellar win over the world No 3, Alexander Zverev, before losing in three tight sets to Sinner. The Serb departed Paris as the third best performer at the grand slam tournaments so far this year and he continues to compete at an extremely high level
India thrash England by 97 runs in first women’s T20 cricket – as it happened
Right on cue, Raf’s report is in.It doesn’t pull any punches. And why should it? That was a chastening defeat for England.But it also rightly sings the praises of the Indians were magnificent.Don’t take my word for it, read it here:Thanks for keeping me company
F1: Lando Norris on pole for Austrian GP with Max Verstappen down in seventh – as it happened
Lando Norris storms to Austrian F1 GP pole as angry Verstappen slumps to seventh
Tomos Williams injury leaves Farrell’s Lions facing race to fill scrum-half slot
Western Force 7-54 British & Irish Lions: rugby union – as it happened
Lions cut loose with eight-try win over Western Force for solid start in Australia
Less death, more social media: Formula One films decades apart reveal a changed world | Emma John