Meta sacrifices a heap of money at the altar of AI

A picture


Mark Zuckerberg announced in April that the company would make huge capital expenditures in the coming year to keep up in the race to develop cutting-edge artificial intelligence.He made good on that promise last week with a $15bn “AI superintelligence” team that would feature reported nine-figure salaries and a 49% investment in Scale AI.Meta also hired Scale’s 28-year-old founder, Alexandr Wang, a former roommate of OpenAI’s Sam Altman.Before Meta’s investment, Scale counted most of the major players in AI among its clients, and some of them were less than thrilled with the development.Bloomberg puts it succinctly: Scale AI’s Wang Brings to Meta Knowledge of What Everyone Else is Doing.

Google, Scale’s largest customer, got scared.The tech giant told the startup that their working relationship would end in response to the deal, Reuters reported on Friday.My colleague Robert Booth has more:One Silicon Valley analyst described the announcement as the action of “a wartime CEO”.Superintelligence is described as a type of AI that can perform better than humans at all tasks.Currently AI cannot reach the same level as humans in all tasks, a state known as artificial general intelligence (AGI).

Meta’s attempt to leapfrog the current state of progress and target superintelligence is seen by observers as an attempt by the company to regain the initiative over AI after significant advances by competitors including Sam Altman’s OpenAI and Google and after Meta’s huge investment in the concept of the Metaverse flopped,The financial magnitude of the move may seem like taking command of the AI race, but Meta is playing catchup,Its most recent AI models are less capable than those of rivals,In April, the company published a model designed with features tailored to gaming a popular benchmark, a desperate move,With its mammoth investment and the formation of a new team, particularly one helmed by a key industry player, the tech giant is buying its way in.

Read more about Meta’s superintelligence team here.Revealed: Thousands of UK university students caught cheating using AIDisney and Universal sue AI image creator Midjourney, alleging copyright infringementHey AI! Can ChatGPT help you to manage your money?Researchers create AI-based tool that restores age-damaged artworks in hoursKeir Starmer says technology can create a ‘better future’ as he addresses AI fearsLast week, Wikipedia halted a test of a new AI-powered article summarizer in response to a backlash from its editors, the volunteers who contribute new information to the online encyclopedia’s articles and evaluate the quality of others’ additions.The site had introduced summaries of articles, generated by artificial intelligence, that would appear at the top of those pages above the introduction to the subject, written by humans.The test ran for two weeks for about 10% users of the mobile version of Wikipedia who opted into it.The feedback was, in the words of Wikipedia’s nonprofit parent, “strongly negative”.

One editor wrote in the public forum: “A truly ghastly idea.” Another: “Keep AI out of Wikipedia.” And: “I am going to join the chorus of editors saying that this is a uniquely bad idea.” Some argued in favor of the introduction of summaries by AI, making the point that technical articles on Wikipedia prioritize depth and complexity over accessibility.Most, though, argued that any hallucinations and mistakes would degrade Wikipedia’s reputation of reliability.

The general sentiment among editors read thusly: “Yuck”.“We’re trying to figure out the balance between AI and Wikipedia.There are AI integrations that do happen on Wikipedia but are very minimal.Little things that make it easier for editors to do their work or readers to get the content they need,” said Pacita Rudder, executive director of Wikimedia New York City, a local chapter affiliated with the foundation.“‘Where’s the line between human output and robotic output?’ is a debate that’s constantly happening within the Wikipedia community.

There are some people who are for it, some against it, but as with anything with Wikipedia, we have to come to a consensus.”Contrast Wikipedia’s deferential response with Reddit’s.The social network began charging for access to its application programming interface in 2023.Reddit’s library of posts is extremely valuable to AI companies, which need enormous collections of text written by contemporary human beings to train large language models like ChatGPT.Reddit execs intended to extract money from AI companies using the company’s library.

They succeeded.They also rendered many users’ experiences worse by crippling popular extensions.In response, users, particularly forums’ volunteer moderators, revolted en masse, blacking out forums with tens of millions of members and demanding reversion.Executives refused.They chose dollars from AI companies over their users’ concerns, the opposite of Wikipedia.

A coda to the story, though: two years later, Reddit largely functions as before,Several days after Wikipedia rolled back its AI test, the Wikimedia Foundation hosted an in-person “edit-a-thon” at the United Nations, an event dedicated to creating and updating pages about the history of the international body, complete with a work list,The conclave of information custodians – a 50/50 balance of new and experienced editors, according to Rudder – was part of the UN’s Open Source Week and occurred alongside an open source hackathon,It was in-person only,The edit-a-thon stands in contrast to the stereotypical tableau of curating Wikipedia articles: a single person online, communicating sterilely with others via a glaring white screen.

At the event, though, editors convened in groups of five around a single laptop to converse excitedly and collaborate in as many languages throughout a large, buzzing auditorium.Italian and Sri Lankan envoys lionized the work of the editors in speeches, as well as the open source community at large.An executive from the Wikimedia Foundation thanked them for their work, as did the UN under-secretary-general for digital and emerging technologies.It was an energetic scene.Asked why she felt it was important to host an in-person-only event, Rudder said: “It’s community, right? There’s this misconception that a lot of Wikipedia editors are alone in their basements, typing away, but that’s not the case,” said Rudder.

Wikimedia NYC hosted the event at the UN.Rudder said the chapter’s role is to bring editors and members of the online community together.She said she felt most energized by meeting new editors.As with Reddit, Wikipedia’s huge text corpus is part of the foundational training data for most, if not all, large language models.And like the white alien company, Wikipedia charges for smooth access to it, though less than Reddit, Rudder said.

The organization launched Wikimedia Enterprise in 2021 with an eye towards corporate customers.Reddit is a for-profit business, whereas the Wikimedia Foundation is a non-profit.Wikipedia’s data is free, but using it easily may cost you.Unlike Reddit, Wikipedia is emphasizing the human labor necessary to maintain its site and the content there by rolling back features in response to community outcry and convening editors in person.Sign up to TechScapeA weekly dive in to how technology is shaping our livesafter newsletter promotionMisinformation about LA Ice protests swirls online: ‘Catnip for rightwing agitators’US immigration agency flies drones capable of surveillance over LA protestsSoftware used in surveillance of immigrants has deep ties to the LAPDA week ago, Apple hosted its annual developers’ conference, WWDC.

The biggest announcement was a redesign of the iPhone Operating System (iOS) nicknamed “liquid glass”.Virtual buttons on iPhone screens will appear transparent, with the images behind them passing through with a slight warp like a magnifying glass.The aesthetic recalls the colorful Macs of old, housed in translucent, whimsical plastic.The refreshed design is pretty! It is also boring.Machines are fabricating entire movies and predicting hurricanes.

Who cares what color my phone’s controls are?There were other updates, of course,Apple is adding live translation to FaceTime calls, for instance,I can imagine many calls with distant family and friends that will run smoother with that feature,How nice,On the whole, though, the updates failed to inspire.

For many years, updates to iPhones have seemed far more incremental than, for example, the addition of speedy 3G connectivity in 2008 with the second generation.Apple’s updates have failed to keep pace with the freewheeling Android ecosystem.I met a venture capitalist in San Francisco in 2019 who did not know what version of the iPhone he was holding in his hand as we spoke.Apple showcased little in the way of new AI features, unlike its peers.Google and Samsung are integrating AI into their mobile experiences at a breakneck pace.

Case in point: live translation is a feature that has been part of the Android operating system for several years.Google’s Pixel Bud headphones can translate the speech of a person talking to you, which Airpods cannot do.Google seems to release a fascinating, if sometimes bizarre, AI feature every week.As recently as Friday, the Verge reported: Google says it is testing Audio Overviews for certain Search queries, available for Labs users in English in the US.After the demonstration, Gizmodo argued: Apple Knows AI Isn’t What People Really Want, but It Can’t Say That.

Even if that is true, though – and ChatGPT’s 500m monthly users might disagree – the announcements showed little in the way of flair.If Apple wants users to stay within the iPhone’s ecosystem, it needs to offer them something equally appealing and enthralling or even more so.Google pushed a new, updated version of the operating system and last week.Samsung teased new features of the next version of its folding phone, per Android Central.Did you hear about them? It is axiomatic in tech journalism that stories about Apple and iPhones will always garner more clicks than stories about Android phones, though a far higher percentage of the world’s phones use Android.

I have many guesses as to why that is, but it is a topic for another day.I only mention it because many fewer people spent the week discussing the Android updates as did Apple’s Liquid Glass interface.Apple’s change amounts to only a cosmetic upgrade – and it’s debatable whether it will be better at all – but it inspired many more jokes.Samsung’s seventh version of its folding phone, while novel, begs the question: as I complain about new iPhones’ lack of thrills, what do I want my phone to do? I do not need a folding phone.I had one, a Motorola Razr, and it did facilitate vital communication; however, that did not arise from the form factor.

Google’s new AI features pose the same question.There may not be consensus on what the majority of users want from an AI-enhanced phone, but if you are not trying something new with technology, you are in decline.It doesn’t feel like Apple is offering surprising features that I would not have thought of.I may not need an audio summary feature for my Google search results, but I am intrigued by it.Also, what a gift to the visually impaired! Siri, by contrast, still struggles to control Spotify and botches notification summaries.

I have used an iPhone as my primary device for about 15 years now,This inflection point would be the moment to switch to Android to try out its shiny toybox of new features, but I am enclosed in Apple’s ecosystem of hardware and apps, a walled garden that is starting to feel less like a bountiful Eden and more like a pen,As big tech grows more involved in Gaza, Muslim workers are wrestling with a spiritual crisisTell us: what questions do you have about the impacts of smartphones on children?‘They went too far’: Musk says he regrets some of his posts about TrumpTrump Organization unveils $499 gold phone raising new concerns on conflicts of interest23andMe’s founder wins bid to regain control of bankrupt DNA testing firmEntrepreneur ‘humiliated’ after London Tech Week turns her and baby awayThe best Apple Watches in 2025: what’s worth buying and what’s not, according to our expert
businessSee all
A picture

Trump threatens to keep 25% tariff on UK steel imports over Port Talbot concerns

Donald Trump is threatening to keep 25% tariffs on some or all of its steel imports from the UK unless it gives specific guarantees over the Indian-owned steelmaking plant at Port Talbot in south Wales, sources have told the Guardian.An agreement to reduce tariffs on UK car exports to the US and scrap them for the aerospace sector was signed off by the US president and Keir Starmer on Monday, on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Canada.However, it did not include the removal of tariffs on steel imports from the UK. Officials are still negotiating over the fine points of a deal to cover the steel and aluminium industry, amid US concerns about the fact that Tata Steel imports raw materials from abroad.Starmer told reporters in Banff, Canada: “There’s further work to do in relation to steel, but we’re getting on and doing that work

A picture

Trump claims EU is not offering a fair trade deal; Reeves pitches UK as ‘oasis of stability’; oil climbs as shares fall – as it happened

US president Donald Trump has said the European Union was not yet offering a fair deal in trade talks between the United States and the 27-nation bloc.Seaking to reporters on Air Force One, as he returned early from the G7 summit, Trump explained:“We’re talking, but I don’t feel that they’re offering a fair deal yet. They’re either going to make a good deal or they’ll just pay whatever we say they have to pay.”Trump also said there was a chance of a trade deal with Japan, but said Tokyo was being “tough”, Reuters reports.TRUMP SAYS EU NOT YET OFFERING A FAIR DEALTrump added that pharmaceutical tariffs were coming very soon and noted that Canada would pay to be part of his “golden dome” project

A picture

Europe will never return to Russian gas, European Commission insists

The European Commission has insisted there will be no return to Russian gas, as it published plans to phase out fossil fuel imports from its eastern neighbour by 2028.The EU energy commissioner, Dan Jørgensen, said a proposed ban on Russian gas imports would remain, irrespective of whether there was peace in Ukraine.EU officials recalled when Russia cut gas supplies in 2006, 2009 and 2014, as well as the deliberate reduction in flows in 2021 before the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, which contributed to a huge rise in energy prices and surging inflation across the continent.Under the proposals, European companies would be banned from importing Russian gas or providing services at EU liquified natural gas terminals to Russian customers. Any contracts entered into from today would have to be wound up by 1 January 2026, but companies with pre-existing agreements have a final deadline of 1 January 2028

A picture

Poundland to shut 68 stores in restructuring that puts 2,000 jobs at risk

Poundland is to shut 68 shops and two distribution centres and aims to close at least 80 more stores, putting more than 2,000 jobs at risk.The British company, which was sold last week to the US investment group Gordon Brothers for £1, has more than 800 outlets in the UK and the Republic of Ireland, employing about 16,000 people. It said it planned to reduce this eventually to no more than 650 outlets.It also wants landlords to cut rents to zero on up to 180 stores – putting the future of those outlets in doubt – while also seeking rent reductions of between 15% and 75% on dozens more stores as part of a restructuring process that it will put to creditors in August.Poundland is also stopping selling online, ditching its Perks loyalty app, ceasing to sell frozen foods and reducing its range of chilled foods to items that make up its £3 meal deals – such as sandwiches – and essentials including milk

A picture

‘Vital’ that British steel gets Trump tariff deal after UK-US trade pact, say unions

Steel trade unions have said it is “absolutely vital” that the UK rapidly secures a deal to protect the sector from Donald Trump’s tariffs, after the industry was excluded from an initial UK-US pact signed on Monday night.Keir Starmer and Trump signed off a UK-US trade deal at the G7 summit in Canada, with the US president saying Britain would have protection against future tariffs “because I like them”.The car industry was relieved that tariffs on the sector will be reduced to 10% from 27.5%. The UK aerospace sector will face no tariffs at all from the US after deal, which followed an initial agreement made in May

A picture

UK bank TSB could be sold off by Spanish owner Sabadell

The Spanish bank Sabadell has said it has received interest from prospective buyers of its UK division TSB, and said it would assess any firm offers it may receive.Sabadell wants to sell TSB as it battles to fend off an €11bn (£9.4bn) hostile approach from its Spanish rival BBVA.The Catalonia-based lender said it had received “preliminary non-binding expressions of interest” for TSB from unnamed bidders, and would examine any potential binding offer.TSB, which has 175 branches in the UK, has more than 5 million customers and 5,000 staff