Italy claim historic first victory over England as Borthwick’s men are rattled in Rome
Even by the Six Nations’ usual standards this has been a remarkable tournament.And to the list of stunning outcomes can now be added the biggest result in the history of Italian rugby.For the first time in 33 attempts they have beaten England at rugby union and no one could possibly claim the boys in blue did not deserve their long-awaited special day.Entering the final half hour it had seemed as though England might just leave Rome with their dignity intact.Instead, not for the first time in this championship, they were the architects of their own downfall with the momentum of the game swinging decisively after two visiting forwards, including captain Maro Itoje, were sent to the sin-bin simultaneously.
Italy, 18-10 down at one stage, sensed their chance and struck the decisive blow in the 71st minute when the replacement Leonardo Marin dived over to finish a stunning counterattack try set up by forceful running from Monty Ioane and Tommaso Menoncello, who had earlier scored a fabulous solo try of his own.Not surprisingly, the roar at the final whistle could have been heard in the Alps.Precise translations of the home chants were not immediately available but it was not hard to imagine something along the lines of “Jonny Wilkinson, Martin Johnson, David Beckham, Jamie Oliver; your boys took one hell of a beating …”It all felt light years away from the days when Italy were losing 36 Six Nations games in a row, a seven-year streak that ended only in 2022.Their head coach, Gonzalo Quesada, has done a spectacularly good job since he took over two years ago and here was the definitive proof.What to say about England? They will assuredly be hurting as they head to Paris, via a short training camp in Verona, for next week’s final round.
At least they scored a couple of well-taken first-half tries through Tommy Freeman and Tom Roebuck but this was another example of just how far their confidence has plummeted.In truth, though, the credit should all go to Italy.Maybe the home anthem has been sung louder and with more intent but, frankly, it was hard to recall anything quite as impassioned.The result from Murrayfield had also clearly encouraged the home support that this might just be their day, particularly when it emerged that Tom Curry had been injured in the warm-up and that Sam Underhill had been drafted into the starting lineup.From England’s perspective it did not change the most urgent collective priority: to start far better than had been the case against the Scots and the Irish.
Initially the signs were good but, once again, they could not profit from a couple of promising early forays into the Italian 22.It allowed the hosts to regroup and start to pose some questions at the other end.Fin Smith had an attempted clearance kick charged down and a scrum free-kick gave the Azzurri further encouragement.The scrum battle was competitive throughout and England were receiving very little for free.Italy were also growing in confidence with ball in hand, Ioane making a couple of surging runs down the left.
Their territorial gains were eventually rewarded with the first points of the game after 20 minutes when an offside penalty allowed Paolo Garbisi to put his side in front and brought the home crowd further into the game.It was just as well from England’s perspective, therefore, that they responded swiftly.A scrum penalty put Italy on the defensive and Smith and Coles then deftly worked their Northampton teammate Freeman over on the left edge.There is real talent in English rugby when it is given the necessary encouragement to flower.The same, however, is equally true in Italy.
The 23-year-old Menoncello would walk into most teams in this championship and his ability to break the line was perfectly illustrated six minutes before the interval.All it took was a nicely timed little pass from his scrum-half Alessandro Garbisi and he was through, leaving the outpaced Elliot Daly trailing in his wake from 45 metres out and swallow-diving over.It was no more than Italy deserved but England, to their credit, again had an immediate answer.After a midfield turnover and with the hosts stretched defensively Smith’s perfectly weighted cross kick found the lurking Roebuck and the Sale winger cut purposefully inside the cover.Smith’s conversion gave England a 12-10 interval lead and set up a nervous second 40 minutes.
England’s decision to ask Smith to go for goal rather than kick to the corner early in the second half underlined that tight reality; they needed every available point.As it turned out, though, their composure was about to desert them again.First Underhill was sent to the sin-bin for a shoulder to the head of Danilo Fischetti and then Itoje also departed for cyncially knocking the ball out of the hands of Italy’s replacement scrum-half Alessandro Fusco.Could Italy capitalise? The answer, gloriously, was yes, leaving England’s supposed heavyweights flat on their backs.Since they last lifted the title in 2020, England have won four of their 14 fixtures on the road, losing all eight combined in Edinburgh, Dublin and France.
Over that same period, France and Ireland have won 11 away games apiece and Scotland have won six.Even if they go and win in Paris next Saturday this will have been a chastening campaign.
Keir Starmer accused of ‘mimicking Trump’ with Middle East crisis TikTok post
Keir Starmer has been accused of trying to mimic Donald Trump’s social media output after posting a TikTok video about the crisis in the Middle East overlaid with the prime minister’s voice and the Dire Straits song Money for Nothing.The video opens with footage showing Royal Navy Wildcat helicopters flying over his head before cutting to British military jets in action and a drone being destroyed, as Starmer’s voice states the position he has taken on the conflict.“Our number one priority is protecting our people,” says Starmer, overlaid with the sound of electric guitars played by Dire Straits.Starmer refused to join the US and Israeli strikes on Iran but has since authorised “defensive” action.Al Pinkerton, a Liberal Democrat MP, said the choice of song when the military was “crying out” for the government’s defence spending plan seemed “particularly cloth-eared”
Proportional representation is true rule by the people | Letters
Gaby Hinsliff (Nobody wants to defend Britain’s voting system any more – but here’s why I will, 26 February) writes that proportional representation (PR) “doesn’t guarantee that we could all just vote for what we want instead of endlessly against what we fear (ask the French)”. Yet France does not use PR, which is precisely why tactical blocking occurs there. Indeed, there is overwhelming cross-party support in France for moving towards PR.Under first past the post (FPTP), whoever wins the most votes takes the seat, even without a majority. That means a majority of voters in a constituency can end up unrepresented, as in Gorton and Denton, where six in 10 votes were not represented
Senior Labour figures warn government amid fears of ‘political earthquake’ in London
Senior Labour politicians across London have warned the government not to take progressive voters for granted, with concerns the party faces a “political earthquake” in the capital in May after a surge in support for the Greens.They have been privately circulating new data that suggests Labour could drop from first to fourth place in London in the May elections – losing control of all but two of their councils – with the Greens soaring into first place to take nine.“The government needs to demonstrate that they’re not taking liberal, progressive voters in the capital for granted,” a senior London Labour figure warned.Another added: “It’s going to be a total catastrophe for us in London. If we lose swathes of voters on our progressive flank then we’re doomed
Crypto billionaire Christopher Harborne no longer interested in Reform-Tory pact
Christopher Harborne, the ultra-wealthy political donor who has given £12m to Reform UK, has told the Guardian he is “no longer” interested in a Reform-Conservative pact before the next general election.A possible collaboration between Reform and the Conservative party had been an important aspect of discussions about donations between Harborne and senior figures including Nigel Farage, sources familiar with the conversations said.The Thailand-based cryptocurrency investor had previously wanted Farage to keep an open mind about a pact between the two parties, the same sources added.This position has changed, however. Harborne said in an emailed statement: “In the past this was possibly the case, but it is no longer the case
Nigel Farage to discuss Chagos Islands deal at Mar-a-Lago dinner with Donald Trump tonight – as it happened
Downing Street has denied there has been a U-turn on UK government policy on Iran after Britain’s deputy prime minister suggested this morning that the UK could take part on strikes on Iranian targets. Royal Air Force jets could legally strike Iranian missile sites being used to attack British interests in the Middle East, David Lammy said in a BBC interview earlier today.David Lammy has said it is an “absolute travesty” that details were leaked from a top secret national security meeting on the US-Israel attacks on Iran and has called for an investigation. There were reports last weekend of cabinet splits at a national security council meeting, which is protected by the Official Secrets Act, over allowing the US to use British bases for the strikes against Iran.Royal Air Force jets could legally strike Iranian missile sites being used to attack British interests in the Middle East, Lammy also said this morning
Starmer is facing a cocktail of dissent that is growing ever more potent
But for the Iran crisis, Labour’s first major policy announcement since the party’s calamitous defeat in the Gorton and Denton byelection would have been arguably the biggest political story of the week.Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, pressed ahead with what is intended to be the party’s full-throated answer to the competition it faces from Reform UK as she declared an end to permanent refugee status and the removal of state support from some asylum seekers.It immediately put her on a collision course with many Labour backbenchers, but it also left the party’s soft-left majority, who had been pushing for a more progressive offering in recent weeks, asking: “Is that it?”The victory speech in Gorton and Denton by Hannah Spencer, the newly minted Green party MP, contained the sort of lines that many on Labour’s backbenches yearn to hear their leader utter, or even nod towards. Hard-working people had become “sick of making other people rich” and now wondered what their toil would yield, said the young plumber.Yet while Keir Starmer’s troops expected at least some red meat this week from their party’s leadership to counter the Green challenge for economically squeezed traditional Labour voters, his instinctive response was to send a letter to MPs in which he repeated an attack line that sought to paint Zack Polanski’s party as extremist
Trump says he fired Anthropic ‘like dogs’ as Pentagon formally blacklists AI startup
Retailers want ‘delightfully human’ AI to do your shopping, but will the chatbots go rogue?
Google Pixel 10a review: cheaper Android is great, but no real advance
Sam Altman admits OpenAI can’t control Pentagon’s use of AI
Elon Musk takes witness stand in trial over Twitter takeover
Joy of teaching English in the age of AI | Letter