Kicking zones and a ban on losing teams: NFL playoff tweaks we’d like to see

A picture


The postseason consistently serves up enthralling football,But there are ways to make it even more compellingNo legitimate Super Bowl champion should have a losing record in the regular season,The Panthers, crowned NFC South champions at 8-9, are not an outlier,Since 2010, five teams with losing records have made the postseason,The 2022 Bucs were the first team to make the dance with a losing record since the league instituted a 17-game schedule.

This season, the NFC South has done it again.This isn’t an annual problem, but it is an inherent design flaw.Division champs getting an automatic playoff berth – and a home game – is a hot topic every season.The usual defence is tradition.Divisions matter.

Rivalries matter,Storylines matter,And they do – up to a point,Preserving divisions and guaranteeing a playoff berth is essential; there is no need for a record-only free-for-all here,The end-of-season Steelers–Ravens game was electric precisely because of what was at stake: a division title, a playoff spot, a good seed and the futures of the league’s two longest-tenured coaches.

But that electricity should not grant teams immunity.You can win your division and still not deserve to play in January.Those ideas do not need to be mutually exclusive.If you win your division with a losing record, you get the hats, the banner and the bonuses.What you should not get is a playoff game.

January should belong to teams that proved, at the very least, they could win more often than they lost,That’s not radical,It can be done while still maintaining that division winners keep homefield if they finish above,500,The Panthers will be a tough out in the wildcard round.

They have the ingredients to replicate the 2011 “Beast Quake” game, when the Seahawks and Marshawn Lynch shocked the Saints despite a regular-season 7-9 record.They’ve taken some big scalps this season and have already beaten the Rams.But rewarding them with a home spot against one of the conference’s best after posting a losing record is wrong.If it was switched up this season, Minnesota would be in the playoff field over Carolina, with the home site awarded to the team with the better record (the Rams).That seems a fair swap.

There was a time when the NFL’s playoff structure felt close to perfect.Twelve teams.Two byes per conference.Excellence was rewarded, mediocrity filtered out, and the bracket made intuitive sense.Then the format expanded to 14 teams, largely to sell another television package and the whole thing began to look misshapen.

Seven teams per conference with a single bye is awkward,One team rests, six do not,The reward for being elite is marginal,The punishment for sneaking in is almost nonexistent,There are some upsides.

The regular season has more meaningful games down the stretch thanks to extra teams being in the hunt.The two added games have real stakes.What’s not to love? A Week 18 slate where a batch of teams rest their starters is worth it, given the weekend ahead.But the overall structure is ungainly.It is designed to flog TV inventory, not find a champion.

A return to 12 teams isn’t happening,The NFL does not contract; it expands,If that is the direction of travel, then it should at least be done cleanly,Sixteen teams,Eight per conference.

Give byes to the top-two seeds, or forgo byes altogether.Preserving homefield advantage for division champions (with a winning record) is a must in the first round.From there, the field should be re-seeded to give whoever had the best regular-season record home advantage.Expansion will eventually arrive – an 18th game, perhaps two new teams.When that time comes, adding an extra playoff spot per conference will be inevitable.

The league can – and should – get there early,It has been a historic season for kickers,Records are falling for distance and accuracy,Pair that with the new kickoff rules and the new kicking ball, and the playing field has been tilted in dramatic ways,The new rules were introduced to bring a spark back to special teams while reducing the volume of high-end collisions.

That has worked.The knock-on consequences, however, have ever so slightly warped the game.The touchback is being placed at the 35-yard line while quality kickers comfortably nail kicks from 60 yards.Add the tweaks to special teams rules (such as touching the center) and the kickers are set up in field-goal range more often with more freedom to drill long shots.Case in point: Dallas’ Brandon Aubrey has kicked more 60-yard field goals in his three-year career than every NFL kicker in the 20th century.

That’s great for Jacksonville, who will have a significant advantage this postseason because of Cam Little’s leg,Little has boomed field goals from 70 yards (preseason), 68 and 67 this season,Kickers bring the drama, but playoff games should be decided by the players who scrap away for 70-something plays,There are two potential changes,One is to add a “kicking zone,” similar to the “landing zone” during kickoffs.

With a kicking zone, there would be a point of demarcation – call it the opponent’s 40-yard line – at which a team can attempt a field goal.Before that, an offense has to choose whether to punt the ball away or go for it on fourth down.It would manufacture fourth-down drama and force coaches into uncomfortable decisions.A set zone has its faults.It would feel artificial and clunky.

It would also remove some of the strategy of the game,And you just know there will be a playoff game decided by a team falling one yard short of the kicking zone, which would inevitably lead to it being scrapped,The quieter solution is probably the better one: narrow the uprights,Kicking is a discrete skill,And we’re living in the glory years, when even college kickers are converting 55-yard efforts.

But the environment now allows those players to take on an outsized role.Reducing the width of the uprights would restore risk and suspense without changing the essence of the game.Long field goals would still be attempted, but they would again feel like choices rather than defaults.Tension would return.So would consequences.

Right now, the talent of the NFL’s kickers has minimized risk.And risky football is fun.Risky football in the playoffs is what fuels group chats and debate shows.Addressing the kicking boom would add even more jeopardy.
businessSee all
A picture

Treasury has ‘limited grasp’ of concerns over booming shadow banking sector, peers say

The UK Treasury has a “limited grasp” of concerns linked to the booming shadow banking sector and may not be prepared for risks the unregulated industry poses to financial stability, peers have said.While a lack of data makes it hard to say whether the $16tn (£12tn) non-bank financial sector could bring the wider financial system to its knees, officials do not seem to be alive to the potential risks, according to a Lords financial services regulation committee report.It says the department’s evidence “demonstrated a limited grasp of the concerns raised during this inquiry, which suggested passivity in the face of potential risks to the UK’s financial stability arising from the growth of private markets”.That raises concerns given the Treasury’s responsibility for “ensuring overall financial stability so that the taxpayer does not serve as a backstop to the financial system”.The report says the UK could be one of the first countries to feel the fallout from a downturn in the US-dominated shadow banking sector, which has quadrupled in value from $4tn in 2008

A picture

Reeves’s promise of pub business rates U-turn averts Labour rebellion

Rachel Reeves has avoided another damaging rebellion against her economic policies with the promise of a U-turn on controversial tax hikes for pubs in England, after weeks of protest from her colleagues and the hospitality industry.Government sources said on Thursday the chancellor was finalising a support package for the struggling industry that would include reductions to business rates for pubs, which had been facing a 76% rise on average over the next three years.Industry figures welcomed news of the U-turn, which comes after similar climbdowns over cuts to winter fuel payments, cuts to disability benefits and a rise in inheritance tax for farmers.But with the Treasury yet to publish details of the support package, Reeves’s colleagues say they are willing to push ahead with an amendment to the government’s finance bill if they feel it does not go far enough.Tonia Antoniazzi, the Labour chair of the all-party parliamentary group on beer, said: “I am over the moon, things are moving in the right direction

A picture

The Primark machine suffers a continental splutter at a bad moment | Nils Pratley

It is probably a good thing that Associated British Foods has not yet split itself in two, liberating the go-getting and supposedly reliable Primark from the more volatile food and ingredients businesses. In standalone form, Primark would probably have suffered a bigger share price thump than the 14% fall that the still-combined conglomerate sustained after Thursday’s profits warning.The problem at Primark is that it has suddenly become hard to know what to expect. A year ago, the stores in continental Europe seemed to be trading well while the UK ones hit a soft spot. Now the UK end is back on form, regaining some market share, while the continental stores have had a serious skid

A picture

‘Shadow fleet’ ships moving sanctioned oil reflagged to Russia at rising rate

Forty ships accused of belonging to a large “shadow fleet” moving sanctioned oil for Venezuela and others were reflagged to Russia last year in an apparent attempt to gain Kremlin protection from American seizure.Analysis by the shipping intelligence publication Lloyd’s List suggests that of those, at least 17 suspicious vessels joined the Russian registry over the past month, compared with 15 ships in the previous five months of 2025.The sudden flurry of activity appears to be linked to Donald Trump’s announcement last month of what he called a US “blockade” of sanctioned oil tankers in and out of Venezuela.The term “shadow fleet” is defined by Lloyd’s List as ships for which deceptive practices are used in order to allow them to transport goods – including oil and gas – in violation of sanctions and price caps.On Thursday, a ship subjected to sanctions by the US over concerns it had been involved in distributing illicit Russian oil was identified as sailing through the Channel under a false name and Cameroonian flag

A picture

Software firm belonging to Tory donor Frank Hester pays out £50m dividend

The software company belonging to the Tory donor Frank Hester, a major contractor to the NHS, has paid a £50m dividend after sales and profits surged.TPP Group, which was founded by Hester in 1997 as The Phoenix Partnership, specialises in healthcare technology and provides its SystmOne software to the NHS. The company says it is used by 7,800 NHS organisations, including more than 2,600 GP practices and a third of acute mental health trusts, with 61m electronic health records stored in its database. It has also expanded abroad, including to China, the Middle East and the Caribbean.The company, which is owned by Hester and based in Leeds, had a turnover of £97

A picture

Pub chain shares rise on reports of government U-turn over business rates – as it happened

Shares in UK pub and hospitality companies have jumped this morning, as the government prepares to announce a climbdown on forthcoming increases to their business rates.Mitchells and Butlers, whose pub brands include All Bar One, Harvester, O’Neills, and Toby Carvery, are up 2.5%, one of the top risers in the FTSE 250 share index today.Rival Marsons, which has more than 1,300 pubs, bars and inns across the country, are up 2%, while JD Wetherspoons have gained 1.2%