Beau Webster steps off the sidelines into the light as promise of Cameron Green wilts | Geoff Lemon

A picture


There was an irony to the fact that Cameron Green’s catch made Beau Webster’s day look even better.Green had not had a good one, having earlier dived in front of Australia’s most prolific slip catcher to spoil a simple Steve Smith catch.It followed a poor day the day before, skying a pull shot after getting settled on 37, and a poor series before that.Then came Webster, an off-break swept into the deep, and Green’s long legs ate up the turf before crashing his body into a dive that gathered up the ball in its fall, the two Australians combining for what might be the tallest wicket in Test history.There is usually only room for a single two-metre all-rounder in a team, unless they’re operating at specialist level in one discipline.

Webster has spent this series on the sidelines of a team that backed Green as the better choice,The returns so far have been 149 runs at 21, and 4 wickets at 70,It has been telling that in Webster’s one opportunity, batting below Green in the order, he first outscored him while looking calmer and more organised with 71 not out, then showed his versatility by switching from seam-up to off-spin to nab three wickets,If Webster’s success shows that he needs more opportunities in the Test side, doing so with slow bowling also showed the nonsense of both teams going into this match without a specialist spinner, having hallucinated a seaming minefield while inspecting a surface that went on to yield Australia 567 and England 384,The other irony is that had Australia picked one, the spinner would have played in Webster’s spot.

Picking him at No 8, which became No 9 thanks to a nightwatch on the second evening, was far too low for his ability.It only happened so that selectors didn’t have to drop Green.Green is the definition of a project player, but anyone who has written funding applications knows that it’s hard to get a funding renewal unless the results are clear.He first drew national-team attention as a tall teenage fast bowler, batting in the bottom four for Western Australia as per the norm.Then injury rehab saw him focus on batting, a skill that flourished with almost alarming speed and breadth.

Suddenly he was up the order for his state, making not just hundreds but huge ones.The promise of the combination, of top-drawer bowling velocity mixed with batting class and run-hunger, was irresistible.When Green prepared for his Test debut, facing India A in 2020, what stood out while watching at Drummoyne Oval that day was the nimbleness of his footwork.Down the pitch and moving back, not charging the bowling but simply arranging his giant boots in a neat pitter-patter to reach the pitch of the ball, shifting to defend as well as to attack.Early reports of his bowling noted similarly high quality: the speed, the movement through the air, the accuracy.

More than five years later, having played 37 of Australia’s 52 Tests in that time, neither Green’s batting nor bowling project the confidence that was observed before he started,Perhaps those observers were just too excitable about a prospect, perhaps learning his trade in the most demanding venue of its practice was too steep a task to set,The expectations may have been too high,But there was more than just talent and potential back then, there was ability that already existed,As of right now, Green comes across as a hothouse flower that has dried up in the terrarium.

Perhaps the lamps were just too bright.The road from here is unclear.The 20-over age means that Green will go to a T20 World Cup with Australia, then stay to earn millions of dollars in the IPL, rather than play the back half of the Sheffield Shield season for Western Australia.Four months trying to send a white ball into orbit without once trying to drop a red ball at his toes.Will that make him a better Test cricketer by the time Bangladesh visit the Top End in August? Will runs and wickets there be any indication of that? How about when visiting South Africa in October, against the pace battery of the World Test Champions, who rolled over Australia to take that title while Green made 4 and 0 and couldn’t bowl?There is a public tendency to resent players who don’t live up to expectations, and Green doesn’t deserve to be resented.

He does, though, deserve people to be clear that he has had a far easier path through Test cricket than most, on the basis of talent rather than achievement.Webster is the opposite, a player of more modest talent whose years of achievement let him scrap his way in.The chosen one and the journeyman, defined as of now by the opposite directions from which they’ve arrived at their Test careers.Green may yet have time to define himself differently, but he needs to earn that chance.Webster already has.

trendingSee all
A picture

Starmer vows to review franchise legislation in response to Vodafone case

The prime minister has promised to review laws governing franchising agreements, in response to the case of a former Vodafone store manager whose family alleges took his own life following pressure from the FTSE 100 telecoms group.Keir Starmer said in the Commons on Wednesday that he would “look closely” at the outcome of a high-profile legal claim against Vodafone.The comments follow a Guardian investigation in December, which revealed claims that Adrian Howe, a former Vodafone employee who had agreed to become a franchisee in 2018, drowned after becoming convinced his deal with the multinational company would prove financially disastrous.Rachael Beddow-Davison and Dan Attwal also told the Guardian about how commission cuts by Vodafone in 2020 caused their franchising companies to run up huge debts, which they each said contributed to them attempting to kill themselves.Beddow-Davison and Attwal are two of a group of 62 former Vodafone franchisees who brought a high court claim in 2024, alleging the telecoms company “unjustly enriched” itself and which MPs have compared to the Post Office Horizon IT scandal

A picture

UK housebuilding in deepest slump since 2020 lockdowns; Warner Bros rejects ‘inferior’ $108bn Paramount hostile bid – as it happened

Newsflash: Britain’s construction sector continued to shrink in December, as housing, commercial and civil engineering activity suffered sharp falls again.Data provider S&P Global has reported that activity across the UK construction sector, and new orders, both fell again last month.Housebuilding and commercial construction work both decreased at the fastest rate since May 2020, when the Covid-19 lockdown forced building sites to close, S&P Global’s survey of purchasing managers at UK construction firms shows.That highlights the government’s struggle to hit its housebuilding targets.Civil engineering was the weakest-performing category of construction activity in December; it also shrank, but not by as much as in November

A picture

Grok’s deepfake images which ‘digitally undress’ women investigated by Australia’s online safety watchdog

Australia’s online safety watchdog is investigating sexualised deepfake images posted on X by its AI chatbot, Grok.Elon Musk’s X has faced a global backlash since Grok began generating sexualised images of women and girls without their consent in response to requests for it to undress them.Ashley St Clair, the estranged mother of one of Musk’s children, said she had no response to her complaints about being digitally undressed.“I felt horrified, I felt violated, especially seeing my toddler’s backpack in the back of it,” she said this week.The fake images included one of a 12-year-old girl in a bikini

A picture

Elon Musk’s xAI announces it has raised $20bn amid backlash over Grok deepfakes

Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence company has raised $20bn in its latest funding round, the startup announced Tuesday, even as its marquee chatbot Grok faces backlash over generating sexualized, nonconsensual images of women and underage girls.xAI’s Series E funding round featured big-name investors, including Nvidia, Fidelity Management and Resource Company, Qatar’s sovereign wealth fund, and Valor Equity Partners – the private investment firm of Musk’s longtime friend and former Doge member Antonio Gracias. The funding round exceeded its initial $15bn target, according to xAI’s press release. The company touted Grok’s image-generation abilities in the announcement of its latest funding round.xAI lacks the prominence of its rival OpenAI, the maker of ChatGPT, and has continually drawn criticism for generating misinformation, antisemitic content and now potentially illegal sexual material

A picture

Australia hold on to win fifth Ashes Test and leave England rueing missed chances

There were a couple of wobbles along the way but at 2.30pm on the final day in Sydney, Australia had knocked off a target of 160 runs to win the fifth Test by five wickets and claim this Ashes series by a 4-1 scoreline.Like their tour as a whole, there was a nagging sense of what might have been for England with a few more runs on the board, or better catching and tighter bowling earlier in the contest. But there could be few quibbles from the injured Ben Stokes as he watched the final rites from first slip.This has been a chastening tour for Stokes and his men, the Ashes lost in a record-equalling 11 days and just that two-day shootout victory in Melbourne to show for it

A picture

Simon Yates announces surprise retirement with ‘deep pride and sense of peace’

Simon Yates, one of Britain’s most storied riders and the winner of last year’s Giro d’Italia, has stunned cycling by announcing his retirement at 33.The Visma-Lease a Bike rider said on Wednesday that he is quitting with “deep pride and a sense of peace” after a 13-year career that delivered wins in two Grand Tours, 11 elite stages and 36 professional races.Yates posted on social media: “I have made the decision to retire from professional cycling. This may come as a surprise to many, but it is not a decision I have made lightly. I have been thinking about it for a long time, and it now feels like the right moment to step away from the sport