Majority of family court cases in England and Wales feature domestic abuse, watchdog says
Nearly 90% of cases before the family courts in England and Wales show evidence of domestic abuse, a watchdog has disclosed.Physical, psychological or sexual abuse of a member of the family or household was uncovered in 87% of cases, according to a review ordered by the domestic abuse commissioner, Nicole Jacobs.The abuse was frequently not recognised as an “active issue” or taken seriously with regard to the type of contact children would go on to have with the abusive parent, she said.In more than half of the cases reviewed, unsupervised overnight contact was ordered.“No child should be forced to spend time with an abusive parent or caregiver if the circumstances aren’t safe for them to do so,” Jacobs said.
“But time and time again we see how the pro-contact culture and antiquated views on domestic abuse are contributing to decisions that put children in harm’s way.“It’s clear that domestic abuse can no longer be considered a side issue within the family justice system, but instead its everyday business that demands a rigorous response.”Academics from Loughborough University examined 298 files from three courts and observed nearly 100 court hearings.As well as discovering evidence of abuse in case files, the team also heard claims of abuse in 73% of observed hearings, the report said.Survivors repeatedly described how they were dissuaded from raising allegations of domestic abuse due to the suggestion that it would have “no impact” on whether the abusive parent would be granted contact.
Others said they felt that pressure had been put on them to accept potentially unsafe child arrangement orders out of fear that, if they contested, an even worse outcome would be granted.Jacobs said survivors were being forced to navigate the complex system without representation.She urged the Ministry of Justice to commit to a rollout of the multi-service Pathfinder courts to resolve problems between parents sooner, and place more emphasis on hearing children’s voices.“The government must also provide the necessary investment to extend the pilot study, conducted by my office, to allow for rigorous oversight on the changes being made and ensure accountability from within the family court,” she added.“Tinkering around the edges will no longer suffice.
”The report highlights how outdated views on domestic abuse among some legal professionals means physical violence is taken more seriously but coercive and controlling behaviour – which often underpins physical abuse and is an offence in itself – is frequently dismissed.A report by Women’s Aid this summer detailed how 19 children had been killed over nine years by adults who had been allowed contact with them despite a history of violence.In March, MPs discussed the presumption of parental involvement, and heard from Claire Throssell, whose two sons, Jack and Paul, were murdered by their abusive father during court-ordered unsupervised contact.On Tuesday Catherine Roper, the chief constable of Wiltshire police, apologised after a staff member’s failure to properly undertake applications under Clare’s law – which allows people to find out whether a partner has a history of violence or domestic abuse – left women at risk of violence, including one who was the victim of attempted murder.Justice minister Alison Levitt KC said: “The horrors that domestic abuse can bring on children are unspeakable, scarring them for life, and as a government we want to do everything in our power to stop this epidemic.
“That’s why we’re improving family courts by helping families get the support they need faster, with our reformed model reducing case times by 11 weeks on average, and ensuring children’s voices are heard.“This is about protecting children, standing up for victims, and making sure justice works for all those who need it.”
Keir Starmer back on familiar ground after walk-on part in the Trump show in Egypt | John Crace
Keir Starmer has always known that Monday’s visit to Egypt was going to be the Donald Trump Show. After all, almost every day is the Donald Trump Show and there was no way the US president was going to share the limelight on this of all days. The day when the living Israeli hostages were freed, 1,900 Palestinian detainees were freed and the first aid trucks entered Gaza.This was The Donald’s peace deal. A narcissist is going to narcissise
Starmer says he expects debate about ‘full horror’ of what happened in Gaza when media allowed in – as it happened
Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader, asks for more detail of what the UK is doing to help ensure more aid gets into Gaza.He says all the bodies of dead hostages need to be returned.And he asks what the UK is doing to ensure that the expansion of illegal Israeli settlements on the West Bank stops.Starmer thanks Davey for the “content and tone” of his response. (He is making a contrast with Badenoch’s
Farage, not Marxism, risks ‘poisoning our kids’ | Letters
I am one of those proud teachers that Nigel Farage has in mind (Nigel Farage accuses teachers of ‘poisoning our kids’ on race issues, 9 October). For many years, as part of teaching media, film and journalism, I sought to educate students about basic political terms and concepts. Marxism was, and is, nothing resembling the totalitarian bogeyman that the USSR so conveniently became. Marxism is a doctrine espousing fairness, equal opportunity, redistribution of wealth and emancipation. It aims to be fully democratic
National grooming gangs inquiry stalls over remit wrangles and lack of chair
Keir Starmer’s national grooming gangs inquiry has stalled amid wrangles over its remit and difficulties in finding a senior legal figure willing to become its chair, the Guardian has been told.Terms of the statutory investigation are still being discussed by a panel of stakeholders including survivors of abuse rings, four months after the prime minister bowed to pressure and set it up.The search for a chair of the panel is still to be completed, the Home Office has confirmed. Judges and lawyers appear to be reluctant to head the inquiry, a source said.Officials are said to be working to appoint a chair who will then play a central role in shaping the terms and scope of the inquiry and identify a first area for review
Vote for a party’s policies and actions, not its name or history | Letters
Polly Hudson (Some people have a choice about whether or not to vote Labour. I wish I did too, 5 October) seems to be confusing her father’s devotion to his political and ethical principles with devotion to a party. He sounds like a dedicated and hard-working MP who sacrificed a lot for his principles and to serve his country and community.But it’s only in dictatorships that devotion to “the party” starts to supersede commitment to moral and ethical principles. As citizens of a democratic country, it is imperative that we vote according to our principles and our ideas of what we want this country to be
Former lord speaker faces suspension for ‘improper influence’ over speeding offence
Former lord speaker Frances D’Souza is facing suspension from the Lords after writing to the Metropolitan police commissioner to try to “influence a police investigation into alleged speeding offences”.Lady D’Souza wrote to Mark Rowley saying she feared she would have to give up attending parliament if she were banned from driving for exceeding the limit in a 20mph zone.The Met police said it had considered launching a criminal investigation into the apparent attempt to influence the commissioner but decided against it. It then passed the letter to the House of Lords conduct committee to investigate whether it breached the code of conduct.D’Souza did not dispute the case but appealed against the sanction – a recommended eight-week ban from the Lords for seeking “to influence a live police investigation”
Cauliflower risotto and sausages with squash and beans: Sophie Wyburd’s recipes for autumn warmers
How to make cinnamon buns – recipe | Felicity Cloake's Masterclass
Punk Royale, London W1: ‘Someone shoved mystery slop in my mouth’ – restaurant review | Grace Dent on restaurants
Enjoying my meat that’s low on miles | Letter
‘It’s really good for the staff’: how restaurants adapt to customers drinking less
Helen Goh’s recipe for pumpkin cheesecake with maple pecan brittle | The sweet spot