Carer’s allowance: woman who won case against DWP calls for end to ‘sickening harassment’
The mother of a teenager with cerebral palsy has demanded an end to the “sickening harassment” of unpaid carers after a significant legal victory against the government,Nicola Green, 42, was pursued by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) for more than a year after she was accused of fraudulently claiming nearly £3,000 in carer’s allowance,When Green insisted she was innocent, the DWP wrote to her employer without her knowledge to try to recoup the sum from her pay,The part-time college worker, whose 17-year-old son has a number of health conditions, appealed against the fine before a tribunal judge, who quashed it in barely 30 minutes last month,Speaking after her legal victory, Green said she had been treated “like a criminal” by the DWP over the £2,823.
75 sum.“I can’t believe what they’re putting people through,” she said.“[I’m] just a law-abiding person, who has never broken the law in my life.I’ve always tried to do things by the book … It feels like harassment.”The DWP wrote to Green on 27 May to say it was considering appealing against the tribunal ruling and that it would not cancel the debt until then.
However, the department wrote to her again on Monday, days after being contacted the Guardian, to say it had cancelled the overpayment and that she would be offered advice about claiming compensation,A DWP spokesperson said: “Ms Green’s overpayment has been cancelled,We are committed to supporting carers across the UK,Tribunals offer customers an opportunity to provide any additional information which may be relevant to their case, and we regularly gather feedback and learn from them,”Green’s case is the latest in the Guardian’s award-winning investigation into the DWP’s pursuit of unpaid carers despite official errors that have plunged tens of thousands of vulnerable people into hardship.
The latest figures show that the government is clawing back at least £357m in carer’s allowance paid out in error over the last six years, leaving hundreds of people with criminal records and some with debts of more than £20,000.The DWP has faced widespread criticism over its “cruel and nonsensical” punishment of family carers who unwittingly earned slightly more than the weekly limit to qualify for carer’s allowance, which rose to £196 a week in April.The department is alerted whenever a carer oversteps the weekly limit but until recently only checked half of these alerts – and as few as 12% for a long time – meaning tens of thousands of people were unknowingly building up debt for years.The controversial “cliff-edge” rule means that a carer who earns £1 more than the weekly threshold must repay the whole of that week’s carer’s allowance, currently £83.30 a week.
That means someone who earns £1 a week over the limit for a year must repay not £52 but £4,331.60.A Guardian analysis has found a sharp increase in the number of cases being quashed by judges in recent years as concern over the DWP’s actions have grown.In the year to April 2025, tribunal judges struck out 42% of carer’s allowance fines, compared with 29% in 2019 and 15% in 2014.In total, the DWP has lost 898 cases at tribunal in the last six years.
Green, who works less than 14 hours a week at Bolton college, said she was reduced to tears by the DWP’s pursuit.She juggles her term time-only job with caring for her teenage son, whom she did not wish to be named publicly.He has cerebral palsy, is deaf and has short bowel syndrome owing to complications arising from being born extremely premature, meaning he was hospitalised for six months from birth.“They don’t care about you.They don’t care about your personal situation.
They don’t care what you’ve been through and they don’t care how much you’re saving the system,” she said.“It’s so unjust and it’s the injustice that’s driven me to challenge it.It’s sickening actually.The tone of the letters – they’re insinuating I’m a criminal.And going through the process you do feel like you’ve defrauded the system, however innocent it has been.
”If you have been threatened with prosecution for benefit fraud in the UK, you can tell us about it by filling in the form below or messaging us,Please include as much detail as possiblePlease include as much detail as possiblePlease include as much detail as possiblePlease note, the maximum file size is 5,7 MB,Your contact details are helpful so we can contact you for more information,They will only be seen by the Guardian.
Your contact details are helpful so we can contact you for more information,They will only be seen by the Guardian,If you include other people's names please ask them first,Contact us on WhatsApp or Signal at +447766780300,For more information, please see our guidance on contacting us via WhatsApp, For true anonymity please use our SecureDrop service instead.
The DWP claimed Green had breached the earnings rules on seven occasions between December 2018 and April 2024.Five of these related to a one-off Christmas holiday bonus from her employer.One was due to unexpectedly receiving sick pay.The final overpayment related to a pay increase awarded to all Bolton college employees.However, tribunal judge Dianne Oliver ruled last month that Green had not in fact breached the rules because her average weekly pay was below the earnings limit.
The DWP did not attend the 30-minute hearing in Bolton.The judgment follows a similar legal victory by another unpaid carer, Andrea Tucker, who defeated the government in February.The rulings are significant because the DWP routinely pursues carers on the basis of individual weekly earnings, rather than averaging them over a year.If the government took the latter approach, far fewer carers would end up with huge debts.
Thunder move one win from franchise’s first NBA title in 46 years after holding off Pacers
The Oklahoma City Thunder moved within one win of the franchise’s first NBA championship in 46 years on Monday night, beating the Indiana Pacers 120–109 in Game 5 of the NBA finals to take a 3-2 series lead.Jalen Williams erupted for a career playoff-high 40 points, MVP Shai Gilgeous-Alexander added 31 points and 10 assists, and the Thunder held off a furious Indiana rally to secure a chance at clinching their first title since 1979 in Game 6 on Thursday in Indianapolis.It was the 10th time this postseason that Gilgeous-Alexander and Williams combined for more than 70 points in a game. Williams was 14-of-25 from the field and added six rebounds and four assists, including several key buckets late in the fourth as the Thunder weathered a Pacers push.ScheduleBest-of-seven-games series
Johnny Sexton insists he is ‘here to help’ Finn Russell despite past Lions criticism
Johnny Sexton has insisted he is “here to help” Finn Russell in his capacity as British & Irish Lions assistant coach, after the pair shook hands and cleared the air last month following the former Ireland captain’s previous criticism of the Scotland fly-half.Sexton toured with the Lions in 2013 and 2017 but was a surprise omission from Warren Gatland’s squad in 2021. In his autobiography, the former Ireland captain revealed how the snub “kills me to this day” and described Russell as a “media darling” before suggesting in a subsequent interview that he was “flashy”.Sexton, who retired after the 2023 World Cup, was added in April to Andy Farrell’s coaching staff for the tour of Australia this summer, making for a potentially awkward reunion with Russell, who is the favourite to start at fly-half in the three-Test series against the Wallabies.The pair had a brief catch-up at the first squad get-together last month, however, with Russell explaining recently that the air had been cleared
Dan Evans reproduces form of old to beat Frances Tiafoe at Queen’s Club
Dan Evans opened up the men’s tournament at Queen’s Club with his biggest win for more than two years, toppling Frances Tiafoe – the seventh seed and world No 13 – 7-5, 6-2 to reach the second round.The win was Evans’s first against a top-20 opponent since he defeated Alex de Minaur in the Davis Cup finals in 2023 and a positive step forward after an extremely difficult period in the final stretch of his career.Having spent five consecutive years inside the top 100, Evans is attempting to re-establish himself at the top levels of the game after falling down the rankings in August last year. The 35‑year‑old scaled as high as No 21 less than two years ago but he now sits at No 199 in the ATP rankings. He received a wildcard to compete at Queen’s Club and he will also need a wildcard in order to compete in the main draw at Wimbledon in two weeks’ time
Royal Ascot ready to roll with MPs worried future of racing is ‘on the line’
Hundreds of staff were putting the finishing touches to Ascot racecourse on Monday ahead of the five-day Royal meeting. The champagne is on ice, a variety of crustaceans have been plucked from the seabed and transported to Berkshire and the famous grey horses that lead the royal procession are ready to be harnessed. The most valuable, historic and glamorous show on turf is good to go.So it was a little jarring, to say the least, to spend an hour on Monday lunchtime in the company of assorted heavy-hitters from the racing industry and a pair of racing-friendly MPs from either side of the House, hearing warnings of a “triple whammy of challenges” that, according to a report from the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for Racing and Bloodstock which was published on Monday, “present no less than an existential threat to the sport”.John Gosden, who will saddle the hot favourite Field Of Gold in Tuesday’s St James’s Palace Stakes, the feature event on Royal Ascot’s opening day, was among them
The trial that gripped Norway like a soap opera has ripped apart track and field’s most famous family | Sean Ingle
The moment that ripped apart track and field’s most successful and eccentric family came in January 2022, after the 15‑year‑old sister of the Tokyo Olympic 1500m champion Jakob Ingebrigtsen was grounded by her father after school.At that point, Jakob and his brothers Filip and Henrik, were all European, world or Olympic champions, having trained like professionals since before they were teenagers. They were also major TV stars in Norway thanks to the docuseries Team Ingebrigtsen, where they appeared alongside their coach and father, Gjert.Gjert, whose manner could make an army drill sergeant sound touchy-feely, outlined his philosophy early in series one. “I don’t want to be an angry man, I want to be a father,” he said
Spaun deserves his dream but US Open chaos did not get best from world’s elite | Ewan Murray
There should be no sense of demeaning JJ Spaun’s US Open glory if observers question the circumstances. Spaun, not so long ago a journeyman professional, played out his dream by holing out from 65ft on the final green at Oakmont.Spaun is a prime example of how the penny can drop for golfers at different stages. Now 34, he is in the form of his life and bound for the Ryder Cup. When he talked later of being awake at three o’clock on Sunday morning because his young daughter was vomiting, his relatability only grew
Ragù, Bristol BS1: ‘I recommend it wholly, effusively and slightly enviously’ – restaurant review | Grace Dent on restaurants
Raise a glass to National Beer Day: tips on the perfect pint
Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for cherry and honeycomb cheesecake pots | The sweet spot
Ken Don obituary
‘The quality of Lebanese wine is absolutely incredible’
Rachel Roddy’s salad of hazelnuts, gorgonzola and honey dressing | A kitchen in Rome