Resident doctors’ focus on pay is doing untold damage to the NHS | Letters

A picture


As a retired doctor, now 80, I feel sad as I watch our resident doctors struggle to exert pressure on the government to increase their pay packet (Wes Streeting ‘thought he had struck deal to halt strike by doctors’, 27 July),This behaviour will have far-reaching consequences, which are unlikely to be beneficial either to the doctors or the country,Clearly, the action will cause delays in treatment and probably unnecessary morbidity and mortality,This will make the NHS vulnerable to pressure from those who favour its abolition,Already, it has alienated large sections of the population whose support the doctors have always been able to count on previously.

But the British Medical Association has assured resident doctors that it is necessary for them to put their livelihood ahead of the wellbeing of the public, to ensure that the NHS survives into the future.This is a false promise.The commitment of resident doctors and nurses has always been integral to the success of the NHS, and there is no doubt that this has been central to the incredible efficiency it has demonstrated since its inception.It was conceived as a non-commercial organisation.There have always been areas of the globe where doctors could earn more than at home.

But for most, the attractions of the NHS outweighed pecuniary advantages available elsewhere.I fear that in setting their sights purely on increased remuneration, today’s resident doctors are leading the NHS towards a change in its entire ethos, the ethos that made it a success.The BMA should concentrate on improving doctors’ working conditions, as Wes Streeting has offered them.Robert BehrmanCookham Dean, Berkshire On Sunday I cancelled my subscription to the British Medical Association after being a member for 39 years, in disgust at its insistence on going ahead with the strike of resident doctors in pursuit of a 29% pay rise, despite having had a 22% rise over the previous two years.It is hard to know what is the correct rate of pay for resident doctors, but no other group in the health service is seeking such a rise in pay, and the decision to strike seems to ignore patients, as well as all the other staff alongside whom they work.

I believe that improvement in the working conditions of doctors and all other groups should be sought through discussions, as the government has offered, not strikes,Whatever the appropriate pay should be for resident doctors, they should be glad that they don’t get the equivalent of the £2 per hour we were paid in the 1980s for each of the 60 hours a week we had to be in the hospital over and above our basic 40-hour week,Prof David CameronBelhaven, East Lothian I do have a lot of sympathy for our resident doctors, even though I was on call on Sunday as a consultant,It is not just that pay has been eroded, but also that the cost of becoming a doctor has gone up, as has the cost of living in general,Unlike in most other higher-paid professions, half of doctors are women.

The cost of childcare has gone up significantly since my day.There is no more cheap hospital accommodation.And the student loan system is misogynistic in principle, the interest accumulating during maternity leave.Women earn less during their careers but end up paying back a lot more for their student loans as a group.And because of the forced itinerant lifestyle, most doctors get their foot on the housing ladder quite late, having to pay increasingly unaffordable rents.

Marianne GemmekeEastleigh, Hampshire Wes Streeting rightly points out that 90% of resident doctors voted for strike action, with a 55% turnout (Resident doctors’ strike undermines union movement, says Wes Streeting, 25 July).That means just under 50% of all resident doctors voted in favour.He fails to point out that Labour is in power on the votes of 34% of the 60% who turned out – about 20% of the electorate.The doctors’ result looks more convincing as a test of opinion, whatever you think of the pay award.Peter WestLondon Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.

recentSee all
A picture

Trump threatens drug giants with crackdown over prices

Donald Trump has threatened to use “every tool in our arsenal” to crack down on pharmaceutical giants if they fail to cut drug prices for Americans within 60 days.The president wrote to executives at 17 companies on Thursday, demanding they match their US prices for prescription drugs with the lowest price offered in other developed nations.Current prices were an “unacceptable burden” on US families, Trump said, claiming they could be up to three times higher than in other countries.After returning to the White House earlier this year and pledging to bring down drug prices, the president claimed that “most proposals” from the pharmaceutical industry amounted to “more of the same”, accusing firms of seeking to shift blame and requesting policies that would pave the way for handouts worths billions of dollars for the sector.“Make no mistake: a collaborative effort towards achieving global pricing parity would be the most effective path for companies, the government, and American patients,” Trump wrote

A picture

Rolls-Royce hits turbo speed. Now keep going for a decade | Nils Prately

Turbo Tufan strikes again. It’s almost becoming predictable. Every time Tufan Erginbilgiç, chief executive of Rolls-Royce, sets “midterm” financial targets, the aero-engine maker beats them, or looks set to do so, in no time.Back in February, Erginbilgiç was able to declare that the 2027 targets for operating profits would be hit two years early, so he set new ambitions for 2028. Six months on, even the refreshed numbers look conservative

A picture

Apple quietens Wall Street’s fears of China struggles and slow AI progress

Apple has been under pressure this year. It’s playing catch-up to its fellow tech giants on artificial intelligence, it’s seen its stock fall by double digits since the year began, it closed a store in China for the first time ever this week, and looming US tariffs on Beijing threaten its supply chain. On Thursday, the company released its third-quarter earnings of the fiscal year as investors scrutinize how the iPhone maker might turn things around.Despite the gloomy outlook, the company is still worth more than $3tn, and it beat Wall Street’s expectations for profit and revenue this quarter. Apple reported a massive 10% year-over-year increase in revenue to $94

A picture

Amazon fails to quiet tariff worries with worse-than-expected financial outlook

Amazon failed to quiet concerns over how Donald Trump’s sweeping tariffs would affect its e-commerce business as it reported its latest quarterly results on Thursday. Wall Street’s affinity for the tech giant faltered in response.The top line numbers from Amazon’s second quarter earnings report exceeded Wall Street’s projections. The tech company beat expectations with its revenue up 13.3% year over year to $167

A picture

Joe Burgess scores four tries as Hull KR’s demolition of Salford raises big questions

This was anything but the kind of advert Super League clubs who voted to expand the competition to 14 teams in 2026 would have hoped for.This may well be the last time we see Salford versus Hull KR as a Super League fixture for some time. There is a growing feeling that, even with two more teams joining the elite next year, Salford’s position is increasingly untenable as they remain riddled by financial problems.Having been forced to request an advance on their central distribution on the eve of the season, a takeover in February was hoped to be the cure for their long-term ills. But 20 rounds into the season, Salford remain under salary-cap constraints, have had to sell players to make ends meet and are still in deep financial trouble

A picture

LeBron James, Nikola Jokić reportedly meet over $5bn upstart to rival NBA

A high-profile meeting last week in France between LeBron James, his business partner Maverick Carter and Nikola Jokić’s agent Miško Ražnatović was about plans for a new $5bn international basketball league, according to a report by Front Office Sports, which cited multiple sources familiar with the matter.The proposed league, spearheaded by Carter, would feature six men’s and six women’s teams that travel together to eight global cities in a touring format. Inspired by LIV Golf and Formula One, the league aims to offer players equity stakes, something NBA rules currently prohibit for active athletes.Ražnatović, a powerful figure in European basketball, posted a photo of the meeting on Instagram over the weekend. The caption, tagged in Saint-Tropez, teased: “The summer of 2025 is the perfect time to make big plans for the fall of 2026