Maryland becomes first state to ban surveillance pricing in grocery stores
Maryland has become the first state in the US to ban surveillance pricing in grocery stores.Maryland’s law bans grocers and third-party delivery services from using a person’s personal data to set higher prices.Wes Moore, the governor, signed the measure into law on Tuesday.“At a time when technology can predict what we need, when we need it, when we’ll pay for it and also – when we’ll pay more for it, and at a time when we’re watching how big companies are then using these analytics against us to make record profits, Maryland is not just pushing back.Maryland is pushing forward because we are going to protect our people,” Moore said at the bill signing ceremony.
When engaging in surveillance pricing, stores rapidly change the cost of products based on consumer data, including their location, internet search history and demographics,That means buyers are paying different prices for the same items purchased around the same time,Critics of this method – also known as dynamic pricing – say that in doing so, businesses are effectively charging each person the most that they’re willing to pay,While Maryland’s new law focuses on grocery stores, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has documented examples of surveillance pricing in stores selling clothing, beauty products, home goods and hardware,Consumer groups note there is an added urgency when it comes to grocery stores, though, given that they affect Americans’ ability to access affordable food.
Bills being considered in Colorado, California, Massachusetts, Illinois and New Jersey may likewise regulate surveillance pricing.The US federal government has weighed in as well.The Federal Trade Commission, under the Biden administration, opened an investigation into these pricing practices and published initial findings from a study last January that found companies use an expansive range of personal data in setting varying prices for buyers.But it’s unlikely the current administration will crack down on surveillance pricing, given that the current FTC chair, Andrew Ferguson, characterized the previous administration’s report as a rush job.It’s in this context of federal inaction, that states like Maryland need to take action says Tom McBrien, counsel at the Electronic Privacy Information Center (Epic).
Anti-surveillance advocates say the new law is riddled with industry carveouts that will make it harder to protect consumers.They welcomed Maryland’s focus on the practice but say they are concerned about loopholes inserted as a result of industry lobbying.“We’re excited Maryland took this step but we do have serious concerns,” McBrien says.“The exemptions allow other ways of arriving at the same outcome that are just harder for consumers to detect.”Maryland’s law includes exemptions for loyalty programs and promotional offers.
While the law bans setting higher prices through surveillance pricing, it doesn’t address reducing prices,If a company raises its prices for everyone, and then offers individualized discounts, “suddenly you’ve arrived at the same outcome,” McBrien says,Consumer Reports, a non-profit which investigated Instacart’s pricing, said in a statement that it appreciated Moore prioritizing the issue but decried the law’s “weak enforcement provisions”,“We urge Maryland lawmakers to revisit the legislation next year to build in stronger consumer protections and remove loopholes that undermine the intent of this law,” it said,Instacart announced it would no longer be using technology that allows grocery stores to charge different shoppers different prices for the same groceries after a Consumer Reports investigation last year exposed the practice.
The harshest critics of Maryland’s new law believe it doesn’t just lack enforcement but erodes existing rights.They point, in particular, to a provision that only allows the state’s attorney general – and not individuals – to enforce the law.“The private right of action is a fundamental piece of accountability,” says Lee Hepner, senior legal counsel at the American Economic Liberties Project.“A meaningful threat of enforcement is the only effective deterrent to violating the law.”“The biggest threat of the Maryland bill is that other states will see it as a model bill that they should replicate in their own jurisdictions,” Hepner says.
“It is very important for us–as we try to get this legislation right in states from Colorado to California to New York–that the Maryland bill not be held up as a model, but in fact be recognized as an industry-written permission slip to engage in ongoing discrimination.”
From the Pocket: The AFL’s deference to technology only creates more doubt and uncertainty
When Greg Swann was appointed executive general manager of football performance at the AFL, many saw him as the man to cure all the sport’s ills. He was one of those footy people known primarily by his nickname, a man who projected an air of knockabout affability, a man renowned for getting things done. He would apply “the pub test” to many of football’s most pressing issues: the draft, the rules, the umpiring, the AFL review centre (ARC). “Swanny”, we were assured, was the man who would make footy’s trains run on time.One of the first things Swann’s predecessor, Laura Kane, did in the role was embark on an overseas study tour
Ultramarathon swimmer sets record pace over 55km in crocodile-filled Australian river
Andy Donaldson and his team were aware of the dangers that lay ahead, but just in case a reminder was needed, a huge 2.5-metre freshwater crocodile waiting at the start ramp ahead of his longest-ever solo swim put the challenge into stark focus.Donaldson, a British-Australian ultramarathon swimmer, was about to embark on the 55km Dam to Dam Challenge from Lake Argyle to Kununurra in the East Kimberley, hoping to become the first man to complete the gruelling endurance swim.Adding to the difficulty was the fact the Ord River in remote Western Australia is well known for its reptilian inhabitants; the freshwater crocodile population numbers 5,500 – one croc for every 10 metres of his swim.Fortunately for the 35-year-old, freshwater crocodiles are smaller and more timid than their saltwater counterparts – the world’s largest reptiles – and unlikely to approach humans
Cardinals ‘heartbroken’ after former defensive end Josh Mauro dies at age of 35
Former Arizona Cardinals and New York Giants defensive end Josh Mauro has died at the age of 35.Mauro’s father, Greg, confirmed the news in a post on Facebook.“With many tears and broken hearts, yet anchored in the unshakable certainty that our precious Josh Mauro is now healed and made new — living in the presence of the Lord — we humbly covet your prayers as our family walks through the devastating loss of our amazing son, brother, uncle, grandson and friend,” Greg Mauro wrote. “On Thursday, April 23rd, Josh breathed his last breath on this earth and his first breath in heaven.”Two of Mauro’s former teams, the Cardinals and Raiders, paid tribute to the player
West Ham urged to show ‘heart and soul’ over London 2029 World Athletics bid
The head of the London Marathon has urged West Ham to show more “heart and soul” amid fears they could scupper Britain’s chances of hosting the 2029 World Athletics Championships.While London’s bid is seen as the favourite, it has hit a major stumbling block with West Ham refusing to give up their stadium for around two weeks in September 2029 because the football season will be under way.Hugh Brasher, who is part of the London 2029 bid team, admitted that the situation was further complicated by the Hammers facing relegation and the departure of the club’s vice-chair, Karren Brady.“Football is an interesting, very tribal, sport,” said Brasher. “Money talks
‘It’s a gamechanger’: Lewis Hamilton’s groundbreaking Mission 44 recruits working in F1
Sports people can be more than the sum of their athletic achievements. Lewis Hamilton stands unquestionably as one of the greatest drivers in the history of Formula One having delivered records and outstanding performances that will be hard to surpass. Yet it is indicative of his character that the seven-time world champion rates them all as sitting only alongside what might ultimately be his most significant and long-lasting legacy. His Mission 44 foundation is making an indelible impact on the makeup of motorsport.“Talent is everywhere, opportunity isn’t and that’s what we’re here to change
‘Like cutting the head off a hydra’: how Mary Cain exposed Nike’s disgraced coaching team
“As someone who has lost touch with reality, I like to hold a firm grasp on it now,” Mary Cain says while we walk through a palm-tree spotted campus in California.She’s telling me why she insisted she write her own memoir, This Is Not About Running, without ceding the narrative to a ghostwriter, as happens with many athletes. “My story is so complicated … there are so many bad actors that I think it forces the reader to embrace nuance, and I don’t think you see that very often.”At 29, Mary Cain is a decade removed from her experience as the United States’ highest hope for a middle-distance track star since Mary Decker smashed women’s world records up and down the stat sheet in the 1970s and 80s.Cain set four different national high school records as a teen, and as a 17-year old made the world championships in the 1500m, finishing 10th in a field of pros
Farage’s attempt to get ahead of £5m gift story only raises more questions
Lib Dems push for ban on MPs taking money from X, citing Maga threat
The bridesmaid ban: how the Home Office tarnished a British citizen’s big day – and cost them £2,000
Exclusive: Nigel Farage was given undisclosed £5m by crypto billionaire in 2024
Reform’s Scottish leader called ‘tone deaf’ after boasting about his houses, cars and yachts
Starmer sees off major Labour rebellion over call for Mandelson inquiry