Father of teen whose death was linked to social media has ‘lost faith’ in Ofcom
The father of Molly Russell, a British teenager who killed herself after viewing harmful online content, has called for a change in leadership at the UK’s communications watchdog after losing faith in its ability to make the internet safer for children,Ian Russell, whose 14 year-old daughter took her own life in 2017, said Ofcom had “repeatedly” demonstrated that it does not grasp the urgency of keeping under-18s safe online and was failing to implement new digital laws forcefully,“I’ve lost confidence in the current leadership at Ofcom,” he told the Guardian,“They have repeatedly demonstrated that they don’t grasp the urgency of this task and they have shown that they don’t seem to be willing to use their powers to the extent that is required,”Russell’s comments came in the same week the technology secretary, Liz Kendall, wrote to Ofcom saying she was “deeply concerned” about delays in rolling out parts of the Online Safety Act (OSA), a landmark piece of legislation laying down safety rules for social media, search and video platforms.
Russell, who has become an influential internet safety campaigner since his daughter’s death, said that last year he raised concerns with Ofcom’s chief executive, Melanie Dawes, about an online suicide forum accessible to UK users,Ofcom opened an investigation into the site this year, shortly after assuming new regulatory powers from the OSA, and the forum voluntarily geo-blocked access to UK users,But Russell said the investigation appeared to have “stalled” before the regulator ramped up its probe this month – when it emerged the forum was still available to UK users through a previously undetected “mirror site”,“If Ofcom can’t deal with something as black and white, cut and dried as that, you have to question what else they can deal with,” Russell said,Ofcom addressed Russell’s concerns in a letter, saying that the site’s geo-block had been constantly monitored, but the mirror site – operating under a wholly different domain name – had come to the regulator’s attention only this month.
Russell said he shared Kendall’s disappointment in delays to implementing further elements of the OSA, including strict rules for the largest and most influential online platforms.Ofcom has said the delays were due to a court challenge from the Wikimedia foundation – the charity behind Wikipedia.The watchdog said it had the “highest respect” for bereaved families and pointed to achievements under its watch, such as age checks for pornography sites and a crackdown on child sexual abuse material.“We are working with urgency to drive tech firms to deliver a safer life online for children and adults in the UK, and while the job is not done, change is happening,” a spokesperson said.The Molly Rose Foundation, a charity founded by Molly’s family, has submitted a letter to the UK government calling on ministers to extend a legal requirement for transparency from public officials to apply to tech companies as well.
The letter urged Alex Davies-Jones, the victims minister, to expand the remit of the public authority (accountability) bill, which introduces a “duty of candour” for public officials,The bill, brought in after criticism of how police officers presented evidence at the Hillsborough inquiry, requires public bodies and officials to help investigations – including coroner’s courts – by providing information and evidence proactively, without favouring their own position,The foundation believes that requiring companies regulated by the OSA to abide by the same rules would prevent them from dragging their heels over submitting evidence in the case of a death where social media use was potentially involved,The inquest into Molly’s death was subject to delays owing to wrangles with Meta over submitting evidence,The letter said: “This shift would fundamentally reset the relationship between tech companies and their victims – a move that would require tech companies to act transparently and expeditiously when responding to legal requests.
”Recent legislation has bolstered coroners’ powers, enabling them to demand evidence of social media use from tech companies under the OSA and prevent important data from being deleted, but the letter’s signatories believe tougher powers are needed,Among more than 40 signatories were members of the group Bereaved Families for Online Safety and the Meta whistleblower Arturo Béjar,A government spokesperson pointed to the legal changes enhancing coroners’ powers to require information from tech firms,“The Online Safety Act supports coroners conducting inquests and families seeking the truth in compelling companies to share data fully where there is evidence of a link between a child’s death and their social media use',” said the spokesperson,“As promised in our manifesto, we have also strengthened this by also giving coroners the power to request that data is preserved to support inquests.
We will not hesitate to act, and will work with families and campaigners to ensure we protect families and children.” In the UK, the youth suicide charity Papyrus can be contacted on 0800 068 4141 or email pat@papyrus-uk.org, and in the UK and Ireland Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie.
In the US, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is at 988 or chat for support.In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14.Other international helplines can be found at befrienders.org
China voices ‘extreme disappointment’ with Dutch minister at centre of car chip row
The Chinese government has expressed “extreme disappointment” with the Dutch minister at the heart of a row over chip supply to the car industry.A spokesperson for the ministry of commerce was responding to a Guardian interview with Vincent Karremans on Thursday in which the politician described the standoff between China and the European Union as a “wake-up call” for western leaders.The spokesperson said: “China has noted the recent remarks made by Dutch minister of economic affairs Karremans in media interviews. China expresses extreme disappointment and strong dissatisfaction with such remarks that confuse right and wrong, distort facts and persist in a single-minded course.“The profound lesson this semiconductor supply chain crisis has taught the world is that administrative measures should not be used to improperly interfere with corporate operations
People in the US: how are your holiday shopping plans being affected by Trump’s tariffs and the cost of living?
We’d like to find out more about your holiday spending plans this year. The New York Times reported on Friday that the Trump administration is pivoting to an affordability message and considering lowering some tariffs rates.The administration has floated policies that would lower prices for coffee and fruit, spoken about a 50-year mortgage proposal, and Trump has mused on social media about giving Americans $2,000 funded by tariff revenue.A Harris poll from September found that 74% of Americans said their monthly household costs had gone up by more than $100.We want to hear from you
Reeves’s plan to ditch income tax rise prompts government bond sell-off
UK bond markets took fright on Friday after it emerged that Rachel Reeves had ditched plans for a manifesto-busting increase in income tax at this month’s autumn budget.On a day of choppy trading in the City, the cost of UK government borrowing rose by the most in a single day since early July, when a tearful appearance by Reeves in parliament spooked investors.The yield – in effect the interest rate – on 10-year government bonds, which are known as gilts, jumped by more than 0.13 percentage points to trade at about 4.575%, the highest level in a month
’Tis the season for dubious TV adverts | Letters
The issues you highlighted in your editorial are real, but please don’t think that advertisers care about them (The Guardian view on the John Lewis Christmas ad: a modern story of fathers and sons, 7 November).This ad is a shameless attempt to make consumers think they are doing something worthwhile in buying overpriced gifts in a failing store that used to share its profits with staff but hasn’t paid them any bonus in the past few years.If anything, the relentless pressure of advertising (where the Christmas season starts earlier each year) only serves to pile more pressure on people who are struggling. The cynicism of these ads – pretending to care while desperately trying to trigger the Pavlovian Christmas shopping response – is truly depressing.Chris LinwardSalford Your editorial’s claim that the new John Lewis Christmas ad was “harking back to the 1990s” and evoked “a less complicated time to be a young man” would be news to anyone who remembers that time as the era of laddism and Loaded, and the underlying unease about men’s emotional lives as shown in novels such as Tim Lott’s White City Blue and Nick Hornby’s About a Boy
US markets struggle amid tech sell-off and economic uncertainty
Wall Street came under pressure on Thursday, enduring its worst day in a month as a sell-off of technology stocks intensified.After an extraordinary rally around hopes for artificial intelligence that propelled global stock markets to record highs, fears that tech firms are now overvalued loom large.Investors are also braced for the release of a batch of official data on the state of the US economy, amid heightened uncertainty over its strength during the federal government shutdown.The benchmark S&P 500 and the Dow Jones industrial average each closed down 1.7% in New York on Thursday, while the tech-focused Nasdaq Composite dropped 2
Thames Water tried to make MP pay its legal fees of up to £1,400 an hour
Thames Water argued that an MP should be forced to pay its hefty legal costs after he represented the interests of the British public in court, a move he described as “retaliation” for pushing for government control of the crisis-hit utility, the Guardian can reveal.The UK’s highest court this week rejected Thames Water’s arguments that the Liberal Democrat MP Charlie Maynard should pay legal fees as high as £1,400 per hour.Britain’s biggest water company has been on the verge of collapse for several years as it struggles under the weight of net debt of £17bn, built up over decades since privatisation. Thames Water’s effective owners have asked for 15 years of leniency from environmental fines from the government to try to recover.Maynard was granted unusual permission to represent the public interest in a court battle over an investor bailout for Thames Water
Trump’s targeting of alleged drug vessels strains UK-US intelligence ties
Britons living abroad: tell us your views on UK politics today
Your Party receives ‘small portion’ of withheld supporters’ donations
Starmer stands by McSweeney and says he has been ‘assured no briefings against ministers done from No 10’ – as it happened
Starmer defies calls to sack chief of staff, claiming briefing didn’t come from No 10
Labour must accept that the two-party age is over and embrace PR | Letters