Elon Musk’s $1tn Tesla pay deal to be rejected by huge Norway wealth fund

A picture


Norway’s sovereign wealth fund has said it will vote against a $1tn (£765bn) pay package for the Tesla chief executive, Elon Musk.The fund, which is the biggest national wealth fund in the world, said that while it appreciated the “the significant value created under Mr Musk’s visionary role” it would vote against his performance award.“We are concerned about the total size of the award, dilution and lack of mitigation of key person risk – consistent with our views on executive compensation,” it said.“We will continue to seek constructive dialogue with Tesla on this and other topics.”The warning from Norges Bank, which is the seventh biggest single shareholder in Tesla with a stake worth $17bn, comes two days before the carmaker hosts its annual shareholder meeting.

On Thursday, investors will vote on proposals for an unprecedented incentive package that could make Elon Musk the world’s first trillionaire.If Musk increases the value of Tesla from about $1tn to $8.5tn over the next 10 years, Musk will receive new shares that would push his stake in the company from nearly 16% to more than 25%.This would increase the fortunes of the world’s richest man to more than $2tn.The Tesla chair, Robyn Denholm, has argued the vote is essential to retain the 54-year-old Musk as chief executive of the company, writing in a letter to shareholders that the company risks losing “significant value” if he were to leave.

Last year, the Norwegian oil fund voted against what was then the biggest pay package in US corporate history of $56bn for Musk,The deal was approved by shareholders in June but was rejected for a second time by a court in Delaware in December,Nicolai Tangen, the chief executive of the Norwegian fund, invited Musk and other chief executives to dinner in Oslo last year,However, Musk turned down the invite after the fund voted against the $56bn pay deal,A text exchange between Tangen and Musk was revealed in a freedom of information request by the Norwegian business publication DN.

It reported that Musk wrote to Tangen in October last year: “When I ask you for a favour which I very rarely do, and you decline, then you should not ask me for one until you’ve done something above nothing to make amends.Friends are as friends do.”Shareholders are divided on the new deal, although two influential shareholder advisory groups – Glass Lewis and ISS – have both recommended that investors reject the $1tn package.Some big pension funds have also opposed the pay package, including the American Federation of Teachers and the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, the largest public scheme in the US.Musk, who is Tesla’s biggest single shareholder, can also vote on the proposal.

Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionLast month, the Tesla boss said on X, the social media website he bought in 2022: “Tesla is worth more than all other automotive companies combined,Which of those CEOs would you like to run Tesla? It won’t be me,”Tesla has been trying to find ways to keep Musk as chief executive as it grapples with falling sales – global vehicle deliveries fell 13% in the first half of the year,That was partly due to the disruption from the redesign of its popular Model Y car,The carmaker reported a 7% rise in its most recent quarter, as many US consumers rushed to buy electric cars before a $7,500 government purchase incentive ended in September.

However, now these tax credits have expired, and the company faces a potential slowdown in its home market.Tesla sales have also been falling across much of Europe: new car registrations dropped 89% in Sweden, 86% in Denmark, 50% in Norway and 48% in the Netherlands in October, according to local industry data.France was an outlier, where the company made a small gain in sales for the second month in a row.Meanwhile, data from the Chinese Passenger Car Association released on Tuesday, showed that shipments from its Shanghai factory continued to decline, with 61,497 units shipped in October, down about 10% compared with last year.Tesla was approached for comment.

cultureSee all
A picture

Jimmy Kimmel on government shutdown: ‘There is no Republican plan for healthcare’

Late-night hosts recapped Donald Trump’s state visit to Japan as the government shutdown continued into its fourth week.On Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the comedian checked in on Trump’s visit to Japan this week. “You know, when Trump visits, you have to find something to do with him,” he said. “You can’t just take him for a stroll around town.“So instead, you take him for a stroll inside a palace, where he gets uncomfortably close to the band,” he said over footage of Trump wandering aimlessly through a ballroom with the Japan’s prime minister, Sanae Takaichi

A picture

Steve Coogan says Richard III film was ‘story I wanted to tell’ as he agrees to libel settlement

Steve Coogan has said his film about the discovery of the remains of Richard III was “the story I wanted to tell, and I am happy I did” after he and two production companies agreed to pay “substantial damages” to settle a high court libel claim over the film’s portrayal of a senior university administrator.Richard Taylor, deputy registrar at the University of Leicester at the time of the find, sued Coogan, his production company Baby Cow, and Pathe Productions for libel over his portrayal in the 2022 film The Lost King, which follows the amateur historian Philippa Langley and her search for the king’s skeleton.Taylor’s lawyers had asserted previously that he was portrayed in the film as “devious”, “weasel-like” and a “suited bean-counter”.Judge Lewis had ruled previously that the film portrayed Taylor as having “knowingly misrepresented facts to the media and the public” about the find, and as being “smug, unduly dismissive and patronising”, which had a defamatory meaning.The case was due to proceed to trial, but lawyers for Taylor read an agreed statement to the court on Monday saying the parties had settled the claim

A picture

From White Teeth to Swing Time: Zadie Smith’s best books - ranked!

How do you follow a smash hit like White Teeth, which, as everyone now knows, sold for a six-figure sum while the author was still at university, and turned Zadie Smith into a literary superstar and poster girl for multi­culturalism at 24? With a novel about a pot-smoking Chinese‑Jewish autograph hunter, the dangers of fame and the shallowness of pop culture, of course.The Autograph Man begins in full wisecracking throttle with three boys in the back of a car on their way to watch a wrestling match between Big Daddy and Giant Haystacks at the Royal Festival Hall. As 12-year-old Alex-Li Tandem gets Big Daddy’s autograph (the start of an obsession), his own daddy drops dead from a brain tumour. Unfortunately, the rest of the novel doesn’t quite live up to the prologue. The critical heavyweights of the time didn’t pull their punches: “A poky, pallid successor” (Michiko Kakutani, who had rapturously reviewed White Teeth, in the New York Times), “cartoonish” and full of “misplaced ironies and grinning complicities” (James Wood in the LRB)

A picture

Nobody Wants This to Lily Allen: the week in rave reviews

Kristen Bell’s sex podcaster and Adam Brody’s hot rabbi return with more romcom angst, while the Smile singer’s new record is a sharp autopsy of marital betrayal. Here’s the pick of the week’s culture, taken from the Guardian’s best-rated reviewsNetflixSummed up in a sentence An on-form return for the hot rabbi-featuring romcom whose plot (are an agnostic sex podcaster and a rabbi really compatible?) plays second fiddle to its millennials-pleasing casting (The Good Place’s Kristen Bell and The OC’s Adam Brody).What our reviewer said “The chemistry between Brody – still able to trade on the heart-throb status he accrued two decades ago playing beautiful nerd Seth Cohen in The OC – and Bell, who specialises in acid-tongued cool, remains electric.” Rachel AroestiRead the full reviewFurther reading Tummy-flipping kisses and a chlamydia love story: TV’s best ever romcomsBBC iPlayerSummed up in a sentence A hugely layered thriller starring the excellent Lauren Lyle as an anaesthetist who flies to New Zealand for the wedding of her younger sister – only to find her dead.What our reviewer said “Get stuck in

A picture

Stephen Colbert on ex-prince Andrew: ‘Pervert formerly known as prince’

Late-night hosts spoke about Donald Trump’s trip to Asia and how he refuses to accept criticism while also reacting to ex-prince Andrew being stripped of his royal title.On the Late Show, Stephen Colbert spoke about Trump’s recent trip to parts of Asia, including South Korea where he negotiated tariffs with Xi Jinping, China’s president.Colbert played awkward footage of the two in front of cameras, adding that he was “not confident we’re gonna win this one”.The talks ended up with both sides agreeing to what amounted to a pre-tariff status quo yet Trump has been “telling everyone he won the negotiations big time” saying that he would rank the meeting as a 12 out of 10.Colbert joked that he “must have been insufferable as a teenager” telling friends he went to 14th base with girls which means “over the bra, under the hat”

A picture

A third of people in England believe in ghosts, survey finds

It is the time of the year when the veil between the living and the dead is at its thinnest, and spirits walk the Earth once more.But it appears you are more likely to be visited by a ghost if you are under 35 years old, while spiritual creatures tend to avoid those who live in the East Midlands.New research from the National Folklore Survey has found that, across England, more than a third of people believe in ghosts and supernatural beings, but belief in the paranormal varies according to age and geography.Led by academics from Sheffield Hallam University, the University of Hertfordshire, and Chapman University in the US, the survey is the first of its kind since the last Survey of English Language and Folklore more than 60 years ago.Just over one in three people in England said they believed in ghosts or the spirits of the deceased, with younger people (aged 25-34) most likely to believe in the paranormal, which also includes magical beings, possession, spells, psychics, angels and demons