Starmer says Farage would spook the City and give us Truss 2 – he could be right
The message Zia Yusuf wanted to send was clear.With a backdrop of the City of London behind him, from the 34th floor of the Shard, the Reform UK chair laid out an economic policy designed to show his party meant business.In a briefing over a full English breakfast for some of the nation’s journalists on Friday morning, Yusuf reiterated an announcement the Reform leader, Nigel Farage, had made overnight from another hotel 5,000 miles away in Las Vegas: the party would now accept donations in bitcoin, and if elected to power would make tax and regulatory changes to bolster Britain’s adoption of cryptocurrency.As far as settings go for a press conference, commanding views over St Paul’s Cathedral and the banks and asset managers of the Square Mile, it is straight out of the Westminster playbook, even if the policy idea is pure Donald Trump.However, the trouble with Yusuf’s message to the City was not the questionable credibility of crypto – viewed with unease at the Bank of England as the wild west of finance – but the party’s broader tax and spending policies.
Riding high in the opinion polls, scrutiny of Reform and its plans for the economy is growing – led this week by an attack from Keir Starmer who claimed that Farage’s tax and spending policies were grounded in the same “fantasy economics” used to devastating effect by Liz Truss.The accusation Labour makes is that Yusuf and Farage would spook the City with unfunded tax cuts, sparking a meltdown akin to the ill-fated former prime minister’s mini-budget.And despite the posturing from the heights of the Shard, the verdict from many economists is that Starmer could have a point.Reform has made expansive tax pledges worth at least £60bn – with most of the costs relating to a promise to raise the income tax personal allowance to £20,000 a year, a substantial increase on its current £12,570.Reform has also pledged to increase the threshold for the 40% higher rate of income tax in England from £50,271 to £70,000.
In the argument about whether Reform’s sums add up, Richard Tice, the party’s finance spokesperson, has suggested most politicians have no idea about the Laffer curve.Named after the US economist Arthur Laffer, it is an illustration of a theory that there are optimal tax rates at which government revenue is maximised.The idea is that tax cuts could stimulate economic activity, thus bringing in more revenue.While a tax rate of 100% would clearly stop dead economic activity, the idea that tax cuts pay for themselves has also been widely debunked including by Greg Mankiw, the chair of the Council of Economic Advisers under George W Bush, who has described Laffer advocates as “charlatans and cranks”.Tice acknowledges that there is an “optimum point”, while Yusuf said that in government Reform would prioritise tax cuts “in the right sequential order and make sure that the numbers add up”.
Many economists, too, warn tax rises announced by Labour will undermine economic growth.However, the criticism remains that Reform has mostly promised sweeping tax giveaways without credible corresponding measures to avoid widening the country’s already £100bn-plus budget deficit and £2.7tn debt pile.Add to this Britain’s low economic growth rate, above-target inflation, elevated national debt and rising borrowing costs for governments around the world linked to investor fears over Donald Trump’s trade war, and the argument is that room for additional borrowing is pretty slim.After Farage’s welfare pledges this week, the Institute for Fiscal Studies said Reform’s announced fiscal policies so far would cost the exchequer between £60bn and £80bn a year in foregone income and additional outlays.
The IFS warned this was not yet balanced by corresponding spending cuts or tax rises elsewhere, which it said would be needed for the plan to be implementable.Yusuf said Reform’s plans were a work in progress and were liable to change as the party developed its 2029 manifesto.“You shouldn’t just transfer or copy and paste all of that [policies from the 2024 document] into an assumption about what the manifesto would be for the next general election,” he added.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionIt could be a fair point given the distance to the next election, and how much the economy is likely to change between now and then.Labour also stands accused of reneging on its early 2024 promises.
However, voters may expect better from a putative party of government – especially one trading on public anger at politicians for moving the goalposts,However, Yusuf insisted that savings could credibly be made from “scrapping net zero”, slashing overseas aid to zero, stripping 5% from “quango spending” each year and removing all funding for “asylum hotels”,“The numbers I just gave you there add up to 78 odd billion, right? And that would be £350bn-£400bn over the course of Nigel’s first term,” he said,“Economists at the Institute for Government have questioned whether these savings would ever be deliverable, highlighting that most of the £45bn of net zero savings promised by Reform was money being spent not by the government, but the private sector,When Truss brought forward her mini-budget, she used a Treasury document running to more than 40 pages to justify her tax plans – yet still tested the confidence of City investors.
For Reform, there could be a danger of history repeating,
My cultural awakening: A Timothée Chalamet drama made me leave my partner – and check him into rehab
It took a viewing of the 2018 film Beautiful Boy, about a father and his addict son, for me to see that my relationship had become damagingly codependentTwo summers ago, I met a man on a dating app who would become my boyfriend. The red flags were there from the start, but I ignored them all. When I stayed at his, he didn’t have a towel to offer me, and he never changed his sheets. It became obvious that he didn’t know how to look after himself. Even though, in reality, he could survive without me (similar to how a teenage boy would survive on his own, eating burgers in bed), I felt like, if I wasn’t there to buy groceries, cook and clean, he might die
Mountainhead to Nintendo Switch 2: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
The Ballad of Wallis IslandOut now Comedy drama co-starring and co-written by comedians Tim Key and Tom Basden. Key plays a lottery winner with some big ideas about what to do with his winnings: namely, pay his favourite musical act to reunite. Hey, it’s more interesting than buying a fancy car. Basden and Carey Mulligan play the folk duo McGwyer Mortimer.The Salt PathOut now Drama based on the true story of a 630-mile pilgrimage along the coast in Cornwall, Devon and Dorset
Gerlin Bean obituary
My friend Gerlin Bean, who has died aged 85, was a leading light of the British Black feminist movement. A founding member of OWAAD (Organisation of Women of African and Asian Descent), she was an effective and persuasive organiser, fiercely committed to empowering her community.Also a founder member in 1973 of the Brixton Black Women’s Group, Gerlin remained a key figure in the south London area for the next decade. She helped set up Sabaar Books, one of the first Black bookshops in Brixton, in the late 1970s, and, as a guidance counsellor at Brixton College, was instrumental in securing creche facilities there that allowed countless women to gain access to further education. Prior to that, she had helped establish the WIPAG (West Indian Parents’ Action Group), which provided nursery facilities and early years’ education for working mothers in Lambeth
The Guide #193: Meet Ernesto, the viral America’s Got Talent contestant … who doesn’t exist
Have you heard Ernesto’s story? It’s a real tearjerker. You may well be familiar with it, in fact, having caught it on YouTube, TikTok or Instagram at some point over the last few weeks.A hard-working carpenter, Ernesto devoted every ounce of himself to his wife and child, skipping meals and working overtime to provide for them and send his son through college. But things changed: said wife and child grew distant and walked out on poor old Ernesto, who lost his house and sense of purpose, eventually ending up on the streets.The one thing Ernesto did have left? His beautiful baritone singing voice, of course
Jimmy Kimmel on Elon Musk’s Doge tenure: ‘He came, he chainsawed, we bled, he left’
With most late-night hosts on vacation, Jimmy Kimmel celebrates the end of Elon Musk’s term in Washington and riffs on the new Taco nickname for Donald Trump.Jimmy Kimmel celebrated a big announcement on Thursday evening: Elon Musk, Donald Trump’s head of the so-called “department of government efficiency” (Doge), posted on X that he would officially step down from his post and leave Washington DC. “We’re just happy that your time as a special government employee has come to an end,” Kimmel said.“Elon had a remarkable 130-day stint in government,” he continued, speaking of Musk’s highly controversial and much-loathed stint of firing civil service workers. “He came, he chainsawed, we bled, he left
London tunnels that inspired James Bond creator will become spy museum
During his time in military intelligence, Ian Fleming, the author of the James Bond novels, regularly worked with Winston Churchill’s spy organisation based 30 metres below ground in a labyrinth of tunnels in central London.The Kingsway Exchange tunnels complex, stretching out across 8,000 sq metres beneath High Holborn, near Chancery Lane underground station, hosted the Special Operations Executive (SOE) and is said to have inspired Q Branch in Fleming’s novels.So it seems appropriate that plans to breathe new life into this long-abandoned second world war subterranean network will include a permanent exhibition about the history of military intelligence and espionage.The Military Intelligence Museum is to collaborate with the London Tunnels company, developing the complex to showcase its original artefacts, equipment, weapons and documents in a modern hi-tech experience at the proposed new £220m London tourist attraction, which is planned to open in 2028.Today the tunnels remain closed, but inside they yield many clues to their fascinating past
Salutes, Maga hats and mass layoffs: Elon Musk at Doge – a timeline
Is every memecoin just a scam? Experts on whether Andrew Tate and Trump are fleecing their followers
The chaos Elon Musk and Doge are leaving behind in Washington
Fight to stop Tesla project in South Australia to continue after council approval
Tech shares climb after strong Nvidia results despite warning over rise of Chinese rivals
Elon Musk announces exit from US government role after breaking with Trump on tax bill