Why is Stephen A Smith blaming Renee Good for her own death?
This past weekend there were hundreds of demonstrations across the United States after Renee Good, an American citizen and mother of three, was shot dead by Jonathan Ross, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer, in Minnesota,The anger has permeated throughout the NBA as well,Steve Kerr and Doc Rivers, the head coaches of the Golden State Warriors and Milwaukee Bucks respectively, described Good’s death as “murder”,Kerr also attacked the Trump administration’s attempts to portray Good as a terrorist,“It’s shameful that the government can come out and lie about what happened when there’s video and witnesses who have all come out and disputed what the government is saying,” Kerr said.
Meanwhile, a fan at the Minnesota Timberwolves home game on Thursday yelled “Go Home ICE” during a moment of silence for Good,Many in the crowd responded with cheers,Most rational thinking people, then, seem to be in agreement on the subject,And then there’s Stephen A Smith,The ESPN hot-take machine seemed to align himself with the Trump regime’s assessment of Good’s death.
Here are his exact words.“I saw the video on numerous occasions and seeing what transpired from a lawful perspective as it pertains to a law enforcement official, don’t expect him to be prosecuted.He was completely justified,” Smith said.“From a humanitarian perspective, however, why did you have to do that? If you could move out the way, that means you could have shot the tires.That means you could have got a few feet away after you shot the tires.
And if you were unsuccessful in doing that, you could have got her down the road.“You didn’t have to do that.She wasn’t driving down the road coming at you 90 miles an hour.She was parked in the middle of the street, and rather than get out the car, she wrongfully tried to drive off and wrongfully disregarded a law enforcement official, which is exactly what ICE is, and, as a result, lost her life because of it.”Making the argument that a woman who posed absolutely no immediate threat at the same time deserved to be shot in the face is as disheartening as it is illogical.
Like so many of the Maga crowd, who don’t seem to take as harsh a line on the January 6 rioters who definitely didn’t comply with law enforcement when they stormed the Capitol, Smith’s rhetoric appears to be blaming Good for her own death when he emphasizes she “wrongfully disregarded an order”.Understandably, this brought on a swift condemnation of Smith.Don Lemon called him a “disappointment”, while former ESPN personality Keith Olbermann called for his firing.Veteran broadcaster Soledad O’Brien said that Smith simply does not understand many of the issues he speaks about once he strays from sports.“Stephen A Smith consistently jumps into issues, whether it’s politics or social issues, or in this case a legal issue that looks at how law enforcement is supposed to react, with zero knowledge or expertise and happily weighs in,” she said.
In response, Smith said his words had been twisted and reported out of context,“I’m talking about legality when I’m talking about justification, nothing else,” Smith said,“Everything else about it is wrong,Morally and ethically wrong,” But he still maintained much of his original position.
“In the moment when you are dealing with law enforcement officials, you obey their orders so you can get home safely,” he said one day later in a lengthy segment designed to clean up his original remarks.“Renee Good did not do that.”The problem is that just because something is a law does not mean that it is just.Yes, law enforcement officials often escape punishment because of qualified immunity.But, as Chuck Modi, my co-host on The Collision: Where Sports And Politics Collide, points out: “If you’re going to make that point, the next thing out of your mouth should be that that is a terrible law.
And he didn’t say that.”If Smith doesn’t condemn the law, the message he is sending is that, in his not so humble opinion, the law is OK.It’s important to remember that every law is not a good law.The Jim Crow laws were legal.Slavery was legal for much of America’s history.
Stating that something is legal, without any further exploration, isn’t enough.Smith is beginning to sound like another media figure he has long attacked: Jason Whitlock.Both have echoed Maga talking points, positioning themselves as the Black faces figures on the right can point to and say, “See, he agrees with us, so we can’t be racist.” It’s why Maga platforms welcome them so readily – they are seen as allies, on their side, the “good ones”.Smith and Whitlock are not unaware of any of this.
“Stephen A Smith has done the math,” O’Brien told me.“This is what you have to say if you want to have the audience that he is trying to build.A rabid audience that will stand by you.And that audience has a financial value.I’m past being disappointed.
”My hope is that one day Smith and Whitlock experience the kind of personal and racial reckoning depicted at the end of Spike Lee’s Bamboozled, when Manray, played by Savion Glover, looks in the mirror and realizes he can no longer wear blackface and tap dance for a white audience that has rewarded him with fame and fortune.That Smith and Whitlock come to see that the gold coins and head pats from Maga hands are no longer worth the cost, and finally hang up their tap shoes for good.But I won’t hold my breath.
John Higgins and Kyren Wilson win at Masters as curious run of 6-2 scorelines goes on
Kyren Wilson, the 2024 world champion, defeated Si Jiahui in impressive fashion to reach the Masters quarter-finals with the 6-2 result continuing a curious statistic: every match at Alexandra Palace this week had finished with the same scoreline. That record extended in the evening session as John Higgins saw off Barry Hawkins, 6-2, to reach the last eight.After edging the first frame following a run of snookers, Wilson – yet to win a tournament this season having broken his cue at the start of the campaign – looked set to build a maximum in the next, but just missed the 11th red into the bottom corner pocket as he moved 2-0 ahead.Si got on the board with a well-crafted break of 97 before the world No 2, who lost to Shaun Murphy in last year’s Masters final, dug in to re-establish his lead at 3-1 heading into the mid-session interval.Although Si pulled another one back by taking a close fifth frame, Wilson, looking to move on from a disappointing first-round exit to Elliot Slessor at the UK Championship, then took the sixth 82-28 before closing out an impressive victory with successive century breaks of 101 and 105
Shiffrin extends slalom stranglehold as Moltzan seals US one-two in Flachau
Mikaela Shiffrin completed another dominant night in Flachau, Austria, on Tuesday, winning a World Cup slalom to extend her season-long stranglehold on the discipline while leading an American one-two finish with teammate Paula Moltzan.Shiffrin followed up her fastest opening run with a composed second run to finish 0.41sec clear of Moltzan, claiming her sixth victory in seven slalom races this season. It was also Shiffrin’s record-extending 107th career World Cup win, her 70th in slalom and her sixth slalom victory on the demanding Flachau course.Moltzan, who was chasing her first career World Cup win, delivered a strong second run to secure second place, marking another podium in a season that has seen her establish herself among the world’s most consistent technical skiers
The hidden hierarchy of tennis practice courts: ‘I was back in the park, smelling the weed’
The unwritten rule in professional tournaments? Do not hog the practice court. But as leading players testify – the reality is very differentOn a cool Wednesday afternoon before the US Open last year, Daniil Medvedev and Alexander Zverev were busy fine-tuning their games in an intense practice set at Louis Armstrong Stadium. Danielle Collins and Christian Harrison, semi-finalists in the mixed doubles tournament, were scheduled to take their place at the hour and the American pair duly arrived a couple of minutes before their allotted slot.An amusing scene soon unfolded. Medvedev and Zverev were clearly desperate to continue playing for a little longer, but their court time had run out
Pittsburgh Steelers part ways with head coach Mike Tomlin after 19 seasons
Head coach Mike Tomlin is leaving the Pittsburgh Steelers after 19 seasons, the team confirmed on Tuesday.“Obviously, I am extremely grateful to Mike for all the hard work, dedication and success we have shared over the last 19 years. It is hard for me to put into words the level of respect and appreciation I have for Coach Tomlin,” Steelers president Art Rooney II said in a statement. “He guided the franchise to our sixth Super Bowl championship and made the playoffs 13 times during his tenure, including winning the AFC North eight times in his career.”Rooney added that the decision was ultimately down to Tomlin, saying the head coach had “decided to step down”
Finn Russell ready for bruising clash with Scotland colleagues against Edinburgh
Finn Russell is braced for a potentially bruising reunion with his Scottish international teammates but is intent on winning the “bragging rights” when Bath host Edinburgh on Friday in their Champions Cup pool decider. Russell has already messaged Duhan van der Merwe to warn him to expect a tough night and says the English champions are seeking to sharpen their attacking game in pursuit of a crucial home draw for the knockout phase.With the victorious side at the Rec set to top pool 2, the Scottish playmaker is anticipating a physical examination from an Edinburgh team he knows extremely well. “I’d imagine there’ll be a couple of late shots and being held on the ground which is always the case when you’re against your old side,” said Russell, who spent the first half of his professional career at Glasgow.“I’m not sure what the weather will be like but if it’s like it is now there’ll be a lot of balls going up in the air
Sport England suspends X social media account and takes aim at Elon Musk
Sport England has revealed that it has suspended its account on X, because the social media platform “increasingly promotes and monetises an environment that is hostile to women and girls”.In a blog post explaining the decision the Sport England chair, Chris Boardman, criticised X’s AI platform tool, Grok, saying it had “contributed to the amplification of and worse, normalisation of, misogynistic content”.“That runs directly counter to what we stand for,” said Boardman, who sits at the heart of a funding agency that invests £250m a year in grassroots sport and community projects. Regarding the decision to withdraw from X, he also pointed to the fact members of the England women’s football squad were attacked on the platform last summer. “Sport should always be a place where everyone feels safe and welcome,” he said
LGB+ people in England and Wales ‘much’ more likely to die by suicide than straight people
Football fan took his own life after using illegal ‘predatory’ betting sites, inquest told
HMRC admits 71% wrongly targeted in child benefit fraud crackdown
Women are feral for Heated Rivalry. What does that say about men?
‘He tried so hard to get help’: the tragic results of NHS right-to-choose for ADHD patients
Death on the inside: as a prison officer, I saw how the system perpetuates violence