Starmer accuses Robbins of obstructing truth about Mandelson vetting

about 10 hours ago

Keir Starmer has accused Olly Robbins of deliberately and repeatedly obstructing the truth about the Mandelson vetting scandal before a high-jeopardy appearance of the sacked top official before MPs on Tuesday.Six days after the prime minister said he had learned that his pick for Washington ambassador had failed security vetting, Starmer admitted his decision to appoint him had been a fundamental mistake.But in a sombre address to parliament, he insisted the Foreign Office was to blame for a “staggering” and “incredible” decision not to brief him, or anybody else in Downing Street, about the vetting advice.Starmer told MPs that the vetting information had now been handed to the trusted Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC), which is expected to assess it before returning it to the government within days for public release.The Guardian understands this includes a short summary document including details of Mandelson’s personal life, and financial and business dealings – which the prime minister is also believed to have now seen – as well as the recommendation that Mandelson had failed vetting.

The ISC is expected to push for further information, which could include an audit trail of who within government knew what, and when, about the vetting decision, as well as minutes of any meetings held by Robbins within the Foreign Office on the affair,Lord Beamish, the chair of the ISC, asked Lords ministers to also release documents relating to the decision-making process within the Foreign Office, which his committee had been told by the Cabinet Office did not exist,“Can I stress, if it does exist, can you expedite that information to ensure it reaches us as soon as possible?” he said,Labour MPs have been furious at the resurfacing of the scandal at a time when the prime minister had rebuilt some goodwill over his handling of the Iran crisis,Many said they believed that he had been in the dark but it was an unwelcome reminder of the fundamental misjudgment in Mandelson’s appointment.

During a dramatic day in Westminster, which included two hours of questions from MPs after Starmer’s statement to a packed Commons chamber, it emerged that: He has ordered an investigation into any security concerns over Mandelson’s tenure in the top diplomatic role amid concerns over potential leaks,Robbins, who was the most senior official at the Foreign Office before he was sacked last week, did not tell his boss, the then cabinet secretary, Chris Wormald, about the vetting failure even when Wormald was conducting a review into the process last September; nor did Robbins tell any other No 10 official or aide,Simon Case, Wormald’s predecessor, had advised Keir Starmer to complete Mandelson’s security vetting before his appointment as ambassador – but was ignored,Robbins overturned the United Kingdom Security Vetting (UKVS) decision to fail Mandelson just 24 hours later, giving little time for any potential mitigations to be put in place,The Foreign Office has now been stripped of this power.

Starmer claimed that he had not misled the Commons over Mandelson, despite admitting his previous version of events was wrong.In his statement to MPs, Starmer said: “A deliberate decision was taken to withhold that material from me.This was not a lack of asking.This wasn’t an oversight.It was a decision taken not to share that information on repeated occasions.

”The prime minister said it was “frankly staggering” he was not told.While he accepted “sensitive, personal information” provided during the vetting process should be protected, he rejected the idea that ministers could not be told the overall recommendation.His position puts him on a collision course with Robbins, who is due to appear on Tuesday at a high-stakes hearing of the Commons foreign affairs committee (FAC), with Downing Street braced for any new revelations from the former permanent secretary that could derail its plan to get the government back on track.Starmer had appointed Mandelson before Robbins even took up his role as Foreign Office chief, and also before security vetting had taken place, with senior officials telling the Guardian that it was clear to them that No 10 wanted Mandelson in Washington whatever the risk.The Labour MP Emily Thornberry, who is chair of the foreign affairs select committee, told MPs that security appeared to have been a “secondary consideration” for Downing Street during the appointments process.

“Doesn’t this look like, for certain members of the prime minister’s team, getting Peter Mandelson the job was a priority that overrode everything else?” she asked.Starmer replied that had he known, he would have blocked Mandelson going to Washington.Robbins is expected to argue on Tuesday morning that he was following established practice when he gave his approval to Mandelson’s security clearance, and that he could have broken the law by telling No 10 about it.Sources close to him say he is not planning to drop any bombshells in front of the committee but will answer the questions asked of him honestly.He will push back on the fact that Mandelson “failed” his security vetting, arguing the final decision on clearance was his to make.

Senior Whitehall officials have criticised Starmer’s decision to sack Robbins for – in their view – following the rules, and suggested the move had sent a chill through the civil service.One senior Labour source said they thought the prime minister would survive the next few days, despite the Mandelson scandal amounting to one of the most significant crises of his leadership, but that the long-term consequence would be toxic relations with Whitehall.“The Foreign Office will be feeling very bruised by this and typically what happens when ministers lose the confidence of their officials, those officials tend to spend the rest of the time leaking like billy-o,” they added.Labour MPs told the Guardian they did not believe that Starmer’s performance had “moved the dial” in favour of a leadership challenge that many are convinced will come before the next election, but not imminently.“I think we are in broadly the same place – that there are significant questions over the prime minister’s judgment here that it will be hard to overlook, but also that the situation in the world right now means that he’s safe for now,” one former minister said.

“Every day something like this happens, it tips the balance of the PLP away from Keir,” another said.“But it doesn’t make any of his rivals any more plausible.”Allies of the prime minister said they believed Starmer would weather this particular scandal.“I think we’ve learned that candour is our friend at these moments, and you can see his obvious frustration that he can’t even be as candid as he wants to be,” one adviser said.But several MPs said they were sceptical of any real remorse from the prime minister after receiving a series of planted suggested questions from whips – including several invoking quotes from Jeffrey Epstein’s victims.

“Absolutely grotesque to pretend that they gave a fuck about the victims at any point,” one MP said,The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know,If you have something to share on this subject you can contact the Guardian's UK Politics team confidentially using the following methods:The Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories,Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs,This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.

If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu,Scroll down and click on Secure Messaging,When asked who you wish to contact please select the Politics (UK) team,For end-to-end encrypted email correspondence you can create a free Proton Mail account and email us at guardian,politics.

desk@protonmail,com,You can message the UK Politics team using Signal or WhatsApp on +44 7824 537227,Finally, our guide at theguardian,com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.

technologySee all

How a fiery attack on Sam Altman’s home unfolded

In the early hours of 10 April, a man approached the gate of OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s house in San Francisco and hurled a molotov cocktail at the building before fleeing. The suspect, 20-year-old Daniel Moreno-Gama, was arrested less than two hours later while allegedly attempting to break into the headquarters of OpenAI with a jug of kerosene, a lighter and an anti-AI manifesto.Federal and California state authorities have charged Moreno-Gama with a range of crimes including attempted arson and attempted murder. His parents issued a statement this week saying that their son had recently suffered a mental health crisis. Moreno-Gama, who has not yet entered a plea, faces up to life in prison if convicted

3 days ago

Kenyan firm sacks more than 1,000 workers after losing Meta contract

More than 1,000 low-paid workers in Kenya have been abruptly sacked by an outsourcing company contracted by Meta, in what activists said was a shocking move exposing the precariousness of tech jobs in the global south.Sama, a company based in Nairobi to which Meta outsourced content moderation and AI training work, announced on Thursday that the workers were being laid off after Meta terminated a contract.Last month reports said some Kenyan workers involved in data annotation were asked to view content filmed using Meta’s AI smart glasses showing wearers using the toilet or having sex.The sacked workers, many involved in AI training, have been given six days’ notice, according to the Oversight Lab, an organisation that advocates for fair regulation and deployment of technology across Africa. It said it was advising the workers on legal options

4 days ago

UK’s OnlyFans tops $3bn valuation amid talks to sell stake to US investor

OnlyFans, the UK adult video platform, is in talks to sell a minority stake to a US investor that will value the business at more than $3bn (£2.2bn).The London-based company is in advanced talks to sell a stake of less than 20% to the San Francisco-based investment firm Architect Capital, according to the Financial Times. Sources familiar with the process confirmed the talks to the Guardian.OnlyFans has decided that offloading a minority stake is the best guarantee of stability for a business dealing with the death of its owner, Leonid Radvinsky

4 days ago

Finance leaders warn over Mythos as UK banks prepare to use powerful Anthropic AI tool

British banks will be given access in the next week to a powerful AI tool that was deemed too dangerous to be released to the public, as a series of senior finance figures warned over its impact.Anthropic, which has so far limited the release of the new model to a small clutch of primarily US businesses, including Amazon, Apple and Microsoft, said it would expand that to UK financial institutions.“That is in the very near term, in the next week,” Pip White, Anthropic’s head of UK, Ireland and northern Europe operations, said in a Bloomberg TV interview. “As you would expect, the engagement I have had from UK CEOs in the last week has been significant.”Anthropic, which is the company behind the Claude family of AI tools, has said that its latest model, Mythos, poses an unprecedented risk because of its ability to expose flaws in IT systems

4 days ago

US tech firms successfully lobbied EU to keep datacentre emissions secret

Microsoft and other US tech companies successfully lobbied the EU to hide the environmental toll of their datacentres, an investigation has found, with demands to block a database of green metrics from public view written almost word for word into EU rules.The secrecy provision, which the European Commission added to its proposal almost verbatim after industry lobbying in 2024, hinders scrutiny of the pollution that individual datacentres emit. It leaves researchers with just national-level summaries of their energy footprints.The rise of AI chatbots has spurred a boom in the construction of chip-filled warehouses with a hunger for power that is being met, in part, by burning fossil gas. Legal scholars warn the blanket confidentiality clause may fall foul of EU transparency rules and the Aarhus convention on public access to environmental information

4 days ago

Liz Kendall urges UK public to embrace AI as government makes first £500m fund investment

The UK technology secretary has urged the country to “make AI work for Britain”, brushing off fears about its impact on jobs and cybersecurity as the government announced its first investment under a £500m sovereign AI fund. Liz Kendall said the UK had to “seize” the opportunity offered by AI despite concerns underlined this month when US startup Anthropic revealed it had developed an AI model that posed a potentially significant cyber threat. Asked how the government makes the case for embracing a technology that could disrupt jobs and now cybersecurity, Kendall said: “We have to seize this to make it work, for Britain, for our jobs, for solving the biggest challenges we face as a world.”Speaking on Thursday as the government unveiled its first investment in a UK company as part of a £500m sovereign AI fund, Kendall acknowledged “people are worried about the risks and what it means for their jobs”, but AI entrepreneurs also believed they can “make it work … they can create jobs”.In January Kendall admitted “some jobs will go” as AI automates certain tasks and roles, but it would also create new employment opportunities

4 days ago

businessSee all