The Your Party committee election was chaos. Why break the habit of a lifetime? | John Crace
Start as you mean to go on.Your Party has had a fair few ups and downs in its short lifespan.Some might call it chaos.Its two most prominent members, Jeremy Corbyn and Zarah Sultana, seem barely able to stand being in the same room as each other.Allegations of financial misconduct over membership fees and donations.
A party conference which Sultana refused to attend on the first day.Accusations of corruption and sexism.A boys’ club.The briefings and counter-briefings from the two factions never let up.Its hatreds seemed to be what gave Corbyn and Sultana a sense of purpose.
A reminder that the left often prefers to pick a fight with other groups on the left rather than the rightwing parties,A misplaced Marxist dialectic or some other thought crime of false consciousness seemingly far worse than threatening to deport hundreds of thousands of foreigners,But one way or another, Your Party has survived to a point where it has held an election for its 24 leadership posts on its central executive committee,And the results were supposed to be livestreamed on its YouTube channel at 11am on Thursday,Except they weren’t.
Because why break the habit of a lifetime? Once you’re addicted to chaos, it rather comes to define everything you do,It’s now part of Your Party’s corporate culture,Come 11,10 the YouTube channel was still silent,Not a word of apology to those who had tuned in.
No hint of when the announcement might be forthcoming.The 1,400 or so Your Party members who had been waiting online started to look for other ways to amuse themselves by posting on the comments sidebar.“This is like a Molière farce,” said one.“They are still trying to find ways to disqualify people they don’t like,” said another.No one seemed to have much faith in the voting system.
Ten minutes later someone chipped in with the news that the announcement might be around 11.30.This prompted one person to announce she was going to have a bath.There was only so much excitement she could take.The comments got progressively more dark.
We weren’t a long way from despair.“They’ve forgotten the password for the YouTube channel,” said one.“Zarah has smashed the streaming equipment in her ongoing battle against ‘The Man’,” said another.This sounded as likely an explanation as any other.The howls got louder and louder.
“We’ll get the results of the Gorton and Denton byelection before we get our own,” “The voting system is so complex they’ve no idea who has actually won,” “There’s been a punch-up in the studio,”And through all this came a single lament: “Is it too much to ask for competence as well as democracy?” I’m afraid that ship has long since sailed,Still, no one could complain they hadn’t been given ample warning.
Eventually, shortly after 11,40, the screen came alive to reveal two people apparently on a Zoom call,Andrew Jordan, the returning officer, went first, having chosen to broadcast the news from what appeared to be a cupboard,Or the smallest bedroom imaginable,He said it was a tremendously exciting moment in the history of a mass socialist party, before handing over to Steph Pike, one of the five members of the oversight committee, who had been observing the election process.
Steph started with a disclaimer.The voting system had been nothing to do with her.She didn’t seem particularly thrilled with life.She read out the names of the other members of the oversight committee.Bar one who wanted to remain anonymous.
That seemed curiously opaque for a mass participation party,“I opened all 22 postal ballots myself,” she said, before getting bored and switching off her camera,It almost felt as if we were watching a sketch show,A parody of how Your Party might make this announcement,Only it was happening in real time.
We cut back to Andrew.There had been 23,347 votes out of a possible 40,000 verified members.This cut to Your Party’s tragedy.When the idea for a party had been first mooted there had been 800,000 expressions of interest.But people got bored of the inertia and the squabbling and started to look elsewhere, as the Greens under Zack Polanski became a viable force.
Four individuals had been excluded for voting twice and some candidates had been removed from the ballot for failing to submit their expenses properly.Realising he was losing his audience, Andrew cut to the chase and read out the results.Corbyn and Sultana, along with Laura Smith and Grace Lewis, had been elected as public office holders.A further 20 others had been elected from the regions to serve on the committee.At which point, Andrew’s job was done.
No explanations,No speeches from the winners,Just a return to a blank screen,It took a while to work out just what this all meant,Andrew had omitted to tell us to which faction – Corbyn’s The Many and Sultana’s Grassroots – each candidate was affiliated, so there was no hint online of what direction the party had chosen.
Which you might have thought was the key piece of information,It was left to each of us to figure it out,Corbyn had won with 14,Sultana had seven,There were independents.
So while at a national level Jezza and Zarah would be jointly in charge, Corbyn would be the leader in the Commons.This was a work of some genius.Because Corbyn officially identifies himself as an Independent MP, Sultana is the only MP who claims to represent Your Party.So Jeremy is now the leader of a party to which he doesn’t belong.Politics as a piece of inspired performance art.
It makes you proud to be British.Within 30 minutes Corbyn had released a statement.He was thrilled to have won.He didn’t sound as if he was extending a hand out towards his opponents.It was going to be his way.
“I will take the fight to Starmer and Farage,” he said.Glad to see he had his priorities right.First we take Keir, then we take Nige.Never change.Sultana was quiet for a couple of hours.
Considering her options,She’s not one to readily accept defeat,The establishment conspiracy extends even into the inner circle of the Your Party elite,But she wasn’t quite ready to throw her toys out of the pram just yet,She would work with Corbyn, she said, just as long as he steered the party in a direction of which she approved.
Mark my words,It’s only a matter of time before it all kicks off again,
The Indiana Bears? Why an interstate move for a cherished NFL team may work out
You think you’re locked out of the housing market? The Chicago Bears have been renting since Warren G Harding was president.They started out in the NFL as tenants at Wrigley Field, sharing the baseball cathedral with the Cubs for 50 seasons before the league insisted all teams play in a stadium with a capacity of at least 50,000. So in 1971, the Bears decamped to Soldier Field, where they’ve been ever since – save for a season-long “road trip” in 2002 to the University of Illinois’ Memorial Stadium during renovations. Soldier Field is prime football real estate: neoclassical, on the downtown lakefront, with sweeping views of one of America’s most sumptuous skylines. But the lease terms are crazy, the city park district (which owns the stadium) is a borderline slumlord, and the Bears – star-crossed to play in the league’s oldest and smallest stadium while representing its third-largest market – have outgrown the place
Norway’s all-conquering Winter Olympians have a message for us all – and it’s not what you think | Cath Bishop
Norway’s Olympians stormed the mountains of Milano Cortina and left the rest of the world wondering how a nation of 5.6 million people regularly tops the Winter Olympics medal table, this year winning 18 gold medals and 41 medals overall.They’re not bad at the Summer Olympics either, despite not playing to their obvious national geographical strengths, winning four gold medals and a total of eight medals in Paris 2024. But all this talk of medals detracts from looking more closely at what the Norwegians do to create one of the best and most sustainable sports systems in the world.Reports have highlighted that there is no competitive sport in Norway for youngsters before the age of 12
US hockey star Hilary Knight responds to Trump’s ‘distasteful joke’ about women’s team
Hilary Knight, the captain of the US women’s ice hockey team, has responded to comments made by Donald Trump after the Americans won gold at the Winter Olympics, calling the president’s quip a “distasteful joke”.After the US men’s ice hockey team won gold on Sunday, Trump called into the locker-room celebration and invited the players to be his guests at Tuesday’s State of the Union address.“I must tell you, we’re going to have to bring the women’s team,” he said. “You do know that. I do believe I probably would be impeached [if the women’s team wasn’t invited]
Saracens’ salary cap penalty under scrutiny over conflict of interest claims
Saracens will consider their position over an alleged undeclared conflict of interest at the centre of the disciplinary process into the 2019 salary cap scandal. The club were fined an unprecedented £5.36m for salary cap breaches over the previous three seasons and were relegated to the Championship, but the punishment has come under fresh scrutiny with these new allegations.Saracens point to an allegation made about the accounting firm Saffery Champness and claims that the level of fine handed down was “largely based upon advice provided to PRL”.According to the Daily Telegraph, Saffery Champness was auditor for Sale Sharks at the same time that it gave “impartial expert advice” about Saracens
English cricket’s hunger for Indian money has led it into a moral and legal minefield | Barney Ronay
The thing about inviting a tiger round for tea is, for all the excitement, the fur, the teeth, the muscles, they do tend to walk off with your dinner and drink all the water in the taps. The thing about saying yes to the person with the biggest stick is, in the end, you don’t get to say yes, or no, or anything at all. And that person still has a very big stick.The thing about closing your eyes and just taking the money is: money passes only in exchange for something of value, and full payment will be taken. Welcome to English cricket in full blind, groping crisis mode, and the first small tremor of what lies in store whatever happens in the next few weeks
Steve Borthwick turns to 2003 World Cup heroes for Six Nations inspiration
Steve Borthwick has turned to England’s 2003 World Cup winners to arrest his side’s drastic decline after enduring another setback with the scrum‑half Alex Mitchell ruled out for the rest of the Six Nations.Borthwick’s squad were due on Wednesday night to have dinner with members of the 2003 team, including the captain Martin Johnson, the Test centurion Jason Leonard and Lewis Moody, who revealed in October that he had been diagnosed with motor neurone disease.Borthwick urged his players to use the opportunity to ask how they dealt with setbacks, after England’s Six Nations hopes went up in smoke for another year with the dismal 42-21 defeat against Ireland last Saturday, seven days after they were outclassed by Scotland.Borthwick is under renewed pressure as a result and will lead England into their final two matches against Italy in Rome and France in Paris without Mitchell, who sustained a hamstring injury against Ireland. Jack van Poortvliet is standing by for the No 9 jersey while Ollie Lawrence has had a knee injection and is a doubt for the Italy match
World Economic Forum CEO quits after Epstein links examined; Ineos Quattro earnings fall – as it happened
Tell us: how are your finances looking ahead of the spring forecast?
Rolls-Royce boss pushes for UK taxpayer support for new jet engine
WPP to sell assets and cut jobs in radical shake-up to counter AI threat
Ocado to cut 1,000 jobs in £150m cost-saving drive
Qantas unveils major changes to frequent flyer program and a bumper $1.46bn profit