How to stop the rise of Reform UK? Expose its contradictions | Letters
The combination of charts showing the spread of Reform UK supporters (Who supports Reform and why?, 13 November), and Aditya Chakrabortty’s typically shrewd and combative commentary (The real Reform voters have been revealed – it’s a slapdash coalition Farage will struggle to hold together, 13 November) represented a rare bright spot in an increasingly bleak political landscape.They provide a clear roadmap towards challenging what too many doomsayers have been presenting as the inevitability of a Reform UK victory at the next general election.The task now for those who are alarmed by the rise of Nigel Farage’s cult is to use these findings to constantly highlight the inherent contradictions within his policies, while remembering the wisdom of one 19th-century political economist who said that philosophers had only interpreted the world, but the task is to change it.Keir Starmer, take note.Les Bright Exeter, Devon Aditya Chakrabortty suggests that, come a general election, Nigel Farage will have to “cobble together an actual platform, he’ll have to pick a side” from his “curious dish of microwaved Thatcherism, seasoned with a big dash of old Labour”.
Reform UK’s policies were already clear in the run-up to the last general election, in its manifesto: “patriotic” education policies; permanent school exclusions; tax relief for private schools; all job seekers to find employment within four months, otherwise benefits will be withdrawn; high-intensity training camps for young offenders; vouchers for private healthcare treatment; making it easier to hire and fire “so that businesses can grow”; and abolishing the renters’ (reform) bill.This is straightforwardly an attack on the working class.What keeps Reform in the game is its ability to outflank the other parties in the race to the bottom on immigration.In a stagnating capitalism, redistribution from the top to the bottom is not on offer – instead we are encouraged to fight among ourselves for the scraps.Reform’s selling point to the working class is that it will put “natives” first.
Its selling point to capital is that it will discipline the working class.I think we’ve seen this somewhere before.Nick MossLondon Focusing on Nigel Farage and Giorgia Meloni’s personality risks missing the deeper forces that have shaped the latter’s trajectory in office (Can Nigel Farage emulate success enjoyed by Italy’s far-right Giorgia Meloni?, 9 November).Meloni has moderated not simply because of her past parliamentary experience or personal inclination towards pragmatism and willingness to compromise, but because Italy’s political and institutional environment requires moderation.Coalition government forces Fratelli d’Italia to work with more centrist partners, most notably Forza Italia.
EU membership imposes further discipline.Access to Brussels’ post-pandemic recovery funds and the need to maintain Italy’s credibility in Europe have indeed pushed Meloni to compromise on key issues, regardless of her personal instincts.None of these constraints apply to Reform UK.Britain’s first-past-the-post system discourages coalition building, and a post-Brexit government faces no external checks equivalent to those from the EU.If Farage were to gain power, the forces that tempered Meloni simply wouldn’t exist.
That’s why personality-based comparisons risk obscuring crucial differences that matter.Dr Margherita de Candia Lecturer in comparative politics, King’s College LondonMarianna Griffini Assistant professor in international relations and anthropology, Northeastern University London Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
GWR train fitted with F1 tech for two-month superfast wifi trial
Train wifi in the UK, long a source of frustration for passengers, is about to get radically faster – for a lucky few at least.A two-month trial has begun on one Great Western Railway (GWR) train, fitted with technology from Formula One that switches between the signals from 5G masts to low Earth-orbit satellites to provide almost seamless, superfast wifi.For now, only one of GWR’s 57 intercity express trains will have a connection good enough to deliver a Netflix series to the seat. However, a successful trial and the promise of lower costs could spell a wider rollout to the rest of the mainline railway by 2030.On a test run from London Paddington to Newbury and back, the Guardian found the wifi fast and reliable enough to video call editors at the office, catch up on old Match of the Days on iPlayer and listen to songs on YouTube at the same time, with only occasional blips and pixelation
TotalEnergies buys €5.1bn stake in Czech tycoon’s power plants business
The Czech billionaire Daniel Křetínský is to become one of the largest shareholders in TotalEnergies after selling a stake in his electricity generation business, which includes several UK power plants, to the French oil company.Křetínský, whose companies own stakes in Royal Mail and West Ham United football club, agreed to sell a 50% stake in his stable of European power plants to TotalEnergies for about €5.1bn (£4.5bn) in exchange for about 4.1% of Total’s share capital
AI firms must be clear on risks or repeat tobacco’s mistakes, says Anthropic chief
Artificial intelligence companies must be transparent about the risks posed by their products or be in danger of repeating the mistakes of tobacco and opioid firms, according to the chief executive of the AI startup Anthropic.Dario Amodei, who runs the US company behind the Claude chatbot, said he believed AI would become smarter than “most or all humans in most or all ways” and urged his peers to “call it as you see it”.Speaking to CBS News, Amodei said a lack of transparency about the impact of powerful AI would replay the errors of cigarette and opioid firms that failed to raise a red flag over the potential health damage of their own products.“You could end up in the world of, like, the cigarette companies, or the opioid companies, where they knew there were dangers, and they didn’t talk about them, and certainly did not prevent them,” he said.Amodei warned this year that AI could eliminate half of all entry-level white-collar jobs – office roles such as accountancy, law and banking – within five years
How Google’s DeepMind tool is ‘more quickly’ forecasting hurricane behavior
When then Tropical Storm Melissa was churning south of Haiti, Philippe Papin, a National Hurricane Center (NHC) meteorologist, had confidence it was about to grow into a monster hurricane.As the lead forecaster on duty, he predicted that in just 24 hours the storm would become a category 4 hurricane and begin a turn towards the coast of Jamaica. No NHC forecaster had ever issued such a bold forecast for rapid strengthening.But Papin had an ace up his sleeve: artificial intelligence in the form of Google’s new DeepMind hurricane model – released for the first time in June. And, as predicted, Melissa did become a storm of astonishing strength that tore through Jamaica
England sweating over fitness of Ollie Lawrence for Argentina match
England are sweating on the fitness of Ollie Lawrence before their final autumn clash with Argentina this weekend.Lawrence starred on Saturday in the statement victory against the All Blacks but limped off in the closing stages and could be forced to sit out the match against the Pumas on Sunday. The 26-year-old centre will be assessed when England reconvene on Tuesday after an extra day off but if Lawrence is ruled out it would be a blow for Steve Borthwick.The England head coach may also be without Freddie Steward, who was withdrawn midway through the first half against New Zealand with a head injury, as he prepares for England’s pursuit of an 11th successive victory and a clean sweep of their autumn fixtures.Lawrence was in fine form against the All Blacks, scoring England’s opening try before teeing up centre partner Fraser Dingwall in the second half
Sean Bowen, jump jockey great who can’t buy a winner at the Cheltenham festival
Mike Trout is 34 years old, weighs 235lb and plays baseball for the Los Angeles Angels. Sean Bowen is 28, tips the scales at around 140lb and is the reigning champion jockey over jumps. At first sight, they do not have a great deal in common besides both being professional athletes (and even then, Trout earns more in a fortnight than Bowen can ever hope to bank in a year).But when you break down what they do and, above all, when they do it, there are some distinct similarities.Trout is widely recognised as the greatest baseball player of his generation, consistently putting up numbers during the six-month, 162-game regular that put him among the all-time greats
Scott Boland seeks to inspire next generation as Indigenous history beckons in Ashes opener
Mind guru Gilbert Enoka: ‘England are about to go to war, and I want to be in the trench with them’
Anthony Joshua will ‘break internet over Jake Paul’s face’ as fight is confirmed
Australia target Joe Root as the England batter to ‘take down’ on eve of Ashes
England to launch first Nations Championship campaign with visit to South Africa
Déjà boo: Sam Darnold didn’t think he’d see ghosts on the field again. Then he faced the Rams