Lammy’s rebuke of Israel marks turning point after weeks of growing frustration
The anger inside the Foreign Office over Israel’s blockade of aid into Gaza had been slowly building until – like an exploding pressure cooker – the foreign secretary, David Lammy, let loose his most damning criticism of Israeli since the Gaza conflict started in 2023.Lammy’s innate ability to put the rhetorical burners on issues has had to be restrained as the UK’s leading diplomat, but once he entered the Commons chamber to condemn Israel’s blockade of aid, this was Lammy unleashed.One UK diplomat formerly based in the Middle East said: “The language was carefully chosen and it was quite simply unprecedented.It marks a turning point.” Even if Lammy’s rhetoric and his actions did not match, sometimes language matters in diplomacy.
The use of words such as “extremist” and “abhorrent” to describe the actions of a longstanding ally ricocheted across the global media landscape.The explanation for Lammy’s suspension of free trade talks at one level is self-evident.The accumulation of pictures of emaciated children, the threats to “purify” Gaza by some Israeli ministers and the apparent inability of the Americans to persuade Israel to accept that a permanent ceasefire was a legitimate price for the release of the Israeli hostages became too much.But frustration had been mounting ever since Gideon Sa’ar, the Israeli foreign minister, met Lammy on what was intended to be an unpublicised visit on 16 April.The main subject of the meeting, described as private by the Foreign Office, focused entirely on matters of state and specifically the Israeli blockade on humanitarian aid in Gaza that had started on 2 March, more than six weeks before.
Lammy had condemned the blockade from the start and at one point on 17 March in the Commons described it as a breach of humanitarian law, a judgment he had to retract since government policy is that only international courts and not the UK government make judgments on breaches of international law,Regardless of the precise legal status of Israel’s blockade, Lammy described it as “unacceptable, hugely alarming and very worrying”,But the meeting with Sa’ar did not go well,Asked by the Telegraph to characterise its tone, Sa’ar said: “You always gain something by making your arguments and intentions clearer,” He insisted the denial of aid was not a form of collective punishment or unlawful.
At the same time, UK concern had been mounting about shadowy plans for the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation that was due to start aid operations at the end of May.The GHF was to be overseen by Jake Wood, a US military veteran who ran Team Rubicon, an organisation that distributed humanitarian aid during natural disasters.In essence, the organisation would replace the now-banned UN human rights agency, Unrwa, as well as Ocha (Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs), the UN’s main humanitarian body.Since November, Ocha has been led by Tom Fletcher, a former chief foreign policy adviser to Tony Blair, Gordon Brown and David Cameron.All three of them came to rely upon him, but he later retreated to academia to be principal of Hertford College, Oxford.
Lammy lured him back into public service, persuading him to apply for the job of chief of Ocha – for historical reasons a job that has largely been a British sinecure,Fletcher’s first few months in the job from November had been attempting to limit the impact of US aid cuts, but he soon realised that Israel’s blockade of aid and plans for the GHF were part of an attempt to remove all trace of the UN from Gaza,He formally sounded the alarm in a speech on 13 May to the UN security council, most remembered for his call for decisive action to “prevent a genocide” and a warning to members to ask themselves how they would account to future generations when asked if they truly did all they could to stop Israel’s “unashamed inhumanity”,In a chamber numbed by empty rhetoric about neglected horror, he managed to elevate the question to a matter of personal responsibility,But he also spelled out the implications of the GHF for Palestinians and the humanitarian community, including the plan to kettle Palestinians in one part of Gaza, seen as a prelude to either voluntary or involuntary deportation.
He said the GHF plan “restricts aid to only one part of Gaza while leaving other dire needs unmet.It makes aid conditional on political and military aims.It makes starvation a bargaining chip.It is a cynical sideshow.A deliberate distraction.
A fig leaf for further violence and displacement,”Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionFletcher followed up his words by rallying diplomats, including the Americans, to acknowledge a catastrophe had to be prevented,The US issued an amber light for the UK to go harder on Israel to end the blockade,At the same time, the UK had already been alerted by the Dutch foreign minister, Caspar Veldkamp, on a visit to London on 6 May that the EU would be reviewing its trade relationship with Israel, reflecting a change in mood inside his own government, and potentially Europe,At the start of the week, the diplomacy bore fruit.
A British-engineered ring-round led on Monday to a joint statement by 27 donors, mainly western countries, endorsing Fletcher’s concern about the GHF.“Humanitarian aid should never be politicised, and Palestinian territory must not be reduced nor subjected to any demographic change,” the 27 said.Despite the limited restart of aid announced by Benjamin Netanyahu, the donors still warned: “Palestinians faced starvation”.Hours later, the Canadian prime minister, Mark Carney, the UK prime minister, Keir Starmer, and the French president, Emmanuel Macron, also intervened again using unprecedented language.“If Israel does not cease the renewed military offensive and lift its restrictions on humanitarian aid, we will take further concrete actions in response,” a joint statement read.
Significantly, the statement made reference to a UN-sponsored conference in June, chaired by France and Saudi Arabia, on a two-state solution,The UK, France and Canada are all members of the G7 group of western countries, due to meet at a G7 leaders’ summit on 15-17 June, the day before Saudi Arabia and France chair a three-day UN summit in New York to advance a two-state solution,Macron has already said that the New York summit may be the moment for a consortium of countries to recognise Palestine as a state,It is possible there could be an interplay between the two summits,The French have launched such recognition initiatives in the past, only to pull back, and inside the Foreign Office there is a belief that recognition, a symbolic card that can be played only once, has to be played at a point of maximum impact.
But the French foreign minister, Jean-Noël Barrot, said this week: “We are determined to recognise the state of Palestine”.Self-evidently, the more Israel occupies Gaza and extends settlements on the West Bank, the less likely there will be any Palestinian state left to recognise.
French Open draws: Jack Draper and Emma Raducanu handed tough paths
Jack Draper will have to navigate a challenging draw at the French Open to consolidate his breakthrough clay court season with a deep run at Roland Garros, where he still seeks his first career win.Draper, the fifth seed, will begin against the Italian left-hander and fellow 23-year-old Mattia Bellucci, who is ranked No 68. Draper has been drawn in Jannik Sinner’s quarter and a career best run in Paris could culminate in a quarter-final match with the top seed.Draper has made dramatic strides on clay in the last month, a surface on which he previously had minimal experience at the highest level. At the Madrid Open, a Masters 1000 tournament, he made his first tour-level final on the surface, losing to Casper Ruud, before an impressive quarter-final run in slower conditions at the Italian Open in Rome
Is the Mets’ $765m slugger Juan Soto sad, bad or just playing in New York?
The 26-year-old has been good rather than great in his first season with his new team, and he’s playing in an unforgiving environmentIf you only tuned into the biggest headlines about him, you might be convinced that Juan Soto’s first quarter of a season with the New York Mets has been a complete flop.Last December, the Mets guaranteed Soto $765m on a 15-year contract, the most lucrative deal in professional sports history. In the early going of his time with the Mets, Soto has been the subject of a handful of viral stories, ranging from the mundane to the bizarre. None of them have been positive. Last Sunday, Soto did not hustle out of the box on a ground ball up the middle, and his casual trot to first base cost him a chance at an infield hit, in the eighth inning of a tied game against the crosstown rival Yankees
Northampton’s Champions Cup final date with Bordeaux should be all-out attack | Ugo Monye
How do Northampton Saints go again? After pulling off a stunning upset to avenge last season’s semi-final defeat by Leinster and take their place in Saturday’s final, the question is how do Phil Dowson’s side overcome one of the French giants, Bordeaux, to clinch the Champions Cup?Had the final been a week later I’d have feared for Northampton but they are helped by the ability to distract themselves with Premiership action, and I think the manner of victory over Leinster plays into their hands. Northampton need to focus on being unashamedly themselves. In Dublin the gameplan was to put the car into fifth gear from the first whistle and that’s precisely what they did. When your approach is so authentic and in keeping with your culture, it makes it that much easier.I also think we have two teams contesting the final after the heartache of last year – maybe even because of it
Haliburton and Pacers stun Knicks with epic comeback in Game 1 of East finals
The ghosts of Reggie Miller were alive and well at Madison Square Garden on Wednesday night – and Tyrese Haliburton once again played the role of Garden villain to perfection.Haliburton helped Indiana complete an unprecedented 14-point comeback in the final reel, tying the game with a wild jumper at the buzzer in regulation, to beat the New York Knicks 138-135 in overtime in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals. The Pacers now hold a 1-0 lead in the best-of-seven-games series for a trip to the NBA finals after pulling off one of the most improbable finishes in playoff history.New York led 119-105 with under three minutes remaining in the fourth quarter, seemingly in complete command. According to ESPN Research, their win probability was 99
Athletes warn against potential health risks of ‘dangerous, unethical’ Enhanced Games
A group of prominent Australian athletes including former Olympic diver Melissa Wu and Diamonds netballer Natalie Butler (nee Medhurst) has taken aim at the Enhanced Games after the “superhumanity” startup confirmed plans for its first event next year in Las Vegas, where former world champion Dolphin James Magnussen is expected to take part.The inaugural Enhanced Games planned for next May will include medical screening and individualised health profiling for the sprinting, swimming and weightlifting events as well as oversight by independent scientific and ethics boards to address widespread concerns for the safety of those who take part.But Sport Integrity Australia’s six-member Athlete Advisory Group, which also includes rugby sevens representative Ben O’Donnell and gymnast Alexandra Kiroi-Bogatyreva, issued a plea on Thursday for athletes to resist the lure of prize money and recognise their status as role models in society by staying clean.“The normalisation of performance-enhancing drugs promotes doping as entertainment, putting athletes at risk, and devalues the efforts of those who choose to compete clean,” the athlete advisory group said.“We are concerned about the negative role modelling impact on young athletes in particular, and the related health risks of using performance-enhancing substances or methods that may be inadvertently viewed as safe
Jim Irsay, longtime owner of NFL’s Indianapolis Colts, dies aged 65
Jim Irsay, longtime owner and CEO of the Indianapolis Colts and one of the NFL’s most recognizable figures, has died at age 65. The franchise announced that Irsay passed away peacefully in his sleep on Tuesday afternoon.“We are devastated to announce our beloved Owner & CEO, Jim Irsay, passed away peacefully in his sleep,” Colts chief operating officer Pete Ward said in a statement. “Jim’s dedication and passion for the Indianapolis Colts, in addition to his generosity, commitment to the community, and most importantly, his love for his family were unsurpassed.”Irsay, who took over full control of the team in 1997 following the death of his father Robert Irsay, presided over the most successful era in Colts history
Elon Musk claims he will step back from political donations in near future
Almost half of young people would prefer a world without internet, UK study finds
Microsoft employee interrupts CEO’s keynote with pro-Palestinian protest
How to protect your data after a cyber-attack
Bankrupt DNA testing firm 23andMe to be purchased for $256m
AI can be more persuasive than humans in debates, scientists find