The Guide #228: Against ​my ​better ​judgment​,​ A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms ​has ​me ​back in Westeros

A picture


Just when I thought I was out … just when I thought I would no longer have that sweeping, ever so slightly irritating theme tune ringing around my head for hours on end, or feel the need to remember the difference between House Tyrell, Tully or Arryn, I suddenly find myself pulled back in to the Game of Thrones extended universe,The blame for this goes to A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, the likably low-key Game of Thrones spin-off series about a cloth-eared hedge knight and his shrewd child squire currently ambling through its first season on HBO/Sky Atlantic,Before its arrival, I had departed Westeros for good,My faith had first been shaken by that rushed, badly plotted final season of Game of Thrones proper, which bashed to bits six previous seasons’ worth of finely tuned political intrigue and fascinating character dynamics in a succession of endless (often badly lit) CGI-laden battles, before flambéing them in dragon fire,Worse came with House of the Dragon, a dreary, po-faced, endlessly withholding slog of a prequel series, the enjoyment of which seemed to rest entirely on whether the viewer was familiar with deep lore buried within a Westeros history book that George RR Martin wrote instead of cracking on with that sixth novel.

If, like me, you were not, the show proved to be little more than a confusing conveyor belt of platinum-haired poshos glowering at each other.Oh and dragons.So many dragons.For my money, the dragons were always the worst bit of Game of Thrones.They were just about tolerable, or ignorable at least, when they were scrawny lizards perched on the shoulder of Daenerys Targaryen, but as they grew, season by season, they began to dominate proceedings, and tipped the show over into the deep waters of the fantasy genre.

Pre-dragons, if you squinted extremely hard, you could just about convince yourself that you were basically watching a fantasy-tinged version of Wolf Hall, with its noble families clandestinely scheming away against each other.That was the real magic trick of Thrones, to convince those of us usually unwilling to dip our toes into fantasy, that we were watching something more than that.But dragons the size of aircraft carriers, including a zombified version that breathed ice instead of fire, made that basically impossible.The spell was broken.Until, that is, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms came shuffling along.

A self-contained, small-stakes story told across six half-hour episodes, it feels like a rejection of the bloat of later Thrones and House of the Dragon.(Happily there’s not a dragon in sight, bar one made of fabric in a puppet show.) Instead, Seven Kingdoms shares some of the cheerful, bawdy qualities of parts of Game of Thrones’s early years, particularly the adventures of mismatched pairings like Jaime and Brienne or Arya and the Hound.Though Ser Duncan the Tall and his companion Egg’s matters are far less pressing: Dunk just wants to enter a jousting tourney to cement his knightly reputation, honour his deceased mentor and earn some coin; the more inscrutable Egg just seems to be going along for the ride, though later episodes will reveal more at play (thanks to early screeners, I raced through the entire first season in a single afternoon).At points, the pair don’t seem to be doing very much at all, just meandering aimlessly about the tourney site, sniping away at each other.

Which is more than enough, really: you could happily watch these two do nothing much, forever.There’s a lovely, easy chemistry between giant rugby player-turned actor Peter Claffey, who plays the dim but lovably sincere Dunk, and the excellent Dexter Sol Ansell as keen-eyed though ultimately innocent Egg.And the figures they bump into – Daniel Ings’s riotous Lyonel Baratheon, a handful of Targaryens of varying shades of loathfulness – are absorbing and entertaining too.The show clanks up several gears in its back half, with just a dash of Thronesian nastiness to keep you from getting too comfortable.In short, it’s terrific.

So now I’m left in a tricky position: do I properly dive back into the Thrones universe? I’ll definitely come back to Seven Kingdoms when it returns for a second season.And I am more than happy to write off House of the Dragon rather than trudge through its final two seasons.But then, according to Martin, there are several other Game of Thrones spin-offs in various stages of development.What to do with them? The answer is to hold out for the ones that prioritise great characters and stories over flash and fantasy – and keep the dragons to a minimum.To read the complete version of this newsletter please subscribe to receive The Guide in your inbox every Friday
societySee all
A picture

Wes Streeting to offer resident doctors bigger pay rise to end dispute

Wes Streeting is to offer resident doctors a bigger pay rise than other NHS staff in England as part of a new package of measures to try to end their long-running dispute.The health secretary also plans to guarantee resident doctors that hospitals will be fined if they do not give them good working conditions, such as rest areas and access to hot food.Streeting is looking at making a series of improvements to previous offers he has made, which may persuade the British Medical Association (BMA) to call off its nearly three-year-long campaign of industrial action.Senior figures in the NHS briefed on Streeting’s thinking are increasingly optimistic that the measures he is finalising may prove enough to break the deadlock before the third anniversary of the first doctors’ strike of the current dispute on 13 March 2023.The health secretary hopes that by offering to significantly improve – but for resident doctors only – the 2

A picture

Mediterranean diet can reduce risk of stroke by up to 25%, long-term study suggests

A Mediterranean diet can reduce the risk of every type of stroke, in some cases by as much as 25%, a large study conducted over two decades suggests.A diet rich in olive oil, nuts, seafood, whole grains and vegetables has previously been linked to a number of health benefits. However, until now there has been limited evidence of how it might affect the risk of all forms of stroke.The study, published in Neurology Open Access, a journal of the American Academy of Neurology, shows an association but does not prove the Mediterranean diet causes a lower risk of stroke.However, experts not involved with the research welcomed the findings, and said there was “huge potential” to reduce a person’s chances of experiencing a stroke

A picture

DWP chief accused of overseeing ‘culture of complacency’ that led to carer’s allowance scandal

The government’s most senior welfare official has been accused of presiding over a “culture of complacency” that led to thousands of unpaid carers inadvertently running up huge benefit debts.Debbie Abrahams, the chair of the work and pensions select committee, said the Department for Work and Pensions had repeatedly failed to prioritise vulnerable people, was unwilling to learn from its mistakes, and was slow to fix errors.Abrahams said she found it “difficult to have confidence” in the DWP’s permanent secretary, Sir Peter Schofield, who had promised MPs more than six years ago that he would fix critical flaws in the carer’s allowance benefit but had failed to do so.An award-winning Guardian investigation revealed hundreds of thousands of unpaid carers, most already in poverty, were landed with large bills for overpayments running into thousands of pounds as a result of DWP shortcomings. Several hundred carers are estimated to have also received fraud convictions

A picture

Pentagon threatens to cut ties with Scouting America over ‘core values’

The Pentagon is again threatening to sever ties with Scouting America unless the organization formerly known as the Boy Scouts of America reverts to “core values” and realigns itself with service to “God and country”.A warning to end the US military’s longstanding partnership with one of the nation’s largest and most popular youth organizations came in a Monday night post to social media by the Pentagon spokesperson, Sean Parnell, who insisted the scouting movement “lost its way” in a 2025 rebrand that promoted inclusivity and included admitting girls and LBGTQ+ members.Donald Trump’s defense department under its head, Pete Hegseth, has previously railed against being “woke” in the US military, including diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) programs, and suggested that women lack the physical strength to be effective combat troops.Hegseth first proposed withdrawing government support for the scouting movement in a memo to Congress in November. The Washington Post reported on Tuesday that a separate draft memo outlining the plan has been circulating in recent days

A picture

Three-quarters of cancer patients in England will survive by 2035, government pledges

Three in four cancer patients in England will beat cancer under government plans to raise survival rates, as figures reveal someone is now diagnosed every 75 seconds in the UK.Cancer is the country’s biggest killer, causing about one in four deaths, and survival rates lag behind several European countries, including Romania and Poland. Three-quarters of NHS hospital trusts are failing cancer patients, a Guardian analysis found last year, prompting experts to declare a “national emergency”.In a new plan to be published on Wednesday, ministers will pledge £2bn to resolve the crisis by transforming cancer services, with millions of patients promised faster diagnoses, quicker treatment and more support to live well.Some cancer performance targets have not been met by the NHS since 2015

A picture

Cost of UK’s drug price deal with US will come out of NHS budget

The cost of the government’s drug pricing deal with the Trump administration will come out of the NHS budget instead of the Treasury’s and could eventually reach £9bn a year, campaigners fear.Patrick Vallance, the science minister, has confirmed that the costs – initially an extra £1bn over three years– will be borne by the Department of Health and Social Care, which funds the NHS in England, and not the Treasury.His admission, in a letter to the Commons science, innovation and technology committee, is the first time the government has specified which Whitehall department would foot the bill.It comes amid growing concern among Labour, Liberal Democrat, Green and Scottish National party MPs that ministers have been evasive about the costs involved and risk that the NHS may have to cut services in order to pay the 25% higher prices for new drugs that ministers agreed to.The £1bn is the estimated extra cost for the first three years of the 10-year deal the government announced on 1 December