The left must learn to take (and make) a joke | Letters
George Monbiot manages to achieve something quite remarkable: an essay on the corrosive potential of humour that ignores the decades-long tradition of the left wielding satire like a broadsword (How does the right tear down progressive societies? It starts with a joke, 10 July),Did we all dream Spitting Image, Saturday Night Live, Have I Got News for You, Ben Elton, or Jo Brand’s “battery acid” quip about Nigel Farage? The left practically invented modern political satire as we know it – and rightly so,Holding power to account through ridicule is not only legitimate but essential,But suddenly, when humour points the other way, it becomes seditious? Dangerous? Please,Humour is neither inherently leftwing nor rightwing – it is anti-hypocrisy, anti-power and often subversive.
To suggest that jokes from the right (which I accept are sometimes crass, reductive or tribal) are somehow uniquely dangerous while ignoring the gleeful savagery historically dished out to Margaret Thatcher, Ronald Reagan, George Bush or more recently Donald Trump, is not analysis – it’s tribal whingeing.What truly undermines progressive societies is the retreat from self-awareness.The idea that “our” humour is noble and “theirs” is insidious.The moment any movement begins to believe it has a monopoly on moral legitimacy and irony, it’s already drifting toward parody.A healthy society can laugh at itself from all angles.
If you’re afraid of jokes, maybe it’s not the comedians who need to be challenged but the fragility of the ideas being defended.John ButlerAnstey, Leicestershire Contra George Monbiot, isn’t the real problem with the left precisely that we have lost the ability to mock our enemies? Don’t we need more venomous satire of our own – fighting fire with fire? The Guardian’s own Martin Rowson is a great example: relentless, scabrous and merciless towards those who themselves show no mercy.Richard Pryor, Lenny Bruce and Jo Brand all used humour as a thought experiment about how our society could be otherwise.Anyone who has seen Eddie Murphy’s “first black president” ducking and dodging assassin’s bullets as he makes a speech will have seen the racial dynamics of the US embodied in a really funny comedy routine.Being permanently offended rather than seeking to cause offence in return shows how house-trained and academicised the left has become.
If “humour permits obscene ideas to seep into the range of the possible”, we need to recognise that socialism is the obscene idea that capitalism seeks to repress and try to cause some offence of our own.Nick MossLondon George Monbiot is right to highlight the right’s use of humour to normalise their odious ideas, but progressives have used humour in a similar way to normalise ideas that those they are targeting find hard to accept.Oscar Wilde was a master at this, with his plays attended in droves and loved by the very people he was lampooning.Did they recognise themselves on stage, resplendent in their pomposity and condescension? Subconsciously at least, they must have, and I suspect he did as much to change society for the better as anyone.It is, as Monbiot points out, a powerful tactic and one that we can continue to employ against those who would use it against us.
Phil UribeLlandrindod Wells, Powys Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
London-Berlin trains on the drawing board for UK-German rail taskforce
Plans for possible direct trains from London to Berlin will be drawn up by a joint UK-German taskforce, reigniting hopes for better rail connections across Europe.The partnership, announced as part of the bilateral treaty to be signed by the British prime minister, Keir Starmer, and his German counterpart, Friedrich Merz, could eventually lead to direct rail services between the two countries after previous plans for London-Frankfurt trains hit the buffers.The Department for Transport described the agreement as a “significant step forward”, with direct trains the most eye-catching part of a commitment to collaborate in enhancing sustainable transport links and mobility.Germany has also agreed to allow some arriving UK airline passengers to use passport e-gates at its airports by the end of August, the Cabinet Office said.Since Brexit, UK travellers have needed to queue to have their passports manually stamped, rather than use automated gates, at EU airports
UK unemployment rises and wage growth slows as jobs market ‘weakens’
Unemployment climbed and wage growth slowed in the three months to May, according to official figures that will pressure the Bank of England to cut interest rates next month.Data from the Office for National Statistics, released on Thursday, showed that Britain’s official unemployment rate rose to 4.7% in the three months to May, up 0.1% from April to reach the highest level since June 2021.Pay growth slipped from 5
Frasers Group sales fall amid ‘challenging’ luxury market and retreat from gaming
A “challenging” luxury market and retreat from gaming have prompted a fall in sales and profits at Mike Ashley’s Frasers.The group, which is majority owned by the billionaire former Newcastle United owner, said sales fell by 7.4% to £4.7bn and pre-tax profits slid by 24% to £379.5m as it closed some of its House of Fraser department stores and Game video game shops
Rise in unemployment shows UK jobs market is cooling, but it is not collapsing
Anaemic economic growth, rising inflation, and a worsening outlook in the jobs market. If the inheritance from the Conservatives had been bad, the situation a year in to the new Labour government does not look much better.The latest figures show unemployment nudged up to 4.7% in May, hitting the highest level in four years, while wage growth slowed for a third consecutive month, and employers cut back on hiring.Given the cocktail of economic concerns facing Britain, a slowdown in the labour market is hardly surprising
Reform’s anti-renewables stance ‘putting jobs and energy bills at risk’
Britain’s green energy industry has accused the Reform UK party of undermining the national interest by threatening to strip public subsidies for wind and solar projects if it comes to power.Groups representing Britain’s biggest clean energy investors said the populist party was “putting politics before prosperity” after Reform’s deputy leader gave “formal notice” to large developers that it would axe any deals struck in an upcoming renewables subsidy auction this summer.The government auction allows developers to bid for contracts-for-difference, guaranteeing them a minimum price for electricity for up to 20 years.In a letter sent to energy companies including SSE and Octopus Energy, Reform claimed there was “no public mandate for the real-world consequences” of the clean power agenda and said all subsidies would be scrapped.Richard Tice, the deputy leader of the party founded by Nigel Farage, added that developers seeking a subsidy contract in the upcoming auction would “do so at your own risk” because the party would “seek to strike down all contracts” if it gained power
Can Trump fire Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell?
Donald Trump told Republican lawmakers that he plans to fire the US Federal Reserve chair, Jerome Powell, in what would be an unprecedented move against the non-partisan central bank.Trump drafted a letter firing Powell and showed it to House Republicans during a private meeting on Tuesday night, according to the New York Times. Stock markets sank on the news but rose as Trump complicated the story by telling reporters it was “highly unlikely” he would fire Powell.This isn’t the first time Trump has said he will fire Powell, whose term is up in May 2026, though it marks a rapid escalation of his threats to do so.Any move by the White House to formally dismiss the Fed chair would be unprecedented
Number of city rail commuters in England and Wales passes pre-Covid levels
UK payrolls down by 178,000 over last year; Bundesbank chief defends central bank independence after Trump’s attacks on Powell – as it happened
Risk of undersea cable attacks backed by Russia and China likely to rise, report warns
Inside Elon Musk’s plan to rain SpaceX’s rocket debris over Hawaii’s pristine waters
The Open 2025: first round updates as Fitzpatrick shares lead at Royal Portrush – live
Tour de France 2025: Pogacar blows field away on stage 12 summit finish in Pyrenees – live