Apprenticeships have collapsed in England – Labour needs to fine-tune the solution, fast | Heather Stewart
Ensuring England’s workforce has the right skills for a rapidly changing economy is key to Labour’s hopes of boosting social mobility and kickstarting economic growth.So it seems unfortunate that more than a week after Keir Starmer’s drastic reshuffle, ministers are still wrangling over exactly which bits of the skills agenda will now move to Pat McFadden’s beefed-up Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).Broadly speaking, the education secretary, Bridget Phillipson, is expecting to hang on to responsibility for further education, while McFadden will probably take on apprenticeships and adult skills.Jacqui Smith, the skills minister, will work across both departments.Labour market experts say there is some logic to the shift: ensuring the right training is available in the right places is one crucial part of tackling the issue of economic inactivity in a rapidly changing employment market, which falls within the DWP’s bailiwick.
But “machinery of government” changes, as official parlance has it, can often bring more disruption than clarity,Over the past two decades alone, responsibility for skills has bounced around Whitehall, from education into the short-lived Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills (2007-09) then on to the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (2009-16), back into education again, and now across to the DWP,Perhaps this nomadic status helps account for successive administrations’ chronic neglect,Government spending on adult education halved between 2011-12 and 2019-20,It then recovered somewhat as the worst years of austerity came to an end, but by last year it was still £1bn down in real terms.
Meanwhile, despite endless speeches by politicians of all stripes about how vocational skills should have the same status as university (I have sat through quite a few: it is compulsory to mention Germany), the numbers of people completing apprenticeships have collapsed.Official figures show 178,220 people earned an apprenticeship in England in 2023-24, down by more than a third on 2017-18, when the apprenticeship levy was introduced.Recently rebranded as the skills and growth levy, this is charged at 0.5% of the payroll of larger firms.It was meant to encourage a flowering of workplace training, although employers have long complained that it is too rigid.
Since Labour came to power, Phillipson has made some changes, cutting the minimum duration of an apprenticeship to eight months.Enrolment in apprenticeships has risen this year, by just over 2%, but business groups are still hoping for a more substantial shake-up.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionCompanies have their own significant part to play, too.It must surely be a piece of the UK’s productivity puzzle that, according to the Learning and Work Institute, employers’ annual spending on training for each member of staff has fallen by 28% in real terms since 2005, to £1,530, a level less than half the EU average.The longtime education expert Sir Philip Augur put it well in a recent Institute for Fiscal Studies podcast about post-16 education.
Welcoming the changes to the apprenticeship levy, Augur said: “Employers have to step up to the plate here,For employers, ‘I can’t get the staff’ is quite often an excuse for bad management,Now, on this occasion, they can’t get the staff because the skills aren’t there,But there needs to be honesty and self-appraisal on the part of employers,”Augur called for the levy to rise “very slightly” to free up more resources for expanding apprenticeships.
McFadden’s team say he is keen to ensure young people get the skills they need to benefit from the jobs scheduled to be created by new government investment in defence and green energy.That will mean working with firms and unions to get the training landscape right.There is plenty of innovative thinking going on at local level.The West Yorkshire mayor, Tracy Brabin, announced plans last week for what she called “skills-led growth” in Wakefield, the UK’s largest city without a university.She hopes to establish a new Wakefield Futures Centre, led by employers, where local people can do courses directly linked to finding work in the fastest-growing sectors in the surrounding economy.
The idea is to make the courses flexible so that adults with caring responsibilities, for example, can take up the offer.This kind of relatively fluid, employer-connected approach could allow mums to pick up new skills, or older workers to switch sector or dip their toe in the market after a period off sick, for example.It could also be used to tempt young people to think about a wider set of options: in Manchester, Andy Burnham is pushing to set up an Mbacc – an Ebacc equivalent, intended to be an alternative to GCSEs, which is tailored to local jobs.Jobcentres, which are getting a rejig under Labour to present a more encouraging face, can then signpost to local opportunities such as these.Getting the skills offer right will have to form one crucial part of any genuine effort to bring down the UK’s unusually high economic inactivity rates, and therefore, ultimately, the welfare bill.
Last year’s crass attempt at cuts failed because Labour could not justify to its own MPs the crude way in which it planned to cut eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip).If the government wants to have another go – as McFadden certainly does – then a fresh skills and training offer could be part of the package for the hard-to-reach claimants Labour said it had a “moral case” to help last time – but for whom across-the-board Pip cuts would have done nothing.It’s not a quick fiscal fix by any means, but get it right and the upside, for individuals, employers and the economy, would be significant and long-lasting.The sooner ministers can clear up who takes on which bits of the task, and crack on with it, the better.
Seth Meyers on Charlie Kirk shooting: ‘Political violence is abhorrent to the highest ideals of this country’
Late-night hosts reacted to the assassination of the rightwing activist Charlie Kirk and decried the rising tide of political violence in the US.Seth Meyers opened Thursday’s Late Night with a separate segment on the Kirk assassination. “We are horrified by this grotesque tragedy and our condolences go out to his family and loved ones,” he said. “It should never be a matter of political ideology to mourn and to extend our fullest and deepest empathy to those who are suffering.“Political violence is abhorrent and anathema to the highest ideals of this country,” he continued
Shrinking audiences, a cash crisis and rivals on the rise: what’s gone wrong at Tate?
When a national institution starts to sound like Spın̈al Tap, you know it’s in trouble.Recently, Tate channelled the mythic rock band’s claim that its audience was not shrinking, just “becoming more selective”. In response to a decline in visitor numbers and a cash crisis leading to redundancies, the museum group emphasised “record numbers of young visitors” to Tate Modern (who cares about all those uncool visitors above the age of 35?).Yet in the summer, Tate’s director, Maria Balshaw, blamed the group’s problems on a dearth of 16-24-year-old visitors from continental Europe. So they appeal to youth, but the wrong youth?This week, Tate Modern will open a blockbuster show that may attract paying adults
Protesters target Royal Opera House over performance by ‘Putin’s diva’
Dozens of protesters have gathered outside the Royal Opera House to demonstrate against an eminent Russian opera singer nicknamed “Putin’s diva” who performed on the opening night of Tosca.Anna Netrebko, 53, one of the world’s best-known sopranos, who draws full houses for her performances at leading opera houses globally, has denied being an ally of the Russian leader.She was ostracised by most major opera houses in the months after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, despite releasing a statement unequivocally condemning the conflict.Netrebko, who has not performed in Russia since 2022, was given a People’s Artist award in 2008 by Vladimir Putin. The crowd of about 50 protesters congregated outside the central London venue included Natalia Filatova, 48, who was wrapped in the Ukrainian flag
And if your head explodes: Pink Floyd’s 20 best songs – ranked!
Fifty years after the release of Wish You Were Here, we count down the best of the band’s Syd Barrett years, their difficult recovery and later reunionLow on memorable tunes, big on racked, strangulated lead vocals, possessed of a worldview that makes every other Pink Floyd album look like a gushing font of Pollyanna-ish optimism, The Final Cut is a slog. But The Gunner’s Dream cuts through the gloom, thanks to a heartbreaking, fragile melody.Overshadowed by the albums that preceded and followed it, Obscured by Clouds might be the most underrated release in Pink Floyd’s catalogue: it boasts fantastic instrumental experiments, musical signposts to The Dark Side of the Moon and, in Wot’s … Uh the Deal?, a beautifully careworn, Beatles-y ballad undersold by its daft title.The studio half of Ummagumma is a mess – a band audibly searching for direction without success – but it contains one unequivocal triumph: Roger Waters’ evocation of the parkland on the banks of the River Cam, its pastoral calm spiked with a curious sense of menace, as if something nasty is lurking in the undergrowth.The More soundtrack throws up everything from proto-heavy metal and mock-flamenco to bongo solos
Stephen Colbert on Charlie Kirk shooting: ‘Political violence only leads to more political violence’
Late-night hosts respond to the shooting of Charlie Kirk and assess Donald Trump’s denials of a sexually suggestive birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein from 2003.Stephen Colbert opened his show on Wednesday with an acknowledgement of the assassination of Charlie Kirk, the rightwing activist and Trump adviser who was shot and killed at age 31 during an event in Utah on Wednesday afternoon. “Our condolences go out to his family, and all of his loved ones,” said Colbert.“I’m old enough to personally remember the political violence of the 1960s,” the Late Show host added. “And I hope it is obvious to everyone in America that political violence does not solve any of our political differences
Jerry Seinfeld compares Free Palestine movement to Ku Klux Klan
Jerry Seinfeld denounced the Free Palestine movement as antisemitic and likened its rhetoric to that of the Ku Klux Klan during a surprise appearance at Duke University.“Free Palestine is, to me, just … you’re free to say you don’t like Jews. Just say you don’t like Jews,” the 71-year-old comedian said on stage, according to the Duke University Chronicle.“By saying ‘Free Palestine’, you’re not admitting what you really think,” he continued. “So it’s actually – compared to the Ku Klux Klan, I’m actually thinking the Klan is actually a little better here, because they can come right out and say, ‘We don’t like Blacks, we don’t like Jews
Here’s a tip: eliminate US tipping culture and pay people a living wage
Apprenticeships have collapsed in England – Labour needs to fine-tune the solution, fast | Heather Stewart
Anarchy in the IPA: as punk brewer’s sales stall, are we past peak BrewDog?
Chinese carmakers told to improve locking devices for UK market
Thames Water paid £1m-plus to corporate spooks firm part-owned by Starmer adviser
As US edges closer to stagflation, economists blame Trump policies