MPs raise concerns over Asda’s link to app offering high-interest loans to staff

A picture


An influential group of MPs has sought assurances that Asda is not “squeezing staff” to drive profit after it emerged they are being offered high-interest loans by Wagestream, a company in which the retailer’s owner has a stake.The business and trade select committee has written to Asda over its links to the “financial wellbeing app” that recently began offering the supermarket’s staff loans of up to £25,000.The default arrangements for Wagestream’s “workplace loans” involve debt repayments being directly deducted from workers’ pay packets.A holding company controlled by Asda’s private equity owner TDR Capital is a shareholder in Wagestream, which has been offering Asda workers a range of other services, including savings pots and wage advances, since 2023.Documents filed at Companies House show that the holding company, Bellis Financial Investments 2, is one of a number of shareholders in Wagestream, alongside former Wonga payday loan investor Balderton Capital, and social impact investors including the Joseph Rowntree Foundation via the Fair by Design Fund.

However, the Guardian understands that the retailer did not flag its financial link to Wagestream to staff when it initially launched the service to workers two years ago.Wagestream – which this week rebranded itself as Stream – started offering “workplace loans” to Asda staff earlier this year.Liam Byrne, the chair of the business and trade committee, said he had written to Asda “to ask them to reassure us that frontline workers aren’t left facing sky-high interest rates, and that its workplace lending is compliant with Asda’s legal requirements under employment law”.“Asda is one of Britain’s most important employers with over 150,000 workers and is at the heart of our grocery market,” he said.“Our concern today is that instead of easing Asda’s debts, its parent company may be piling pressure on Asda’s people – squeezing staff to service liabilities and drive profit to its financial investments.

If this is the case, it raises serious questions as to Asda’s responsible stewardship, and the long-term financial sustainability of the business as a whole.”Asda’s finance director, Michael Gleeson, told the committee in 2023 that a £100m investment in Wagestream and two other financial services businesses had been funded out of proceeds from the £1.7bn sale of Asda’s warehouses, which the company now has to pay rent on under a leaseback deal.“We are part owners of each of those three companies,” he told MPs.Bellis is understood to hold a 4% stake in Wagestream.

Asda said it does not pay Wagestream for any services or receive any financial benefit if a member of staff chooses to use the app.However, as a shareholder, Asda’s parent group has a direct interest in its success and would have the right to a share of any future dividend payments or proceeds from the sale of the group.Wagestream is yet to pay a dividend and remains loss-making, having last reported a £22.2m pre-tax loss in 2024.That could change before long, however, with revenues having grown by more than two-thirds (64%) to £36.

9m last year, when it handed out 20.6m wage advances worth a total of £1.5bn.The rollout of workplace loans could propel earnings, which have so far relied on fees linked to its wage advance product.Wagestream said a rise in revenues in the upcoming year would probably outpace costs and start “moving the business towards profitability in future periods”.

A spokesperson for Asda, which is the UK’s third largest supermarket, said: “Asda offers colleagues access to a range of established financial products through a partner regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).These include salary advances, workplace loans and savings products paying a competitive interest rate of 4.33%, which is currently used by more than 18,000 colleagues.“Many other large employers, including all of Asda’s direct competitors in the grocery sector, offer similar products to their employees through the same or competitor providers.”Asda added that all applications for Wagestream’s workplace loans were subject to “robust affordability checks” before being approved.

“At present, fewer than 2% of Asda colleagues have taken out a loan,The representative APR on these loans is 13,9%,”Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionWagestream began rolling out the loans to clients including Asda at the end of 2024,Those loans come with a representative APR of between 13.

9% and 19.9%, meaning at least 51% of borrowers will get that rate.But the ultimate cap is negotiated with each employer, topping out at 34.9% APR.Wagestream insists that its model still saves borrowers an average of £593 a loan, with customers having been charged an average APR of 62% by former lenders before turning to the app.

Nadine Houghton, a national officer at the GMB union, which represents Asda workers, said it was concerned about the financial links between Asda and Wagestream: “It leaves a sour taste in the mouth that TDR has a financial interest in the app that facilitates Asda workers taking these financial risks, while also being the overall decision-maker for how much these workers are paid and the hours they are able to work.”“We now find out that Wagestream is offering dangerous loans at high interest rates and GMB members working in Asda tell us they have used the app to take advances on their pay, which can contribute to a cycle of debt.“The bottom line is that employers should pay workers enough to live on, to have savings and to not need to rely on dangerous high-interest loans or advances on their pay just to cover day-to-day living costs.”Wagestream said in a statement that “as a regulated financial services provider, Wagestream has a conflicts of interest policy and has implemented processes to review and monitor conflicts of interest to comply with FCA rules.”“TDR Capital’s holding in Wagestream does not create a conflict as it falls well below the thresholds set out by the FCA.

As a minority shareholder, TDR Capital does not have operational or day-to-day control of any of Wagestream’s undertakings,” the statement added.Wagestream said it considers potential conflicts when deciding on whether to partner with employers, which in turn sign its terms and conditions that require good consumer outcomes and transparency, including around fees.TDR declined to comment.
societySee all
A picture

Children detained under Mental Health Act held for hours in A&E departments

Children as young as nine detained under the Mental Health Act are spending hours in NHS accident and emergency departments under police control rather than in specialist mental health assessment suites.The detention under the act of children in England and Wales in police cells was banned in 2017 but a lack of suitable options has led to the use of A&E departments.Research to be presented at a British Sociological Association conference at Northumbria University on Friday found that 187 nine-to-18-year-olds were detained under the act in a single constituency in the north of England between 2017 and 2021. Three-quarters were taken to A&E, where legally they could wait for up to 24 hours, accompanied by police officers, until they were assessed.It was mainly children aged 16 and over who were able to access adult facilities who were taken to specialist suites under the care of trained mental health staff

A picture

Hospices ‘on the brink’ financially if assisted dying is legalised

Hospices are “on the brink” and two in five are making cuts this year despite the importance of end-of-life care if assisted dying becomes legal, the sector has warned before the first House of Lords debate on the legislation.Hospice UK, which represents the sector, said many were financially struggling and still “in the dark” about how funding for end-of-life care will be improved when assisted dying legislation is passed.The terminally ill adults (end of life) legislation is due to have its second reading in the House of Lords on Friday, with Charlie Falconer, a Labour peer and the co-sponsor of the bill, taking over from the MP Kim Leadbeater.Before the debate, in which 190 peers have put their name down to speak, Falconer expressed optimism that it will pass through the Lords in time for it to become law by the spring.“There is more than enough time for the Lords to scrutinise the bill and return it to the Commons before the end of the parliamentary session,” he said

A picture

Cost of place in children’s care homes in England hits almost £320,000 a year

The cost of a single place in a residential children’s care home in England has nearly doubled in five years to an average £318,000 a year, with private firms racking up huge profits as a result of market failure, according to the public spending watchdog.The £3bn children’s homes market, which is increasingly dominated by private firms, some funded by private equity, is “dysfunctional” and too often fails to deliver a good service for youngsters or value for money, a National Audit Office (NAO) report said.In the most extreme instances – likely to involve children with complex needs who require 24-hour supervision by multiple staff – councils had been charged up to £63,000 a week (£3.3m a year) for a single placement, the NAO said.Privately owned care firms ramped up fees above the rate of inflation, with the biggest providers enjoying average annual profit rates of 22

A picture

Girls who play after-school sport in UK 50% more likely to later get top jobs, study finds

Girls who play after-school sport in the UK are 50% more likely to get top jobs later in life, according to research, which reveals that the boost is equivalent to a university degree.Despite this benefit, girls are far less likely to play sport than boys, with 11- to 18-year-olds each missing out on 1.4 hours a week, or 280m hours annually, with 340,000 more girls excluded due to cost and lack of local access, according to the research. One in three girls surveyed for the report said boys had access to a wider range of sports.The research found that women who played extracurricular sport as children were much more likely to reach senior professional roles

A picture

Boom times and total burnout: three days at Europe’s biggest pornography conference

The crowd that gathers in Amsterdam is exuberant. Pornography use is more common than ever, so earnings for many here are through the roof. But there is trouble afoot, from AI to chronic illness …Brittany Andrews, a cheerful American porn star, cuts to the chase in her workshop on how to succeed in the adult industry.“Do you think about how much money you’re going to make before you make a clip? Do you know what stuff sells the best? Or do you just follow your creative spark?” she asks. She points to a young Ukrainian model in a gold sequined bra and denim shorts

A picture

More than half of UK births now involve medical intervention, audit finds

More than half of women having a baby in Britain now do so with the help of medical intervention, an audit of NHS maternity care has revealed.Of the 592,594 births that took place in 2023, 50.6% involved either a caesarean section or the use of instruments such as forceps or a ventouse suction cup.Experts said the rise in medically assisted deliveries represented a “major shift” driven by births becoming more complicated in recent years, partly because more older or obese women are having babies.The increasing regularity of medical intervention is largely down to the sharp rise in caesarean births, in which the baby is delivered during an operation