Victims robbed of £4bn in ‘insulting’ car loan redress scheme, say claims firms
Victims of the car loans scandal could miss out on more than £4bn in compensation if the City regulator ploughs ahead with plans for an “insulting” interest rate in its redress scheme, consumer groups and claims firms say.The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has been accused of offering a reduced rate of interest which will be added to compensation from banks for borrowers caught up in the car loan commissions scandal.Claims law firms and consumer groups say borrowers should be offered the same terms as Marcus Johnson: the sole driver whose case was upheld by the supreme court in a landmark case in August.While the terms of the final payout are sealed, Johnson is widely believed by industry experts to have received about 7% interest on his compensation package, after judges ordered the parties to negotiate a “commercial rate”.But the watchdog has proposed a rate of 2.
09% on the compensation.The FCA has estimated that victims payouts will average £700 resulting from 14m unfair loans, costing lenders – including Lloyds, Barclays, Close Brothers and the financial arms of manufacturers like Ford – a combined £11bn.Critics say these terms are “unacceptable” and will ultimately rob drivers of another £4bn of compensation, based on calculations outlined in the FCA’s own consultation documents.Darren Smith, the managing director of the claims law firm Courmacs Legal, said: “The FCA’s proposal to cap interest at 2.09% is frankly insulting to the millions of victims who were overcharged, many well over a decade ago.
”He said lenders would not stand for cut-price rates being offered to consumers.“It exposes a staggering hypocrisy,” Smith said.“If the boot was on the other foot, and a bank was a successful claimant in a commercial dispute, would they meekly accept 2.09% on their losses? [Lloyds Banking Group’s chief executive] Charlie Nunn would rightly be asking the general counsel at Lloyds to demand the full commercial rate of interest from the wrongdoer.”The scheme is meant to draw a line under the scandal, which centres on unfair loan commission payments paid to car dealers by banks and specialist lenders.
The FCA has estimated that 14m historic car loan contracts that may be deemed unfair because of these commission payments,When discounting administrative costs, about £9,7bn of the £11bn sum will go straight to consumers,However, that sum is based on paying out a 2,09% annual interest rate on base levels of compensation.
Consumers would be due £14.3bn if the interest rate were closer to 8%, according to FCA documents.That rate of 8% is what has historically been paid out alongside successful county court cases, and by the Financial Ombudsman Service before its own rates were cut earlier this year.The current proposals mean a consumer will on average receive about £700 in compensation, rather than £1,030 at the 8% rate.“The interest rate is way too low, in my view,” said Martin Lewis, the founder of MoneySavingExpert, in his BBC podcast this month, adding that he was planning to raise the issue in his response to the FCA consultation.
Kevin Durkin, of HD Law, who represented Johnson during his supreme court case, agreed, told the Guardian that the FCA’s proposals were “unfair” and did “not adequately compensate consumers enough for the many years they’ve suffered under an unfair relationship with their lender.The FCA redress scheme should reflect what the supreme court awarded to Mr Johnson.”Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionConsumer advocates have also raised concerns.Alex Neill, a co-founder of the consumer rights organisation Consumer Voice, said: “The proposed rate of interest is unacceptable and would leave drivers losing out on £4bn they’re rightly owed.“Suggesting that those hit hardest – who have already faced extra costs due to this mis-selling scandal – should negotiate for a fair rate themselves is clearly unworkable.
”However, the Financing and Leasing Association (FLA) said the interest rate should reflect changes to compensation payouts at the FOS, which earlier this year were cut from 8% to the average Bank of England base rate, plus 1%,“The FCA is applying the same rate” in its redress scheme, the FLA said,An FCA spokesperson said: “Our proposals take account of court decisions on redress,We believe interest that links to the Bank [of England] base rate is fair, proportionate and aligns with the planned approach of the Financial Ombudsman,“Consumers would have the right to challenge this if they have evidence this was unfair to them.
We welcome feedback on our proposals.”Lloyds declined to comment.The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know.If you have something to share on this subject you can contact the Business team confidentially using the following methods.Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories.
Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Scroll down and click on Secure Messaging.When asked who you wish to contact please select the Guardian Business team.
SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postIf you can safely use the tor network without being observed or monitored you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform.Finally, our guide at theguardian.com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.
Talking Horses | Willie Mullins eyes Melbourne and Breeders’ Cup double after shock triumph
If five wins from the seven turf events, one short of the record, felt like a standard return for European runners at the 2025 Breeders’ Cup at Del Mar, then the identity of the biggest winner of all was a huge, and very refreshing, surprise.Willie Mullins blew into Del Mar with Ethical Diamond, his first ever runner at the meeting, and left with the $2m first prize in the Turf, nearly five times as much as he banked when Nick Rockett landed the Grand National in April. And the style of his win was equally memorable. Punters who backed the proven Group One form of Minnie Hauk and Rebel’s Romance might beg to differ, but it gladdened the heart to see an Ebor Handicap winner leave the pair of them standing with a stretch run for the ages.Mullins was, momentarily at least, lost for words after Ethical Diamond and Dylan Browne McMonagle powered across the line
NFL week nine: Bills take down Chiefs, Jaguars edge Raiders in OT thriller – as it happened
(2-6) Las Vegas Raiders 29-30 Jacksonville Jaguars (5-3)(6-2) Los Angeles Rams 34-10 New Orleans Saints (1-8)(6-2) Buffalo Bills 28-31 Kansas City Chiefs (5-4)OK now that the Mad Max dust storm has settled or rather is settling, I think the performance of the night has to be Buffalo’s defense stepping up in the biggest of all spots to keep Patrick Mahomes in check. The all-world QB finished 15/34 for 250 yards, zero touchdowns, one pick and a rating of 57.2. Mahomes led the NFL in passing scores going into this and he didn’t get to add to his tally. Huge!Right, that is me done again for another week
Pitch invading prankster Daniel Jarvis charged after lining up with Kangaroos players at Ashes Test
A pitch invader who lined up alongside Australia’s rugby league players while the national anthem played at the weekend’s Ashes match in Liverpool has been arrested.Daniel Jarvis, a serial prankster, allegedly escaped the attention of security before kick-off in the second Test against England, slipping undetected on to the pitch to link arms with Kangaroos star Cameron Munster as Advance Australia Fair played.Munster noticed the interloper but did not realise it was a prank until he recognised the man known as “Jarvo” to his considerable social media following.“Some guy tried to get in between me and him [Pat Carrigan] and I said, ‘Nah’. Then he asked me again, ‘Can I stand next to you and hold you?’
India beat South Africa by 52 runs to win Women’s Cricket World Cup final – as it happened
Harmanpreet lifts the trophy at last. A shower of gold fireworks shoots into the sky. There’s gold tickertape too, and the voice of Freddie Mercury.“We are the champions,” he sings. And then the worst line in any Queen song: “no time for losers”
Saracens Women enjoy World Cup bounce with record crowd for derby
If fans had been told at the start of the day to predict which Canada international would be the star of the Premiership Women’s Rugby London derby, most would have picked out Sophie de Goede. The versatile world player of the year is in incredible form, after her starring role in Canada’s run to the Rugby World Cup final just over a month ago, but she did not have the chance to live up to those hypothetical expectations as she failed a fitness test a few hours before kick-off.Such is the Canadian presence at Saracens, though, that another Canuck stood out, with the wing Alysha Corrigan at the heart of the north London club winning 47-10 against Harlequins in this fierce rivalry in front of a record 3,733 spectators.Corrigan produced not only two skilful tries but she was also able to beat several defenders throughout the encounter and had defensive prowess which marked her out at a sunny but cold StoneX Stadium. Canadian flair was on display throughout, with Olivia Apps also an electric presence and Laetitia Royer impressing on her debut
Coco Gauff’s serving troubles return in WTA Finals defeat against Pegula
Coco Gauff’s serving woes followed her into the final week of the season, as the American’s title defence at the WTA Finals in Riyadh began with a bruising 6-3, 6-7 (4), 6-2 loss to her compatriot Jessica Pegula in their first match of the group stages.Despite fighting hard and remaining competitive until the end, the third seed simply could not overcome her 17 double faults against an in-form Pegula, the fifth seed, who maintained her composure after getting pulled into a final set by her struggling opponent, and saved her best level for the closing stretch of the match.Pegula’s victory could prove to be an important win in the Stefanie Graf group, with Aryna Sabalenka looming and favoured to advance. Earlier on Sunday, the world No 1 opened her tournament with a confident 6-3, 6-1 win over Jasmine Paolini, the eighth seed. The victory was Sabalenka’s 60th of the season, the first time she has achieved this milestone
Jaguar Land Rover restart helps UK factories return to growth
UK factories return to growth with JLR restarting operations after cyber-attack – business live
Oakley Meta Vanguard review: fantastic AI running glasses linked to Garmin
‘History won’t forgive us’ if UK falls behind in quantum computing race, says Tony Blair
Eli Katoa’s seizure and brain bleed prompts calls for NRL to assess concussion protocols
From burnout to brilliance: Amanda Anisimova on how honesty sparked her remarkable revival