What is the row between Wes Streeting and pharmaceutical companies about?

A picture


Wes Streeting, the health secretary, has accused pharmaceutical companies of being “shortsighted” and undermining their relationships with the government after the two sides failed to come to an agreement last week, but what is the row all about?The dispute is over the financial terms for drug companies to provide medicines to the NHS, including potentially life-saving cancer drugs.In 2023, the government, NHS England and the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI) made a five-year deal that included drug companies paying a percentage of their income on sales to the NHS above a certain threshold.This was about 15%, but this year it rose unexpectedly to almost 23%.It has been called a “clawback tax” and was intended to “promote innovation and access to cost-effective medicines … while also supporting the sustainability of NHS finances”, the agreement states.It essentially prevented drug companies from making runaway profits.

The idea was to use a voluntary pricing scheme to ensure a “partnership approach” between the drug companies and the health service.It was “designed to balance medicines’ costs for the NHS while encouraging growth and investment in the UK pharmaceutical industry”, said Doina Ionescu, Merck’s general manager for healthcare in the UK and Ireland.There have been rising sales of newer drugs to the health service, increasing from £6.9bn, when the percentage was originally set, to £8.4bn, according to the government’s figures.

The government thinks this means there could be a £373m underpayment.It says the new rate is in line with the terms of the original agreement.However, some drug companies now say it is not worth their while to launch as many new medicines for use in the UK.They say the clawback rates are far lower in Ireland, Germany, Spain, France, Italy and Belgium.Peter Wickersham, the general manager for the UK and Ireland of Gilead Sciences, one of the world’s largest drug firms, said at the weekend that the UK government’s approach means its Trodelvy drug for a form of breast cancer will not now be made available to people in England for one form of the disease.

The ABPI says it is directly affecting NHS patient access to new medicines in disease areas such as cancer and contributes to the UK’s poor performance in international comparisons of treatable and avoidable mortality.They are.The biggest firms make billions of dollars in profits every quarter.But they say that unless the terms are changed to bring them closer into line with other countries in which they can choose to operate, fewer medicines will be launched for use in the UK and patient outcomes could decline.Those that supply the US are also facing pressure from the US president, Donald Trump, to cut prices, which means they face falling revenues from a major market.

Talks over a review of the scheme – which was due to run to 2028 – broke down on Friday after the pharmaceutical industry rejected Streeting’s pricing offer as “unsustainable”,There is now a stalemate,The ABPI said: “We need to reach a solution that improves patient access to future innovation, allows the sector to fulfil its growth potential, and does not require industry to pay back nearly three times as much of its revenues as is required in other European countries,” The government said it was “regrettable” the ABPI did not want to take its proposals onboard,
A picture

Thomasina Miers’ recipes for rice-stuffed roast chicken and courgette soda bread

Little beats a loaf of fresh bread still warm from the oven. Today’s one is flecked with courgettes (zucchini), toasted seeds, a pleasing hint of green chilli and plenty of cheddar – the more mature, the better. It is delicious in the extreme, and even more so when spread with pickled chilli butter. But first a year-round roast chicken, inspired by the red rices of Mexico, that fills the day with a happy glow. If ever there was a dish to sing for its supper …I am endlessly in awe of the amount of umami unleashed by a simple braise of tomatoes, garlic and onion

A picture

Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for spiced coffee granita with whipped cream | The sweet spot

A low-effort dessert inspired by café de olla, which is a drink I consumed daily while on holiday in Oaxaca, Mexico. It’s a black coffee gently spiced with cinnamon and cloves, and sweetened with piloncillo (an unrefined sugar). Here, I’ve turned it into something refreshing for summer, using dark brown sugar instead, not least because it’s easier to find. I can never resist a post-dinner coffee, and this scratches both that caffeine and sugar itch.Prep 5 min Cook 15 min, plus cooling Freeze 2 hr 30 min+ Serves 4500ml freshly brewed coffee, or espresso 1 stick cinnamon 3 cloves 75g dark brown sugar 120ml double cream Pinch of flaky sea saltPour the coffee into a small pan, add the cinnamon, cloves and sugar and heat gently until it comes to a simmer

A picture

Can do: the tinnification of wine and cocktails

I’ve been asked about the “tinnification” of drinks pretty much everywhere else, so it feels only apt to talk about it here, too, because producers are putting just about everything they can in a can these days. Obviously, canned drinks aren’t anything new – the first canned beer went on sale in 1935, when post-prohibition America saw Krueger’s Finest Beer punted to drinkers in Virginia. Similar attempts had been made many years earlier, but it wasn’t until after two years of testing that the boffins finally developed a special coating that prevented the beer from reacting with the tin can.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link

A picture

The magic of samphire season: Jimi Famurewa’s recipe for mackerel, chorizo, new potato and samphire

North Norfolk captured our hearts by stealth. For most of my life, this arcing coastal stretch of East Anglia was somewhere I had never visited, nor ever spent that much time thinking about; a span of English countryside that I mostly associated with Alan Partridge, Colman’s mustard and, in the context of my south London home, an awkward schlep. But then, almost exactly a decade ago, I stumbled through an internet rabbit hole on to an entry for a clutch of self-catering cottages in a seaside village near the gently bougie, wax-jacketed market town of Holt. Decision made.Soon we were rumbling out across an impossibly wide and flat expanse, bound for the ripe, blustering winds and billowing steam trains of a varied network of time-warp beaches and little towns

A picture

How to turn beetroot tops into a delectable Japanese side dish – recipe

The ohitashi method is such an elegant way to enhance the natural flavours of leafy greens, while also reducing food waste. This traditional Japanese technique involves blanching and chilling leafy greens, then steeping them in a simple seasoned broth that imparts a wonderful and rounded savoury umami flavour. Most recipes for such greens use just the leafy part, but with ohitashi the stems are cooked first.Ohitashi is a wonderful way to prepare vegetables in advance, because the vegetables need to steep in a delicious broth for at least a few hours and up to five days, soaking up the marinade as they age. You can make ohitashi-style vegetables with just about any leafy greens: spinach, kale, chard, radish leaves, turnip tops or nettles

A picture

There’s a lot more to lettuce than salad | Kitchen aide

My garden has produced an abundance of lettuce (mainly butter lettuce) this year but there’s a limit to how much salad I can eat. What else can I use them for? Julian, by email“Start thinking of lettuce, and especially butter lettuce, as bread or a taco shell,” says Jesse Jenkins, author of Cooking with Vegetables, and happily this is a “highly adaptable” strategy, too. Sure, you could pile in grilled spicy pork belly and herbs, but this dinner fix also works well “with everything a big green salad does: a piece of nicely grilled protein, some sauce, a few pickled crunchy things, all wrapped in a big, beautiful green leaf”. But why stop there? “I also like to use butter lettuce to wrap cheese toasties,” Jenkins says. “It catches all the fatty goodness and acts as a barrier between the crunchy bread and the roof of your mouth