Impact of chatbots on mental health is warning over future of AI, expert says
The unforeseen impact of chatbots on mental health should be viewed as a warning over the existential threat posed by super-intelligent artificial intelligence systems, according to a prominent voice in AI safety.Nate Soares, a co-author of a new book on highly advanced AI titled If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies, said the example of Adam Raine, a US teenager who killed himself after months of conversations with the ChatGPT chatbot, underlined fundamental problems with controlling the technology.“These AIs, when they’re engaging with teenagers in this way that drives them to suicide – that is not a behaviour the creators wanted.That is not a behaviour the creators intended,” he said.He added: “Adam Raine’s case illustrates the seed of a problem that would grow catastrophic if these AIs grow smarter.
”Soares, a former Google and Microsoft engineer who is now president of the US-based Machine Intelligence Research Institute, warned that humanity would be wiped out if it created artificial super-intelligence (ASI), a theoretical state where an AI system is superior to humans at all intellectual tasks.Soares and his co-author, Eliezer Yudkowsky, are among the AI experts warning that such systems would not act in humanity’s interests.“The issue here is that AI companies try to make their AIs drive towards helpfulness and not causing harm,” said Soares.“They actually get AIs that are driven towards some stranger thing.And that should be seen as a warning about future super-intelligences that will do things nobody asked for and nobody meant.
”In one scenario portrayed in Soares and Yudkowsky’s book, which will be published this month, an AI system called Sable spreads across the internet, manipulates humans, develops synthetic viruses and eventually becomes super-intelligent – and kills humanity as a side-effect while repurposing the planet to meet its aims.Some experts play down the potential threat of AI to humanity.Yann LeCun, the chief AI scientist at Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta and a senior figure in the field, has denied there is an existential threat and said AI “could actually save humanity from extinction”.Soares said it was an “easy call” to state that tech companies would reach super-intelligence, but a “hard call” to say when.“We have a ton of uncertainty.
I don’t think I could guarantee we have a year [before ASI is achieved].I don’t think I would be shocked if we had 12 years,” he said.Zuckerberg, a major corporate investor in AI research, has said developing super-intelligence is now “in sight”.“These companies are racing for super-intelligence.That’s their reason for being,” said Soares.
“The point is that there’s all these little differences between what you asked for and what you got, and people can’t keep it directly on target, and as an AI gets smarter, it being slightly off target becomes a bigger and bigger deal.”Sign up to TechScapeA weekly dive in to how technology is shaping our livesafter newsletter promotionSoares said one policy solution to the threat of ASI was for governments to adopt a multilateral approach echoing the UN treaty on non-proliferation of nuclear weapons.“What the world needs to make it here is a global de-escalation of the race towards super-intelligence, a global ban of … advancements towards super-intelligence,” he said.Last month, Raine’s family launched legal action against the owner of ChatGPT, OpenAI.Raine took his own life in April after what his family’s lawyer called “months of encouragement from ChatGPT”.
OpenAI, which extended its “deepest sympathies” to Raine’s family, is now implementing guardrails around “sensitive content and risky behaviours” for under-18s.Psychotherapists have also said that vulnerable people turning to AI chatbots instead of professional therapists for help with their mental health could be “sliding into a dangerous abyss”.Professional warnings of the potential for harm include a preprint academic study published in July, which reported that AI may amplify delusional or grandiose content in interactions with users vulnerable to psychosis.In the US, you can call or text the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline on 988, chat on 988lifeline.org, or text HOME to 741741 to connect with a crisis counselor.
In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie.In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14.Other international helplines can be found at befrienders.
org
The Breakdown | England’s juggernaut must be wary of wheels coming off as World Cup stakes rise
It was the basketball great Kobe Bryant who best summed up the precarious status of the dead cert. His multi-talented LA Lakers team came into the 2004 NBA finals as clear favourites to beat the less fashionable Detroit Pistons only to lose 4-1 in the series. “Talent doesn’t get it done, you have to be able to execute,” reflected Bryant. “When you have talent and you execute, that’s when you win.”In other words there is no such thing in sport as an absolute certainty, no matter how good you are
The Sparks’ Cameron Brink is redefining what it means to be a young WNBA star
It’s the fourth quarter of a tense, close bout in Los Angeles between the hometown Sparks and the Indiana Fever. The game has serious playoff implications for both teams, so every bucket feels fraught, and it’s going down to the wire. Cameron Brink, the 6ft 4in second-year Sparks center with an unmistakable Rapunzel-esque blonde braid has fouled out of the game, but you wouldn’t know it from her enthusiasm on the bench. No one is clapping harder, cheering louder, for her teammates.That’s fundamental to who Brink is, according to everyone I talk to around the team in their final push for the playoffs in recent weeks – the Sparks are in a battle with Seattle Storm for the final spot
Take the strain: Tug of War World Championships
“Pick up the rope! Take the strain! Steady! Pull!” When the referee barks those commands, eight competitors on each team muster every ounce of strength in their bodies and attempt to haul one another across the crumbling earth. Clutching a rope made of hemp or polypropylene, the first team to tug their opponents four metres from their starting position is the winner. They dig their steel-plated heels into the dirt – but strictly no spikes are allowed – while coaching staff guide and encourage them to victory. In the round-robin stages, each contest lasts two ends and the top four teams reach the semi-finals; the semi-finals and finals are decided over three ends. With varying age and weight categories, competitors range from their teens to their 70s
Athletics can’t keep kidding itself – it needs a five-pronged plan to save track and field | Sean Ingle
The world’s fastest man is being trash-talked by a YouTuber. “Are you ready man?” asks Darren Watkins, AKA IShowSpeed, on a live stream broadcast around the world. “You know my name’s Speed, right? And you know I am going to win.” Noah Lyles, the Olympic and world 100m champion, smiles at the teenage upstart. Then he bites back
Unprecedented strike shows racing unified to send pre-budget message to Labour over betting duty crisis
There was just a single day of racing in Britain between 22 December and 9 March during the famously bitter winter in 1962-63 and dozens of blank days during the foot-and-mouth outbreaks in 1967 and 2001. Even in the era of racing on Polytrack and Tapeta, which dates back almost 40 years, there are occasional days when, to the delight of headline-writers, the so-called “all-weather” surfaces cannot cope.But there has never been a day throughout those decades when a scheduled programme of racing has been called off voluntarily, so the decision to “strike” on Wednesday, when meetings were due to be staged at Lingfield, Carlisle, Uttoxeter and Kempton, is a sign of how seriously racing’s administrators and stakeholders view the threat to the sport’s finances from a government proposal to “harmonise” the rate of duty charged on profits from betting on sport and other uncertain events, and fixed-margin casino products such as online slots where the operator takes a guaranteed percentage of turnover.Martin Cruddace, the chief executive of Arena Racing Company, one of Britain’s two major racecourse operators alongside Jockey Club Racecourses, has described the proposal as representing an “existential threat” to Britain’s second-biggest spectator sport.That might seem a little overwrought given that the current rate of betting duty is 15% of an operator’s gross profits, while the rate for gaming products is 21%
Surrey all out for 246, McKinney punishes Essex: county cricket day one – as it happened
It was one of those soul-soaring autumn days in the East Midlands, trees like overripe broccoli, skies huge and blue. On the bright green benches of Grace Road, a man filled out the crossword, while the County Championship resumed for its final three-round act. Nothing is decided, not even next season’s schedule – to be voted on later this month – with a choice of a 13-game two-division playoff compromise or the status quo.Leicestershire, the runaway stars of Division Two, are in touching distance of promotion for the first time since 2003, but this was one of their more forgettable days. They are without Rehan Ahmed (England), Ben Green (Somerset), Liam Trevaskis and Tom Scriven (injured) and Gloucestershire were able to make merry – with a stylish hundred for Graeme van Buuren and half-centuries from Ben Charlesworth, Miles Hammond and James Bracey
Anglo American agrees mining mega merger; Londoners face commuting struggles as tube strike enters second day – as it happened
Slashing migration would actually lead to higher house prices in Australia. Here’s why
Apple to debut new, thinner iPhone at ‘awe-dropping’ annual product event
Meta hid harms to children from VR products, whistleblowers allege
Raising the bar: Duplantis leads the stars aiming to break world records in Tokyo
’Bigger than a bow’: Women’s Rugby World Cup organisers take aim at online hate