Meta ‘hastily’ changed moderation policy with little regard to impact, says oversight board
Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta announced sweeping content moderation changes “hastily” and with no indication it had considered the human rights impact, the social media company’s oversight board has said.The assessment of the changes came as the board also criticised the Facebook and Instagram owner for leaving up three posts containing anti-Muslim and anti-migrant content during riots in the UK last summer.The oversight board raised concerns about the company’s announcement in January that it was removing factcheckers in the US, reducing “censorship” on its platforms and recommending more political content.In its first official statement on the changes, the board – which issues binding decisions on removing Meta content – said the company had acted too quickly and should gauge the impact of its changes on human rights.“Meta’s January 7, 2025, policy and enforcement changes were announced hastily, in a departure from regular procedure, with no public information shared as to what, if any, prior human rights due diligence the company performed,” said the board.
It urged Meta to live up to its commitment to uphold the United Nations’ principles on business and human rights, and urged the company to carry out due diligence on the impact.“As these changes are being rolled out globally, the board emphasises it is now essential that Meta identifies and addresses adverse impacts on human rights that may result from them,” the statement said.“This should include assessing whether reducing its reliance on automated detection of policy violations could have uneven consequences globally, especially in countries experiencing current or recent crises, such as armed conflicts.”The criticism of the changes was published alongside a series of content rulings including admonishment of Meta for leaving up three Facebook posts related to riots that broke out across the UK in the wake of the Southport attack on 29 July last year, in which three young girls were murdered.Axel Radukabana was jailed for a minimum of 52 years for carrying out the attack.
The board said the three posts, which contained a range of anti-Muslim sentiment, incited violence and showed support for the riots, “created the risk of likely and imminent harm” and should have been taken down.It added that Meta had been too slow to implement crisis measures as riots broke out across the UK.The first post, which was eventually taken down by Meta, was text-only and called for mosques to be smashed as well as buildings where “migrants“ and “terrorists” lived to be set on fire.The second and third posts featured AI-generated images of a giant man in a union jack T-shirt chasing Muslim men, and of four Muslim men running after a crying blond toddler in front of the Houses of Parliament, with one of the men wielding a knife.The board added that changes to Meta’s guidance in January meant users could now attribute behaviours to protected characteristic groups, for example, people defined by their religion, sex, ethnicity or sexuality, or based on someone’s immigration status.
As a consequence, users can say a protected characteristic group “kill”, said the board.It added that third-party factcheckers, which are still being used by Meta outside the US, had reduced the visibility of posts spreading a false name of the Southport attacker.It recommended the company research the effectiveness of community notes features – where users police content on platforms – which are also being deployed by Meta after the removal of US factcheckers.“Meta activated the crisis policy protocol (CPP) in response to the riots and subsequently identified the UK as a high-risk location on August 6.These actions were too late.
By this time, all three pieces of content had been posted,” the board said.“The board is concerned about Meta being too slow to deploy crisis measures, noting this should have happened promptly to interrupt the amplification of harmful content.”In response to the board’s ruling, a Meta spokesperson said: “We regularly seek input from experts outside of Meta, including the oversight board, and will act to comply with the board’s decision.“In response to these events last summer, we immediately set up a dedicated taskforce that worked in real time to identify and remove thousands of pieces of content that broke our rules – including threats of violence and links to external sites being used to coordinate rioting.”Meta said it would respond to the board’s wider recommendations within 60 days.
The board ruling also ordered the removal of two anti-immigrant posts in Poland and Germany for breaching Meta’s hateful conduct policy.It said Meta should identify how updates to its hateful content policy affect the rights of refugees and asylum seekers.
Daniel Dubois dismisses Oleksandr Usyk’s ‘mind games’ before showdown
Daniel Dubois has warned Oleksandr Usyk that none of the mind games will matter when they step into the ring for their heavyweight title unification contest and suggested the Ukrainian would simply not be able to “handle the pain” when they meet at Wembley on 19 July.On Tuesday afternoon, Dubois and Usyk presented a compelling study in contrast as, in separate conversations to officially launch the fight, the two men echoed the differences between them that had already been made plain 24 hours earlier.During a face-off on the Wembley pitch on Monday afternoon, the normally mild-mannered Dubois had shoved Usyk, who responded, after his initial surprise, by bursting into laughter. Dubois, the IBF champion, shook his head when asked if his actions had been premeditated. “No, it was just one of them things,” he said
Fine forecast as Women’s State of Origin goes from strength to strength | Jack Snape
A forecast for clear skies for Brisbane on Thursday has players and officials optimistic that women’s rugby league will launch itself into a new era of prominence in the first match of this year’s Women’s State of Origin.Last year’s series featured three contests for the first time, unprecedented television ratings and record crowds, but each clash was affected by inclement weather, giving rise to hopes of even larger attendances in 2025.Maroons’ forward Jess Elliston said the example of a near-capacity crowd in game two last year in Newcastle despite heavy rain showed fans were now committed to the women’s game.“Even though we were getting booed like all shit, it was the most insane atmosphere I’ve ever been to, you couldn’t hear anyone,” she said. “My chest was rattling from the booing, which was just so cool
No criminal charges to be brought over death of ice hockey player Adam Johnson
No criminal charges will be brought against an ice hockey player arrested on suspicion of manslaughter after the death of Adam Johnson, with the Crown Prosecution Service deciding there was no realistic chance of a conviction.The Nottingham Panthers player died of a neck injury from a skate after a collision with Sheffield Steelers’ Matt Petgrave in a match in October 2023. The Panthers described the incident at the time as a “freak accident”. CPR was administered on the ice at the Sheffield Arena, but Johnson died from his injuries.Petgrave was put on police bail, but after an 18-month investigation the CPS said it had now closed the case
Nat Sciver-Brunt named England Women’s captain and vows to empower team
Nat Sciver-Brunt has said she will empower her players to be the “best version of themselves” after being appointed as the new captain of the England women’s team. As first reported last week, the 32-year-old all-rounder has stepped up to fill the vacancy left by Heather Knight’s departure in March, the first appointment by the new head coach, Charlotte Edwards.Sciver-Brunt, who is on parental leave after her wife, the former England seamer Katherine Sciver-Brunt, gave birth, said: “I’m really proud to take on the role and it’s an honour to have been asked by Charlotte, someone I’ve always looked up to.“I will try my best to lead this team to success, whilst empowering them to be the best version of themselves. We have a really talented group, and we have a group that’s united
The Breakdown | Red Roses triumph again but cannot afford another World Cup wobble
Seven straight Six Nations titles is impressive but rivals may have been encouraged by the nervous finish against FranceThere are two contrasting schools of thought after England’s grand-slam clinching win against France on Saturday. According to John Mitchell, the Red Roses’ head coach, his side’s nervy 43-42 victory was ideal preparation for the World Cup this year. Alternatively, as the former England hooker Brian Moore succinctly put it during post-match TV analysis: “If they were playing New Zealand, would they have got away with that?”Between them Mitchell and Moore know plenty about World Cup disappointment. The former was head coach of the All Blacks side beaten in the semi-finals of the 2003 men’s tournament in Australia. Moore was part of the England team edged out by the Wallabies in the final in 1991
Marathon great Des Linden’s last dance: what happens when an 18-year career ends?
One of America’s greatest distance runners is excited about the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead after a job she modestly describes as ‘cushy’There is no better word to describe Des Linden’s 18-year professional career than consistent. No matter the race, weather, or competition, she always showed up with her best – and the results back it up. A two-time Olympian, winner of the 2018 Boston Marathon, and world record-holder in the 50k, Linden is one of America’s greatest ever distance runners. But like any good thing, her career can’t last for ever.“This will be my last time racing Boston in the professional field,” Linden said a few weeks before this year’s race
M&S cyber-attack linked to hacking group Scattered Spider
Amazon denies planning to publish tariff costs on main site, as White House blasts ‘hostile and political’ act – as it happened
Elon Musk’s Doge conflicts of interest worth $2.37bn, Senate report says
Self-service tills: a bleeping pain or brilliant? | Letters
Stick or twist? England’s selectors weigh up options for Zimbabwe Test
Saints’ Phil Dowson fears Premiership clubs ‘sleepwalking’ towards financial crisis