Carter Hart’s return shows hockey’s redemption machine never stops
On Thursday, the Vegas Golden Knights announced that goaltender Carter Hart will join the team on a professional tryout contract.Hart was one of five former Team Canada World Junior players initially charged with sexual assault stemming from an incident in 2018, and, though acquitted earlier this year, remains suspended by the NHL until 1 December.In a statement about Hart’s contract signing, the Golden Knights said that the team remains “committed to the core values that have defined our organization from its inception” and that the team expects “that our players will continue to meet these standards moving forward”.Which sounds all well and good, but there’s a difference between expecting someone to meet a standard and maintaining it – or even enforcing it.It’s not surprising that Hart is back on the ice in the NHL.
For one thing, he was indeed acquitted, along with the other four accused, which is technically grounds for readmittance, whether one agrees with the ruling or not.For the league, the union, and the teams, the story is – or can be – relatively simple: a player cleared by the courts is ready for a comeback.But the real reason Hart’s return will strike many as unsurprising is because, well, this is just how hockey works.That is, yes, everyone can talk about values and standards and expectations, but in reality hockey is still driven by silence.The 2018 sexual assault scandal was neither an isolated incident nor unprecedented.
Shortly after the Team Canada story broke, the Canadian Hockey League and its member major junior leagues publicized the findings of an independent review panel examining its hazing, bullying, harassment, and abuse policies.The panel determined that the leagues and its teams have “a systemic or ‘culture of embedded behaviours’, where off-ice misconduct is perpetuated, condoned, or ill-addressed” and that a “code of silence” existed when it came to reporting misconduct.As the allegations surrounding the 2018 Team Canada players swirled, it also emerged that Hockey Canada, the country’s national governing body for the sport, had paid out $2.9m in settlements in 2022.And just a year prior, the same code of silence was revealed when former Chicago Blackhawks player Kyle Beach came forward as the player at the center of sexual abuse allegations against the team in 2010.
Beach alleged that he’d been sexually assaulted by one of the Blackhawks’ then-video coach Brad Aldrich.A follow-up report found that, though Beach informed the team of his allegation, and the information was discussed in a meeting that included the general manager, Stan Bowman, and head coach, Joel Quenneville, nothing happened for three weeks – until after the Blackhawks had won the Cup.Much like with Hart, the men at the center of that scandal went away – but not for long.After stepping down from his role as general manager in Chicago, Bowman was hired three years later, in 2024, by the Edmonton Oilers and remains the general manager there.Quenneville is back behind the bench, as of May.
He’s the head coach of the Anaheim Ducks.It’s a pattern of redemption without reckoning.As for the moral question, that’s left up to the fans.The NHL and hockey more broadly makes what it might simply call a business decision – even cynically, perhaps, seeing an opportunity for a cut-rate contract – and moves on, leaving its supporters to sort out the ethics of it all, or to do the mental gymnastics of separating the player from the person.The case of the Team Canada players was billed as a reckoning for hockey – finally.
In the end, the case itself, and the judge’s ruling, made a clear line of justice difficult to draw.And so, yet again, no reckoning.The so-called watersheds come and go, the turning points lead to the same place.The behavior, the pattern, remains.A scandal, a moment of reflection, then a quiet reabsorbing of those involved back into hockey’s ecosystem.
The machinery of hockey, from development to junior to pro, protects itself.The game goes ahead and change, when it happens, feels incidental rather than intentional.Hart was acquitted, that’s true.Legally, he bears no criminal responsibility.He has the right to rebuild his career.
But what the courts decide and what a sport chooses to celebrate or reward are not the same thing,Neither is acquittal equal to absolution,Acquittal doesn’t negate the power imbalances that shaped the case,And it doesn’t delete the learned behaviour that makes these situations seemingly so common – the kind that teaches young athletes that consent may be negotiable, or that group loyalty outweighs empathy, or that success is a sanitizer,The accused in this case were found not guilty, that is not up for debate.
Still, being legally innocent and being ethically fit for a role are two different things,The court may have had its say, but hockey’s silence, as usual, speaks louder,
‘A foot out in the cold’: leaders huddle at IMF as icy economic winds blow
“The security blanket is covering us, but maybe we have a foot out in the cold.” That was the typically colourful warning from the International Monetary Fund’s managing director, Kristalina Georgieva, this week to its gathering of finance ministers in Washington.At its spring meetings in April, the IMF said the erratic trade policies emanating from the White House, half a mile away from its glass and steel HQ, amounted to a “major negative shock” for the global economy.Since then, experts’ worst fears have not materialised – global growth has held up; frantic negotiations, agile manufacturers and new trading links have prevented supply chains collapsing.But the US economy has been cushioned against the full effects of the trade shift by the AI mega-boom – and the IMF issued a clear warning this week that it may not last
What could a Trump deal on critical minerals mean for Australia – and could Maga be a sticking point?
Australia’s rich deposits of minerals used for green energy technologies and military hardware are increasingly prized, especially because of rising anxiety about China’s stranglehold on the global supply chain.That anxiety escalated after Beijing imposed new restrictions on rare earths exports, prompting a furious rebuke from Donald Trump and a warning from his treasury secretary that western allies would need to “decouple” from China if it proved an unreliable supplier.The timing of the latest US-China trade conflict could be good for Anthony Albanese, who will arrive at next week’s White House meeting armed with a valuable bargaining chip to negotiate with the deal-making president.The Australian government is expected to offer the US access to a proposed critical minerals stockpile, amid wider attempts to shield the country from the worst of Trump’s trade strikes and secure the Aukus submarine deal.But one expert thinks the critical minerals fight puts Australia in a “really compromised position”, caught between the competing priorities of its strongest strategic ally and its biggest trading partner
Olivia Williams says actors need ‘nudity rider’-type controls for AI body scans
Actors should have as much control over the data harvested from scans of their body as they do over nudity scenes, the actor Olivia Williams has said, amid heightened concern over artificial intelligence’s impact on performers.The star of Dune: Prophecy and The Crown said she and other actors were regularly pressed to have their bodies scanned by banks of cameras while on set, with few guarantees about how the data would be used or where it would end up.“A reasonable request would be to follow the precedent of the ‘nudity rider’,” she said. “This footage can only be used in the action of that scene. It cannot be used in any other context at all, and when the scene has been edited it must be deleted on all formats
‘Legacies condensed to AI slop’: OpenAI Sora videos of the dead raise alarm with legal experts
Last night I was flicking through a dating app. One guy stood out: “Henry VIII, 34, King of England, nonmonogamy”. Next thing I know, I am at a candlelit bar sharing a martini with the biggest serial dater of the 16th century.But the night is not over. Next, I am DJing back-to-back with Diana, Princess of Wales
Premier League team news: predicted lineups for the weekend action
Saturday 12.30pm TNT Sports 1 Venue City GroundReferee Chris Kavanagh This season G6 Y20 R0 3.33 cards/gameSubs from Gunn, Victor, Murillo, Boly, Zinchenko, Sangaré, Douglas Luiz, McAtee, Domínguez, Awoniyi, Kalimuendo, Hudson-Odoi, Bakwa, Hutchinson, Igor JesusDoubtful Wood (knee)Injured Aina (hamstring, Dec)Suspended NoneForm DLLDLL Leading scorer Wood 2Subs from Slonina, Jörgensen, James, Hato, Acheampong, Santos, Buonanotte, Fofana, Guiu, Estêvão, George, Mheuka, Gittens, WalshDoubtful Neto (knock), Fernández (knee)Injured Palmer (groin, Dec), Badiashile (muscle, Dec), Delap (hamstring, Dec), Essugo (thigh, unknown), Colwill (knee, unknown)Suspended Mudryk (indefinite)Form WWDLLW Leading scorer Caicedo, Fernández 3Saturday 3pm Venue Amex StadiumReferee Craig Pawson This season G4 Y9 R1 2.5 cards/gameSubs from Steele, McGill, Veltman, Coppola, Boscagli, De Cuyper, Milner, Watson, Rutter, Tzimas, KostoulasDoubtful Gómez (thigh), Mitoma (knock), Veltman (calf)Injured March (knee, Dec), Gruda (knee, unknown), Hinshelwood (ankle, unknown), Webster (knee, unknown)Suspended NoneForm LWLDWD Leading scorer Welbeck 2Subs from Ramsdale, Schär, Lascelles, Krafth, Willock, Ramsey, Miley, Osula, MurphyDoubtful Joelinton (groin), Osula (ankle)Injured Hall (hamstring, Nov), Wissa (knee, Nov), Livramento (Knee, Dec)Suspended NoneForm LDWDLW Leading scorer Woltemade 3Saturday 3pm Venue Turf MoorReferee Tim Robinson This season (Championship) G2 Y11 R0 5.5 cards/gameSubs from Hladky, Weiss, Sonne, Roberts, Delcroix, Ekdal, Worrall, Humphreys, Pires, Ugochukwu, Mejbri, Bruun Larsen, Edwards, Trésor, Broja, Barnes, Banel, Flemming, AgyeiDoubtful Anthony (thigh), Foster (dead leg)Injured Beyer (hamstring, unknown), Roberts (achilles, unknown), Amdouni (ACL, unknown)Suspended NoneForm WLLDLL Leading scorer Anthony 4Subs from Perri, Meslier, Bijol, Bornauw, Justin, Tanaka, Gruev, Harrison, James, Piroe, NmechaDoubtful Perri (thigh), James (ankle), Okafor (adductor)Injured Gnonto (groin, Nov), Gray (hip, Nov)Suspended NoneForm LDLWDL Leading scorer Okafor 2Saturday 3pm Venue Selhurst ParkReferee Jarred Gillett This season G5 Y15 R1 3
‘Illusion of democracy’: Ben Sulayem’s last rival exits FIA presidential race
The FIA has been accused of presenting an “illusion of democracy” in an uncompromising broadside from the last remaining challenger to Mohammed Ben Sulayem as he formally announced his attempt to succeed the organisation’s incumbent president was over. Tim Mayer, a former FIA senior steward, also condemned Formula One’s governing body for lacking transparency and threatening the sport’s future.The 59-year-old American, who was sacked from his FIA role last year, had been standing as a candidate against Ben Sulayem but on Friday in Austin acknowledged the incumbent would run unopposed because of the way FIA electoral regulations are composed.“There will be only one candidate, the incumbent,” Mayer said. “That’s not democracy – that’s the illusion of democracy
‘Inspiring’ Lewis Moody will make it a day of emotion at Leicester-Bath clash
Your Guardian sport weekend: Premier League returns, F1 in the US and World Cup cricket
‘Great day for the region’: York join Toulouse in 14-team Super League
The beautiful stroll: England’s seniors take walking football to world stage
Owen Farrell to miss out on England recall for autumn internationals
Sadia Kabeya: ‘Meeting others in rugby who look like me brought me out of my shell – I can be myself now’