Restrained Pant struggles as India’s new safety-first style fails to suit situation

Restrained Pant struggles as India’s new safety-first style fails to suit situation | Andy Bull

about 16 hours ago

Turns out Rishabh Pant is a dab hand at doing impressions.At Edgbaston he showed off his new one, of the batter his coaches would like him to be.Pant was, by the standards of his own scatterbrained batting, a model of self-control, and restricted himself to just one glorious four and a single crisp, delicious six in the 60 minutes or so he was at the crease.They were good ones, a roly-poly sweep off Shoaib Bashir and a skip down the pitch to punch another of his deliveries over long-on, but otherwise Pant restrained himself to showing off his range of ascetic leaves, blocks and defensive shots.There was, it’s true, the odd moment or two when he nearly broke character.

He couldn’t help himself but come running out to try to belt one of the first balls bowled by Chris Woakes after tea over the road into the botanical gardens.He seemed to change his mind midway through his swing, and ended up scuffing it away for a single, like a kid reaching his hand out to grab a cookie and then yanking it back again as they remember the promise they’d made to their parents.The crowd in the Hollies Stand actually started booing every time he blocked one, as if they wanted to goad him into playing the hits.Eventually Pant snapped and tried to hit Bashir for another six.But Bashir took a little pace off the ball so Pant didn’t catch it cleanly, and ended up being caught by Zak Crawley five yards in from the boundary.

The problem is that Bashir’s bowling is just too damn tempting,He has taken four wickets in this series now, and every one of them has been caught in the deep,His Test career is turning into an advanced course on how to bowl when you’re being battered to all corners,It all felt very different to the last Test on this ground, back in 2022,Back then, Pant smacked 146 off 111 balls in the first innings, then 57 off 86 in the second, and, even though England were on the wrong end, Ben Stokes enjoyed it all so much that he said afterwards how well he felt Pant would fit into his England team.

And in the idle hours of a slow second session, it was easy to wonder exactly what it would be like to watch Pant bat if he was on England’s side rather than his own.Whatever else is hypothetical about it, you can be sure that one thing Stokes and coach Brendon McCullum wouldn’t be telling him to do is to try to play more defensively.India, though, have retrenched ahead of this game.They have taken on the character of their coach, Gautam Gambhir, a fighting batter who once battled seven hours for 137 runs to save a draw against New Zealand.Their captain, Shubman Gill, scored a fine century off 199 balls, batting like a prefect who had just been on the wrong end of the headmaster’s lecture about leadership.

They have left out their two scariest bowlers, Jasprit Bumrah and Kuldeep Yadav, and packed the side with three all-rounders, Nitish Kumar Reddy, Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja, in an attempt to bolster their batting without compromising on their bowling options.Reddy turned out to be Unready.He was cleaned up for one trying to leave a ball which hit the top of his off stump.The decision to pick him alongside Sundar was such a strikingly odd decision that Gambhir ought to be under heavy pressure, his team having won only three Tests out of 11 since he took over.But given that he used to be an MP for the Bharatiya Janata Party, and the BCCI are utterly intertwined with the political party, India’s board has given him their full support.

The safety-first style doesn’t especially suit India, and more importantly, it doesn’t especially suit the situation they’re in either.There isn’t a batter in the game who wants to face Bumrah or an English one ever born who enjoys facing the sort of left-arm wrist spin Yadav deals in.If the genie gave England three wishes this week, the first would have been for India to rest Bumrah, the world’s best bowler, the second would have been to leave out Yadav, who has taken 43 wickets at an average of 24 each against them across formats, and the third would have been to encourage India’s top order that they ought to amble along at three runs an over.Sign up to The SpinSubscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week’s actionafter newsletter promotionAt that rate, they could bat for two days without racking up the sort of score that would make England feel outmatched, and all of the first four before they arrived at a target Stokes felt his side shouldn’t at least try for.In Gambhir’s day, a team who have made 310 for five in a day would have felt themselves well placed.

In Stokes’ one, it was hard to avoid the sense that the score left them sitting just where England want them,

technologySee all

AI companies start winning the copyright fight

Hello, and welcome to TechScape. If you need me after this newsletter publishes, I will be busy poring over photos from Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez’s wedding, the gaudiest and most star-studded affair to disrupt technology news this year. I found it a tacky and spectacular affair. Everyone who was anyone was there, except for Charlize Theron, who, unprompted, said on Monday: “I think we might be the only people who did not get an invite to the Bezos wedding. But that’s OK, because they suck and we’re cool

2 days ago

China hosts first fully autonomous AI robot football match

They think it’s all over … for human footballers at least.The pitch wasn’t the only artificial element on display at a football match in China on Saturday. Four teams of humanoid robots took on each other in Beijing, in games of three-a-side powered by artificial intelligence.While the modern game has faced accusations of becoming near-robotic in its obsession with tactical perfection, the games in China showed that AI won’t be taking Kylian Mbappé’s job just yet.Footage of the humanoid kickabout showed the robots struggling to kick the ball or stay upright, performing pratfalls that would have earned their flesh-and-blood counterparts a yellow card for diving

2 days ago

Whitehall’s ambition to cut costs using AI is fraught with risk

A Dragons’ Den-style event this week, where tech companies will have 20 minutes to pitch ideas for increasing automation in the British justice system, is one of numerous examples of how the cash-strapped Labour government hopes artificial intelligence and data science can save money and improve public services.Amid warnings from critics that Downing Street has been “drinking the Kool-Aid” on AI, the Department of Health and Social Care this week announced an AI early warning system to detect dangerous maternity services after a series of scandals, and Wes Streeting, the health secretary, said he wants one in eight operations to be conducted by a robot within a decade.AI is being used to prioritise actions on the 25,000 pieces of correspondence the Department for Work and Pensions receives each day and to detect potential fraud and error in benefit claims. Ministers even have access to an AI tool that is supposed to provide a “vibe check” on parliamentary opinion to help them weigh the political risks of policy proposals.Again and again, ministers are turning to technology to tackle acute crises that in the past might have been dealt with by employing more staff or investing more money

2 days ago

Musk vows to unseat lawmakers who support Trump’s sweeping spending bill

Elon Musk has vowed to unseat lawmakers who support Donald Trump’s sweeping budget bill, which he has criticized because it would increase the country’s deficit by $3.3tn.“Every member of Congress who campaigned on reducing government spending and then immediately voted for the biggest debt increase in history should hang their head in shame! And they will lose their primary next year if it is the last thing I do on this Earth,” he wrote on his social media platform, X.A few hours later he added that if the “insane spending bill passes, the America Party will be formed the next day”.With these threats, lobbed at lawmakers over social media, the tech billionaire has launched himself back into a rift with the US president he helped prop up

2 days ago

Gov.uk smartphone app to launch with limited functionality

A government app intended to “cut life admin” will be free to download by millions of UK citizens from Tuesday, but its functions will be limited and the cabinet minister in charge has admitted: “The design is not as we would like it to be.”The gov.uk app will be accessible on smartphones for people aged 16 and over and is intended to be the main mobile hub for many citizen interactions with the government, although not the NHS or HM Revenue and Customs.Peter Kyle, the secretary of state for science and technology, said the version launched this week would only steer users to existing government webpages, with more functionality to be added by the end of the year.A generative artificial intelligence chatbot trained on 700,000 pages of the gov

3 days ago

Microsoft says AI system better than doctors at diagnosing complex health conditions

Microsoft has revealed details of an artificial intelligence system that performs better than human doctors at complex health diagnoses, creating a “path to medical superintelligence”.The company’s AI unit, which is led by the British tech pioneer Mustafa Suleyman, has developed a system that imitates a panel of expert physicians tackling “diagnostically complex and intellectually demanding” cases.Microsoft said that when paired with OpenAI’s advanced o3 AI model, its approach “solved” more than eight of 10 case studies specially chosen for the diagnostic challenge. When those case studies were tried on practising physicians – who had no access to colleagues, textbooks or chatbots – the accuracy rate was two out of 10.Microsoft said it was also a cheaper option than using human doctors because it was more efficient at ordering tests

3 days ago

trendingSee all