Failure to compensate pelvic mesh implant victims ‘morally unacceptable’, say campaigners

A picture


The government’s failure to respond to calls for a compensation scheme for women harmed by pelvic mesh has been described as “morally unacceptable” by campaigners.Thousands of women were left with life-changing complications after receiving transvaginal mesh implants, with some unable to walk or work again.Saturday marks two years since plans for financial redress for women harmed by pelvic mesh implants were set out by England’s patient safety commissioner, Dr Henrietta Hughes.However, ministers have made no commitments to providing compensation to women harmed by the medical scandal.The plans, outlined in the 2024 Hughes report, included compensation for children left disabled as a result of their mothers using the epilepsy drug sodium valproate in pregnancy.

The government recently admitted that there was still no timetable to provide compensation for victims affected by pelvic mesh and valproate.Hughes has now pledged to take the matter directly to the prime minister.Campaigners have said the lack of government action is worsening the mental health of people affected by the scandals.Kath Sansom, the founder of the advocacy group Sling the Mesh, said: “As every week, month, year passes, women are getting more frustrated, upset.You can’t put their pain on hold.

A lot of them have had to give up work or reduce their hours.They’re struggling to make ends meet.We have some members, they’ve had to sell their homes and move in with elderly parents, marriages broken down …“We see those women at three in the morning trying to put up a post saying, ‘I don’t want to be here any more’ … I’m so angry that these women have their lives ruined and no one is taking accountability by giving them compensation … it’s morally unacceptable.”For years pelvic mesh was regarded as the gold standard fix for stress incontinence and prolapse in women, conditions that can occur after childbirth or as women approach menopause.“None of us were warned about the risks.

We were all told it was a gold standard surgery,” said Sansom.Surgery to remove mesh can cause serious complications, including organ injury, heavy bleeding, serious infection, and leg and lung clots, with surgeons having compared the procedure to removing chewing gum from hair.The Hughes report was commissioned directly in response to the First Do No Harm review led by Julia Cumberlege, which outlined nine recommendations for delivering justice to women harmed by pelvic mesh, the epilepsy drug sodium valproate and the hormone pregnancy test Primodos.The Labour MP Sharon Hodgson, whose mother experienced debilitating pain and constant infections after a pelvic mesh implant, described the government inaction as “insulting”.“No government response to the Hughes report after two long years since its publication is insulting to the thousands of mesh- and valproate-harmed women and children.

This is more than just a response to a report; this is about restorative justice.”Hodgson, who chairs the First Do No Harm all party parliamentary group, added: “All of these women and the families, they were all gaslit.They were all told it was all in their heads: ‘There’s nothing wrong with you.’ And the women who would have children damaged by valproate, again, they [doctors] went: ‘Oh, this drug’s safe.’ So they’ve had years of being gaslit.

“This compensation would say loud and clear that this was not all in your head.It was not your fault.And what happened was wrong.”Hughes said: “These are not abstract policy questions; they are about real people whose lives have been fundamentally changed by systemic failures in healthcare.Every month of delay compounds the injustice these patients have already endured.

“I will be approaching No 10 directly to secure the commitment to action that has been missing for two years.”A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: “We recognise the significant impact that sodium valproate and pelvic mesh have had on people and their families.“This is a complex issue and our priority is to ensure any response is fair, balanced and sensitive to those affected.We are carefully considering the recommendations within the Hughes report, in collaboration with relevant departments, and we aim to provide an update in due course.”The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know.

If you have something to share on this subject, you can contact us confidentially using the following methods:The Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories,Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs,This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said,If you don’t already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu,Select ‘Secure Messaging’.

If you don’t need a high level of security or confidentiality you can email investigations.contact@theguardian.com.Finally, our guide at theguardian.com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.

trendingSee all
A picture

Mandelson revelations show need for tougher UK constraints to resist rule of the rich | Heather Stewart

Peter Mandelson’s personal disgrace is deep and unique, and may yet bring down a prime minister – but by laying bare the dark allure of the “filthy rich”, it also underlines the need for tougher constraints on money in politics.It is hard to know what system or process could have shielded sensitive government decisions from the risk that a senior cabinet minister might nonchalantly pass on the details to a friend, the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.But Epstein’s efforts to influence government policy – working to water down Alistair Darling’s bonus tax at a time when the banks had crashed the British economy, for example – underline the powerful forces with which politicians are faced.One bulwark against this is the expectation that most will display a probity and strength of character Mandelson clearly lacked.The Bank of England governor, Andrew Bailey, spoke for many on Thursday when he unfavourably compared the disgraced Mandelson with the late Alistair Darling

A picture

Thinking of trashing a small business on social media? Please, think again | Gene Marks

A viral Reddit post mocks a $22 grilled cheese sandwich and helps to sink a Bay Area shop. A restaurant owner is forced to push back on a viral complaint. A small business owner in Maine faces a viral backlash after posting a “No ICE” sign. The owner of a furniture store mistakenly receives backlash after being confused with another store. An influencer calls out a South Carolina boutique in a TikTok video after a negative shopping experience

A picture

‘I fell into it’: ex-criminal hackers urge Manchester pupils to use web skills for good

Cybercriminals, the shadowy online figures often depicted in Hollywood movies as hooded villains capable of wiping millions of pounds off the value of businesses at a keystroke, are not usually known for their candour.But in a sixth-form college in Manchester this week, two former hackers gave the young people gathered an honest appraisal of what living a life of internet crime really looks like.The teenagers in the room are listening intently, but the day-to-day internecine disputes they hear about is not the stuff of screenplays.“It’s just people getting into these online dramas and they’re swatting and doxing each other and getting people to throw bricks through their windows,” one of the hackers says.If the language sounds unfamiliar, it should – “swatting” and “doxing” involve people outing each other online by posting their genuine identities – but their message is clear: though cybercrime may seem alluring, the reality is anything but

A picture

Battle of the chatbots: Anthropic and OpenAI go head-to-head over ads in their AI products

The Seahawks and the Patriots aren’t the only ones gearing up for a fight.AI rivals Anthropic and OpenAI have launched a war of ads trying to court corporate America during one of the biggest entertainment nights of the year.Ahead of the Super Bowl, Anthropic has launched a series of ads going hard at its rival.For the scrawny 23-year-old who wants a six-pack, a ripped older man who is supposed to depict a chatbot suggests insoles that “help short kings stand tall” because “confidence isn’t just built in the gym”. And for the man trying to improve communication with his mom: his therapist prescribes “a mature dating site that connects sensitive cubs with roaring cougars” in case he can’t fix that relationship

A picture

Super Bowl 2026: Seattle Seahawks 29-13 New England Patriots – as it happened

Thank you!That will do it for our live coverage of the 60th NFL Super Bowl. Another season is all over, but don’t worry fans, soon it will be draft time, then free agency, training camp, and before you know it, they’ll be right back at it, beating the living crap out of each other in the heat of September and in the chill of November. We can’t wait! From all of us at the Guardian, thanks for sticking with us, emailing in and following along. And wherever you are, good morning, good afternoon and good night.MVPKenneth Walker III is the MVP! It’s always a bit surprising when the QB doesn’t get it, but it’s deserving

A picture

Winter Olympics 2026: USA take gold in figure skating team event – as it happened

You can read a full report from Sunday’s action here:Final team standings69 USA 68 Japan 60 Italy 56 Georgia 54 CanadaMen’s standings200.03 Malinin (USA) 194.86 Sato (JPN) 179.62 Rizzo (ITA) 171.93 Gogolev (CAN) 154