Give terminally ill people choice in how they die, MSP urges Scottish parliament

A picture


Scottish politicians have been urged to show terminally ill people compassion and choice in how they die as they began to debate a new law to permit assisted dying.Liam McArthur, a Scottish Liberal Democrat MP, said too many dying people faced “horrendous choices and bad deaths”, including unregulated suicides or prolonged trauma because they were denied the right to an assisted death.The Scottish parliament is preparing for what may be a knife-edge vote later on Tuesday on whether to start scrutinising an assisted dying bill proposed by McArthur, days before MPs at Westminster vote on passing similar legislation for England and Wales.In an emotional opening speech to MSPs, McArthur said voting to block the bill at this early stage, before it is fully considered, would deny choice to the terminally ill, and prevent Holyrood passing a measured and compassionate law.He said more than 300 million people worldwide lived in countries where assisted dying was legal and working fairly, while closer to home the Isle of Man had passed assisted dying laws and Jersey was close to doing so.

“It is the voices of dying Scots and their families that must be at the heart of today’s debate,” he said, promising to accept many proposed amendments, including fixing the age at 18 and over, and tighter scrutiny and monitoring.“We can’t continue to leave this issue in the ‘too difficult’ box.That would be unforgivable.”Before McArthur spoke, about 60 disability rights activists who oppose the bill heard the Silent Witness actor Liz Carr urge MSPs to reject it during a rally outside Holyrood.She said disabled people were not immune to arguments about the pain and suffering some terminally ill suffered.

“We know these stories, we know about pain, we know about suffering,” she told the rally.“So we also have the wisdom to say we can live good lives, but we need the resources, we need the support, we need the social care, the health care, the welfare reform, the accessibility and the bloody attitudes to look at us and go, actually, you can be an older person, an ill person, a disabled person and have value.”A number of prominent Scottish party leaders have already announced they will vote against the bill going forward, including Nicola Sturgeon, the former first minister, and the current first minister John Swinney, and Scottish Labour’s leader Anas Sarwar, and his deputy Jackie Baillie.But Russell Findlay, the Scottish Conservative leader, and his deputy Rachael Hamilton are to support it at stage one.Speaking before the debate, Findlay said he shared many reservations about the bill, which include the definition of terminal illness and protecting people against coercion, but believed it could be improved.

“I believe that those suffering from terminal illness should have the right to choose to end their lives with dignity,” he said,That argument was challenged by Edward Mountain, another Scottish Tory MSP, who said that while the bill could prevent direct coercion of the terminally ill, it could not prevent passive coercion or coercion by the state,Too many Scots could not access proper palliative care, and could not afford private care,That may coerce them into assisted suicide, to cut costs and stress,And the drugs used to end life could also cause distress, he claimed.

“This parliament has a duty to make it easier to choose life, rather than making it easier to die, which is what this bill will do,” he said.But Rona Mackay, an SNP MSP and deputy convenor of Holyrood’s assisted dying all-party group, said this bill was not “a leap into the unknown.It is a cautious, evidence-based step forward.Voluntary assisted dying is founded on international best practice.[The] framework it proposes is safe, compassionate and practical.

sportSee all
A picture

From early positivity to cursing on court: how the Djokovic-Murray partnership ended | Tumaini Carayol

In the echoing surroundings of an empty Margaret Court Arena before the Australian Open in January, Novak Djokovic and Andy Murray were working through their first training session at an official tournament together. Aside from the sweet sound of tennis balls being struck between Djokovic and Carlos Alcaraz, his training partner for the day, the only audible noise was the communication between Djokovic and Murray. Their technical and tactical discussions were constant.It was a fascinating sight. After years of playing against and trying to outsmart each other from across the net, they were now charged with understanding their distinct perspectives and figuring out the best solution to ensure that Djokovic was ready to continue competing for the biggest titles in the world

A picture

England expect most players will choose country over IPL for West Indies ODIs

England expect most of the five Indian Premier League players picked for their one-day international series against West Indies to report for international duty rather than complete the rescheduled tournament.The IPL’s league phase will now conclude on 27 May, two days before England play their opening game against West Indies at Edgbaston, meaning that Jofra Archer and Jamie Overton, whose teams have already been eliminated from playoff contention, will certainly be free to play for their country.The playoffs begin on 29 May, with the final to take place on 3 June, the day of the final ODI. Jos Buttler, Jacob Bethell and Will Jacks, whose sides are towards the top of the table, could all find their allegiances tested, but the England and Wales Cricket Board is confident that at least the latter two will prioritise England’s first white‑ball games on home soil since Brendon McCullum took over as coach of the limited-over sides and Harry Brook as captain.It is not certain that all of the 10 English players who had been at the IPL before its suspension last week will choose to go back at all, and with some teams not playing again until next Wednesday there is still time for them to make up their minds

A picture

Court urged to jail Jakob Ingebrigtsen’s father for ‘regime of repeated abuse’

The father of the Norwegian track and field superstar Jakob Ingebrigtsen should go to prison for two and a half years for “a regime of repeated abuse” that spanned a decade, prosecutors have told a court in Norway.Summing up the state’s case, the prosecutor Angjerd Kvernenes said that Jakob and his sister, Ingrid, had suffered physical and mental abuse at the hands of their father and former coach, Gjert, which began when Jakob was seven years old.In her closing arguments, Kvernenes reminded the court that Jakob, who won the Olympic 1500m title in Tokyo before winning 5,000m gold in Paris, had described how he had been punched and kicked by his father when he was still at primary school.“Jakob has explained about fear, about unpredictability, and about how the repeated blows to his head when he was seven and a half years old have affected him further in his upbringing,” she said. “The extent has been so great that Jakob has lived under a regime of repeated abuse over time

A picture

Olympic wrestling champion Kyle Snyder arrested in Ohio prostitution sting

Olympic wrestling champion Kyle Snyder was one of more than a dozen people arrested as part of a prostitution sting in Ohio.Police in Columbus conducted an operation aimed at reducing prostitution in the city on Friday, and the 29-year-old Snyder was arrested in a hotel room for engaging in prostitution. He was released from custody at the scene.Columbus police spokesperson Caitlyn McIntosh said officers had posted online ads last week to “solicit others to engage in sexual activity for hire”. Police said a man later identified as Snyder had replied to one of the postings and arranged to meet at a local hotel

A picture

The Mavs’ Cooper Flagg lottery miracle fuels conspiracy theories – and hope

Trading away Luka Dončić made Nico Harrison a reviled figure among Dallas fans. Now he has an unexpected chance to redeem himself Dallas is ground zero for one of America’s most historic conspiracy theories. Just half a mile from the grassy knoll where John F Kennedy was assassinated on 22 November 1963, sits the American Airlines Center – the newest site of Dallas conspiracy lore.While this year’s NBA draft lottery took place in Chicago on Monday night, the heart of the drama haunts Dallas. Mavericks general manager Nico Harrison’s career lives to see another day after his team improbably beat 1

A picture

Draper survives dramatic Moutet tussle to reach Italian Open quarter-final

Forty minutes into his dramatic, anxiety-filled fourth‑round tussle with Corentin Moutet in Rome, Jack Draper still had just one game to his name. In the face of one of the most cunning, varied players on the tour, he was completely disconcerted. He did not know what to do. Draper spent almost the entirety of the short break between sets shouting encouragement at himself.Draper responded to the adversity with an exhibition of his growing mental strength and inner belief as he found a way into the quarter-finals with a 1-6, 6-4, 6-3 win