Disabled woman killed herself after DWP mistakenly withdrew benefits
A disabled woman killed herself after her benefits were mistakenly stopped leaving notes saying she had no food, could not pay bills and was in “debt, debt, debt”,At a rare second inquest into the death of Jodey Whiting, her mother blamed the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) for her suicide in 2017,Joy Dove told the hearing in Middlesbrough: “I know for a fact,It was the DWP that caused it … I’m sorry, I’ve got to say it,”A coroner, Clare Bailey, recorded a conclusion of suicide which, she said, had been precipitated by the mistaken withdrawal of benefits by the DWP.
Afterwards Dove said it was not a one-off failing by the DWP.“The way they have treated some of their most vulnerable claimants is absolutely disgraceful.”She added: “It should not have taken an eight-year fight for justice to get where we are today.It has been an uphill battle to get answers and accountability.”Merry Varney, a solicitor for Leigh Day, representing Whiting’s family, said the cause of death was the same for many other families: “The DWP.
”Whiting, a mother of nine, was 42 and housebound – unable to walk even a few steps – when she took her own life, the inquest heard.It followed the stopping of her employment and support allowance because, the DWP said, she had failed to attend a medical assessment.She was deemed fit to work and was told she would also lose her housing and council tax benefits.Dove said the reason why she had not attended was because she had been in hospital with pneumonia at the time.She recalled seeing her daughter “shaking and crying”, feeling ashamed and embarrassed and saying she had lost hope of ever getting her benefits back.
Dove said she was sure that the stress of losing her benefits was the trigger for her daughter to decide to take her own life,“I know my daughter and I know it was [that],”The first inquest into Whiting’s death lasted 37 minutes, her family said, and heard no evidence relating to the DWP decision,Dove has fought a long and relentless legal battle for a second, fuller inquest, going all the way to the court of appeal,That took place at Teesside magistrates court on Monday with the inquest hearing of Whiting’s physical and mental health problems which included chronic pain, making her dependent on opiates.
Dove described her daughter as “the most caring person ever”, the “perfect daughter” and someone “not afraid to show her feelings”.Extracts from notes found alongside prescription drugs in Whiting’s flat in Stockton-on-Tees were read in court.Bridget Dolan KC, the coroner’s counsel, said: “She wrote about not being able to pay her bills and having no food.“In some she wrote about feeling breathless and having back pain and trying to pay her bills and being in debt.”Another note stated: “I have had enough.
” One note ended with the words: “Debt, debt, debt.”An independent case examiner report on the decision to remove Whiting’s benefits found that mistakes had been made and her payments should not have been withdrawn.Helga Swidenbank, a director at the DWP responsible for accessibility and disability services, said the department should have recognised that Whiting had “good cause” not to attend a health assessment, given her illnesses and mental health concerns.She said opportunities were missed to identify Whiting’s vulnerabilities and people who worked for the department at the time were “deeply regretful and very sorry” for what happened.Swidenbank was not at the department in 2017 but said she thought staff were not as “tuned into mental health disabilities” as they should have been.
She added: “I understand that there is a culture shift from being process-driven to being much more compassionate.”The department’s processes have changed but work still needed to be done, she said.“We are a work in progress.”The coroner said she was sorry that Whiting’s family had had to “walk such a long road” and described Dove’s persistence and resilience as remarkable.She recorded a conclusion that Whiting’s death was suicide “in the context of a deteriorating mental state, precipitated by the withdrawal of state benefits”.
But she said she had heard of many changes and new structures at the DWP which left her satisfied that no wider recommendations were needed.In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie.In the US, you can call or text the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline on 988, chat on 988lifeline.
org, or text HOME to 741741 to connect with a crisis counselor.In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14.Other international helplines can be found at befrienders.org
The ones we love: all 16 of REM’s albums – ranked!
The REM album that REM appeared to hate: guitarist Peter Buck called it unlistenable, “a bunch of people so bored with the material that they can’t stand it any more”. In truth, the songs aren’t bad, but there’s something lifeless about Around the Sun: its best tracks sound infinitely better on the 2007 REM Live album.“I guess a three-legged dog is still a dog,” mused frontman Michael Stipe after drummer Bill Berry’s 1997 departure from REM. “It just has to learn to run differently.” Thus Up was heavy on synths and drum machines, muted, crepuscular – and a relative commercial failure
‘My biggest fear’: the artist spending three days banged up in a jail cell
Cell 72 will put a detained man on show for three full days and nights to confront spectators with the grim reality of confinement. Is the project exploitative or a chance to change society? A filthy mattress lies in the corner of an otherwise barren room. The only adornments here, screwed to the wall, are a metal table and a payphone. But this is no ordinary prison. Rather, it’s a north London gallery which has been temporarily converted into a humid, fetid cell
Footballer, Bachelor star … fantasy writer? The TikTok furore over Luke Bateman’s book deal
Hello Caitlin. I hear people on TikTok are up in arms over a Queensland farmer/Canberra Raiders player/Bachelor star scoring a book deal. Who is this modern day Renaissance man?Julia, a colleague described Luke Bateman’s four years with the Raiders as the one of an “honest toiler, who always played above his weight”, and to be frank, it’s a fairly apt description for the guy.The Toowoomba countryman grew up as the typical sports-playing boy. On his now famous TikTok account, he has spoken earnestly about reading books in a toilet cubicle as a child so his peers wouldn’t witness his sensitive side
Jimmy Kimmel: ‘We are living in the golden age of stupid’
Late-night hosts looked at the latest mistakes made by the Trump administration while expressing fear at the president’s sinister new portrait.On Jimmy Kimmel Live! the host spoke about how “stupid” is the through-line of both that night’s show and the moment.He said that we are “living in the golden age of stupid right now” while talking about those who refuse to believe scientific fact and the rise in measles down to fewer vaccinations.“The only thing we learned from Covid is how to make sourdough bread,” he joked and said that “people who do their own research always do it wrong”.This week has also seen Donald Trump continuing to war with Harvard and with the writer Michael Wolff after he claimed that the reason behind all of this was that the president didn’t get accepted when he applied years ago
He’s been hanged, stabbed and cut in galleries – now artist Carlos Martiel is being buried alive
In 2022 in a Los Angeles gallery, Carlos Martiel placed a noose around his neck and suspended his nude body from a rope tied to the ceiling. The piece was titled Cuerpo, Spanish for “body”, and the photographs and footage alone are shocking, mournful and distressing, as volunteers take turns holding his body aloft to prevent the real risk of asphyxiation.In conceiving the work, the Cuba-born, New York-based Afro-Latinx artist viewed hundreds of photographs of public lynchings from across the US – a brutal history of normalised extrajudicial violence that has moved artists from Billie Holiday to film-maker Steve McQueen. Those lynchings were also a kind of public performance: of terror, dehumanisation and white supremacy.“I couldn’t put into words everything I thought and felt during the development of the work; it was a very profound and intense experience for me,” Martiel says, over email
‘Tudor high drama’: English Heritage looks for descendants of abbey rebels
They included a brewer, a tailor and a shoemaker – a hardy bunch of craftspeople prepared to stand up to the might of the Tudor regime to try to save their local monastery.Exactly five centuries on, English Heritage is appealing for people who think they may be descendants of those who took part in the uprising against Cardinal Thomas Wolsey’s closure of Bayham Abbey to come forward.The idea is to get some of them together for a commemorative event this summer to mark the Bayham Abbey uprising, which took place on 4 June 1525 and is seen as a precursor to the turbulent years of religious reform that followed.Michael Carter, an English Heritage historian, described the Bayham Abbey uprising as a moment of “Tudor high drama”.He said: “It is a fascinating precursor to Henry VIII’s religious reforms – a harbinger not only of the dissolution of the monasteries 10 years later but also of the Pilgrimage of Grace, a major revolt against the reforms in the north of England in 1536 and 1537
UK sales of new Tesla cars slump by more than a third amid Musk backlash
Amazon ‘testing humanoid robots to deliver packages’
English-speaking countries more nervous about rise of AI, polls suggest
Trump family disown debut of crypto wallet: ‘I know nothing about this project!’
Peers vote to defy government over copyright threat from AI
BBC and Sky bosses criticise plans to let AI firms use copyrighted material