NHS physician associates should not diagnose untriaged patients, review finds
NHS physician associates should be banned from diagnosing patients who have not already been seen by a doctor, a government review has concluded.The review calls for the government to overhaul the role of physician associates (PAs), who it says have been substituted for doctors to fill staffing gaps despite having significantly less training.The health secretary, Wes Streeting, ordered the review of the more than 3,500 PAs and 100 anaesthesia associates (AAs) working for NHS England after six high-profile deaths of patients who were misdiagnosed by PAs.Prof Gillian Leng, the president of the Royal Society of Medicine, spoke to more than 1,000 people for the review and concluded there were “no convincing reasons to abolish the roles of AA or PA” but there was also no case “for continuing with the roles unchanged”.She wrote in the report: “Despite the significantly shorter training, PAs and to a lesser extent AAs have sometimes been used to fill roles designed for doctors.
The rationale for doing this is unclear, and was probably one of pragmatism and practicality, relying on medical staff to provide the additional expertise when required.“This lack of planning may have been responsible for driving the resentment felt by some resident [doctors] and potentially exposed patients to unnecessary risk.”One of her main recommendations is that PAs should not see “undifferentiated or untriaged patients”, meaning those who have not yet been diagnosed by a doctor.Leng recommended further work to establish which patients they should be able to see and to set clinical protocols that would enable PAs to diagnose patients with mild ailments.“Let’s be clear, [the role of PAs] is working well in some places, but there indeed has been some substitution and any substitution is clearly risky and confusing for patients,” she said.
Leng recommended PAs should be renamed “physician assistants” and AAs “physician assistants in anaesthesia” to ensure that patients and their families are clear on whether they have been seen by a doctor.She observed that this confusion was the core concern voiced by the bereaved families she had spoken to, who believed it was a contributing factor in their loved ones’ death.She noted in her report that despite the role’s rapid expansion since it was introduced in England in the early 2000s, there was limited data and evidence on whether PAs were safe or unsafe.Most concerns related to PAs being the first clinician to see patients unsupervised.“Making the wrong initial diagnosis and putting patients on an inappropriate pathway can be catastrophic,” she said.
The report found that “relatively few doctors felt it was appropriate for PAs to diagnose illness” and it identified disparities between the tasks PAs considered right for them to carry out and what doctors thought.Leng recommended that newly qualified PAs work in hospitals for two years before they are allowed to work in GP surgeries or mental health trusts, enabling them to start their careers where there are more training opportunities and supervision.She also recommended more leadership training for doctors, who shared concerns about the lack of preparation for supervision duties, and better career development for PAs and AAs.She suggested a named doctor supervise each PA, while uniforms, lanyards, badges and staff information should be standardised to “distinguish physician assistants from doctors”.Dr Tom Dolphin, the chair of the British Medical Association, said the report “laid bare the catastrophic failures in NHS leadership that have put patients at serious risk of harm”, but he argued the recommendations did not go far enough on national patient safety standards.
“Prof Leng has succeeded in exposing how NHS England introduced these roles and encouraged their expansion without any robust evidence of their safety,” he said.“The report reveals inadequate national leadership, no accountability and no attempt to listen to the concerns raised by doctors, patients and coroners.“The blurring of lines between doctors and non-doctors, aided and abetted by the GMC [General Medical Council], has been an unfolding disaster for all to see, and many doctors today will be relieved to see that they were right to raise the alarm,” Dolphin said.Dr Naru Narayanan, the president of the hospital doctors’ union, the HSCA, said: “Safety concerns will continue until a properly defined national scope is established.The review acknowledges this by calling for standardised job descriptions and clinical protocols.
This work needs to be fast-tracked.“Given how poorly these roles have been defined, and the fact physician assistants earn more after a couple of years of clinical training than resident doctors do after nearly a decade in medicine, it’s not surprising there’s been tension.We’ve got a shortage of medical training places and a limited supply of trainers.Additional support and time for senior doctors, as recommended by Prof Leng, are essential.”
Trump privately indicates he may soon fire Fed chair Jerome Powell
Donald Trump has privately indicated he is on the verge of firing the Federal Reserve chair, Jerome Powell, rattling Wall Street and renewing questions over the US central bank’s independence.The US president insisted on Wednesday that it was “highly unlikely” he would dismiss the Fed chair, after reports he had suggested he would and shown a draft letter dismissing Powell to political allies.“I don’t rule out anything, but I think it’s highly unlikely. Unless he has to leave for fraud,” said Trump. The president has recently criticized Powell for a $2
Rachel Reeves warned by City grandees not to weaken banking safeguards
Rachel Reeves has been warned by City grandees that her plan to slash financial red tape could have little benefit for British households while increasing risks in the banking industry.The chancellor used a speech to City bosses attending the annual Mansion House dinner on Tuesday to argue that in too many areas regulation was acting as a “boot on the neck of business”, as she pledged sweeping changes to help revive the economy.However, leading figures involved in Britain’s post-2008 drive to prevent a repeat of the financial crisis warned Labour against unpicking bank ringfencing – a key measure introduced after the collapse.Sir John Vickers, the architect of the UK’s ringfencing rules, deployed after the financial crisis to separate high street banking from riskier investment banking, said a wholesale retreat from the reform would be a “very bad idea”.Lord Turner, who took over as chair of the Financial Services Authority during the 2008 crash and played a leading role in the post-crisis redesign of the banking system, also warned the chancellor to proceed with caution
Ad agency WPP asked to work on campaign nudging UK savers to invest in shares
The advertising agency WPP has been asked to work up ideas for a government-endorsed advertising blitz to urge more consumers to invest in stocks through a “Tell Sid”-style campaign expected to cost tens of millions of pounds.Plans for the nationwide push were announced by chancellor Rachel Reeves on Tuesday at her Mansion House speech, as she unveiled a fresh deregulation drive meant to increase financial risk-taking across the UK to help spur growth.The government has thrown its support behind City lobbyists, which are desperate to get money out of cash accounts and into stocks, which they say will not only deliver better returns but help revive the UK stock market. It comes as the London Stock Exchange continues to lose stock market listings and floats to foreign rivals.The campaign – which the Treasury said “will help to explain the benefits of investing” – will be directed and funded by City firms including banks and investment platforms
Diageo CEO steps down after drink firm’s lacklustre performance
Diageo, which owns the Guinness and Johnnie Walker brands, is to replace its embattled chief executive, ending her rocky tenure in charge of the British alcoholic drinks firm.In a statement to the stock market, Diageo said it had begun the hunt for a successor to Debra Crew, who the company said had stepped down “by mutual agreement”.Her departure follows a lengthy period of investor disquiet about the company’s lacklustre performance under the former captain in US military intelligence.The London-based company’s chief financial officer, Nik Jhangiani, will lead the business on an interim basis and has been tipped as a frontrunner for the permanent job.The group, whose vast portfolio of labels also includes Tanquery gin and Smirnoff vodka, said it was looking at internal and external candidates
Aldi is trialling grocery delivery in Australia. We put it to the test against Coles and Woolworths
Aldi is known for its permanently discounted prices and its famously odd products sold in the middle aisle.Last week, the German-owned supermarket chain took another step into the Australian mainstream, trialling a grocery delivery service with DoorDash in Canberra ahead of a potential expansion around the country.Aldi has long resisted offering deliveries, given the service would make a basket of groceries more expensive, undercutting its price advantage over Coles and Woolworths.Guardian Australia tested it out.I normally take an ad hoc approach to grocery shopping and visit a few different stores, rather than doing a weekly shop
Diageo CEO Debra Crew steps down; UK inflation rises to 18-month high of 3.6% – as it happened
Shares in Diageo, which owns the Guinness and Johnnie Walker brands, rose by 3.5% today, making it the top riser on the FTSE 100 index, after its embattled chief executive stepped down.Debra Crew has quit with immediate effect, “by mutual agreement,” the drinks giant said. Her departure comes after investor disquiet about the company’s lacklustre market performance under the former captain in US military intelligence.Until a permanent successor is found, Nik Jhangiani, chief financial officer, will assume the role of chief executive on an interim basis
Can Trump fire Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell?
Debra Crew couldn’t shift Diageo’s post-Covid hangover
Internet-safe iPhone for children goes on sale for £99 a month
WeTransfer says user content will not be used to train AI after backlash
Australia’s selectors took a punt on Sam Konstas as Test opener – and he is left with the debt | Geoff Lemon
Edwards left with food for thought as India edge England in first women’s ODI