Vital steps to move the NHS from cure to prevention | Letters
Your articles on health inequality this week included excellent coverage of the government’s project to shift the emphasis of healthcare from treatment at the clinic and hospital to prevention through public health initiatives (Downing Street’s radical plan for the NHS: shifting it from treatment to prevention, 29 June),However, one key element is missing from the analysis that has frustrated the implementation of such necessary innovations: the way that undergraduate students are educated and socialised into medicine within longstanding conservative curricula,Historically, doctors gain an identity that is grounded in the sanctity of the “clinic” (primarily the hospital) as a well-patrolled territory with idiosyncratic rituals and language,Patients are kept on the other side of the fence,Medical education traditionally affords little work-based experience in the first two years, but after that students gain increasing exposure to clinical work.
However, this is largely focused on secondary care (hospital and clinic) settings, and on cure rather than prevention,Medical students soon learn that their professional identity construction depends on strict separation from community-based practices such as social work as they identify with the curative rituals of the clinic,Healthcare as a whole will not be able to focus on prevention, as Wes Streeting wishes, until medical students’ miseducation into the sanctity of clinical cure is addressed,This is a pedagogical challenge that must no longer pass under the radar,Dr Alan BleakleyEmeritus professor, Peninsula school of medicine, University of Plymouth Of course Denis Campbell is right to say that moving the NHS from treatment to prevention is a great idea.
The problem is, and has been for years, that finding the money for preventing ill health is apparently impossible while the NHS still has to treat ill health that wasn’t prevented.Treasury rules seem to forbid investing for future savings.Christina BaronFormer NHS trust chair Your report (29 June) on “medieval” levels of healthcare inequality affecting the poorest sections of society is borne out by the National Diabetes Foot Care Report 2022 for England.This found that people with diabetes living in the most deprived areas of England are 82% more likely to undergo a major amputation than those in the least deprived.Such a predisposition to major amputation in the circumstances of poverty contributes to a postcode lottery with a 4.
8-fold variation in major amputation rates, ranging from 3.5 to 16.8 amputations per 10,000 population with diabetes per year.People in deprived areas face economic and social barriers to care and restricted referral pathways, resulting in delayed access to specialist care.They are then too late for conventional treatment and require amputation, with all the suffering, costs and life-changing effects these have.
Thus the income and home address of people living with diabetes can contribute significantly to whether they lose or keep their legs.However, it should be possible to prevent most major amputations.Such an aspiration is in keeping with the preventive ethos of the 10-year NHS plan, which it is hoped will facilitate more rapid and equitable access to initial care in the community and prevent amputations in all people living with diabetes.Prof Michael Edmonds, Jonathan Hunt (patient), Dr Erika Vainieri and Dr Chris ManuKing’s College Hospital, London The excellent Black report on inequalities in health was commissioned by Labour in 1977 and published in 1980, by which time the Tories were in government and the report was marginalised and ultimately dismissed by them.The report recommended improvements in child benefits, childcare allowances, preschool education, school milk and meals, disablement allowances, housing and working conditions.
Nothing new there, then.We know what needs to be done to make the quality of life more equal for all of us.Anyone who lives in or is familiar with those parts of the north (and elsewhere) suffering extreme deprivation knows that things must change.The situation is intolerable.It is a blight on our so-called civilised society.
Val CooperLondon The ministerial U-turn on planned health-related benefit reforms included a welcome pledge to “listen”.They would do well to study the link between deprivation and the “lifestyle diseases” arising from obesity, smoking and excessive alcohol consumption.As well as explaining the 11-year life expectancy gap between the most and least deprived parts of the country, it is a vital but often overlooked factor in the debate over health and disability benefits.My research reveals that people in the poorest communities typically experience poor health up to 21 years earlier than those in richer areas.In Blackpool, for instance, “healthy life expectancy” is just 53.
5 years, compared to 74,7 years in Rutland,People in Blackpool are therefore far more likely to leave the workforce before state pension age – and therefore claim health and disability benefits – than those in Rutland,The government must pursue a longer-term approach to curb the rising welfare costs of poor health and disability,We need a comprehensive public health strategy to tackle the root causes of premature poor health.
For too long successive governments have shied away from bold actions around smoking, obesity and alcohol to significantly improve public health,Prof Les MayhewCity St George’s, University of London Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section,
AI helps find formula for paint to keep buildings cooler
AI-engineered paint could reduce the sweltering urban heat island effect in cities and cut air-conditioning bills, scientists have claimed, as machine learning accelerates the creation of new materials for everything from electric motors to carbon capture.Materials experts have used artificial intelligence to formulate new coatings that can keep buildings between 5C and 20C cooler than normal paint after exposure to midday sun. They could also be applied to cars, trains, electrical equipment and other objects that will require more cooling in a world that is heating up.Using machine learning, researchers at universities in the US, China, Singapore and Sweden designed new paint formulas tuned to best reflect the sun’s rays and emit heat, according to a peer-reviewed study published in the science journal Nature.It is the latest example of AI being used to leapfrog traditional trial-and-error approaches to scientific advances
Google undercounts its carbon emissions, report finds
In 2021, Google set a lofty goal of achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2030. Yet in the years since then, the company has moved in the opposite direction as it invests in energy-intensive artificial intelligence. In its latest sustainability report, Google said its carbon emissions had increased 51% between 2019 and 2024.New research aims to debunk even that enormous figure and provide context to Google’s sustainability reports, painting a bleaker picture. A report authored by non-profit advocacy group Kairos Fellowship found that, between 2019 and 2024, Google’s carbon emissions actually went up by 65%
‘A billion people backing you’: China transfixed as Musk turns against Trump
Few break-ups have as many gossiping observers as the fallout between the once inseparable Donald Trump and Elon Musk.The ill-fated bromance between the US president and the world’s richest man, which once raised questions about American oligarchy, is now being pored over by social media users in China, many of whom are Team Musk.The latest drama comes from Musk’s pledge to found a new political party, the America party, if Trump’s sweeping tax and spending bill, which Musk described as “insane” passed the Senate this week (it did). Musk had already vowed to unseat lawmakers who backed Trump’s flagship piece of legislation, which is expected to increase US national debt by $3.3tn
AI companies start winning the copyright fight
Hello, and welcome to TechScape. If you need me after this newsletter publishes, I will be busy poring over photos from Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez’s wedding, the gaudiest and most star-studded affair to disrupt technology news this year. I found it a tacky and spectacular affair. Everyone who was anyone was there, except for Charlize Theron, who, unprompted, said on Monday: “I think we might be the only people who did not get an invite to the Bezos wedding. But that’s OK, because they suck and we’re cool
China hosts first fully autonomous AI robot football match
They think it’s all over … for human footballers at least.The pitch wasn’t the only artificial element on display at a football match in China on Saturday. Four teams of humanoid robots took on each other in Beijing, in games of three-a-side powered by artificial intelligence.While the modern game has faced accusations of becoming near-robotic in its obsession with tactical perfection, the games in China showed that AI won’t be taking Kylian Mbappé’s job just yet.Footage of the humanoid kickabout showed the robots struggling to kick the ball or stay upright, performing pratfalls that would have earned their flesh-and-blood counterparts a yellow card for diving
Whitehall’s ambition to cut costs using AI is fraught with risk
A Dragons’ Den-style event this week, where tech companies will have 20 minutes to pitch ideas for increasing automation in the British justice system, is one of numerous examples of how the cash-strapped Labour government hopes artificial intelligence and data science can save money and improve public services.Amid warnings from critics that Downing Street has been “drinking the Kool-Aid” on AI, the Department of Health and Social Care this week announced an AI early warning system to detect dangerous maternity services after a series of scandals, and Wes Streeting, the health secretary, said he wants one in eight operations to be conducted by a robot within a decade.AI is being used to prioritise actions on the 25,000 pieces of correspondence the Department for Work and Pensions receives each day and to detect potential fraud and error in benefit claims. Ministers even have access to an AI tool that is supposed to provide a “vibe check” on parliamentary opinion to help them weigh the political risks of policy proposals.Again and again, ministers are turning to technology to tackle acute crises that in the past might have been dealt with by employing more staff or investing more money
Iga Swiatek glides past Collins to become live Wimbeldon contender
Crawley, Duckett and Root fall cheaply after India set England colossal 608
Ryan Moore guides Delacroix to Eclipse win and puts Oisin Murphy in the shade
Tour de France 2025: Philipsen wins stage one and takes yellow on chaotic day – as it happened
Tour de France 2025: Philipsen wins chaotic first stage as Evenepoel and Roglic suffer
Jannik Sinner barely breaks sweat to cruise through Martínez mismatch