Ethical dilemmas raised by the assisted dying bill | Letters
The opinion piece by Dave Sowry, a board member of My Death, My Decision, highlights the risks of treating autonomy as an ethical principle in isolation (I accompanied my wife to Dignitas,The Lords’ filibustering is an insult to all like her who have suffered, 3 December),While it is sad that he was widowed early, he and his wife were able to travel and make choices – choices shaped principally by fear,That does not mean the law should be altered,What his account overlooks are the thousands of patients in the UK denied genuine choice because they lack access to palliative care.
The House of Lords is rightly undertaking line‑by‑line scrutiny of the proposals, and expert testimony has raised serious concerns and widespread opposition.The current law already affords dignity and protection to vulnerable, elderly and disabled people.What we lack is sufficient palliative care and hospice provision, as repeatedly shown by Hospice UK and National Audit Office reports.Mr Sowry refers to differing moral frameworks, yet does not grasp the consequences of elevating autonomy above all other ethical principles.Healthcare staff cannot be detached from patients or the process; nor can families remain unaffected by a loved one’s decision to seek assisted suicide.
To leave poor and vulnerable people unsupported, and potentially pressured into an assisted death, would be a grave injustice,If the bill is to proceed, it should be removed from the health service – assisted suicide is not a medical treatment,Only by recognising the social context in which decisions are made can we understand why this legislation is so deeply flawed,Dr Sarah Davies Consultant physician, Old Colwyn, Conwy Dave Sowry writes: “Watching the House of Lords debate, it would be easy to forget who the bill is about,Terminally ill people should be the focus of all the deliberations.
” Mr Sowry is entitled to represent his own situation, but legislators have an obligation to consider the second-order effects of laws that are going to affect everyone.This is a classic individual v collective dilemma.Individuals with terminal illnesses who are very clear in their own mind that they want to die are disadvantaged by our current laws – but in a compassionate society oriented around trying to prevent suicide, legalising assisted suicide for terminally ill people undermines all suicide-prevention efforts.Five per cent of all deaths in Canada are now attributable to assisted suicide.Countries with state-assisted suicide programmes have seen their overall suicide rate increase.
It would become a nonsense to have suicide-prevention programmes if this bill were passed into law,Assisted suicide is not legislation that can be passed in principle and the details worked out later, when every tweak means unnecessary deaths,If supporters of the assisted dying bill are frustrated by its progress, they should have crafted a better bill,Sarah McCulloch Borehamwood, Hertfordshire Like Dave Sowry’s wife, my sister-in-law also died with the help of Dignitas,She was in the final stages of untreatable mesothelioma, and had access to the best possible palliative care, but knew that even with that, the process of dying would be frightening as she gasped for breath.
Gordon Brown (It is not too late to put the brakes on assisted dying, and focus on what is really needed, 2 December) is right to argue for more funding for hospices to make them more accessible, but that still doesn’t address the issue that people want a change in the law to allow people to make a choice about the manner and timing of their death,I am sure I am not alone in opposing the lords’ use of their unelected privilege to subvert the expressed will of those who wish to see this bill passed,We are capable of managing the risks,I have tried to convey my concerns about the lords’ obfuscation through their 1,000-plus amendments to the Speaker of the House of Lords without success,Jean Farrer Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire The data cited by Gordon Brown in his argument against assisted dying make for grim reading.
But it’s the people behind the data that matter most.A gentleman we recently spoke to said he’d have gladly accepted an assisted death while in his local hospital.For all the efforts of the staff, his pain was unmanaged.He wanted to die.Once in the care of his local hospice, though, he changed his view.
He enjoyed several more weeks with family and friends close by.That same hospice, like most, regularly turns patients away.It can’t afford to run services in line with demand.This same heartbreaking decision is happening thousands of times each year.And so while there is a legitimate discussion about the clinical limitations of palliation, we should be clear that the limiting factor on palliative care in this country is not medical science, but how the service is planned, delivered and paid for.
Hospices are collectively neutral on whether assisted dying should be an available choice,But the question which parliamentarians must reckon with, is how to guarantee, as close to practically possible, that no one makes that choice because of a fear of not getting the care they need,Charlie KingDirector of External Affairs, Hospice UK Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section,
‘True activism has to cost you something’: Bridgerton’s Nicola Coughlan on politics, paparazzi and parasocial fandom
Back in 2008, when Nicola Coughlan was at drama school, a guy in her class swaggered over and, with all the brimming confidence of young men in the noughties, asked her, “Do the Irish think the English are really cool?” Coughlan, born in Galway, mimes processing the question. “Well,” she said, “it’s quite complicated. Like, there’s a lot of history there, between the two countries. Like, there’s a lot going on.”The Guardian’s journalism is independent
From Eternity to Jamiroquai: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Eternity Out nowMiles Teller and Elizabeth Olsen star, along with Callum Turner, in a quirky metaphysical romantic drama from A24, in which, upon arriving in the afterlife, everyone must decide where, and with whom, they would like to spend eternity. Should Olsen’s character pick the man she settled down with (Teller) or her first love (Turner)?It Was Just an AccidentOut now This Palme d’Or-winning feature from Iranian director Jafar Panahi blends social realism with political commentary, as a man (Ebrahim Azizi) and his pregnant wife (Afsaneh Najmabadi), travelling with their young daughter (Delmaz Najafi), are involved in a minor car crash.Folktales Out now Documentary-makers Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady (Jesus Camp) follow a group of teens as they take a gap year at a traditional folk high school in Arctic Norway, where the emphasis is less on a traditional curriculum and more on dog sledding and survival skills.Five Nights at Freddy’s 2Out now Based on the second video game in the popular series, this sequel sees Josh Hutcherson reprising his role as night guard Mike Schmidt, and Jim Henson’s Creature Shop back on puppet duty, for this horror about animatronic critters possessed from within by unquiet souls. Catherine BrayThe CharlatansO2 Academy Leeds, 6 December; touring to 12 DecemberReleased in October, the Charlatans’ 14th album We Are Love found the indie perennials continuing to push their sound via production help from Dev Hynes
The Guide #220: The best things we watched, read and listened to this year – that weren’t from 2025
We’ve just inched into December, which of course means Christmas list season. Already, five days in, plenty of publications have shared their cultural best-ofs for 2025 – you can read the Guardian’s best books and songs of the year right now, with our countdowns in TV, film and music coming very soon.Meanwhile, many of you will have been bombarded on social media by screengrabs of your colleagues/friends/enemies’ Spotify Wrapped playlists (though Mood Machine author Liz Pelly has written pretty convincingly about why you shouldn’t share yours). This year’s Wrapped includes a “listening age” feature, which uses the release dates of the music you streamed to determine how horribly out-of-date your tastes are – revealing to some users that they are, in fact, centenarians.But there is, of course, no shame in taking a break from the deluge of new releases to catch some forgotten or not-forgotten classics
Stephen Colbert on Pete Hegseth’s Venezuela scandal: ‘Frantically pointing the finger’
Late-night hosts talked Donald Trump’s renaming of the Institute of Peace, Pete Hegseth’s ongoing Venezuela scandal and a new batch of photos from Epstein Island.Stephen Colbert opened Thursday’s Late Show with a note about the president’s meeting with leaders from the auto industry, where announced that he would do away with the guidances enacted by Joe Biden to make more electric cars. “This is a Green New Stand,” said Trump in the Oval Office. “And people were paying too much for a car that didn’t work as well … All of the nonsense is going to be taken out of the cars.”“All you need in a car is the basics, folks,” said Colbert in his Trump voice
Barbican revamp to give ‘bewildering’ arts centre a new lease of life
Project will make the famously confusing London landmark easier to navigate and more accessible“Everything leaks,” says Philippa Simpson, the director of buildings and renewal at the Barbican, who is standing outside the venue’s lakeside area and inspecting the tired-looking tiles beneath her feet.Water seeps through the cracks into the building below and serves as a reminder of the job facing Simpson and the team who are overhauling the 43-year-old landmark.The first phase of the project will cost £231m, and Simpson – who did a similar, if less daunting, job for the Young V&A in east London – hopes it will be finished in time for the 50th anniversary in 2032. The overall bill is estimated to be £451m.A mammoth task awaits her
Jimmy Kimmel on Pete Hegseth, ‘our secretary of war crimes’
Late-night hosts tore into Pete Hegseth’s Venezuelan boat blame game, Donald Trump’s cabinet meeting naps and the annual Spotify Wrapped lists.Jimmy Kimmel opened his Wednesday-evening monologue with an acknowledgement of a yearly tradition: the annual Spotify Wrapped list, documenting users’ listening habits for the year.“This Spotify, they really have it figured out,” he said. “They spy on you all year. It’s what they do
Reeves criticises budget leaks and says income tax decision taken ‘in partnership’ with PM
Badenoch criticises Farage over refusal to apologise for alleged racist remarks
Leader of Reform-run council accused of ‘authoritarian’ attempt to silence opposition
Davey claims ‘historic victory’ for Lib Dems after tokenistic vote in favour of customs union with EU – as it happened
Roy Darke obituary
Having nothing to say has never stopped Kemi holding a press conference | John Crace