Young carer who unwittingly breached allowance rules forced to repay £2,000
A young carer who had looked after her disabled mother from the age of eight was forced to repay more than £2,000 when she unwittingly breached carer’s allowance benefit earnings rules after joining a government youth employment scheme.Rose Jones, 22, said she was twice wrongly advised by her jobcentre work coach that her wages earned under the Kickstart scheme would not affect her eligibility for carer’s allowance.Less than a year after she completed the six-month scheme, under which the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) paid her wages, she received a demand from the DWP demanding she pay back £2,145 of overpaid benefits.“I was shocked when the letter arrived – it came on my 20th birthday – and I really didn’t know what to do.I thought it was a mistake because my work coach had told me it was fine.
It was a really scary letter to receive,” Jones said.The case is the latest in a stream of carer’s allowance injustices highlighted by a year- long Guardian investigation and a relatively rare case involving a young carer – most unpaid carers are much older adults.At least 144,000 UK carers are repaying more than £250m in earnings-related carer’s allowance overpayments caused by what MPs said were “human mistakes” on the part of carers and repeated DWP administrative and policy failures.Thousands of carers have been prosecuted and millions of pounds of public money wasted.The government last year vowed to reform aspects of carer’s allowance after widespread public outrage.
It commissioned an independent review of carer’s allowance overpayments which is expected to report to ministers in July,Jones began caring for her mother, who has physical and mental disabilities, at the age of eight, helping around the house and with shopping, looking out for her safety, and accompanying her to hospital appointments,Being a carer affected her childhood and education, she said: “I was always quite hesitant to be away from my mum,I’d worry about her all the time when I was at school and struggle to focus,I wouldn’t want to go on sleepovers at friends’ houses.
”When she turned 16 she started to claim carer’s allowance and it was only when she took up a place in 2021 on the DWP’s Kickstart scheme aimed at young people at risk of long term unemployment, introduced during Covid in 2020, that it became an issue.Jones said: “Before I’d accepted the job [though the Kickstart scheme] I told him [the job coach] I was on carer’s allowance and I told him the exact amounts I’d be on and that I’d be working from home so I’d be doing the same amount of caring as always.“He assured me that he was confident that my carer’s allowance would not be affected.I asked him a couple of times, not just one phone call.I checked again after a couple of months once I had started earning my wage, and he reassured me, so I thought at this point everything was fine.
”The demand, when it came, felt massively unjust,“I’d been told by the work coach it was fine,I’d been a carer for my mum all my teenage years and felt my experiences had just been disregarded,”Under Kickstart, the DWP paid employers £1,500 a month towards wages and training costs, with participants guaranteed to be paid the equivalent of 25 hours a week at the national minimum wage,In Jones’s case, this is £656 a month, which worked out for the purposes of the DWP’s earnings rule calculation at £151 a week.
Jones was taken on as a digital marketing assistant by a local firm and under carer’s allowance rules was allowed to earn up to £128 a week on top of her carer duties, equivalent to 19.5 hours at the minimum wage for 18- to 20-year-olds.Because she had unwittingly breached the weekly earnings limit, carer’s allowance rules meant she forfeited her £67.60 carer’s allowance.This “cliff edge” rule meant had she gone even £1 a week over the limit for six months she would have had to repay over £2,000.
Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionJones said she was frustrated by different branches of the DWP – the jobcentre, the employment section and the carer’s allowance unit – which did not seem to be clear on the rules and had not routinely shared information about her case.She was also shocked that the DWP had known about the earnings breach but had waited months before alerting her, allowing a debt to accrue that will take her years to repay.“It’s left me with a bit of distrust towards the DWP,” she said.Emily Holzhausen, the director of policy at Carers UK, said: “It’s devastating to see a young person who has had a more challenging start in life be badly let down by the DWP.“It’s not the first time that hard-pressed carers have been given the wrong information by people working for the DWP; the very people they trust to get the rules about benefits and entitlements right.
“The fact that the DWP’s computer systems don’t speak to each other have left many unpaid carers with unacceptable overpayments – despite the DWP having information that could have been used to stop them earlier.”A DWP spokesperson said: “We understand the huge difference carers make as well as the struggles so many face.“The carer’s allowance overpayment rate is now the lowest on record and we are increasing funding and bringing in more staff to check 100% of alerts to help prevent carers falling into debt.“But we want to go further, that’s why we’ve launched an independent review of carer’s allowance to explore how earnings-related overpayments have happened and what changes can be made.” This article was amended on 15 June 2025.
An earlier picture caption called Rose Jones Ruth,Owing to a miscalculation, it also said that she received £164 a week instead of £151 a week,
Vodafone terminates contracts of 12 franchisees who joined £120m lawsuit
Vodafone has terminated the contracts of 12 franchisees who have continued running the brand’s high street stores while also being part of a £120m high court claim against the telecoms group.The legal case was launched in December, when 62 franchisees claimed Vodafone had “unjustly enriched” itself at the expense of scores of vulnerable small business owners by slashing commissions to franchisees operating the mobile phone company’s retail outlets.A dozen of the claimants had remained in the franchise programme even though they had joined 50 former colleagues in pursuing the legal case. Some of the 62 said they had had suicidal thoughts because of the pressure exerted by the telecoms group – while many claimed the company’s actions made them fear they would lose their livelihoods, homes or life savings after running up personal debts of more than £100,000.Vodafone, which says the legal claim is worth £85
Letting banks loose is back on the agenda as UK politicians chase growth at any cost
As the old ways of turning a profit become more difficult – from assembling cars to selling soap powder – politicians of all stripes want the City to inject some dynamism into the economy.From Labour to Reform, the siren call of London’s financial district is strong. If only, they ask, the wheels of the banking industry could be cranked to spin faster, surely much more money could be generated and we would all be rich.While Rachel Reeves boasted of the huge benefit to economic growth from public investments in rail and renewable energy as central pillars of the government’s spending review, in truth it is not enough to propel the economy forward.To generate the kind of income that will pay for the next 30 years of an ageing society, plans to link Manchester and Liverpool by a marginally faster and more reliable train, though good in itself, is not the answer
Grilled cheese shop offers Minnesotans a second chance after prison
All Square, a neon-lit diner in Minneapolis, specializes in grilled cheese sandwiches with a twist. Variations on the menu include Jamaican jerk chicken with guava jam, brown sugar bacon doused in ranch dressing, and Granny Smith apple slices coated in brie and mozzarella.But the sandwich shop offers more than elevated comfort food. All Square, which also operates a food-truck catering service, exclusively hires formerly incarcerated Minnesotans.“It started with the idea of: how do we respond to this systemic issue of excluding formerly incarcerated folks from, well, everything once we welcome them home?” said Emily Hunt Turner, a civil rights lawyer who founded the restaurant in 2018
There hasn’t been a ‘big chancellor’ since Osborne: IFS chief gives final mark
“In my lifetime, who have been the big chancellors?” says Paul Johnson, as he prepares to hang up his spreadsheets as the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies. “You’ve had Healey, Lawson, Clarke, Brown. Arguably Osborne. We haven’t had one since then. They’re the long-lasting ones
‘Grenfell was caused by corporate greed’: report calls for far stronger penalties over unsafe cladding
Companies who are found responsible for unsafe cladding should face unlimited fines and permanent bans from public contracts, according to a report that also says England’s existing laws have not gone far enough to prevent future tragedies.The thinktank Common Wealth said the law fails to effectively hold companies to account for corporate negligence, leaving the door open for another disaster like the Grenfell fire, which killed 72 people in June 2017.The report’s author, Leela Jadhav, said England was falling behind other countries which have stronger due diligence laws.“The Grenfell Tower fire was a disaster caused by corporate greed, not an accident,” she said. “Justice in real terms means sanctions, prosecutions and a more robust and enforceable accountability regime
M&S ‘praying for sun’ but full recovery from cyber-attack unlikely this summer
The bosses at Marks & Spencer will surely be praying for sun.As UK temperatures rise over the coming week, M&S will be hoping it prompts shoppers to fill their virtual baskets with shorts, swimwear and sandals to get its summer sales back on track.After six weeks of costly disruption as the result of a cyber-attack, the retailer started taking internet orders again on Tuesday, making a selection of its fashion ranges available for standard home delivery in England, Scotland and Wales.However, the partial resumption of online services does not mark the end of the website woes. Shoppers in Northern Ireland were told they would have to wait a little while longer before theycould place orders, while click-and-collect and next-day-delivery services would only become available again in the coming weeks
Disney and Universal sue AI image creator Midjourney, alleging copyright infringement
‘They went too far’: Musk says he regrets some of his posts about Trump
Meta to announce $15bn investment in bid to achieve computerised ‘superintelligence’
UK students and staff: tell us your experiences with AI at university
As big tech grows more involved in Gaza, Muslim workers are wrestling with a spiritual crisis
AI can ‘level up’ opportunities for dyslexic children, says UK tech secretary