De Niro to JLaw: should celebrities be expected to speak out against Trump?
If you were hoping Jennifer Lawrence might be able to tell you who to vote for and why, you’re in for some disappointment.“I don’t really know if I should,” the actor told the New York Times recently when asked about speaking up about the second Trump administration – and she’s not the only one.“I’ve always believed that I’m not here to tell people what to think,” Sydney Sweeney recently told GQ, after a year in which she was the subject of controversy over a jeans ad and a possible Republican voter registration.This marks a shift from Donald Trump’s first term, when more celebrities seemed not just comfortable speaking out against the administration, but obligated to do so.Now voters will no longer be able to so easily consult with Notes-app-made posts on Instagram to decide who and what they care about before they head to the polls.
The era of movie-star-swung elections has come to an end.Of course, this era didn’t really exist in earnest.Celebrity opinion doesn’t seem to hold much genuine sway over the public, with the possible exception of the segments of each that belong to Taylor Swift.(Call that an extremely vocal plurality, if not necessarily a majority.) If it did, the George Clooney/Jennifer Lawrence/Tom Hanks/Scarlett Johansson party would soundly thump the Dean Cain/Tim Allen/James Woods/Chuck Norris party in every contest.
In her recent interview, Lawrence is speaking to precisely that point, albeit without invoking any catty status differences: “As we’ve learned, election after election, celebrities do not make a difference whatsoever on who people vote for,” she continues,“So then what am I doing [when speaking out against Trump]? I’m just sharing my opinion on something that’s going to add fuel to a fire that’s ripping the country apart,”Lawrence still isn’t actually shy about confirming her feelings (“The first Trump administration was so wild and just, ‘how can we let this stand?’” she says earlier in the interview, and she alludes to the dispiriting feeling when some voters actively chose a second term after seeing the results of the first),Sweeney, for her part, is more genuinely evasive,(“I’m just here to kind of open their eyes to different ideas.
That’s why I gravitate towards characters and stories that are complicated and are maybe morally questionable, and characters that are – on the page – hard to like, but then you find the humanity underneath them,”) But the effect is similar: putting the work first and doing that shut-up-and-sing thing that has been thrown around, in some form another, for half a century or more but felt particularly amped-up around the George W Bush administration, when applied to the artists formerly known as the Dixie Chicks, among others,To some extent, Lawrence is correct to advocate for her work as more potentially meaningful than issuing a statement that underlines her celebrity status, noting that her political views are pretty easy to read in terms of what her production company puts out into the world (including a documentary about abortion bans), and what she does as a performer: “I don’t want to start turning people off to films and to art that could change consciousness or change the world because they don’t like my political opinions,” she says elsewhere in the interview,“I want to protect my craft so that you can still get lost in what I’m doing, in what I’m showing,” In other words, it’s the artistic principle of “show, don’t tell” bleeding over into politics.
More personally, who wouldn’t grow exhausted by the expectation that these opinions should be publicly expressed and available for judgment and nitpicking, and prefer instead to speak through art, if that alternate platform was available to them? Trump doesn’t consume art, but he does perform the old-media equivalent of constant name-searching, which means he is likely to name-check any celebrities with high-profile opposition to him – or even those he senses are somehow aligned with his movement, like Sweeney, whose jeans ad he nonsensically praised.Getting dragged into the Trump sphere is a real lose-lose proposition for anyone who wants a genuinely interesting career in the arts.If that sense of self-preservation spares us some cookie-cutter awards show speeches that don’t move the needle outside of the auditorium applause-o-meter, or Clooney relitigating the specifics of Democrats’ mistakes and pitfalls in the 2024 election, all the better.The other side of that strategy, though, is a form of quivery brand management that doubles as faulty market research, implying a tidy split between Trump supporters and those who oppose the president’s policies.In fact, 77 million voters pulling the metaphorical lever for Trump in 2024 out of approximately 258 million adults in the US equals a less-than-robust 30%, not 50 – a percentage his approval rating has rarely crossed.
Currently, that number continues to sit below 40% by most estimates,Maybe that’s splitting hairs; 77 million voters is a hell of a lot of people, and 37% of 258 million is even more than that, even if it’s not a majority,But the gesture toward “lowering the temperature”, as so many including Lawrence allude to, feels less noble and more businesslike capitulation,Personal politics becomes a choice between allowing people to read between the lines (as Lawrence does) or an outright opacity (like Sweeney’s) that is, ironically, very politician-like,It also fits with an executive mindset that treats audiences more like shareholders than human beings.
As little as celebrity advocacy tends to move the needle on broad political decisions, and likely more effectively moved toward particular issues rather than tilting at the windmills erected by specific politicians, it’s also cathartic to see which folks aren’t backing down,It is telling, too, that some of the most outspoken figures are those closer to Trump’s advanced age,Harrison Ford, for example, had no compunction about telling the Guardian that he considers Trump one of history’s biggest criminals,Robert De Niro has gone further as an anti-Trump spokesperson, recently noting that he was “very happy” to see so many mobilizing against Trump at recent No Kings protests, and repeatedly bringing up his concern that Trump will not abide by the legal term limits on his presidency: “We cannot let up because he is not going to leave the White House,Anybody who thinks, ‘Oh, he’ll do this, he’ll do that,’ is just deluding themselves.
”Does anyone need to hear this alarm sounded by De Niro in particular? Probably not, and surely some former fans will dismiss him as an anti-Trump crank,But at 82, the actor is too late in his career to spend much time calculating what is best for business, which also inures him from charges of empty virtue-signaling,He is clearly saying this stuff because he fully believes it,It’s not that De Niro needs Lawrence, Sweeney or whoever else to stand alongside him, but for all the strangeness of a legendary actor reinventing himself as a cable-news staple, it does seem like De Niro better understands his fellow baby boomer New Yorker,He especially seems to get that Trump is a poisonously ironic figure to inspire this kind of celebrity silence.
This president is himself a celebrity first, a corrupt politician second, and an actual political strategist in a distant and possibly accidental third.He may well survey his presidency and secretly conclude that his greatest triumph was asserting that celebrity over others – to get away with literally telling people how to think and how to vote (or maybe in the future, that voting is no longer necessary) while cowing others from expressing their opinions on the matter.If celebrities had no political sway at all, Trump would be doddering and leering his way around a TV studio.Lawrence and Sweeney are right to aspire toward their work saying more than they do – but maybe not for the reasons they think.Celebrity without art is what gets you Donald Trump in the first place.
For this administration, it’s not the singing that’s important; it’s the shutting up.
Pound hits lowest since April as investors anticipate budget tax rises; markets hit by AI valuation jitters – as it happened
The pound has now dropped to $1.3064, a new six-month low, as City traders anticipate tax rises in this month’s budget.Sterling has lost more than 0.5% today, or around three-quarters of a cent, with analysts pointing to Rachel Reeves’s promise of an “iron clad” commitment to her fiscal rules, and her failure to rule out tax rises.Fiona Cincotta, senior market analyst at City Index, says:In a rare pre-budget speech, Reeves reiterated her commitment to budget goals and what many are considering as weaves, paving the way for more tax hikes and tough decisions in the Budget that would come close to breaking the party’s manifesto pledges
Gopichand Hinduja, head of Britain’s richest family, dies aged 85
Gopichand Hinduja, the billionaire head of Britain’s richest family, has died aged 85.Hinduja died on Tuesday in London after a long illness, a spokesperson said.The low-profile Hinduja family topped the Sunday Times Rich List this year with a collective net worth of £35.3bn, thanks to their sprawling business interests across banking, oil, real estate and entertainment.Gopichand Hinduja, nicknamed “GP”, co-chaired the family business with his older brother Srichand, who died in 2023
Primark owner’s boss urges Reeves not to hit shoppers with budget tax rises
The boss of Primark’s parent group has urged Rachel Reeves to avoid hitting consumers with a repeat of last year’s tax-heavy budget which he claimed sent the retailer’s sales into reverse, saying “don’t do it again”.As the chancellor prepares to make her budget speech on 26 November, George Weston, the chief executive of Associated British Foods (ABF), said: “A budget this late has the potential to have an enormous impact on Christmas trading.”Weston said “any tax rises are going to have an impact on consumer confidence,” but urged Reeves to “tax the rich folks” instead of opting for a sweeping rise in VAT or income tax that would affect most households.Weston said Primark’s Christmas ranges were now “trading really well in the UK and we have got some wind in our sails” but he said that if you considered the outlook for consumer spending “you could be gloomy”.He said that the chain’s sales reversed from growth before last year’s budget, to a steep drop-off in the run-up to Christmas
BP signals more cost cuts on way after fall in profits
BP has said it will ramp up efforts to hive off parts of the business, as the energy company reported a drop in profits in its latest quarter.The company reported an underlying profit of $2.2bn (£1.7bn) in the three months ended in September. It marked a slowdown against its previous quarter, when it made a profit of $2
City watchdog ‘nakedly’ siding with lenders on car finance redress, MPs say
The City regulator has “nakedly taken the side of lenders” in its planned compensation scheme for car loan victims and has been “patently influenced” by concerns over profits, a group of cross-party MPs have claimed.The All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Fair Banking joined a growing chorus of critics concerned about the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) proposed redress scheme, which is meant to compensate borrowers who were overcharged as a result of commission arrangements between lenders and car dealers.The APPG’s latest report has accused the regulator of buying into “doom-mongering” by lenders who claim that a large compensation bill would risk spooking investors and causing lasting damage to the UK economy.That was at the expense of car loan victims who they said were due up to £15.6bn, rather than the £8
Outrage in Paris as Shein prepares to open its first permanent store
The online fast-fashion retailer Shein will open its first permanent bricks-and-mortar store in the world in Paris this week amid political outrage, fury from workers and warnings from city hall that it will damage the French capital’s progressive image.The Singapore-based clothing company, which was founded in China, has built a massive online business despite criticism over its factory working conditions and the environmental impact of low-cost, throwaway fashion.Shein, which has previously trialled temporary pop-up stores, will on Wednesday open a permanent shop on the sixth floor of Paris’s prestigious BHV department store, a historic building that has stood opposite Paris’s city hall since 1856. There are about 23 million Shein customers in France, one of its biggest European markets.But with vast banners for Shein draped across the building, the brand’s arrival has sparked outrage over the promotion of fast fashion
Roebuck and Steward injuries likely to trigger major England reshuffle against Fiji
WTA Finals tennis: Sabalenka fends off Pegula; Gauff beats ailing Paolini – as it happened
Ben Stokes signals 2027 Ashes readiness by signing new two-year central contract
The Breakdown | Fixation on forward rotation threatens to turn rugby contests into war of attrition
Meet the British shot put champion doubling up as a bobsleigh pilot with an eye on Milan 2026
Andrew Wiggins: how a shy NBA player negotiated growing up a star in the social media era