Women’s groups hail Noel Clarke libel defeat as victory for victims and press freedom

A picture


Women’s groups have said a high court judgment dismissing a libel claim against the Guardian by actor Noel Clarke marks a victory not just for his victims, but for press freedom and public interest reporting as a whole.They said too often “wealthy and abusive men” have been able to use the courts to try to silence victims, hiding “behind injunctions, NDAs, [and] threats of defamation suits”.Clarke claimed the allegations published by the Guardian after an investigation were false and he had been the victim of an unlawful conspiracy.During the five-week civil case, 26 witnesses gave evidence against him, detailing allegations of bullying and professional and sexual misconduct.On Friday, Mrs Justice Steyn rejected Clarke’s claims, ruling the Guardian had proved both its defences: truth and public interest.

The judge said that while she accepted some of Clarke’s evidence, “overall I find that he was not a credible or reliable witness”.Harriet Wistrich, lawyer and chief executive of the Centre for Women’s Justice, said the judgment was “great news” and “a blow to wealthy and famous men who think they can use money to silence women”.“Noel Clarke could easily have avoided being named as a sexual predator accused of harassing women.All he had to do was not act in ways that constitute sexual harassment,” said Karen Ingala Smith, former chief executive of domestic and sexual violence charity nia.“Clarke now adds himself to the list of wealthy abusive men who have tried and failed to use the law to minimise, hide or deny their behaviour,” she added.

“My thoughts are with his victims and I am glad justice has been upheld.”Charlotte Proudman, a barrister whose book He Said, She Said revealed how women are silenced in the family courts, said: “This judgment is a landmark moment for survivors of sexual ​misconduct and for investigative journalism.“The court’s finding that the Guardian’s reporting was substantially true sends a clear message: women who come forward should be believed, and journalists who investigate abuse play a vital role in holding perpetrators to account.“It is a victory not just for the women who bravely spoke out, but for press freedom and public interest reporting as a whole.”Andrea Simon, director of the End Violence Against Women Coalition, said: “It is vital that there is freedom to report on cases like this, yet we know that journalists are often held back from reporting due to the threat of legal action from those with power and status.

“The law should not be weaponised by perpetrators to silence survivors,However, this often plays out in the criminal justice system and the media, with women’s credibility put under the microscope, contributing to a culture of disbelief of women across society,”Earlier this summer, the UK government announced plans to stop bosses using NDAs to silence abused workers,The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know,If you have something to share on this subject you can contact us confidentially using the following methods.

Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories.Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs.This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu.Select ‘Secure Messaging’.

SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postIf you can safely use the tor network without being observed or monitored you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform,Finally, our guide at theguardian,com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each,“For so long predatory and abusive men have hidden behind injunctions, NDAs, threats of defamation suits and blacklisting campaigns against victims,” said Jamie Klingler, co-founder of Reclaim These Streets,“All credit is due to those survivors and to Kath Viner and the team of journalists that refused to back down and kowtow to teams of lawyers intent on denying the multitude of accounts of sexual misconduct by their client.

politicsSee all
A picture

‘It has cycled back around’: Brick Lane and Bradford fear a repeat of infamous far-right clashes

The shoppers and shopkeepers of White Abbey Road in Bradford well remember a time almost 25 years ago when the street was engulfed in flames after a protest march against the National Front turned violent. On east London’s Brick Lane, the British-Bangladeshi population remember the invisible lines they could not cross without being set upon by the far right.For both communities, whose showdowns with racist groups came in different decades, the atmosphere in the UK today feels worryingly familiar, with far-right sentiment on the rise, stoked by politicians.“It feels like it has cycled back around,” says Mohsin Shuja, 42, who works in a jewellery shop on White Abbey Road. As a teenager during the 2001 Bradford riots, he was involved in protests against the far right that descended into clashes with police

A picture

Silicon Valley is full of wealthy men who think they’re victims, says Nick Clegg

Silicon Valley is full of hubris and hugely wealthy and macho men who think they are victims, the former politician and Facebook executive Nick Clegg has said.The former leader of the Liberal Democrats makes the claim in a new book chronicling his three careers as an MEP in Brussels, an MP and deputy prime minister in Westminster and as a communications and public policy strategist in San Francisco.In an interview with the Guardian, Clegg heaped praise on his former boss, Mark Zuckerberg, the founder and chief executive of Meta, but was scathing of the culture fostered in the tech capital of the world where he said wealth and power was interlaced with “self pity”.“In Silicon Valley, far from thinking they’re lucky, they think they’re hard done by, [that] they’re victims. I couldn’t, and still can’t, understand this deeply unattractive combination of machismo and self-pity

A picture

‘Why here?’: inside mid-Wales village where far-right figure has created a settlement

During the middle ages, monks would travel to the village of Llanafan Fawr in mid-Wales to visit the church and relics of St Afan, a son of the king of Gwynedd, martyred by foreign pirates centuries before.Today, a different sort of pilgrim can be found there. Two hilly, wooded parcels of land in Llanafan Fawr have been bought by the Woodlander Initiative (TWI), a land-buying scheme led by Simon Birkett, a far-right figure with links to Patriotic Alternative, the UK’s largest fascist group. Critics say Wiltshire-based Birkett’s aim is to create a racially exclusive settlement; he has cited Orania, a whites-only town in South Africa, as an inspiration for the project.TWI successfully bought the two small plots totalling a few acres from a local farmer late last year, after attempts in Cumbria and East Sussex fell through

A picture

‘If I felt Zuckerberg and Sandberg were monsters, I wouldn’t have worked at Meta’: Nick Clegg on tech bros, AI and Starmer’s half measures

When Britain’s former deputy PM took a job at Meta, nothing could have prepared him for the ‘cloying conformity’ of the tech world. So why does he still think social media is a force for good? Read an exclusive extract from Nick Clegg’s new book hereThe rain is just starting to fall from a grey London sky as Sir Nick Clegg arrives, ducking through the traffic and carrying what looks like his laundry. Clean shirts for the photoshoot, he says, before apologetically wondering if he might possibly get a coffee. Within minutes he has further apologised for wanting to swap the leather club chair he is offered for a hard plastic one; and then, in horror, for any impression inadvertently given that my questions might send him to sleep.Impeccable English manners should never be mistaken for diffidence – at 58, Clegg remains the only British political figure who could convincingly be played by the equally posh but self-effacing Colin Firth, whose old London home Clegg recently bought – but there are backbench nobodies more grandly self-important than the former deputy prime minister who became number two at the tech giant Meta

A picture

Checked out: Jenrick’s migrant hotel record haunts his rightwing bid for attention

Robert Jenrick had been migration minister for just a few days in 2022 when he gave a broadcast interview that could easily have been given by a minister in the current government.“Suella Braverman [the former home secretary] and her predecessor, Priti Patel, were procuring more hotels,” he told Sky News. “What I have done in my short tenure is ramp that up and procure even more. Because November, historically, has been one of the highest months of the year for migrants illegally crossing the Channel.”He went on to add: “I would never demonise people coming to this country in pursuit of a better life

A picture

David Lammy given warning after fishing with JD Vance without licence

David Lammy has received a formal warning after reporting himself for fishing without a licence with the US vice-president, JD Vance.The foreign secretary took Vance angling at his official country retreat in Chevening, Kent, on 8 August as he hosted him at the start of a holiday in Britain.It later emerged Lammy did not possess the required licence for rod fishing, with a Foreign Office spokesperson blaming an “administrative oversight” and saying the minister had subsequently bought a licence.Lammy referred himself to the Environment Agency over the incident.Anglers in England and Wales aged 13 or over must have a rod licence to fish for freshwater species such as carp, and can face a fine of up to £2,500 if they do not