Labor’s Measuring What Matters is a worthy goal – but one that has utterly failed to live up to its promise | Greg Jericho
This week, the Bureau of Statistics realised its latest series of Measuring What Matters in an attempt to assess things beyond the mere economics.It comes off the back of the bureau’s first attempt to measure productivity in the non-market sector.Both raise questions of what we value and also whether our focus is where it should be.In 2020 the then shadow treasurer, Jim Chalmers, announced an ALP government would develop a wellbeing framework that would seek to “measure what matters”.It was a worthy goal mocked by the then treasurer, Josh Frydenberg.
As Patrick Commins has explained, the wellbeing framework looks at a vast array of life – well beyond GDP.Unfortunately, the framework has not lived up to its promise.Rather than driving policy, it is now little more than a data dump.And unfortunately, much of it is out of date.For example, one measurement included is experience of discrimination.
The most recent figures are from 2020, which the ABS noted are probably suspect because they were done during the period of Covid restrictions:If the graph does not display click hereUntil the government actually funds the ABS to regularly measure what matters, the wellbeing framework will be irrelevant to policy discussion.And measuring things matters because you can’t know what you don’t see (or count).But equally important is recognising that not everything can be measured as accurately as we might like (or suppose).Productivity, for example, has been the big topic of the past few months.It is essentially measured by GDP per hour worked.
But we already know that GDP misses large swathes of the economy – it doesn’t measure housework, it doesn’t care about distribution,And yet we divide it by hours worked and, before you know it, we have five reports from the Productivity Commission, a productivity roundtable and masses of writing on the issue (including by me), most of which ignores that our measurement of productivity is pretty ropey,Given the value of a thing produced is quantified by its price, this essentially means that if you to do one activity that provides a more expensive product in the same amount of time it would be more productive to do that expensive thing,If we all went off to work in the mines, Australia’s productivity would increase,Would that make us a better society? I doubt it, but it is essentially the (unstated) conclusion of the Productivity Commission’s reports.
But while productivity is easy to measure when counting goods produced, once we get to services, things get very fudgy.Service quality is hard to measure and more services in the same time is not always good.This is important because Australia is much more of a service economy than in the past, so measuring productivity is harder than in the past:If the graph does not display click hereServices are also less productive because it takes more people to do a service than it does to make a good, so again if you want to raise productivity we could just stop people doing services and get them to start making things.Sounds great unless you need a firefighter or a nurse or a teacher.These jobs come from what is classed as the “non-market” sectors of education, health and social care and public administration and safety.
And those sectors have also become more prominent – not just across all work, but even within services:If the graph does not display click hereThis is a problem for measuring productivity because, while measuring services is hard, measuring non-market services is even harder because often the services are not paid and more of them might actually be worse,The Bureau of Statistics has for the first time attempted to count non-market productivity in the most recent GDP figures,It also has pointed out the huge difficulties,For example, it explains that because heart surgery costs more than repairing broken bones “each open-heart surgical procedure carries more weight than each broken bone treated in the emergency room,The heart surgery costs more to perform, so it is assumed to be more valuable.
”You can see the problem.If hospitals were doing more open-heart surgeries than fixing broken bones they might be more productive – but is that a good for society? Do we want policies that encourage more open-heart surgeries rather than other less productive surgeries?Similarly care work is counted as less productive than surgeries – but would it be good for society to encourage fewer age care workers?The issue is that non-market sector productivity is falling:If the graph does not display click hereThat is weighing down overall productivity.But the reality is much of the fall is just a hangover from the Covid period when there was an abnormal increase.Non-market sector productivity rarely grows much – except, as occurred in the 1990s, due to the huge IT improvements.If the graph does not display click hereI am glad the ABS has taken on this unenviable task, because it highlights just how much we should not get caught up on productivity figures.
Do we really think education and health and social care are only as good as they were 20 years ago, or that productivity in those areas is 9% lower than it was in 2021?And is that even bad if, for example, it means more care workers per patient?That’s not to say we shouldn’t improve productivity in services and the non-market sector,But what are we improving? Is our measurement of it just a good guess and not really something that matters? And is non-market sector productivity “almost” everything?Measuring what matters is important but also is realising that not everything we measure matters as much as we might think,Greg Jericho is a Guardian columnist and policy director at the Centre for Future Work
Geelong gave my grandfather more disappointment than fulfilment. For me it is the opposite | Dean Sherr
My grandfather was a stoic man. Settling in the western Victorian town of Ballarat upon arrival as a child from a small town in Ukraine, he took up interest in the nearest VFL club, Geelong. Thus began a lifelong affinity with the Cats he would pass down to his four sons and eight grandchildren.Battle-hardened by a modest upbringing, the loss of his mother at an early age and the mental scars of his service in Kokoda, football became a comforting escape from everyday life. Too frail to get to games himself, his lounge room and pay TV were always open to watch games, where most weekends, I would join him
World Athletics Championships 2025: Nader pips Wightman to 1500m world gold after Kerr injury – as it happened
Jake Wightman was leading for most of the end but Isaac Nader, of Portugal, saw the gap and pushed himself on the line from the outside. Reynold Cheruiyot wins the bronze.Neil Gourley finishes tenth and Josh Kerr ends the race last.Here’s a report on that stunning men’s 1500m final.And our report on Katie Moon’s third pole vault crown …That wraps up today’s action, but tomorrow there’s Sydney McLaughlin in the women’s 400m hurdles final, the men’s javelin medals will be decided … and Keely Hodgkinson returns to the global stage, as she begins her hunt for a first world championship gold in the women’s 800m
USA’s Katie Moon rises again to claim third successive world pole vault gold
USA’s Katie Moon leapt to gold in Tokyo on Wednesday in a thrilling final to become the first woman to win three successive pole vault titles at the World Athletics Championships.Moon has fond memories of Japan – she won gold at the Tokyo Olympics in 2021. This time she edged out compatriot Sandi Morris with a final successful leap at a season’s best 4.90m.Morris, a silver medalist at the 2016 Olympics in Rio, placed second on 4
Super League faces 11th-hour challenge to ‘press pause button’ on expansion
Super League’s proposed expansion to 14 teams is at risk of an 11th-hour challenge from clubs amid fears it could jeopardise the future of rugby league as a professional sport.Hull KR and Hull FC voted against expansion at Headingley in July, but other clubs are now understood to have expressed doubts about the Rugby Football League’s plans and want to “press the pause button” until 2027.The concerns centre on the financial sustainability of a 14-team Super League and the RFL’s failure to share a detailed business plan with the clubs. The Guardian has learned that while the RFL leadership gave a presentation at an informal owners’ meeting before the vote in July, multiple requests from several clubs for a detailed financial analysis underpinning expansion have gone unanswered.No documents were provided at the formal shareholders’ meeting where the vote took place, and the minutes of that meeting have not been shared
‘I’m chilling’: Gout Gout passes first test as he qualifies for world 200m semi-finals
Few sporting debuts have arrived with as much hype, but Australian sprint sensation Gout Gout passed his first test at a major global meet by booking a place in the semi-finals of the World Championships in Tokyo.The 17-year-old handled the pressure under the bright lights of Japan’s National Stadium, powering home in a time of 20.23 seconds to grab the third qualifying place in the fifth of six heats.He finished behind Jamaica’s Bryan Levell and Zimbabwe’s Makanakaishe Charamba, the only two athletes in the heat higher than his world ranking of 16.Gout started slowly and was quickly caught by Levell on his inside, but found his stride and comfortably claimed third in a time two-tenths off his personal best of 20
Grand Slam Track denies Michael Johnson earned $2m from scrapped series
Michael Johnson’s Grand Slam Track organisation has denied the former American sprinter has pocketed $2m from the series while athletes have gone unpaid, calling the speculation “categorically false” – and claimed he was facing financial losses himself.Johnson is facing the prospect of legal action from athletes, agents and the suppliers who helped to stage three GST meetings, with sources claiming they are owed as much as $19m (£13.9m). It is understood that two athletes claim they had to withdraw from buying a house when prize money was not paid, and many privately believe they will never receive their money.However a representative for the four-time Olympic champion has told the Guardian that, contrary to the speculation he had been paid $2m (£1
‘We were being watched by the KGB’: how Scorpions made Wind of Change
Josh Pyke: ‘I turned around and throat-punched the guy – and the whole gig stopped’
My cultural awakening: a Bastille show helped me get over my crippling Covid-era anxiety
The Guide #208: How theatre is holding its own in the age of artificial intelligence
From Spinal Tap II to Ed Sheeran : your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
Seth Meyers on Charlie Kirk shooting: ‘Political violence is abhorrent to the highest ideals of this country’