Small changes to ‘for you’ feed on X can rapidly increase political polarisation
Small changes to the tone of posts fed to users of X can increase feelings of political polarisation as much in a week as would have historically taken at least three years, research has found.A groundbreaking experiment to gauge the potency of Elon Musk’s social platform to increase political division found that when posts expressing anti-democratic attitudes and partisan animosity were boosted, even barely perceptibly, in the feeds of Democrat and Republican supporters there was a large change in their unfavourable feelings towards the other side.The degree of increased division – known as “affective polarisation” – achieved in one week by the changes the academics made to X users’ feeds was as great as would have on average taken three years between 1978 and 2020.Most of the more than 1,000 users who took part in the experiment during the 2024 US presidential election did not notice that the tone of their feed had been changed.The campaign was marked by divisive viral posts on X, including a fake image of Kamala Harris cosying up to Jeffrey Epstein at a gala and an AI-generated image posted by Musk of Kamala Harris dressed as a communist dictator that had 84m views.
Repeated exposure to posts expressing antidemocratic attitudes and partisan animosity “significantly influences” users’ feelings of polarisation and boosts sadness and anger, they found.Musk bought Twitter in 2022, rebranded it X and introduced the “for you” feed, which instead of only showing posts relating to accounts users actively follow, uprates content calculated to maximise engagement.The extent to which more antidemocratic posts make users feel greater animosity towards political opponents “demonstrates the power of the algorithm”, said Martin Saveski, assistant professor at the University of Washington information school, who, with colleagues at the universities of Stanford, Johns Hopkins, and Northeastern, produced the study published in the journal Science.“The change in their feed was barely perceptible, yet they reported a significant difference in how they felt about other people,” added Tiziano Piccardi, assistant professor at the Johns Hopkins University computer science department and co-author of the research.“Based on US trends, that shift corresponds to roughly three years of polarisation.
”The study also found that relatively subtle changes to the content of users’ feeds can significantly reduce political animosity among Republicans and Democrats, suggesting X had the power to increase political harmony if Musk chose to use it in that way,Sign up to TechScapeA weekly dive in to how technology is shaping our livesafter newsletter promotion“What’s exciting about these results is that there is something that the platforms can do to reduce polarisation,” said Saveski,“It’s a new approach they could take in designing their algorithms,”X was approached for comment,Eight in 10 American adults say that not only can Republicans and Democrats not agree on policies and plans, but they cannot agree on basic facts, according to Pew research.
More than half of people in the UK believe the differences in people’s political views are so divisive it is dangerous for society, recent polling by Ipsos found.The changes in political polarisation resulting from exposure to X posts were measured using a novel approach.First, the academics used AI to analyse posts in X’s “for you” feed in real time.Then the system showed more divisive posts to one cohort and fewer divisive posts to another, a power normally the sole preserve of X.Divisive posts included those that showed support for undemocratic practices, partisan violence, opposition to bipartisan consensus and biased evaluations of politicised facts.
After a week of reading these subtly altered feeds, the researchers asked users to rank how warm or cold, favourable or unfavourable they felt towards their political opponents,The changes in “affective polarisation” were ranked at more than two degrees on a 0 to 100 degree “feeling thermometer”,This was the same amount of increased polarisation that typically occurred in the US in the four decades to 2020,Feeding users fewer posts with antidemocratic attitudes and partisan animosity decreased political division by a similar amount,Social media platforms have long been accused of encouraging divisive content to boost user engagement and therefore advertising revenues.
But the research found that while there was a slight reduction in overall engagement in terms of time spent on the platform and numbers of posts viewed when divisive content was down-ranked, those users tended to “like” or repost more often.“The success of this method shows that it can be integrated into social media AI to mitigate harmful personal and societal consequences,” the authors wrote.“At the same time, our engagement analyses indicate a practical trade-off: interventions that down-rank [antidemocratic and partisan content] may reduce short-term engagement volume, posing challenges for engagement-driven business models and supporting the hypothesis that content that provokes strong reactions generates more engagement.”The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know.If you have something to share on this subject, you can contact us confidentially using the following methods.
Secure Messaging in the Guardian appThe Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories,Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs,This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said,If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu,Select ‘Secure Messaging’.
SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and postIf you can safely use the Tor network without being observed or monitored, you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform.Finally, our guide at theguardian.com/tips lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each.
Soon-to-be-axed 7am Manchester-London train will still run – but without passengers
The good news for rail travel between Manchester and London is that a morning train will continue to link the two cities in under two hours. The bad news: passengers will no longer be able to get onboard.The rail regulator has axed one of Britain’s fastest and most lucrative intercity services, the 7am Avanti West Coast from Manchester Piccadilly to London Euston, as part of a timetable shake-up that will take effect in mid-December.What will heap on frustration for passengers, as well as the operator, is that the exact same train service will continue to run between the stations from 7am each weekday: crewed, fast and empty.The train and staff still need to travel from Manchester as they are rostered to operate subsequent services out of Euston on the new December timetable, under rail’s complex planning
Jetstar cancels 90 domestic flights across Australia after global Airbus A320 recall
Jetstar has grounded some of its Airbus fleet in Australia and cancelled domestic and international flights after the aerospace manufacturer ordered software changes to thousands of its A320 planes following a mid-air incident.Ninety Jetstar flights were affected on Saturday with disruption expected to continue until Sunday, the airline’s head of flying operations, Tyrone Simes, told reporters at Melbourne airport.Airbus said on Friday it was ordering an immediate software change on a “significant number” of its bestselling A320 family of aircraft, a narrow-body plane which is also used by Virgin Australia and Qantas.Simes said on Saturday Airbus had issued Jetstar with a maintenance directive to reverse a software upgrade that had been installed on some planes and resulted in a malfunction.He said 34 of Jetstar’s 85 Airbus fleet were affected, but engineers could complete the software update on the ground in Australia, which would take about two to three hours for each plane
After a teddy bear talked about kink, AI watchdogs are warning parents against smart toys
As the holiday season looms into view with Black Friday, one category on people’s gift lists is causing increasing concern: products with artificial intelligence.The development has raised new concerns about the dangers smart toys could pose to children, as consumer advocacy groups say AI could harm kids’ safety and development. The trend has prompted calls for increased testing of such products and governmental oversight.“If we look into how these toys are marketed and how they perform and the fact that there is little to no research that shows that they are beneficial for children – and no regulation of AI toys – it raises a really big red flag,” said Rachel Franz, director of Young Children Thrive Offline, an initiative from Fairplay, which works to protect children from big tech.Last week, those fears were given brutal justification when an AI-equipped teddy bear started discussing sexually explicit topics
One in 10 UK parents say their child has been blackmailed online, NSPCC finds
Nearly one in 10 UK parents say their child has been blackmailed online, with harms ranging from threatening to release intimate pictures to revealing details about someone’s personal life.The NSPCC child protection charity also found that one in five parents know a child who has experienced online blackmail, while two in five said they rarely or never talked to their children about the subject.The National Crime Agency has said that it is receiving more than 110 reports a month of child sextortion attempts, where criminal gangs trick teenagers into sending intimate pictures of themselves and then blackmail them.Agencies across the UK, US and Australia have confirmed a rising number of sextortion cases involving teenage boys and young adult males being targeted by cyber-criminal gangs based in west Africa or south-east Asia, some of which have ended in tragedy. Murray Dowey, a 16-year-old from Dunblane, Scotland, killed himself in 2023 after becoming a victim of sextortion on Instagram and Dinal De Alwis, 16, killed himself in Sutton, south London, in October 2022 after being blackmailed over nude photographs
Constitution Hill falls again as Golden Ace storms to Fighting Fifth Hurdle win
Golden Ace, the reigning champion over hurdles, but dismissed in the betting as a 22-1 outsider, won a dramatic Fighting Fifth Hurdle here on Saturday.Constitution Hill, the 2023 Champion Hurdle winner, suffered a third fall in four starts at the second while The New Lion fell when leading the field two out. Golden Ace, the only mare in the race, then held off the challenge of Anzadam to claim the spoils.The result was a vindication for the willingness of Jeremy Scott, Golden Ace’s trainer, to take on the best hurdlers with his seven-year-old. It was a near facsimile of her win in a similarly dramatic Champion Hurdle in March, when Constitution Hill was again an early faller and State Man came down when clear at the last
‘I could have been a better captain’: Stokes admits errors as England seek Ashes reset
The sheer number of Australian voices triumphantly telling England to show some humility this past week has been slightly ironic. The first Test finished as an eight-wicket thumping, done inside 48 hours and worthy of criticism, but it was not without a genuine wobble from the hosts en route.Either way, Ben Stokes looked to do so when his players resumed training at Allan Border Field on Saturday morning before next week’s day-night second Test at the Gabba. Gone was the “shell-shocked” captain seen during the immediate aftermath of going 1-0 down and in his place, having reflected during the past few days, a far more conciliatory figure.Performances can only truly change perceptions of this England side, but there was an acceptance from Stokes that some of the blowback has been valid
UK at risk of ‘sudden confidence crisis’ if markets lose faith in budget – as it happened
Asda hits out at government for ‘killing confidence’ among consumers
OBR challenges claims Reeves dropped income tax rise due to rosier forecasts
Germany to urge EU to soften 2035 ban on sale of new petrol and diesel cars
Ryanair closes frequent flyers club after members take advantage of discounts
JP Morgan boss gave go-ahead for new £3bn tower in London after UK assurances